10 WWE Storylines That Were Probably Racist

Like many sports around the world, professional wrestling is an industry where performers from a multitude of ethnic backgrounds compete as (perceived) equals, vying against each other in a series of contests to capture championships, win matches and gain in-ring glory. While wrestling is escapism from the real world and should never be confused for anything else, often a bit of the real world creeps in. Race and racism often find their way into storylines, sometimes in an innocuous way, sometimes drawing fans€™ focus away from what the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. called €œthe content of their character.€ Go back 20-plus years and it€™s easy to find examples of racism littered throughout WWE, whether it€™s Jesse Ventura calling Tito Santana €œChico€ and his forearm the €œflying burrito,€ or Mr. Fuji and Don Muraco using terms like €œyard ape,€ €œPuerto Rican hubcap thief€ or honky.€ It€™s nowhere near that level today, but some racist elements remained throughout the modern era. Even when used with the best of intentions €“ getting wrestlers over, setting a villain up for comeuppance €“ racist storylines and characterizations don€™t do anyone any favors in the long run. They can pull fans out of their escapist moment and provide a painful reminder that even though many would like to believe that everyone should be judged €œon the content of their character,€ sometimes it€™s the color of wrestlers€™ skin that defines their character. Highlighted here are 10 more recent examples of potentially racist storylines in WWE. Feel free to chime in with others in the comments. Let€™s be clear here though: In no way does pointing out these examples insinuate that the person is racist.

Honorable Mention: €˜White Boy Challenge€™

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VnBmTn7tl1s Today, Teddy Long is the former Smackdown general manager who calls everyone €˜playa€™ and has a penchant for making tag team matches. But in the mid-2000s, he was a bitter manager complaining that €˜the man€™ was holding him and his stable (€˜appropriately€™ named Thuggin€™ and Buggin€™ Enterprises) down. While managing Rodney Mack, Long instituted the €˜White Boy Challenge,€™ where he€™d ask for any white wrestler to come out and last against Mack for five minutes. For a while, Mack was successful at defeating some jobbers, but when Goldberg answered the call, that was that for Mack. Overall, Long using race did nothing to advance an angle or build a successful career for any of his charges.

10. €˜Gang Wars€™

In 1996, a group of wresters formed a mini-Nation of Islam/Black Panther styled stable called the Nation of Domination. While the group originally was a multi-cultural unit, dissension soon ended that version. Out of the ashes of the original Nation of Domination grew a series of factions, each led by former members of the NOD. Savio Vega formed the Puerto Rican stable Los Boricuas and Crush led a group of white bikers, the Disciples of the Apocalypse. They feuded with a new, all-black Nation throughout 1997. This is an instance where race was at the very center of these three groups. Of course, it was the Attitude Era, so pushing the envelope was nothing new during that time. But the gang wars saw about a dozen superstars defined solely by their race. Of the three factions, only one produced any significant stars, with the Nation giving us The Rock and Mark Henry, along with D-Lo Brown and The Godfather.

9. JBL Literally Boots Illegals Back Across the Border

In 2004, Bradshaw transitioned from a beer-swilling brawler to a wheeling and dealing tycoon. In doing so, he not only changed his appearance, he revamped his entire persona. Gone was the guy who just loved to fight, and in his place was a smarmy Wall Street Texan who craved power. First up on his list of conquests was the WWE Championship that Eddie Guerrero held. To earn a title shot, JBL decided to try win the €œGreat American Award€ by visiting the Texas-Mexico border. During a nighttime promo, JBL spoke of his disdain for €œlazy€ illegal immigrants from Mexico (always a great move when the champ is Mexican-American) and then confronted a group of €œillegals€ trying to cross the border. He barked at them to get back on their side of the border, then kicked one man squarely in the rump to send him flying.

8. Randy Orton vs. Shelton Benjamin

http://youtu.be/fsk5GmnQ-9A?t=4m43s A villain putting down the hero as he talks about why he€™s superior is a classic way to get heat. When the heel is a champ, it€™s common to tell the face that he doesn€™t deserve a title shot. But in 2004 (what were they drinking that year?), Randy Orton took it a couple steps too far when he was confronted by Shelton Benjamin. Benjamin had just jumped over to Raw in the draft and beat Triple H twice, setting him up nicely for a high-profile feud with the Intercontinental Champion. Orton didn€™t think Shelton deserved a title match, and let him know just why:
€œMan, Shelton, you sure are uppity. You know what, that€™s the problem with you people. Give you an inch and you take a mile. Quite frankly Shelton, I wouldn€™t soil the Intercontinental Championship by defending it against you.€
You would think that this would set Benjamin up to silence Orton and take the IC title from him, but you€™d be wrong. Orton retained at Bad Blood, never getting his comeuppance. In fact, two months later he would win his first World Heavyweight Championship over Chris Benoit. Benjamin would capture the Intercontinental Championship in October 2004, but he€™d never get to take Orton down for his insults.

7. Shelton Benjamin vs. Yoshi Tatsu

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JA0QZTeaG2A Apparently, stuff rolls downhill in WWE. A full five years after being targeted by Orton, Shelton Benjamin openly mocked new Japanese superstar Yoshi Tatsu. In fact, the entire segment consisted of Shelton acting like a Japanese stereotype €“ bowing at everyone, threatening to call Godzilla, speaking in a badly overdubbed movie voice €“ before getting his head kicked off and pinned. Granted, Shelton€™s job was to get Yoshi over, and Matt Striker and Josh Matthews called Benjamin out for making a €œmockery€ of Tatsu, but this was so far over the top. Looks like the WWE€™s Be a STAR program came along two years too late to prevent this.

6. Saba Simba

It sounds weird to say this since he€™s a prime offender of racist behavior, but thank God for €œRowdy€ Roddy Piper. When WWE €˜debuted€™ a new superstar decked out in tribal gear €“ including a headdress and a shield €“ it took Piper all of three seconds to correct Vince McMahon€™s introduction of Saba Simba by blurting out, €œHold on, that€™s Tony Atlas.€ What made the segment so surreal was listening to McMahon claiming that Atlas, a former WWE Tag Team Champion and Mr. USA, was proud of his heritage (with no mention of where he was descended from), and Piper scoffing that that was a ridiculous claim and he looked foolish. Piper immediately burying the gimmick probably saved the day. Otherwise, Vince might have tried to have Kamala and Saba Simba form a tag team. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KG5LI168rBo We see it all the time with superstars being repackaged and reinvented, but taking a guy who had been around in professional wrestling for 15 years as just a strongman and turning him into a dancing tribal performer is just ludicrous.

5. Mexicools

On paper, it sounds like a recipe for success: Three popular Mexican luchadores debut on Smackdown, where the WWE Cruiserweight Championship is defended. Two of the three are former Cruiserweight champs from WCW. It sounds like a great way to revitalize the Cruiserweight division and also provide a new tag team as well. Instead, we got the horribly stereotypical Mexicools, three luchadores dressed like gardeners riding a €œJuan Deere€ lawnmower to the ring. A backstage skit one night had a concessions manager mistake them for the help and demanding they sell sodas and popcorn. Even though this was done in a mocking way, it still helped perpetuate stereotypes. Thankfully, the Mexciools weren€™t portrayed as heels for their entire run, as they became fan favorites in part due to their lucha-style. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=of90rOGoVN8 This is one area where WWE often falls down: The company thinks that by drawing a lot of attention to race, they are showing that the performers can rise above those characterizations or stereotypes. Instead they are simply drawing more attention to negative stereotypes and racist attitudes. The best way to send a positive message is the way they are treating Roman Reigns €“ a Samoan wrestler who is not being defined by his ethnic heritage at all.

4. Cryme Tyme

You really have to wonder about WWE creative sometimes. Do they really sit around a table and say, €œHey, we have two young black wrestlers in developmental, let€™s bring them up, dress them like street thugs with bling and have them steal stuff. We can call them Cryme Tyme! We€™ll make millions!€ On one hand, it was so over-the-top that it the duo actually got pretty over (along with their €œMoney, money, yeah, yeah€ catchphrase), and they even backed Cena for a brief time. Fans rallied to the team and helped make them one of the more popular tag teams in the late 2000s. But watching JTG and Shad steal Deuce and Domino€™s convertible or having a €œho sale€ of Lita€™s underwear after she loses her retirement match makes you wonder if this is the only way two young black men can make it to the main roster. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R6-n3MkJJoA But then again, you could point to The Rock and Mark Henry as members of the Nation of Domination as proof that anything is possible. Just hang in there another couple of years, JTG!

3. €˜Rowdy€™ Roddy Piper vs. The World

When it comes to the Hot Rod, take your pick. Do you like when he said Mr. T€™s lips looked like a catcher€™s mitt and that he would €œwhip him like a slave.€ Do you prefer when he smashed a coconut on Jimmy €˜Superfly€™ Snuka€™s head? Or maybe the soul food reference to Tony Atlas? Or how about when he painted half his body black for his WrestleMania VI match against Bad News Brown? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pc8ewByCsKM All of those have a racist element to them. Piper had a way of being a molten hot heat magnet in the 80s, but a lot of his methods wouldn€™t even come close to flying today. While these statements and actions were designed to piss off the crowd and fire up his opponent, Piper easily created a kilted villain who easily could be painted (metaphorically) as racist. Then again, Piper thrived on controversy, and using race in his feuds certainly generated controversy. So€ mission accomplished?

2. Virgil As DiBiase€™s Manservant

No matter how you slice it, rich, white Ted DiBiase talking about how he can buy a person, such as €œmy man Virgil,€ a black bodyguard whose primary job is to hold DiBiase€™s money, is racist. Virgil also chauffeured DiBiase around and seconded him to the ring, often serving as a distraction and a punching bag for the Million Dollar Man€™s opponents. Sure, you could make the case the Virgil was meant to represent Dusty Rhodes €“ real name Virgil Runnels €“ but having a rich white man barking orders at a subservient black man just screams degrading. How they got away with this on television for several years is beyond comprehension. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3lhpWkv_Wws Interestingly, many fans fondly remember the Million Dollar Man character and overlook this very racist element of his character in favor of that maniacal laugh. He€™s now an almost-beloved Legend who shows up in the occasional backstage segment. People don€™t seem to care about the manservant aspect of the character. But at least Virgil finally got his comeuppance and captured the Million Dollar Championship. That€™s more than can be said for the next guy.

1. Triple H Puts Booker T In His Place

This is probably one of the most famous instances of overt racism creeping into WWE. In the lead-up to WrestleMania XIX, Triple H began deriding his opponent, Booker T, saying €œpeople like you€ don€™t deserve to be World Champion. Triple H mocked Booker T.€™s hair and spinarooni, asking him to dance for him. It felt like people were watching something from our parents€™ generation, where saying stuff like that was just €œthe way it was.€ Putting aside the despicable nature of the comments, Triple H definitely put himself in the heel category, and the fans were just begging Booker to shut his mouth up at WrestleMania. Jim Ross€™ commentary as Booker made his way to the ring €“ talking about how Booker was the youngest of seven, his mother died when he was 12 and he paid for his criminal mistakes €“ set the stage for a triumphant climax to this less than savory story at the biggest PPV of the year. So naturally, Triple H kicked out of Booker€™s Harlem Hangover, hit a Pedigree and then laid on the mat for 20 seconds before pinning him. End of story. No day of reckoning for Triple H, no wrestling justice served. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r4RebbQqQz4 Did Triple H generate a lot of heat for his Mania match against Booker T? Definitely. Was he the most hated guy in Safeco Field and Booker the babyface everyone was pulling for? Absolutely. Was it worth the promo and angle they used to get there? Well, that€™s the question with a lot of these examples. It seems like WWE believes that interjecting race and racism into their angles add a layer of depth to the storytelling. But as evidenced by these examples, the use of race and racism doesn€™t magically elevate a person or angle. In the long run, it€™s just an element that isn€™t needed in professional wrestling.

Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.