10 WWE Superstars Who Are Overdue A Main Roster Push

It’s time to give these wrestlers some more of the spotlight.

Kevin Owens
WWE

There is no question that WWE has a deeper and more talented roster than ever before, and yet it was this past spring that 53 year-old Goldberg returned for a run with the Universal Championship. While they’ve spent the last decade hoarding the top talent in the industry, WWE has consistently been unable, or unwilling, to demonstrate the patience required to create new stars.

The Universal Champion Roman Reigns and WWE Champion Drew McIntyre have firmly been established as the faces of SmackDown and RAW. With five hours of television to fill between the two shows, there is plenty of opportunity for each brand to build up their mid-cards and establish new stars. There are numerous wrestlers on each show who have been let down by lazy pushes, 50/50 booking, or - as Tazz recently referenced on AEW Dynamite - creative having nothing for them.

Survivor Series 2020 was the official retirement of The Undertaker, and WWE should use that as the catalyst to shift their attention from stars of the past, to their stars of the present and future. The good news is that WWE already have wrestlers on their roster who, with the right booking, could become the superstars of tomorrow. Here are ten wrestlers WWE should invest in by giving a sustained push right now.


10. Chad Gable

Chad Gable
WWE.com

It’s disappointing that the best thing that has happened to Chad Gable in the last 12 months is that he’s rid himself of the dreadful Shorty G moniker. Gable competed in the 2012 Summer Olympics in London, and is one of the most proficient technical wrestlers in the industry. In Gable, WWE essentially have Kurt Angle 2.0, yet his talents have been wasted with poor booking and, for the last year, a silly gimmick- these will be recurring themes on this list.

During his time on NXT, Gable demonstrated his tag team wrestling prowess as one half of American Alpha, alongside Jason Jordan. The tag team divisions on the main roster have been in desperate need of an overhaul for some time and, while Jordan is no longer available due to a neck injury, it shouldn’t be hard to find a suitable partner for Gable. How good would Gable be teaming up with Drew Gulak to go on a run through the tag team division?

It seemed as though Gable was going to be pushed when he made it to the finals of the King of the Ring tournament in 2019, but after losing to Baron Corbin, his momentum fizzled out. Gable is being woefully underused by a company that isn’t recognizing his talent. If he isn’t given a push in the singles or tag team division soon, Gable may be a candidate to jump ship to AEW and see if the grass is greener on Wednesday nights.


9. Mustafa Ali

Mustafa Ali
WWE

Kofi Kingston’s WrestleMania victory was one of the best stories WWE produced in 2019. One half of the current RAW Tag Team Champions, Kingston’s journey to pinning Daniel Bryan and claiming the WWE Championship at WrestleMania 35 was enough to put a smile on the most cynical fans face. While Kingston’s ascent to the pinnacle of WWE was as inspiring as any storyline, it’s easy to forget that had it not been for a stomp to his face at the hands of Randy Orton, Mustafa Ali was going to be the recipient of a push into the WWE title picture.

It seems WWE are aware of what they have in Ali; he was due for the push prior to WrestleMania 35, and he was seconds away from becoming Mr. Money In The Bank, before Brock Lesnar entered the match. Recently, Ali has been given a spotlight as the leader of the group RETRIBUTION, although their booking has been an unmitigated disaster. Having been buried before they could build any momentum, it’s going to take a herculean effort to restore credibility to Ali’s faction.

WWE will not want to throw in the towel on RETRIBUTION, mere months after introducing them on Monday Nights. It will take patient, long-term booking to build them into a force to be reckoned with, and once an aura has been created around the group, Ali should be seriously considered as the man to win the United States Championship from Bobby Lashley.


8. Sonya Deville

Sonya Deville
WWE.com

With a background in mixed martial arts, Sonya Deville is a formidable wrestler, whose star has been rising for the last 18 months. In 2019, Deville and Mandy Rose were wrestling as the tag team Fire and Desire. They were unable to capture the tag team titles - nor the SmackDown Women’s Championship - and their partnership imploded in early 2020, when Deville was caught meddling in Rose’s relationship with Otis. Their rivalry and storyline was one of the best programs in WWE on the road to WrestleMania.

While Deville and Rose were merely in Ziggler and Otis’ corners, at WrestleMania, their own feud culminated in a No Disqualification Loser Leaves WWE Match at SummerSlam. Deville lost the match, posted a good-bye on her social media accounts, and hasn’t been seen on WWE television since. It’s likely Deville was booked to lose in order to give her time away from the ring following an attempted kidnapping at her home in Florida. Deville should take as much time as she needs after what was surely a traumatic event.

When Deville does return, she should be booked to go on a singles run on SmackDown. Deville has always had the in-ring ability and her feud with Mandy Rose proved that she has the chops to cut a promo. Given what she’s gone through in her personal life, Deville could be an incredibly sympathetic babyface, working her way through what’s becoming a very strong women’s division., before contending for SmackDown’s top prize.


7. Kevin Owens

Kevin Owens
WWE.com

Kevin Owens debuted on the main roster by pinning John Cena clean at the 2015 Elimination Chamber pay-per-view. That is one hell of a way to let fans know they ought to take The Prizefighter seriously. Fast forward five years and Owens has put together an impressive resume.

Of all the wrestlers on this list, Owens is the only one who has spent time at the top of the card while on the main roster. He’s a former Universal, United States, and Intercontinental Champion, and has highlighted some of WWE’s most celebrated segments, including the Festival of Friendship alongside Chris Jericho. So can he be overdue for a push?

Since 2017, Owens has been fairly directionless. He had a rivalry with Shane McMahon, during the company’s ill-conceived attempts to make The Chairman’s son a weekly television staple; he has had an on-again, off-again partnership with Sami Zayn; and creative have flipped his character from babyface to heel so many times, you might as well start calling him Big Show.

Recently on SmackDown, Owens laid waste to Jey Uso, putting himself next in line for a shot at Roman Reigns’ Universal Championship. While this feud should be great, you’d be hard-pressed to think Owens has any legitimate shot of taking the title from Reigns. After the Big Dog’s inevitable victory, and some time away from television, creative needs to give Owens a clear identity, before having the opportunity to re-establish himself at the top of the card.


6. Andrade

Andrade WWE
WWE

Following an excellent run as NXT Champion, Andrade was drafted to SmackDown, along with manager Zelina Vega, as part of the 2018 Superstar Shake-up. Apart from a final four finish at the 2019 Royal Rumble, and a run with the United States Championship, Andrade has had an unremarkable tenure on the main roster.

Andrade suffered, as many other NXT call-ups have, from being promoted to the main roster despite no plans being in place for him. He had an excellent program with Rey Mysterio during his US Title run, but since dropping the belt, Andrade hasn’t been able to build any momentum. He was one of the wrestlers who suffered the most when Paul Heyman was removed from his role as Executive Director of RAW, as Heyman had plans to push the former Andrade if he had been given more time. Andrade most recently suffered a loss to his former tag team partner Angel Garza, in mid-October, and hasn’t been seen on Monday nights since he and Vega were attacked by The Fiend and Alexa Bliss, following the match.

Unfortunately, the recent departure of Vega from WWE will, likely, have a negative impact on Andrade. Unless he gets another manager, the company may not see Andrade as someone worth pushing, unless he works on his English. Given his excellent work rate and terrific move-set, Andrade could be an upper mid-card performer if booked properly, but so far, creative’s handling of him has been nothing short of a failure.


5. Keith Lee

Keith Lee
WWE

The Limitless One has only been on the main roster long enough to have a cup of coffee, so the word overdue may be a stretch, but Keith Lee has reputation and skillset that should have made creative strap a rocket to his back. Lee has had an excellent 2020, delivering an exciting- albeit brief- encounter with Brock Lesnar at the Royal Rumble, before capturing the NXT Title at The Great American Bash, this past summer. While he should have been presented as one of the biggest threats to emerge from developmental, his tenure on the main roster has been more confusing than successful.

Since making his debut on the RAW after SummerSlam, Lee was immediately thrust into a storyline involving Randy Orton and WWE Champion Drew McIntyre. While Lee pinned Orton clean at WWE’s Payback pay-per-view, he spent August and September losing, by disqualification, in singles competition. That is one effective way to take the wind out of a budding star’s sails.

Lee is currently embroiled in a rivalry with Braun Strowman, whose mere presence next to Lee does nothing to accentuate either man’s size. Pushing and building up giants is a slam dunk for creative and how Vince McMahon has dropped the ball with Lee is astonishing. After Team RAW’s clean sweep at this year’s Survivor Series, Lee has started to gain some momentum, and the next couple months should be focused on building Lee into a credible Royal Rumble contender.


4. Bianca Belair

Bianca Belair
WWE.com

It’s difficult to believe that Bianca Belair has been on the main roster since WrestleMania 36. Before being shuffled to SmackDown in the most recent WWE Draft, Belair was briefly associated with her real life husband Montez Ford and the Street Profits. She then disappeared from television altogether, before reappearing in a series of promo packages that pushed her gimmick as the EST of WWE (fastEST, smartEST, strongEST- do you see how clever that is?).

Given that both women’s divisions are in desperate need of fresh rivalries and new characters, the fact that Belair has not been used much since her elevation to the main roster seems like a major waste. On the flip side of that, Belair has not been unnecessarily overexposed, still has an aura around her character, and is a phenomenal wrestler. She is an athletic powerhouse who can go against the best wrestlers on WWE’s roster, which she proved this past February when she went one-on-one with Charlotte Flair on NXT.

While Lana walked away as the sole survivor in this year’s women’s 5-on-5 elimination match at Survivor Series, Belair was one of the stand out performers from that match. A budding feud with Bayley seems to be on the horizon and WWE couldn’t have booked Belair with a better opponent for her first proper rivalry. It should be the beginning of an ascent up the card that eventually leads Belair into the SmackDown title picture.


3. Aleister Black

Aleister Black NXT
WWE

Even by WWE standards, it took little time for creative to take an NXT diamond and turn him into a lump of coal on the main roster. While at Full Sail, Aleister Black was a no-nonsense, killer who could get his opponents over by saying their name. Since being promoted to RAW, Black has been presented as a brooding loner, who spends his days in a dark room, waiting for someone to pick a fight with him.

The Dutch Destroyer is a gifted wrestler, whose Black Mass is one of the best finishers in the industry. Having seen what he is capable of in NXT, it’s frustrating to see another potential star being wasted. Not every performer can be booked to get over, but Black is the complete package and should have been a slam-dunk.

It’s a shame Paul Heyman wasn’t given more time to get Black over, while he was overseeing creative on RAW. With rumours that Black had recently requested to return to NXT and concerns he may face punishment booking for the manner in which Zelina Vega- his real life wife- was recently released from WWE, his future doesn’t look promising.

From his entrance, to his character, to his in-ring ability, Black didn’t need many tweaks to his presentation when he was promoted to the main roster. WWE should take a mulligan on Black and, following an extended absence from television, re-introduce him in 2021 as the composed, lethal striker he was while on NXT.


2. Shayna Baszler

Shayna Baszler WWE
WWE

Following a terrific Royal Rumble performance that saw her eliminated last by Charlotte Flair, it seemed WWE had big plans for Shayna Baszler. While she was presented as an absolute badass during a 416 day NXT title reign, Baszler’s debut on RAW was perplexing, as she attempted to, quite literally, bite Becky Lynch’s head off. Despite her bizarre introduction on the main roster, Baszler ran through all five of her opponents at the Elimination Chamber pay-per-view and seemed as though she was destined to dethrone The Man at WrestleMania 36.

Then she lost. With a creative team unable to book captivating storylines for the women’s division, Baszler has been struggling to regain the aura she had while wrestling on the black-and-yellow brand. Since WrestleMania, The Queen of Spades lost the cinematic, comedy version of the annual Money in the Bank Ladder Match, and currently represents half of the women’s tag team champions, in a directionless, reluctant partnership with Nia Jax.

Baszler has the potential to be the face of the women’s division for years to come and is currently being under-utilized on Monday nights. She has credibility, with a background in mixed martial arts, and simply needs to be booked as the version of herself that she was in NXT.

Pushing Baszler should be of the utmost priority for WWE’s creative, particularly because a title match against Asuka at WrestleMania 37 has the potential to be a Match of the Year Candidate.


1. Big E

Big E
WWE.com

There have been rumours suggesting that Big E is in line for a significant push, which was why he was separated from his New Day stablemates Kofi Kingston and Xavier Woods and why he’s disappeared from television in recent weeks. While it’s a smart move to avoid over exposing any superstar, how WWE have yet to establish the former NXT Champion as a dominant singles wrestler is somewhat puzzling.

There may be no current WWE superstar better than Big E to begin a long face- run, ascending up the card and eventually defeating Reigns for the Universal Title. He is an athletic powerhouse who has shown he is more than capable of being a dominant singles performer. Not only does he have the in-ring talent to justify a major title push, Big E oozes charisma and is one of the most entertaining men with and without the mic. On top of all of that, he has a physique that should have Vincent Kennedy McMahon salivating.

Fans have been clamouring for WWE to strap a rocket to Big E’s back and to have him ascend to the main event, but given he hasn’t been a single’s wrestler for some time, creative should not rush his push. There is enough talent on SmackDown for Big E to have a slow build, leading to either a Royal Rumble victory or, at the very least, a significant match at WrestleMania 37, which can carry him to a Universal Title shot at SummerSlam.


In this post: 
Kevin Owens
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Brady Coyle is a board game enthusiast, an outdoor enthusiast, a crossword enthusiast and doesn't understand the concept of synonyms. He saw a button that said "Contribute" and, presented with the opportunity to share his opinion, he will never say no. He lives in Toronto, Canada, a place where nothing ever gets done because everyone is too busy saying "sorry" to each other.