10 WWE Superstars Who Should Switch Brands In 2017

The grass is always greener on the other side...

Wwe Brand Split
WWE.com

The 2016 Brand Split was a watershed moment for WWE, a chance to blow the company’s increasingly stale roster open and nurture new champions, new storylines, and new rivalries. While there were some teething problems at first, the split has once again created two wrestling shows worth watching, rescuing SmackDown! from its five year slump as a WWE’s resident B-show.

Still, each roster has its own unique perks and pitfalls, and both are guilty of misusing or under-utilising certain subsets of their talent pools. RAW's stagnant mid-card is still a fairly lifeless and directionless place, a land where gimmicks go to die, momentum fizzles out, and title belts are all but forgotten about. Smackdown LIVE isn't exactly without fault either; Shane O'Mac's tag team division is barren, while his mid-card and main event scenes are in dire need of some big name talent.

While it’s fair to say that the majority of superstars are now better off than they were pre-Draft, this isn't the case for everyone. With another Draft likely to be on the cards come summer time, certain names should be looking to jump ship, before they begin to sink...

10. Emma

Emmalina II
WWE.com

Emma’s re-debut as Emmalina is already one of 2017's most baffling wrestling-related moments. Hyped for months in advance, and often missing her scheduled appearance due to lingering injuries, Emma was to be repackaged as a ‘throwback’ to glamorous characters like Sable and The Kat. It really doesn’t need explaining that this is a woeful misuse of Emma’s talents, who has the potential to be one of the company’s top heels. Ultimately, the 'Emmalina' gimmick was dead on arrival, as Emma all but announced she would be returning to her previous character.

Having already been repackaged once (from fun-loving party-person to sneering, aviator-wearing jerk), Emma doesn’t need a new character or gimmick, she needs feuds, stories, and a creative team that can really get behind her.

SmackDown LIVE’s team has shown that they’re committed to experimenting with the blue brand’s women’s division, and Emma would benefit immensely from a push to the top, facing off against talents like Mickie James and Becky Lynch. She could even see herself traded alongside Dana Brooke, a similarly directionless character whose NXT pairing with Emma still ranks as the highlight of her WWE career.


9. Rusev

jinder rusev lana
WWE.com

Rusev is one of the funniest, most charismatic, and athletic big men currently working for WWE. With every chance he gets, he seems to reinvent himself ever-so-slightly, and his pairing with Lana is still TV gold. The problem is, he’s been languishing in RAW’s midcard for what feels like years, always coming close to the top but never amounting to more than a transitional US Champ or a severely outdated Cold War villain. He’s currently teaming with Jinder Mahal, because 'foreign'.

If given the right kind of push over on the blue brand, he could return to his status as a sadistic, conniving brute, or alternatively, branch out into being a bumbling slapstick oaf. Either way, he needs some direction and focus, as he’s currently just treading water on RAW. And unlike RAW, SmackDown could actually use more names to bolster its midcard.

Think about the great matches he could have over on SmackDown, with the likes of AJ Styles, Luke Harper, or even American Alpha. There’s an Intercontinental Championship with Rusev’s name on it. He just needs the right brand, and the right opponents to machka.


8. Gallows & Anderson

luke gallows karl anderson
WWE.com

Despite consistently being hyped as ‘huge stars in Japan’ and ‘a dominant force, everywhere they’ve wrestled’, Gallows and Anderson’s initial WWE run amounted to little more than a streak of losses and some bad ‘ball’ puns. Although they’ve finally made good on their promise to secure tag team gold, they’ve also been shoehorned into a weird, two versus one angle with Roman Reigns, in yet another attempt to get the The Big Dog cheered.

A move to Smackdown LIVE would not only be a wise move for The Club, it would also do a great deal to bolster the blue brand’s currently lacklustre tag division. While American Alpha and Heath Slater & Rhyno have made for solid babyface champions, they haven’t really had any believable competition yet. The likes of Breezango, The Vaudevillains and The Ascension have long been resigned to undercard status, and with The Hype Bros currently sidelined due to Zack Ryder's knee injury, the division has all the depth of a puddle.

What Smackdown needs is a duo of hard-hitting, no nonsense brawlers who can sit at the top of the division for a good while, knocking back all-comers. If The Revival aren’t about to be called up, Gallows and Anderson will do just fine.


7. Kalisto

Kalisto TLC
WWE.com

It’s anyone’s guess why Kalisto was drafted to Smackdown LIVE. With no tag team partner, and no Cruiserweight division to compete in, the former Lucha Dragon has become the blue brand’s resident whipping boy since the Brand Split. Most recently, he’s been involved in a bizarre feud with Dolph Ziggler, in which righteous babyfaces Kalisto and Apollo Crews fought the dastardly Dolph Ziggler… in a two on one handicap match. Seen only as a minor road block when building feuds for larger stars, Kalisto is stuck in a thankless role, and needs a new place to show off his high-flying skills.

By injecting Kalisto into the Cruiserweight division, 205 Live would have access to another recognisable face, someone familiar in a sea of untested prospects. Even if they used Kalisto as just another way to build up-and-coming heels, he’d be in a better position than he's in now. At least he’d be working with wrestlers who are matched to his skillset, and opponents who could believably sell his offense.

It’s not like Smackdown would even miss having a high-flyer around. AJ Styles, one of the most proficient high-flyers in the world, is one of the brand’s hottest stars, and rarely a Smackdown minute goes by without Mauro Ranallo shouting “Tope suicida!” as yet another Superstar attempts a death-defying leap to the outside.


6. Cesaro

Sad Cesaro wwe
WWE.com

Cesaro is one of the most talented wrestlers in WWE, but he’s often been given short shrift over the years. Many argue that this is due to his supposed inability to talk (a strange accusation to level at someone as multilingual as Cesaro), or because his various character changes have failed to connect with the WWE Universe. Others blame it on WWE management’s refusal to give The Swiss Superman a real push into the main event scene, opting instead to keep him fighting for midcard and tag belts.

While his odd-couple run with Sheamus has been entertaining, and even gave Cesaro his second tag championship, there’s only so much steam left in the angle. Once it runs out, it’d be disappointing to see Cesaro go back to being ‘another talented Superstar with a chip on his shoulder, trying to reach for that fabled brass ring’, especially when he could receive a believable push on Smackdown LIVE.

Match him up against Styles, The Miz, Cena, Ziggler and even Corbin, and you’ve got the recipe for some really fruitful rivalries. You never know, with Kassius Ohno debuting in NXT, we could even see the Kings of Wrestling become kings of the Smackdown Tag Division.


5. The Undertaker

undertaker goldberg
WWE.com

This is a weird one, considering that The Undertaker has already switched brands unofficially on a whim. Despite declaring Smackdown to be ‘his home’ back in 2016, The Deadman eventually found himself on RAW this year, with his brand philandering never mentioned on air.

This is because, as WWE’s longer ‘flagship show’, RAW appears to have monopolised ‘novelty’ or ‘attraction’ matches, big name bouts designed to rope in lapsed or casual fans through nostalgia. Brock Lesnar vs Goldberg, The Undertaker appearing in the Royal Rumble, and whatever Shaq and Big Show are up to all stand as examples of this. They all serve to push Smackdown’s full time wrestlers further down joint PPV cards.

He may only be a part-timer, but if The Undertaker were to firmly stake a claim to SmackDown, the brand with which he is synonymous, he’d be able to elevate lower full time talent to main event spots. It’s a feud that Baron Corbin was born for, and could even lead to dream matches with John Cena and AJ Styles. The Undertaker will do just fine as a sideshow attraction on RAW, but he’d be able to make a much bigger impact over on the blue brand, which could really use some star power.


4. Sheamus

WWE Roadblock End Of The Line Sheamus The New Day
WWE.com

Like his partner Cesaro, Sheamus is a singles competitor trapped in a tag wrestler’s angle. A United States title or World Title run seems unlikely (and unpleasant), but as one of the most effective heels in the company, the Celtic Warrior would make a fine addition to the Intercontinental title scene.

So long as he was kept far away from Randy Orton, Sheamus could be inserted into any mid-to-upper card feud, and would lend it a sense of legitimacy. There are also plenty of Superstars on SmackDown with whom Sheamus has never fought, and freshening up matches is only ever a good thing.

It’d even be interesting to see Sheamus interact with Daniel Bryan, a notoriously anti-heel General Manager who lost his World Heavyweight Championship to The Celtic Warrior in under 20 seconds at WrestleMania 28. I’m still sore about that, and I’m sure Bryan is too.


3. Braun Strowman

Braun Strowman Randy Orton
WWE.com

Like any WWE Superstar, Braun Strowman only has so many opponents. But whereas most other wrestlers can reignite feuds with changed alignments, refreshed characters and unique new situations, Braun Strowman doesn’t really have that luxury. He tends to beat his foes in such a decisive fashion that there's very little joy in watching repeat beatings. It’s been shown that Sami Zayn cannot beat Strowman, and if the same happens with Roman Reigns when their feud comes to a head, who is left for Braun to run over?

The entire SmackDown locker room, that’s who.

It might seem like a cheap way of creating the illusion of change, but it would provide Strowman with an all new set of opponents to face. Not only that, but there are actually some intriguing stories waiting for Braun over on the blue brand. After clearing out RAW’s locker room, Strowman’s only motivation would be to finish the job on Smackdown. This could lead to a clash with his former master Bray Wyatt, an enticing feud that was already teased at Survivor Series last year.

It’d also be a refreshing change of pace to see how benevolent SmackDown leaders Daniel Bryan and Shane McMahon deal with a monster like Strowman, and whether or not they attempt to control him or just let him run wild.


2. Carmella

Carmella Bayley WWE Draft
Twitter

Just like with Kalisto, fans were bemused and confused by WWE’s decision to split Carmella from Enzo and Cass. While the duo had done just fine by themselves while Carmella finished up in NXT, it seemed inevitable that The Princess of Staten Island would join them when the time was right. After all, Carmella and Enzo are so similar, they’re essentially gender-swapped versions of the same character.

Although her current storyline with James Ellsworth is worth a few cheap laughs, it feels like both stars are treading water in lieu of something more substantial. It’s unlikely that Carmella will be given a shot at the Smackdown Women’s title any time soon, so why not send her over to RAW where she can reform with Enzo and Cass? She could even provide the spark that leads to their inevitable breakup feud – her manipulation skills have already made short work of Ellsworth, and they could be used to drive a wedge between Muscles Marinara and his very tall friend.

Failing that, why not draft Enzo and Cass over to Smackdown, whose tag division is in dire need of a shot in the arm. Enzo and Cass might not be the most technically gifted wrestlers, but they’re a bright, colourful, catchphrase-spouting group, stuck on a roster that already has The New Day.


1. Sami Zayn

Sami Zayn Post-WrestleMania Raw
WWE.com

Sami Zayn is one of the most believable, likeable, and emotionally resonant Superstars employed by WWE, but he’s currently being used as an upmarket Kalisto, a post-jobber roadblock for larger Superstars with more direction. Sami’s feud with Braun Strowman showed him at his best, and while it was a solid David vs. Goliath story, it ultimately ended with Sami failing to eliminate Strowman from the Royal Rumble. Despite being one of WWE’s few true babyfaces, Sami is somewhat lost in the shuffle at the moment. But this doesn’t have to be the case.

The prestige of the Intercontinental Title was built upon smaller, leaner, more technical (and incidentally, Canadian) wrestlers like Bret Hart, Pat Patterson and Chris Jericho, and Sami fits this mould perfectly. He could have fantastic bouts for the title over on Smackdown, with the likes of Baron Corbin, The Miz, Dolph Ziggler, and even AJ Styles.

Although one could argue that it makes sense to keep the tension between Zayn and Kevin Owens alive by having them share the same roster, it’d be better to separate them, ensuring that any future feuds later down the line would have more impact. After all, absence makes the heart grow fonder.

Sami made no bones about wanting to be drafted to Smackdown in 2016, and even argued with Mick Foley about being traded outside of any official draft. With that in mind, the lead-up to 2017's draft could prove a pivotal few weeks for Sami Zayn.


In this post: 
Kalisto
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Liam is a writer and cranberry juice drinker from Lincolnshire. When he's not wearing his eyes away in front of a computer, he plays the melodica for a semi wrestling-themed folk-punk band called School Trips.