10 WWE Tag Teams That Broke Up Way Too Soon

WWE pulled the plug on these tandems much earlier than they should have.

MNM WWE
WWE.com

After only one year together on the main roster, Enzo Amore and Big Cass might be headed for a breakup if this angle involving Enzo's mystery attacker angle is any indication. Of course, Cass is bound to be revealed as the assailant sooner rather than later, forcing yet another popular tag team to part ways before they even came close to reaching their full potential.

Most tag teams break up at one point or another, it's just the way wrestling works. However, Enzo and Cass have barely scratched the surface of what they can accomplish as a tandem on Raw. In fact, they have yet to win a single set of tag team titles, so splitting them up, at least at this point anyway, is pretty premature.

Needless to say, they are far from the first duo in WWE's illustrious history to meet an untimely fate, as this has been a trend dating back years. Just as a tag team starts to hit the peak of their popularity, they are broken up, and it could be for a variety reasons. Whether it was because Vince McMahon saw singles potential in one of them or because nothing was being done with them creatively, their run was cut short when in reality it should have lasted a lot longer.

Either way, it doesn't take away from the fact that they should not have been split up when they were, with these ten talented tandems being prime examples.

10. The Bella Twins

bella twins
WWE.com

There were very few points in their eight years on WWE's main roster together that The Bella Twins were separated, and when they weren't on the same side of the squared circle, they were feuding. Although they briefly parted ways in the weeks preceding WrestleMania 25 (only to reunite coming out of the event), their first official breakup occurred at SummerSlam 2014 when Nikki Bella "shockingly" turned on her sister Brie.

Of course, it wasn't shocking in the slightest. In fact, just about everyone watching that night knew the turn was coming, and it wound up being the absolute worst thing to happen to the duo. Granted, it was high time both Bellas branched off into singles competition and established their own identities, but their feud was unbearable to watch unfold that fall.

Who could forget the classic "I wish you died in the womb" line? Or the atrocious "Growing Up Bella" promos from Nikki? On top of it all, the entire rivalry was for naught when they reunited at random at Survivor Series with zero explanation as to why. If nothing else, they were better together than they were apart, at least when Brie was still wrestling regularly.


9. The Hardy Boyz

Hardy Boyz
WWE.com

The Hardy Boyz have spent more time together than apart in their two decades in the wrestling business. While it was apparent early on both Matt and Jeff had bright futures as singles competitors later on down the road, that doesn't necessarily mean they should have been broken up as early as they were in late 2001.

Similar to The Bella Twins, The Hardy Boyz's breakup that year is typically forgotten by fans because of how short it lasted. WWE tried to turn Matt Hardy heel and have fellow Team Xtreme member Lita play peacemaker, but their lackluster Armageddon match forced officials to pull the plug on the experiment when they saw it wasn't working.

The Hardy Boyz continued to compete as a tandem through WrestleMania X8 before they were once again split up in the first-ever Brand Extension, with Matt going to SmackDown and Jeff staying on Raw. Both guys won gold on their respective shows, but it did a major disservice to the tag team division in WWE and they were at the height of their popularity as a unit.


8. The New Age Outlaws

New Age Outlaws Tag Titles
WWE

Fans didn't quite know the level of success that Road Dogg and Billy Gunn would reach as a tag team when they initially aligned in late 1997. Of course, it wasn't until they joined D-Generation X the night after WrestleMania XV that they really started to take off, quickly becoming the most beloved tandem in the entire company.

They won several tag team titles over the year that followed, just beginning to scratch the surface of what they were capable of before Dogg and Gunn branched off into the singles ranks at the onset of 1999. Each of them could have done their own thing without actually formally splitting up, but that didn't stop WWE from having Gunn betray his best friend that April because they had high hopes for him as a singles star.

Once Gunn flopped as the King of the Ring winner and Dogg's weaknesses as an in-ring competitor were exposed, they were quietly put back together in September 1999 and remained a unit until Dogg's departure from the company in 2001.


7. The Dudley Boyz

Dudley Boyz Royal Rumble
WWE.com

It's strange to say that a team that had been together for nearly six years by the time they first parted ways was broken up "too soon", but mind you, The Dudley Boyz had been around in WWE for only three years before they were unceremoniously split up in March 2002.

By that point, there were still many more tag team titles to be won by Bubba Ray and D-Von, either on Raw or SmackDown. Instead, Vince McMahon had it in his mind that it would be better to break up a majority of the longer-standing tag teams. Yes, we had seen The Dudley Boyz vs. The Hardy Boyz what felt like a thousand times over the course of those three years, but why not just place them on separate shows?

WWE attempted to push Bubba Ray and D-Von as singles acts, but failed miserably. Bubba Ray floundered for the better part of 2002 while D-Von's reverend gimmick was destined for undercard purgatory. Less than a year after their split, they reunited at Survivor Series in Madison Square Garden to a huge pop and went on to dominate the tag team ranks on Raw and SmackDown for the next three years.

Their 2010 breakup in TNA was long overdue, but it was premature to split them up in 2002.


6. La Resistance

la resistance
WWE.com

Considering the athletes involved, in all honesty, La Resistance should have been much bigger than they were in WWE. Rene Dupree and Sylvain Grenier looked like superstars, and although their anti-America gimmick was rather one-dimensional, it helped them elicit heat for a time in 2003.

Rob Conway was also a solid addition to the group later that summer, and by Bad Blood, they were World Tag Team champions. Haphazardous booking did them no favors, but their fall from grace was largely WWE's fault. Thus, the decision to split them up in the spring of 2004 because of the "Well, we tried" mindset was asinine.

More specifically, Grenier and Conway remained a unit on Raw while Dupree was drafted over to SmackDown. Grenier and Conway mostly went nowhere on Monday nights and later disbanded, and Grenier had a hot first month on the blue brand before fizzling out and becoming just another guy on the roster.

Dupree and Grenier briefly reunited on Raw in early 2007, but by that point, La Resistance was long gone. All three original members of the group were released one-by-one months later.


5. MNM

Mercury Nitro Melina MNM
WWE.com

SmackDown's tag team division needed all the help it could get in 2005, and thus the main roster call-up of Joey Mercury, Johnny Nitro, and Melina was much-needed. Collectively known as MNM, the trio wasted no time in taking the tag titles from Rey Mysterio and Eddie Guerrero in their debut match on the blue brand.

This immediately established them as a threat to the rest of the roster, and although they went on to lose the straps another two times in the next year, they always found a way to regain the gold. Mercury, Nitro, and Melina had tremendous chemistry as a trio and helped bring the division to new heights, which is why they should have stayed together a lot longer than one year.

Almost exactly one year removed from their arrival in WWE, Nitro turned on Mercury and moved over to Raw with Melina shortly thereafter. They amounted to great success on Monday nights, though Mercury wasn't as fortunate, returning to developmental following the breakup.

MNM had one more run together in the final few months of 2006 and into 2007 for a feud with The Hardy Boyz, but they came up short in every one of their encounters. WWE didn't get as much out of the tandem as they could have, despite what they saw in Nitro as a future breakout star.


4. World's Greatest Tag Team

World's Greatest Tag Team
WWE

Kurt Angle was already in exceptional shape as a singles star at the dawn of 2003, but putting the debuting Shelton Benjamin and Charlie Haas with him as part of Team Angle only added to the act. Because of how well they worked together as a tag team, it should have come as no surprise that Benjamin and Haas won the WWE Tag Team Championship no more than two months into their main roster run.

The World's Greatest Tag Team lived up to their lofty name by proceeding to contest classics with the likes of Eddie Guerrero and Tajiri, Rey Mysterio and Billy Kidman, and The APA. They were undoubtedly the best thing to happen to SmackDown's tag team division since the dissolution of the SmackDown Six, but of course, it didn't take long for WWE to ruin a good thing.

A little over a year after they came together on the main roster, Benjamin and Has were separated in the 2004 Draft Lottery when Benjamin was sent packing to Monday nights. There, he amounted to major singles success, winning the Intercontinental Championship multiple times, while Haas toiled away on the blue brand's undercard.

They reunited on a few different occasions in WWE in the years that followed, but they weren't the tandem they once were.


3. The Prime Time Players

Prime Time Players Raw June 22
WWE.com

At the time Darren Young and The Prime Time Players joined forces in February 2012, it was the best thing for them both, considering neither one of them were going anywhere on their own on NXT: Redemption. O'Neil was a talented talker and Young was decent in the ring, and together, they were a highly entertaining tandem.

Unfortunately, the timing was never right for them to capture the WWE Tag Team Championship at any point in 2012 or 2013. They embarked on a babyface run as a unit in the summer of 2013, getting over as fan favorites. Instead of sticking with them as a tag team, however, WWE opted to split them up in January 2014 because they saw singles potential in O'Neil.

Not only did the split come out of nowhere, the subsequent feud that followed between them was fairly forgettable, and they went on to accomplish nothing in the singles ranks. It was a total waste of a year until they put their differences aside in February 2015 and returned to the tag team division, eventually winning the WWE Tag Team Championship at Money in the Bank.

They split once again mere weeks after dropping the tag titles.


2. Carlito And Primo

Colons Carlito Primo
WWE.com

Primo was promoted from FCW to WWE's main roster at a very strange time in August 2008, shortly before SummerSlam where he was instantly lost in the shuffle on Raw. He won his debut match, disappeared from TV, and jumped ship over to SmackDown less than a month later where he and his brother Carlito came together as a tag team.

In their second only match together, they beat Curt Hawkins and Zack Ryder to become WWE Tag Team champions. It was an excellent use of both men, and obviously as brothers, their chemistry was strong. They didn't defend their twin titles a ton in the remainder of 2008, but they did have an enjoyable series of matches with John Morrison and The Miz heading into WrestleMania 25.

It was at The Show of Shows where they won the World Tag Team Championship and merged the tag titles for the first time. They reigned as Unified Tag Team champions for a few more months before dropping the straps in the summer to Edge and Chris Jericho and splitting up the very next week. But why?

Having been in WWE for five years by that point, it was evident Carlito was never going to be a breakout singles star, and Primo was certainly not ready to thrive in one-on-one competition. Carlito floundered up until his release from the company the subsequent spring.


1. The Wyatt Family

NXT Wyatt Family
WWE

At first glance, you'd think The Wyatt Family would have been one the most special attractions WWE has had in years, and upon their arrival on the main roster, they were. Bray Wyatt, Luke Harper, and Erick Rowan were largely protected and maintained their mystique for a while. That was, however, until they ran into the roadblock known as John Cena.

As if the flopped feud versus Cena wasn't bad enough, WWE continued to horribly handle The Wyatt Family in the remainder of 2014, making them look weak against Chris Jericho and Big Show on a handful of occasions. They then suddenly vanished from WWE programming that September before vignettes began to air indicating the group had parted ways.

The Wyatt Family had plenty of mileage left prior to their split, and none of them were any better off on their own (Harper didn't win a single match during his one month reign as Intercontinental champion). WWE should have reunited the stable far sooner than they did, but they were apparently too stubborn to admit defeat.

There have been various incarnations of The Wyatt Family over the years, but nothing will ever top that original trio of Wyatt, Harper, and Rowan that was broken up prematurely.


Contributor
Contributor

Since 2008, Graham has been a diehard pro wrestling fan and, in 2010, he combined his passions for WWE and writing when he joined Bleacher Report. Equipped with a master's in journalism, Graham has contributed to WhatCulture, FanSided's Daily DDT, Sports Betting Dime, and GateHouse Media. Along the way, he has conducted interviews with wrestling superstars like Chris Jericho, Edge, Goldberg, Christian, Diamond Dallas Page, Jim Ross, Adam Cole, Tessa Blanchard, Ryback, and Nick Aldis among others.