10 WWE Things That Only Made Sense With Hindsight

Hindsight is 20/20.

The Shield Breakup
WWE

It has been said that life is like a mosaic, in that its fleeting moments cannot be properly evaluated in isolation, but only when you take a step back to view them within their proper context.

That's probably a little too grandiose for professional wrestling, but the principle can be applied to a medium whose great heart-stopping, life-affirming moments are often preceded by months (and, in some cases, years) of laying the groundwork and testing the fan waters with a tentative elbow.

There have been many WWE moments over the last few years that have left long-suffering viewers scratching their heads: the wrong guy going over, a popular wrestler with designs on the main event inexplicably getting the shovel treatment, a gaping plot-hole seemingly left unaddressed.

Some of them, even years later, are still no closer to a resolution (at least not one that would really satisfy the fans). But occasionally, the loose ends just neatly tie themselves up at the last minute, and you grudgingly come round to the idea that, yes, it may have been a sensible decision after all.

Hindsight is 20/20, though.

10. R-Truth's Sudden Push

R Truth Capitol Punishment
WWE.com

It is stated in the wrestling booking handbook that a main event push must be preceded by a solid run in the mid-card, and any wrestlers who go directly from C to A are doomed to fail.

Whether R-Truth, who is today little more than a comedy figure, ever had the potential to be a top-level guy is up for debate, but coming from obscurity - though jarring initially - actually aided, as opposed to hindered, his run to the main event in 2011.

This is was because the former TNA star, now a heel, was able to make reference to a shady conspiracy keeping him from breaking through WWE's glass ceiling, which elevated him to the best run of his career, culminating in the headline spot of Capitol Punishment alongside John Cena.


9. AJ Styles Feuding With Shane

AJ Styles Shane McMahon
WWE.com

News that AJ Styles would be facing Shane McMahon at this year's WrestleMania was greeted with collective groans from the internet wrestling community, who feared that the 'Phenomenal One' - stuck in the ring with a 40-something authority figure - would be denied the opportunity to have his WrestleMania classic.

His WrestleMania classic, to be fair, could still be to come - but there's no denying that this one blew just about everyone's expectations out of the water, with the pair putting on what was easily the best match of the show, despite its low billing.

It was an illustration that we the fans don't always know best, and WWE - or someone at WWE, anyway - has an eye for a solid match pairing (as well as a reminder that AJ is the best worker in the company by a long way).


8. Seth Playing The Waiting Game

Seth Rollins Cash In
WWE.com

Seth Rollins' waiting game didn't make a great deal of sense, right up until the moment his music hit during WrestleMania 31's main event.

It became particularly confusing a couple of hours earlier, too, when 'The Architect' emerged second best in the show's opener against Randy Orton, seemingly dashing fans' hopes of seeing a cash-in later in the night (after all, you don't really have any right to challenge for the title after you've just taken a clean loss).

But give WWE their due: everything seemed all of a sudden neat and tidy when Triple H's protege came rushing down to the ring just as Lesnar had Roman beat, making the last few months of waiting in the wings seem instantly worthwhile (a prolonged feud with Jon Stewart possibly excepted).


7. Paul Heyman's Mind Games

Big Show Survivor Series 2002
WWE.com

Next to Sean O'Haire, Paul Heyman is probably wrestling's greatest advocate, but he doesn't always get it right. Case in point: his decision in 2002 to ditch Brock Lesnar to manage Big Show instead, a double-cross that was preceded by weeks of trying to talk 'The Next Big Thing' out of defending his WWE Championship at Survivor Series.

At the time, it seemed more than a little odd that Heyman was essentially playing down Lesnar's chances of beating Show, particularly off the back of back-to-back pay-per-view victories over Undertaker and SummerSlam's ground-shifting main event.

But things made sense when it became clear that Heyman was doing the bidding of his new client all along (even if dumping Brock for an older, slower model might be called into question).


6. HBK In JBL's Pocket

Shawn Michaels Bradshaw
PopScreen

Even Shawn Michaels wasn't safe from the 2008 recession; in fact, it turned out he had blown his family's savings, and had to perform odd jobs for JBL in order to earn it back.

Initially, that seemed like a pretty sure-fire way to emasculate the 'Heartbreak Kid', particularly off the back of his loss to Chris Jericho, a feud which also called his ability to protect and look after his loved ones into question.

But in hindsight, it actually did Michaels' career at the time a lot of good. After being comprehensively beaten (and, in some ways, humiliated) by Y2J, Mr. WrestleMania needed to tie up the loose ends and prove that he was, in fact, a man of integrity.

The segments were a little cringe-worthy, granted, but HBK emerged from his stint in JBL's pocket ready for a WrestleMania match with The Undertaker, and for that reason it served its purpose.


5. The Shield Break-Up

Shield Break Up
WWE.com

The Shield's implosion was great news for fans of gifs, but bad for those - i.e. most of us - who felt that the respective career prospects of Roman, Seth, and Dean were better served together than apart.

In the immediate aftermath, those fears seemed well-founded, with Seth becoming somehow less relevant after swapping a place in the hottest wrestling stable in a generation for one in Triple H's back-pocket.

But with hindsight, there's no getting away from the fact that it did him the world of good, helping him become a star in his own right and ultimately headline the following year's WrestleMania (albeit as a last minute addition to the match).

It also probably helped the two men he betrayed, as they too quickly established themselves as viable singles competitors not long after. A good move all round - regardless of how much we might miss them as a trio.


4. CM Punk Winning MITB Again

CM Punk Money In The Bank
WWE.com

There isn't a rule against a wrestler winning the Money in the Bank ladder match twice, but there probably should be.

The whole concept is practically designed to give fledgling talent a way to shoe-horn themselves into the main event, and its first four editions at least attempted to accomplish exactly that, with Edge, Rob Van Dam, Mr. Kennedy (sort of), and CM Punk finally getting their big breaks.

But for number five, CM Punk won again, which seemed odd for a little while - until he brilliantly cashed it in on fan-favourite Jeff Hardy, cementing the heel turn he had desperately needed for close to a year after his inaugural title reign ended in such a nondescript manner. This was great booking, albeit 12 months too late.


3. Triple H And Steph's Wedding

Triple H Steph Wedding
WWE Network

Marriage rules are being relaxed the world over, but one thing generally remains constant: both participants must be conscious during the ceremony.

That's why, on first viewing, it seemed strange that the Las Vegas drive-thru at which Triple H elected to tie the knot with Stephanie had no qualms about reading them their nuptials despite the fact that Vince's daughter was visibly unresponsive, having (presumably) been kidnapped and drugged by her husband-to-be.

A while later, we would find out that Stephanie was in on it the whole time, and faked being unconscious for some shocking video footage, because reasons. Test - who nearly landed the gig of the chairman's son-in-law - was understandably left heartbroken, but she let him down as gently as she possibly could.


2. Goldberg Burying Lesnar

Brock Lesnar Goldberg
WWE.com

It was shocking to see Goldberg make light work of Brock Lesnar at Survivor Series, and perhaps even more shocking two months later when he repeated the feat during the Royal Rumble.

The second of which, in particular, left many fans scratching their heads, wondering exactly how much humiliation WWE was prepared to heap on one of its prized assets in the name of helping a 50-year-old part-timer relive his yesteryear glory.

But fast forward a few months and all is right with the WWE universe, with Lesnar back where he belongs as Raw's unstoppable world champion.

So how did happen? The story of Lesnar underestimating his opponent - not once, but twice - simply worked thanks to some stellar character work from the 'Beast Incarnate' (and his advocate), who proved that his defeats were mere anomalies with a dominant display of his own at WrestleMania.


1. HBK Going Over Jericho

Shawn Michaels Chris Jericho Judgement Day 2008.jpg
WWE.com

Chris Jericho's 2008 feud with Shawn Michaels was a flash-point in the career of Y2J, who was beginning to see his return momentum from the year before fall away after a few months floundering in the mid-card.

But the first victory of the series went to HBK, a decision that baffled many onlookers at the time, given that the Texan went into the match in the midst of the midlife crisis that followed his retiring Ric Flair at WrestleMania XXIV.

Looking at the storyline in its complete form, however, this was a master-stroke. It emboldened Jericho's conviction that Shawn - who had faked injury against Batista the month before - wasn't a man to be trusted, and set him on the path to becoming a more potent force once he turned heel.


Contributor