10 WWE Title Matches Nobody Asked For

Because who cares what the fans want anyway?

roman reigns triple h wrestlemania 30
WWE.com

Think back to some of the WWE Title matches you were desperate to see, like Stone Cold vs. The Rock from WrestleMania X-Seven or even the 'Ultimate Challenge' from 'Mania VI between Hulk Hogan and The Ultimate Warrior. Title bouts should be the pinnacle of any card they're featured on. The key word there is should, but that's not always the case.

Sometimes, WWE present matches nobody wanted in the first place. Maybe a performer not involved was on a hot streak at the time and fans wanted to see them in that spot, or perhaps the match just felt totally random and out of place. If you need a modern example, then Shinsuke Nakamura's bland title shot against Jinder Mahal at SummerSlam 2017 fits the bill.

Mere months earlier at Money in the Bank, it looked like WWE were setting the scene for Nakamura vs. AJ Styles. That was scrapped (or at least put on the back burner) in favour of a short build towards the Japanese star's crack at Jinder.

Who cares what the fans want to see, eh?


10. Hulk Hogan Vs. Yokozuna (King Of The Ring 1993)

Hulk Hogan Yokozuna
WWE.com

Bret Hart was doing just fine as WWF Champion before the almighty Hulk Hogan decided to show back up and sweep Vince McMahon off his feet in 1993. Hart represented a different kind of champ, and fans were getting on board with his athletic, in-ring focused main events against guys like Shawn Michaels and Razor Ramon.

WrestleMania IX changed that when Hulk swanned back in and took the title from Yokozuna to close out the show. The very first King of the Ring pay-per-view then featured a rematch between Hulk and Yoko for the belt, although that match wasn't the main event. Thankfully, McMahon saw sense and focused the show on Bret's tournament win instead.

Still, the slow pace of Yokozuna vs. Hogan harked back to a bygone era the WWF had moved on from in Hulk's absence. Once the nostalgic buzz of Hogan's return had worn off, and fans at King of the Ring were audibly disinterested in the dated style of the 'Foreign Heel vs. American Hero' clash.


9. Shawn Michaels Vs. Ken Shamrock (In Your House: D-Generation X)

Ken Shamrock Shawn Michaels
WWE.com

The entire wrestling world was still reeling from the events of November's Survivor Series by the time In Your House: D-Generation X happened the following month. People were struggling to come to terms with the idea that Bret Hart had been screwed by the WWF and moved to WCW, and Hart's departure left a sizeable hole in the main event scene.

Looking to move on quickly from the 'Montreal Screwjob' (ironic, given WWE's incessant need to bring it up any chance they get these days), Shawn Michaels faced the fresh face of Ken Shamrock for the WWF Title in the main event. That wasn't quite the match fans wanted, especially after something so earth-shattering had rocked the federation to its core.

Cast as the 'Black Hart', Owen Hart would have made more sense against Michaels and his DX cronies at In Your House. Gifting Shamrock a hasty title shot just felt out of step amidst the backdrop of real-life drama. The match wasn't bad, but it felt like a TV headliner rather than pay-per-view.


8. John Cena Vs. R-Truth (Capitol Punishment 2011)

John Cena R Truth Capitol Punishment
WWE.com

WWE haven't presented another Capitol Punishment show since, meaning R-Truth's WWE Title shot against John Cena wasn't the only one-off in June, 2011. The pay-per-view poster depicted then-US President Barrack Obama in a referee's shirt, with Rey Mysterio and John Cena on either side of him.

That might've been a better main event than Truth vs. Cena was, and that's even allowing for the former's great work as an unpredictable, borderline deranged heel. R-Truth did everything he could to whip up interest in his title match, but the fact remained that nobody seriously believed he'd beat Cena. This was a 'B' level headliner at best.

Sandwiched in between the end of Cena's feud with The Miz and the start of his brilliant series with CM Punk, the Truth match just kinda' existed. Until reading about it here, there's even a chance some fans had forgotten it even happened in the first place.


7. Triple H Vs. Roman Reigns (WrestleMania 32)

triple h roman reigns.jpg
WWE.com

Oh how you've tried, WWE. The ceaseless attempts to make Roman Reigns the greatest babyface in company history continue even to this day, although Vince McMahon has realised that this is akin to bashing one's head against the nearest brick wall. Fans just don't want to cheer Reigns as a hero, and they haven't for years.

The big plan for WrestleMania 32 was to stack the odds against Reigns in a bold attempt to endear him to an audience who had long since made their minds up. To say it didn't work would be a gross understatement; fans spent much of the build booing Roman and cheering Triple H, which was the exact opposite reaction to the feud WWE wanted.

Come crunch time at 'Mania, people rebelled yet again on the main event. There was a sense that Reigns vs. Triple H could have worked earlier in the card, but giving the match close to 30 minutes at the end of a near six-hour show was a recipe for disaster.

It's almost like WWE wanted Reigns to be heel.


6. Triple H Vs. The Great Khali (SummerSlam 2008)

Great Khali Vice Grip Triple H SummerSlam 2008
www.wwe.com

Triple H isn't getting out of the woods just yet, because he's had more than one unwanted WWE Title match during his career. We'll give his feud with Roman Reigns some credit, because at least it was more progressive than a mind-numbing showdown with The Great Khali at SummerSlam 2008. Exactly who asked for this one?

Almost a full month on from producing an under-rated gem against Edge at The Great American Bash, Triple H had to work around Khali's limitations on the biggest pay-per-view of the summer. This was complete throwaway when the WWE Title match at SummerSlam needed to be everything but.

Khali's aura had evaporated by the summer of '08. The freak show quality of his matches was old hat, but that didn't stop WWE from trying to squeeze another marquee match out of the big Indian. What resulted was a tame 10-minute affair that the card wouldn't have missed. Even writing that about a WWE Title match feels rotten, but it's true.


5. Jinder Mahal Vs. Randy Orton (Backlash 2017)

Jinder Mahal Randy Orton
WWE.com

Randy Orton and Jinder Mahal couldn't have had more different experiences at WrestleMania 33. Whilst Orton was defeating Bray Wyatt to win the WWE Title, Mahal was thrown from the ring by Mojo Rawley (remember him?) in a 33-man Battle Royal during the pre-show. The next month, Mahal was beating Orton for the title.

Talk about a rapid build; Jinder was plucked from the undercard and placed in the WWE Title mix within a matter of weeks. One week, he was just another guy on the roster, the next, he was 'The Modern Day Maharaja' and WWE's hand-picked new heel booked to dominate SmackDown. Meanwhile, fan opinion nestled somewhere between shock and apathy.

As nice as it was that WWE were trying to push someone new, the title shot Mahal received at Backlash was totally unexpected. It was brave to ask that fans forget about Jinder's recent history as borderline enhancement talent, just as it was to expect Mahal vs. Orton to be a match people flocked to see.


4. Sycho Sid Vs. The Undertaker (WrestleMania 13)

Undertaker, Sid, WrestleMania 13
WWE.com

Curse you, Shawn Michaels. Had you not 'lost your smile' before WrestleMania 13, then we may have witnessed a much-anticipated rematch with Bret Hart on the biggest show of the year. Things worked out alright for Hart (he had a blistering Submission Match against Steve Austin instead), but the 'Mania main event didn't fare so well.

Just starting to creep out of his slow, zombie-like style inside the ring, The Undertaker was faced with the prospect of dragging Sycho Sid to a passable big man match to close out the pay-per-view. The tacked on No DQ stipulation didn't help things as hoped either. 'Taker vs. Sid was not a good match, and it went over 20 minutes.

This wasn't the main event fans wanted to see at 'Mania 13. A Submission Match between Hart and Michaels would have been much better. Yes, the absence of HBK did allow for Stone Cold to grab the spotlight, but sitting through that main event was torturous at the time.


3. Brock Lesnar Vs. Hardcore Holly (Royal Rumble 2004)

Brock Lesnar Hardcore Holly
WWE.com

Hardcore Holly's only WWE Title shot on pay-per-view was the least exciting match on the Royal Rumble 2004 card. That shouldn't come as a surprise, because Holly had been presented as a midcarder for his entire run with the company up until WWE tried to quickly turn him into a realistic challenger for the beast-like Lesnar.

6 minutes and 30 seconds later, Hardcore's title dreams were shattered and the revenge storyline pinning down the build was ignored from that point on. Holly had targeted Lesnar due to suffering a broken neck at his hands in 2002. Fans were willing to invest initially (and probably would have enjoyed a SmackDown match), but the Royal Rumble was a step too far.

This was stop gap booking, something which should never happen at the Royal Rumble. The next month, Eddie Guerrero would rise to the top and beat Lesnar for the WWE Title, and the positive reaction to that win only outlined just how subdued the response had been to Holly's brief push.


2. Randy Orton Vs. Big Show (Survivor Series 2013)

Big Show Randy Orton
WWE.com

He was already popular before then, but the storyline screwing of Daniel Bryan at SummerSlam 2013 only intensified fan desire to see the underdog become a genuine WWE headliner. Matches against Randy Orton at Night of Champions, Battleground, and Hell in a Cell bolstered claims that he was ready, but it had all gone to pot by Survivor Series.

Suddenly, Big Show was drafted in as an emotional babyface. He was a step down from the world-class Bryan, and everybody knew it. By the time it was clear WWE planned to present Show one-on-one with Randy Orton at Survivor Series, groans were audible; that creative also had the temerity to book Show to stand up for Bryan (like the underdog needed anyone's help) was also irritating.

The match between Show and Orton couldn't live up to the dynamic sequences Randy and Bryan had worked on the three consecutive pay-per-views before it. Show's involvement in Bryan's feud with The Authority was avoidable and just shouldn't have happened.


1. Diesel Vs. 'King' Mabel (SummerSlam 1995)

Mabel, King Mabel, Viscera, King of the Ring
WWE.com

After winning the 1995 King Of The Ring (a situation few could have predicted), 'King' Mabel was geared up for a WWF Title bout against Diesel at SummerSlam. The match was about as bad as you'd expect. Quite why Vince McMahon thought this was a solid idea is anyone's guess; the clumsy, reckless Mabel must be considered one of the worst pushes in WWE history.

There was no chance Diesel vs. Mabel was going to be able to follow a ladder match between Shawn Michaels and Razor Ramon from earlier that night. The dreadful headliner couldn't even top Bret Hart's match with Isaac Yankem D.D.S or a dreary casket match pitting The Undertaker against Kama. By far, the WWF Title match was the one fans were least hyped to see on the show.

Mabel's performance showed why he should never have been in such a lofty position at SummerSlam. He and Diesel struggled to pad out their nine-minute match and the challenger even dangerously sat his full weight on the champion's back near the end.

-

Which other WWE Title matches do you feel nobody wanted at the time? Let us know down in the comments section!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.