10 WWE Vs. NJPW Matches Fans Dream About

It's the promotional dream war fans crave, and these are the matches we fantasize.

NJPW Naito Roman Reigns 2
NJPW/WWE

This week, wrestling fans were given a treat they never thought they would get. Chris Jericho, after saying for years he would only ever work for Vince McMahon, broke his vow and began a salacious affair with New Japan Pro Wrestling following a 20 year absence. He wrestled Kenny Omega in a match that exceeded all expectations and arguably stole the show. Now, everyone is asking when Chris Jericho will return for more dream matches with other New Japan superstars.

Dream matches are easier when you're not signed to WWE. With other companies lacking the exclusivity Vince McMahon requires, wrestlers are better able to have the matches fans crave, regardless of style or region. Still, fans can't help but think about an ideal world in which WWE tear down its walls and allow their talent to play with others. Specifically, what would happen if WWE stars clashed with New Japan wrestlers?

Be it because of wrestling style, storyline intrigue, or clashes of persona, these are the matches we can only see in our wildest of dreams in a WWE vs. New Japan war.

10. The New Day Vs. The Elite

NJPW Elite New Day
NJPW/WWE

The Elite, the subgroup of Bullet Club headed by Kenny Omega and the Young Bucks, are one of the most popular wrestling acts on the internet. With their YouTube series "Being The Elite," their mix of high spots and comedy, and their irreverent, meta-attitude online, the Elite seem to understand perfectly who wrestling fans are in 2018. The comparisons to the New Day are obvious, given that group's affinity for goofy humor, tongue-in-cheek gesturing, and Xavier Woods' exploits on YouTube with his gaming show "Up Up Down Down." Fans would love to see these two groups throw down and determine who are the real Gods of Geekdom.

What's funny, or perhaps heartbreaking, about this matchup is that Omega has in fact tried to make it happen. In a recent interview, he admitted that he was making appeals to the powers that be to let this interpromotional match go ahead, saying that it would set the wrestling world on fire and make money for both sides. Hardcore wrestling fans would heartily agree with Omega's sentiment, but alas, until the politics change, it's just a mere sentiment.


9. Sheamus Vs. Tomohiro Ishii

NJPW Ishii Sheamus
NJPW/WWE

Sheamus is the world's friendliest rooster. He's also a big lad who likes to pummel you until you're red. Tomohiro Ishii is the world's most adorable pitbull. He's also a small bloke who likes to pummel you until you're red. I think this is the making of a beautiful friendship: a friendship that involves lots of chopping.

The muscle of Chaos, the group founded by the King of Strong Style himself Shinsuke Nakamura, Ishii has gained a reputation as one of the best hard-hitting wrestlers in the world. His matches are frenetic, intense battles with hard chops, power moves, and stiff punches that even the nosebleed sections can hear.

His most obvious WWE opponent is Sheamus. While Vince's apartment of bombardment isn't known for strong style, that has not stopped Sheamus from kicking the absolute jimmy out of his opponents. From stiff punches to stiff kicks, the Celtic Warrior will make sure you the audience hears and feels the pain. I can't think of anyone more suited to give him a lesson in what real pain is than the Stone Pitbull.


8. Finn Bálor And The Club Vs. Bad Luck Fale, Tama Tonga, And Tanga Loa

NJPW Guerillas Of Destiny Finn Balor Club
NJPW/WWE

Finn Bálor, back then Prince Devitt, originally founded the Bullet Club in 2013 alongside Tama Tonga, Bad Luck Fale, and the good brother himself, Karl Anderson. In the months that followed, members such as the Young Bucks and Luke Gallows followed suit, and the group became one of the most popular factions in wrestling. As the years wore on, Devitt, Gallows, and Anderson eventually found themselves in WWE, but Bullet Club maintains to this day. While WWE have teased and alluded to the Bullet Club in the past, there's been no official reunion of the OG leaders until recently, when Bálor aligned with newly face Gallows and Anderson, culminating in a two sweet gesture.

However, it's still not the real Bullet Club. Fale and the Guerrillas of Destiny remain the heart and soul of a group that has a revolving door of bosses. Devitt and Anderson were the original pulse of Bullet Club, and with Gallows, a matchup against GOD and Fale would be a BC family reunion fans would be dying to see. However, given BC's attitude about loyalty (especially Tama Tonga), I don't expect hugs, kisses, and two-sweets for the WWE guys.


7. Andrade "Cien" Almas Vs. Tetsuya Naito

NJPW Naito Almas
NJPW/WWE

Right now, Tetsuya Naito is the leader of Los Ingobernables De Japon, a spinoff of the Los Ingobernables stable from CMLL. The original leader of that stable was La Sombra, a luchador who mentored Naito during his Mexican excursion and helped him shed the Stardust Genius persona.

In the years that followed, La Sombra left CMLL and rebranded himself as Andrade "Cien" Almas. Like his friend Naito, he found great difficulty ingratiating himself to audiences as a babyface. Nearly doomed to irrelevance in NXT, Almas gained a new attitude (and an attractive manager), and quickly rose through the ranks as one of the brand's top heels.

These changes paid off some months ago, with Almas dethroning Drew Galloway as the NXT Champion. Years after helping Tetsuya Naito with his own glow-up, Almas has now done the same for himself. If the two former allies were ever to meet in a hypothetical dream match, fans would bask in the history between the two as each man is a mirror of the other.

Plus, who wouldn't love to see Zelina Vega do a hurricanrana on Naito?


6. Neville Vs. KUSHIDA

NJPW Kushida Neville
Defiant Wrestling/WWE

Given Neville's uncertain status after walking out, this match actually has the most potential of happening in real life. However, for the time being, the King of the Cruiserweights is stuck in WWE, and so a dream match with the Time Splitter himself is just a fantasy.

Seen also in Ring of Honor and Defiant Wrestling, KUSHIDA is the ace of New Japan's junior heavyweight champion. His mixture of aerial expertise and technical acumen has earned him the reputation as one of the best small guys in the world right now. Neville, conversely, has shown that he is one of the best in-ring talents signed to WWE, putting on stellar matches and dragging the reborn Cruiserweight division out of its early dregs into something respectable. A match between these two immediately has a King Kong vs. Godzilla vibe, if King Kong and Godzilla were basically midgets, of course.

Like I said, after walking out, Neville might really be done with WWE. So we can hold out hope we might finally see the Pro Wrestling World Cup winner finally take on Nevil-er-PAC, I suppose he'd be called.


5. Shinsuke Nakamura Vs. Cody

NJPW Cody Shinsuke Nakamura
NJPW/WWE

Nakamura and Cody have very similar stories. They both saw that their respective promotions had nothing more for them. Cody was stuck with a bad gimmick and no airtime in WWE, and Nakamura was losing his top guy status with no clear direction for him in New Japan. It was time for both men to move on.

Cody asked for his release, and proceeded to use his star power and connections to become one of the most popular wrestlers on the indie scene, joining the Bullet Club and the New Japan roster. Nakamura, meanwhile, came in on a red carpet in NXT and quickly became champion, and while his main roster run has been less fruitful, he still has the swagger and charisma to keep him over.

Here we have two men who decided enough was enough and it was time for a change. They left the promotions that made them superstars, and found success in enemy territory. A match between the King of Strong Style and the American Nightmare would be the intriguing battle between two traitors who are now stalwarts of the opposing team.


4. Roman Reigns Vs. Tetsuya Naito

NJPW Naito Roman Reigns
NJPW/Roman Reigns

It must not have been easy for Roman Reigns. Picked by WWE to be the next top sympathetic babyface, his big push was rejected by the fanbase, and he became a polarizing figure (to put it generously). Obviously now, Reigns has embraced his hated babyface role with the same gusto as John Cena before him, but for a time, it must have been demoralizing to go from being the next big thing to the big thing no one wants.

Tetsuya Naito was in a similar situation. In 2013, after overcoming knee surgery and winning the G1 Climax, the Stardust Genius seemed destined to defeat Kazuchika Okada and become the next top star of New Japan. However, greater fan interest in the Okada/Tanahashi program and a lack of enthusiasm for the forced push of Naito derailed those plans, as he became hated.

Roman Reigns and Tetsuya Naito have career trajectories that parallel and come at a distinct diverging point, with New Japan embracing Naito's negative reaction and making him the tranquilo antihero. In any case, a hypothetical matchup between the two top babyface experiments would carry heavy intrigue.


3. Randy Orton Vs. Kazuchika Okada

NJPW Okada Randy Orton
NJPW/WWE

One of JBL's favorite go-to phrases during his commentary days was "If you built a superstar from the ground up, you'd get Randy Orton," alluding to the fact that the third generation wrestler has the physical and aesthetic assets that make him a prototypical top guy. In that same way, Kazuchika Okada looks and moves like he was built to lead a company. The IWGP Heavyweight Champion is a tall, blonde, and built wrestler who is made to look and act like the biggest deal in the world.

Aside from aesthetics, Randy Orton and Kazuchika Okada are strangely similar in-ring as well. While Okada is generally considered above and beyond as one of the best wrestlers in the world, Randy Orton has earned much praise from those in the industry for his ability to work the crowd and put together a match. Cody Rhodes in fact compared Orton and Okada, saying the latter had the most WWE superstar quality out of the New Japan roster.

When you combine that with each man having incredibly over finishing maneuvers, you have the making of an exciting dream match.


2. John Cena Vs. Hiroshi Tanahashi

NJPW Tanahashi Cena
NJPW/WWE

Hiroshi Tanahashi is the man responsible for New Japan's current boom period. After a dark age of terrible booking and lackluster talent that plagued the company in the mid-2000s, Tanahashi's natural charisma, babyface fire, and talent gave New Japan an identity that it has used to rebuild itself.

The most obvious comparison among Tanahashi's Western comparisons is John Cena. The man held down the fort in WWE for over a decade, and even as he's stepped into an elder statesman role to focus on outside projects, he has still left a massive hole at the top that's yet to be sufficiently filled.

As both men are in their 40s now, and both are loyal stalwarts of their respective promotions, this dream match is likely never to happen. However, if it did, fans would be enamored by the sight of the two great top babyfaces of their generation squaring off. Tanahashi is considered one of the greatest workers of the 21st century, and Cena's only gotten better with age at putting matches together. With Cena's trilogy with AJ Styles being a classic, a program with the Ace would be just as, if not, better.


1. AJ Styles Vs. Kenny Omega

NJPW Kenny Omega AJ Styles
NJPW/WWE

Kenny Omega seems to have no major interest in actually defecting to WWE like the former Bullet Club leaders before him. Why would he? He's one of the top stars in New Japan, and is set to be the poster child for their expansion into the West. He's wrestling the best talent in the world, and there's not a single person in WWE he could conceivably want to feud with.

Oh, except for AJ Styles, that is.

Omega has expressed online that he still needs to have a dream match with AJ Styles at some point in his career. Makes sense. Styles is a legend in his own right, and having taken WWE by storm, he's now one of the most popular wrestlers in the world. A Styles-Omega match, with its Bullet Club history and the assurance of in-ring quality would arguably be on the same level of hype as Omega's match with Chris Jericho.

Although, if Kenny wants that match with AJ, he might have to consider his future carefully. Styles is in his 40s, and is seemingly not interested in wrestling into his 50s or leaving WWE. So the clock is ticking on this dream encounter.

Would Kenny seriously come to WWE just to wrestle AJ? We can only wait and see.


Contributor
Contributor

A mystery wrapped in an enigma wrapped in bacon wrapped in wrestling listicles wrapped in tin foil wrapped in seaweed wrapped in gak.