10 WWE Worst WrestleMania Gimmick Matches
A lot of set up, precious little pay off.
If there’s any time to pull out the stops, it’s WrestleMania.
The 'Show Of Shows' is WWE’s chance to draw the eyes of the world to its product, and to attract an audience who might be devotees, lapsed fans, or casual viewers, it’s important to put on a smorgasbord of entertainment.
This means matches that go beyond simple one on one grappling. A great WrestleMania gimmick match can take the form way beyond the simple showdown, incorporating ladders and cells, or comedy and invention, to entice a broader crowd.
A bad WrestleMania gimmick match, though, can be disastrous. From the ill executed to the badly conceived, from those that could have been good but fell apart to the ideas that were dreadful from the off, making a mess of a complex stipulation bout can be far more damaging to the product than any ponderous singles fight.
Whether these matches are so bad they’re perversely enjoyable or just plain drivel, these are the times the bookers have attempted to add a little spice to the stew and ended up making something entirely inedible.
10. Dean Ambrose vs Brock Lesnar (WrestleMania 32)
There’s an element of grading on a curve here - unlike a lot of the matches on this list, this street fight isn’t downright terrible. Ambrose is massively charismatic, and Lesnar carries an undeniable aura and sells well when called upon to do so.
With the talent involved, though, this should have been far better. It’s a street fight in name only, tame even by WWE’s PG era. Ambrose swings a kendo stick and a chair a few times and lets off a fire extinguisher; Brock demonstrates that he’s more powerful than any weapon.
All this leads to a match that should have been bonkers and brutal but winds up quite dull. Most frustratingly, this seems to be due to Lesnar’s unwillingness to take it up a notch. Ambrose has since discussed his attempt to pitch something exciting and crazy, but Lesnar wasn’t interested, even though all of Ambrose’s notions were for spots that would do dreadful damage to him and make the Beast look more brutal still.
No one was expecting Ambrose to actually utilise Terry Funk’s chainsaw to slice Brock in half, but this was flagrant false advertising: we were sold a rampage and wound up with a run of the mill match. We’re not angry, we’re just disappointed.
9. Gimmick Battle Royale (WrestleMania X-Seven)
This is bad like The Room is bad. Don’t get it twisted: the gimmick battle royale is a terrible piece of wrestling, featuring all the silliest wrestlers from the past several generations, including but not limited to the Bushwhackers, Kamala, Hillbilly Jim, and Earthquake.
Most of the participants no longer have it, if indeed they ever did. Many of them had long since departed the business, tempted back by the promise of the spotlight, or a quick payday, or both.
The work, then, is sloppy, but the nostalgia on offer here is downright delightful, and it’s capped off by the guest commentary team of Mean Gene Okerlund and Bobby Heenan, who quip and chuckle their way through the brief runtime. In one particularly memorable quip, Heenan states that the Iron Sheik won’t make it to the ring until WrestleMania 38, so we’ll see him in a few weeks.
Sheik gets the win, then receives the Cobra Clutch courtesy of Sergeant Slaughter. By any standards it’s one of the worst gimmick matches in WrestleMania history, but it could be the most watchable.
8. Bret Hart vs Bob Backlund (WrestleMania XI)
Bob Backlund made a surprise return to WWE in 1992, and acquitted himself surprisingly well. While his straight laced character didn’t initially fit the colourful era, he made the necessary adjustments and even briefly held the world title.
Within that run, though, is this dud, an I Quit match against Bret Hart that stands as one of the Hitman’s few WrestleMania clunkers. The two technically gifted grapplers feel like a good fit, but the match quickly descends into a sequence of holds and counters delivered at a creeping pace. It’s less an I Quit match than a masterclass on how to use submissions to bore a crowd.
It’s made surreal by the presence of guest referee Roddy Piper, who queries the competitors as to whether or not they wish to quit far too frequently, and at a level of enthusiasm way out of whack with the match itself.
Bret Hart wins, which is the right call, but Backlund doesn’t even say “I quit”, instead just garbling something indecipherable into Piper’s mic. It’s easy to see how this could have been good - unfortunately, in practise, it isn’t.
7. Akebono vs Big Show (WrestleMania 21)
When Paul Wight jumped from WWE to AEW in 2021, it was a huge surprise. Here was a man who’d been one of WWE’s most loyal servants, leaving his tenured post for pastures new.
Remembering how he was treated at times, though, it’s perhaps more surprising he didn’t leave sooner. There’s plenty of scope for debate around the nadir of Big Show’s career, but exhibit A must be the exhibition sumo match with Akebono at WrestleMania 21.
Akebono was a legitimate sumo star, but that fame didn’t translate too well to the US. While we’re by no means sumo experts, this didn’t look like a great example of the form, with Big Show bested by the veteran in a minute, both mercifully and pointlessly brief.
As far as wrestling ribs go, this one’s pretty grandiose. Someone backstage thought it would be funny to dress good old Paul up in sumo garb and have him look a fool at the company’s flagship show (it’s rumoured this was a punishment following weight gain). It’s sort of funny, for a bit, but then it just becomes depressing.
6. Edge vs Randy Orton (WrestleMania 36)
Edge’s return at the 2020 Royal Rumble was the feel good moment of a year light on them. The Hall Of Famer was back - the possibilities were endless. The roster boasted abundant dream matches, and so his immediate rivalry with Randy Orton felt a tad deflating - we’ve seen this plenty. Still, a last man standing match at WrestleMania sounds like a good time, right?
More like a long time. It would be unfair to call this match downright bad, but it wore out its welcome long before it creaked to the finish. The two stalked each other around the empty performance centre for almost forty minutes, stopping to exchange punches or weapons shots then back to shuffling around.
More than any other match in the empty arena era, this one felt eerie, with long action-free stretches highlighting how badly the crowds were missed. The idea was for a grand sense of scale; instead it was just a grind.
The finish went for high emotion as Edge bashed Orton’s head atop a production truck for the win, but instead of gasps, all the fans gave was a collective sigh of relief it was over. Two years later, we’re getting the Edge/A.J Styles showdown we’ve been clamouring for, and assuming it’s less than 40 minutes long, it should be a cracker.
5. Torrie Wilson vs Candice Michelle (WrestleMania 22)
This one is a “Playboy Pillow Fight” match. There’s not really a whole lot more we need to say, really.
Oh, alright then. This was during WWE’s charming phase of encouraging one of its female stars to pose for Playboy; doing so would most likely net you a spot on the WrestleMania card. Here it was Candice Michelle who did the honours, and wound up in a match that serves as four minutes of titillation for the crowd.
Michelle and Wilson give a game effort, but there’s no way they’re going to put anything decent together with the pillow fight stipulation and the fact that female talent was often actively discouraged from attempting anything resembling actual wrestling during this era.
There’s a sizeable portion of the fan base who were tuning in for this kind of business, so hopefully they managed to get what they needed out of this four minute affair, but for the rest of us, it’s the kind of wrestling you’d hate to be caught watching (even more than most wrestling).
4. Bret Hart Vs Vince McMahon (WrestleMania XXVI)
It took a lot to bring Bret Hart back to the WWE fold, such were the scars left by his departure and the loss of his brother Owen. He needed to return with a bang, and on the surface the idea of taking on Vince McMahon at WrestleMania was a fine one. Logic would dictate that the elderly former wrestler with a chip on his shoulder would swiftly but comprehensively batter the even older promoter, and the old wounds would heal accordingly.
Instead, this was made far too complex. It turned into a lumberjack match, with the rest of the Hart family paid by Vince to turn on Bret. This was a ruse, though, and swiftly descended into a load of guys watching as Bret methodically took Vince apart.
For a gruelling 11 minutes, Bret worked on Vince’s spine to soften him up for the inevitable sharpshooter finish. It was unnecessary and pretty unedifying, not to mention deadly dull. Still, hopefully Bret got a little catharsis out of it.
3. The Fiend vs Randy Orton (WrestleMania 37)
We’re bending the rules slightly as the gimmickry took place outside the ring and in the build up - what followed on night two of WrestleMania 37 was a straightforward wrestling match, which was exactly the problem.
The saga of Orton and The Fiend included immolation, resurrection, and Alexa Bliss turning into a creepy schoolgirl (and attempted home wrecker, drawing the ire of Orton’s wife for a suggestive pin). The two men repeatedly attempted to murder one another, with Randy going so far as to douse Wyatt in lighter fluid and set him ablaze (then do his little pose).
So when the WrestleMania blow off was a six minute bog standard bout which got no crazier than Bliss causing a distraction by emitting black goo from her forehead, eyebrows were raised.
This was dire stuff, the limp ending to a feud that few people enjoyed. We could have had another Firefly Funhouse match, or some other inspired nonsense. Instead we got an RKO outta nowhere to bring the empty arena era’s worst business to a boring conclusion.
2. The Undertaker vs Big Boss Man (WrestleMania XV)
During his legendary career, The Undertaker has taken part in some of the finest Hell In A Cell matches we’re ever likely to see, but his record is by no means unblemished. This oh-so-Attitude Era match sees the Deadman step inside the structure with The Corporation’s own head of security for 10 minutes of nothing.
There are problems from the off in the form of the video package, which focuses exclusively on ‘Taker vs Vince McMahon, with Bossman barely getting a look-in. That heatless quality extends to the match. These two big men were veterans and immensely talented, but there’s nothing to latch onto here, neither seeming interested in doing much beyond walking and punching
The crowd don’t even try to get into the match. Goofiness abounds as Bossman handcuffs Undertaker to the cage only for the cuffs to immediately break. Eventually after a long 10 minutes Undertaker hits a Tombstone and we’re done.
What follows is the infamous spot of Undertaker hanging Bossman, and while it’s a bonkers visual, it’s easily the most engaging part of the match. Used to end a feud with some actual venom, it would still be quite stupid, but effective.
1. Miss WrestleMania Battle Royale (WrestleMania XXV)
With the odd exception, WWE let down its women’s division pretty badly - we’ve already discussed the great pillow fight of ‘06. It truly bottoms out here, though, in a match that manages to waste the time of 24 of the company’s female wrestlers, fail to entertain the crowd, and climaxes with something deeply insulting.
It all starts with Kid Rock. The Detroit noisemaker played a remarkably long set as the women shuffled past him , with their identities purposefully kept hush hush. From there, it was your standard WrestleMania battle royale, i.e quick, pointless, and giving almost no one a chance to shine.
Every battle royale has a winner, though, and this one was a doozy: Santina Marella, i.e the comedy wrestler Santino Marella in a dress. There were plenty of possible choices for the victor here, including Mickie James and Gail Kim (both of whom would shortly depart the company) and Beth Phoenix.
Instead, WWE sold out an entire roster for the sake of a quick gag. It was not well received, but thankfully they learned their lesson. No, hang on - they did essentially the exact same thing for the first women’s Money In The Bank match.