10 WWE Wrestlers Who Should NEVER Have Come Back

"Never go back", said no wrestler ever when the price was right. But which returns were the worst?

Kurt Angle
WWE.com

Buried - in more ways than one - in this list are a series of wrestlers that have been responsible for some of the greatest moments and matches in industry history.

Legendary battles, iconic angles, stories that lasted lifetimes. The stuff that hooks you to this stuff and keeps you forever. The things promoters can only dream of. Addictions, but healthy kinds, where longterm investment is virtually assured by virtue of a life spent accepting wrestling as a habit as much as a hobby. That's what most of these performers achieved at one point or another.

All that, and then some pr*ck on the internet makes some sh*tty jokes about one sh*tty comeback.

Such is life though, eh?

Wrestling coverage is as fickle a game as wrestling itself, and those that decided to go for that elusive extra run did so fully aware of the risks. In all cases, you'd hope that enough money was doled out to make it worth the performers' while, but that's far that just something to be taken as read.

Apart from when that money comes from a less-than-ethical source...

10. Shawn Michaels

Shawn Michaels Kane sweet chin
WWE.com

Shawn Michaels' first comeback in 2002 was, for an entire generation of wrestling fans, the first opportunity to watch 'The Heartbreak Kid' wrestle at all.

The business boomed like never before pretty much the day after he left it in 1998. Stone Cold Steve Austin's inexorable rise came at his expense at WrestleMania XIV, and by the time he returned four years later, the bloom was off the rose. The company was at least perfectly placed to house his skills - innumerable awesome matches would have been missing from the 2000s if not for his contributions between SummerSlam '02 and his WrestleMania XXVI retirement, but the same cannot be said for a horror choice made when millions of dollars were on the line.

Crown Jewel 2018 needed to go ahead for WWE to keep their end of a 10 year deal, even if it existed under the shadow of Jamal Khashoggi's murder. Michaels took the deal and the match, but damaged his legacy (and ultra-prestigious retirement) when he wasn't able to stop it absolutely reeking.


9. Stone Cold Steve Austin

Stone Cold Steve Austin
WWE.com

Though it really doesn't hold up to scrutiny if watched week-to-week, enough people have nostalgic memories of Steve Austin's Raw General Manager/Sheriff runs between 2003 and 2004 that it can have a pass this time around. But as early as 2005, it was becoming increasingly clear that WWE couldn't really be a*sed to treat 'The Rattlesnake' that seriously.

Austin knew it too. He walked out of a pay-per-view payday when he was asked to lose to Jonathan Coachman, and turned semi-regular spots into occasional cameos as the years passed. On and off relations with the company resulted podcast/interview projects coming and going on the Network, but he remarkably became something of an elusive figure on reunions and get-togethers until Raw 25...when they absolutely f*cked it with him.

Called upon to open the show and not say a single word during a segment with The McMahons, Austin was marginalised as a single issue Stunner machine. Attempts to rectify that fateful night have over-reached, with his 2019 and 2020 appearances going way too long out of sheer necessity rather than carefully-thought-out creative.


8. Ultimate Warrior

Ultimate Warrior
WWE

In various shoot interviews and retrospective documentaries about The Ultimate Warrior's 1996, it appears as though almost everybody within WWE knew the New Generation return was almost certain to fail.

This could just be a little bit of in-hindsight bragging of course, but it was always more logical to assume the project would fail than succeed. Warrior and Vince McMahon had already acrimoniously parted twice before this third (and almost final) time in a decade defined by the chaos of an industry and company in decline.

Nothing about Warrior's presence fit in the company he returned to, and increasing megalomania from the man himself didn't help the enormous and irreversible perception problems. The in-house style had advanced beyond his abilities, and McMahon's patience (eventually) evolved beyond putting up with his deficiencies.

It exists now as a curio rather than a worthwhile tenure - a picture of intrigue rather than investment. Not all bad - at least it was Triple H that ate sh*t at WrestleMania XII


7. Mick Foley

KURT ANGLE Mick Foley Victory Road
Impact Wrestling

It'd be easy to pick on one of Mick Foley's several WWE returns, if only because he always alluded to not wanting to be one of those multiple retirement guys until money and opportunities became too great to deny. But he's taken pelters for those before.

His TNA run though? Remarkably under-reported.

Perhaps this is the biggest indictment of it. To its fans, TNA was a viable alternative to WWE and a genuine North American number two. In the grand scheme of things, it was mostly just this on a more literal level, and stuck to the bottom of Vince McMahon's shoe. And just before it really hit the skids, Mick Foley was the World Champion.

Initially arriving as a babyface authority figure, Foley felt like one of the more egregious versions of the traditional TNA tactic of signing a former major star just to have them there. This remained inoffensive enough until he mixed in with everything, turned heel, worked main events for months and couldn't possibly live up to the amazing legacy he'd assembled years earlier.

He later wrote about his experiences in "Countdown To Lockdown: A Hardcore Journal", but - mirroring his in-ring career - it doesn't really hold up as well as his earlier work.


6. The New Age Outlaws

new age outlaws
WWE.com

With Billy Gunn looking jacked and Road Dogg thankfully free of the many demons that had consumed him years prior, there was a lot to love about the New Age Outlaws returning for a Raw 1000 reunion with D-Generation X.

It felt at long last like the group could be whole again, and an under-represented Attitude Era act could finally enjoy the nostalgia run they'd never been able to fully replicate as Voodoo Kin Mafia in TNA. It was genuinely...sweet.

And then it soured.

Stretching the idea ludicrously beyond its expiration point, The Outlaws were at various points booked to team with and turn on CM Punk, defeat Cody Rhodes and Goldust to become tag team champions (and beat them handily in rematches to force a split and the devising of the wretched Stardust gimmick) and batter newcomers The Ascension alongside The APA in a senseless burial of a supposedly dominant double act.


5. Eva Marie

Eva Marie
WWE

There was genuine buzz around Eva Marie's 2021 WWE return, if only because the division and company at large seemed in need of a performer that could actually generate a bit of discourse following the interminable booking of just about everybody else there.

Loathed in her original run by a fanbase too furious to know they were being worked, Marie's shtick was more about what she couldn't do than what she could. She couldn't wrestle that well, unlike the division rising up around her on NXT. She couldn't transfer her decent promo game on Total Divas over to Raw or SmackDown, at least not in a way that made a difference to any ongoing stories. Unfortunately, she couldn't feign interest in it all forever - a 2016 exit was mutually beneficial after a SmackDown Live restart that never really got off the ground.

2021 was an opportunity to rectify all that, but the chemistry felt off from the very beginning. Half-a*sed promos led into a half-baked alliance (and then feud) with fellow main roster debutant Doudrop, before the former 'All Red Everything' was creatively shuffled to one side. A release followed soon after, bringing with it as little fuorer as her ill-fated return.


4. Batista

Batista WWE WrestleMania 35
WWE.com

In interviews following his WrestleMania 35 snoozer with Triple H, Batista made clear how happy he was to finally get the type of WWE farewell he'd been pining for since he'd left the permanent grind in 2010.

It was easy to see why he was ultimately so satisfied with how the 2019 run went. Though the match was lost to the vanity of Triple H deep into the longest WrestleMania ever, it was at least exactly what he'd returned to do. Dangerous and menacing in his return attack against Ric Flair, 'The Animal' made himself a meme during the rest of the programme to such an extent that Hunter actively chased more of that sort of thing in the match itself.

Serious to silly and eventually slow, the whole thing at very least erased some memories of his atrocious 2014 run-that-never-should-have-been. There, the poor f*cker was forced to try and generate cheers when the audience only wanted the guy half his size, with the whole failing to such an extent that he had to turn heel against his wishes and better interests. The less said about it the better, and 2019's stint did at least update some of those conversations.


3. Scott Steiner

scott steiner
WWE.com

Scott Steiner wasn't in great fettle when he signed for WWE in 2002, but the whole point of wrestling is to obscure any failings in the pursuit of promoting perfection.

This was categorically not on Triple H's agenda during the 'Big Bad Booty Daddy's first feud. After weeks of a musclebro build that eschewed physicality, the pair sluggishly worked through a disastrously dull that existed to reduce Steiner's aura to that of a peasant in 'The Game's drab kingdom.

From there, he was forced into useless and unending matches with the Raw undercard crew before fizzling out completely less than 12 months on from his electric Madison Square Garden debut. It didn't even feel that out of place - there were many things that defined this era, but Hunter's incredible knack for normalising his viable challengers remained Raw's calling card until Batista and John Cena's inexorable rise gave him no choice but to finally step aside.


2. British Bulldog

British Bulldog Mean Street Posse
WWE.com

A murky political agreement to do with Owen Hart's tragic passing was allegedly at the core of Davey Boy Smith's 1999 return to WWE after an injury sustained in WCW looked set to end his career early.

In hindsight, maybe the latter might have been better for him than ever coming back.

Where he was once supremely capable and carry-able, the Bulldog was physically wrecked by the time he made his way back to the biggest stage and was badly exposed in headline matches against the likes of The Rock and Triple H. Though he still carried the muscle of old, he didn't look...right anymore, with his puce skin and sad denims doing much to erase the memories of Wembley Stadium less than a decade prior.

The Attitude Era's relentless pace didn't wait around for him to try and catch up either. Paired with The Mean Street Posse just because before eventually working barely passable brawls for the European and Hardcore Titles, Bulldog looked and felt like the relic he was being booked as. His passing in 2002 was desperately sad, and it's hard to watch this era back without thinking how close he was to his unfortunate end.


1. Kurt Angle

Kurt Angle WWE Hall Of Fame WrestleMania 33
WWE.com

There's a very telling moment in the Network profile piece made for Kurt Angle's 2017 return to the WWE fold that foreshadowed the reality of the run to follow.

It occurs as cameras go with Angle to Titan Tower for his visit there since leaving in 2006. Triple H is full of beans when he arrives, offering way more love to him as a retired icon than he ever did when they worked together. It's legitimately sweet, not least because the documentary had profiled his recovery from the various addictions that had contributed to the two sides parting way in the first place.

Hunter gleefully knocks on Vince McMahon's door with Angle in tow, but the second The Chairman sees the crew, he doles out the coldest rejection this side of the NXT 2.0 revamp. Whatever his relationship with 'The Olympian' was, it wasn't one he wanted to share with the world.

This couldn't have been clearer on screen. McMahon simply didn't view Kurt as a 'Wrestling Machine' anymore. Matches were short and relatively meaningless outside of his debut alongside Ronda Rousey (appropriately, against Triple H and Stephanie McMahon), and even he buried his own tepid career-ending loss to Baron Corbin at WrestleMania 35.


Kurt Angle Quiz: How Well Do You Know WWE's Olympic Gold Medallist?

ECW Logo
WWE

1. Why Did Kurt Angle Leave An ECW Show In 1996?

In this post: 
Kurt Angle
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.