11 Problems Nobody Wants To Admit About WWE NXT

The future of the WWE, or heading for a crash?

WWE NXT has been one of the success stories of 2015, with the peak being SummerSlam weekend when the brand sold out Brooklyn's Barclays Center and had a match of the year contender with Sasha Banks versus Bayley. Long before that, fans had been singing NXT's praises, but that was the weekend when commercial viability really arrived. Not long afterwards, an international tour of the UK was announced, and it felt as if the brand really had made it. But scratch below the surface, and there are a range of problems that fans don't want to admit. People are blinded by fandom of NXT's refreshing style and the way it has redefined women's wrestling. But far from being the future of WWE, is it in fact headed for a crash?

11. High Costs For Limited Returns

NXT did good business with the Brooklyn special, but you could make the argument that was off the back of SummerSlam. They also look set to do good business on the UK tour, but are these examples the exceptions rather than the standard? NXT mostly runs in very small set-ups, with high production costs. The regular fanbase at shows is a few hundred people, sometimes without paying. By the time you factor in the cost of setting up the crew, lighting, staging and other expenses of a show, NXT isn't really that much of a business sensation. It doesn't have a TV deal and doesn't do large crowds. You've also got the wrestler costs and performance center costs. In the future it may pay off if an Austin is brought through, but right now NXT's big expenses don't really look to have a great return for WWE.

10. Stars Made Or Just Imported?

NXT is supposed to be about making new young stars. However, if you look at the success stories, they are actually guys that WWE have imported from other wrestling companies. It is the old WCW trick of just signing talent rather than making them. Furthermore, a lot of those signings aren't even that young. Is Finn Balor, at age 34, really going to be the guy to carry Raw in the next decade? Nope. He's 35 next July and hasn't even made his main roster debut yet. Even Sasha Banks had a background in the indies, she could "work" before coming to WWE. It feels like every big star has just been an established wrestler from another company, the likes of Apollo Crews, Sami Zayn, Kevin Owens, Seth Rollins, Neville, Samoa Joe, Hideo Itami... Are WWE really developing talent in NXT, or just signing made wrestlers and telling a story of development?

9. The Celebrated Women's Division Is Actually Really Light

Bayley and Sasha Banks are fantastic pro wrestlers, no doubt about that. Charlotte and Becky Lynch are also very good. But take a look at NXT's current female roster. Charlotte is gone, Lynch is gone, and Banks will be fully gone in the near future. Who does that leave for Bayley to work with? Dana Brooke, Carmella, Alexa Bliss, Emma, Asuka and Blue Pants. Blue Pants isn't even a contracted NXT worker. The fact is that the division is really light, and WWE attempted to tackle that issue by signing Asuka. The problem with Asuka is going to be the same problem every Japanese wrestler faces, and that's getting over in a US audience. Look at the problems the exceptional KENTA has had as Hideo Itami. The NXT women's roster peaked this spring, and is now light on the ground. Bliss and Brooke, the two stars WWE are keenest on, are nowhere near ready to run with the title. After so much celebration, the division is now remarkably light.

8. Television Matches Are Too Short

NXT's television gets a lot of praise, but the content is actually fairly weak. There'll be a good ten minute plus main event every now and again, but the undercard is usually very soft. Two and three minute matches are regular occurrences, and that sort of booking ultimately helps no one. Yet fans have overlooked this aspect, when they'd be absolutely ridiculing it if it was on Raw. What's probably going on, is that fans find it refreshing to have such an easily digestible show. The one hour run time is a god send compared to three hour Raw shows. Yet the run time is actually a problem, and such short matches are actually problematic to the wrestlers and long term development.

7. The Wrestling Style Isn't Transferable To Raw

NXT's top matches are fantastic, but the style is also wholly unrealistic. Far from getting these wrestlers ready for the types of matches they'll encounter on Raw, the NXT brand is instead allowing the wrestlers to work a style that is more suited to the indies. For example, do you really think you're going to see a reverse rana off the top rope in a Raw divas match any time soon? That was a great moment when Sasha and Bayley did the move at NXT Takeover Brooklyn, but it isn't realistic to be taking that style to the main roster. As such there's a problem, where NXT wrestlers are going to look superb on the NXT show, and the seem tepid on the main roster. It is because they are working a style that won't be allowed on Raw or Smackdown. It is a problem that you can see Neville contending with each week, as he's limited to the same formulaic high spots and moves on Raw and Smackdown. It isn't the same guy who was so sensational in NXT, because he doesn't have the same stylistic opportunities.

6. It Has Made Raw Look Bad

Because NXT is allowed to work such a sensationalised style, it has in turn made Raw look bad... and at a time when Raw really didn't need to be made to look any worse! Raw wrestlers have even talked about this subject and there's some degree of bitterness from Raw stars to NXT stars. That's not good for anyone. Brie Bella said the following back in February, "If I was an NXT Diva, I would not want to come up to the main roster because you get so much time down there." "When it comes to TV we get so frustrated because it's hard to tell a story in 3 minutes and especially when they want an entrance. You're thinking, 'What? Can you cut the entrance, we want time to wrestle?' Especially after watching the NXT Rival pay-per-view and seeing the girls go 20 minutes." As mentioned in the previous slides, most NXT matches are actually short as well. But when it is an NXT main event or special, the time and freedom to do high work rate and spot-fest matches is making Raw look bad.

5. Fan Baiting

In long term booking, sometimes the bad guy has to win. Sometimes the company has to do the unpopular thing in the short term, just to have a big pay off in the long term. But down in NXT, there's a fan baiting mentality of just always booking the popular result. Even when heels win, like Kevin Owens over Sami Zayn, it is done in a fan baiting type of way. K.O was basically a babyface in wolf's clothing. You only need to look at NXT Takeover Brooklyn to see NXT fan baiting at its most apparent. Every single babyface won on that special, even when it didn't really make any sense for WWE's fututre - like Jushin Liger over Tyler Breeze. That sort of booking just isn't sustainable. Another point should also be raised, home grown talent like Baron Corbin (age 31) are jobbed to imported talent like Samoa Joe (age 36)... is that really the way of the future? Jobbing out the developmental stars to the ready made stars? It has a feel of WCW to it with that type of bringing established outsiders in to beat the internal development wrestlers.

4. Average Talent

There's this reputation of NXT being stuffed full of exceptional wrestlers. But it just isn't true. Most of the really good workers are shipped in from other companies, and the rest of the roster is just a bit bland. Take a look at the roster, do you really see anyone who could be the next Triple H or The Rock? Most of the talent are actually pretty average, and even the exceptional wrestlers are going to struggle to become huge stars. Being a WWE main eventer is more than just the ability to work a match. If it was all about in-ring ability, then Tyson Kidd would be main eventing WrestleMania shows. NXT talent may be able to produce in the ring, but is there really anyone who can be WWE's next franchise star? Even NXT products like Seth Rollins and Roman Reigns, as successful as they are, they don't look like disturbing John Cena's spot any time soon. If the developmental NXT system is to really work, it needs to churn out a John Cena.

3. Limited Appeal

When you go on an internet forum or see the Barclays Center full to the rafters, it is easy to fall into the trap of thinking NXT is really popular. In fact, the majority of WWE fans don't even bother watching it. While Raw bubbling under four million viewers is considered a disappointment, NXT's television show isn't even doing a million viewers. That's partly because it is on WWE Network, but it is also because it doesn't have a John Cena or any big league perception. What powers WWE is its mainstream casual audience, not the vocal minority of the internet wrestling community. All the noise about NXT is exactly that, noise. Hard business numbers aren't correlating with the perceived popularity.

2. Top Stars Are Jumping Ship

NXT is a ticking time bomb, in which its success is ultimately going to be its downfall. Just look at the success stories of the first half of 2015, Kevin Owens, Charlotte, Sasha Banks. Where are they now? Over on Raw. It is a cannibalistic effect, in which NXT stars get over and then leave the brand. In the long run, that's going to leave NXT as a weak show. It can't be sustained. The danger is that there will ultimately be no reasons to tune in for NXT, as all their assets will have been stripped and moved to Raw. In the long term, it is big danger. And WWE can't just keep on plucking the next big stars from the indies, because many simply don't want to come. The Briscoes for example, they've turned WWE down in the past, because they can make more money on the indies. And that's another big problem for NXT, and is the reason why NXT wrestlers can't wait to jump ship to Raw. NXT simply doesn't pay that well. Raw pay (and indie pay in some cases) exceeds NXT money.

1. Some Talent Are Being Held Back

The purpose of NXT is supposed to be developing talent, but in the case of Finn Balor, he's being held back by the brand. Sure, he's the champion, but this is a man good enough to be a US or IC champion on the main brand. He's as accomplished as they come in the ring, and his character is also over. He's more than ready for the main roster. It is now at the point where WWE are hurting his progression. He's 34 years old and has been on the NXT roster for over a year. When he first signed, he was told that he'd be on Raw within a short period of time, but it is now looking like he'll be an NXT guy until at least 2016. And even though Samoa Joe has only been on NXT for a few months, there's a feeling that he should be on WWE's main roster. What world do we live in where Braun Strowman bypasses NXT and goes straight to a rumoured Raw feud with The Undertaker, but Samoa Joe is hidden away on small shows in NXT?

WWE Writer

Grahame Herbert hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.