11 Reasons WWE Made Brock Lesnar Vs The Undertaker Hell In A Cell

WrestleMania has arrived early.

WWE announcing Brock Lesnar versus The Undertaker for October's Hell In A Cell show is a very bold move. It is a WrestleMania calibre main event, placed firmly in a month that is usually the dead end of WWE's year. The move was somewhat of a surprise. Industry experts had pegged the third instalment of this decade's Taker / Lesnar rivalry as taking place at April 2016's WrestleMania 32. Instead, Undertaker and Lesnar will wrestle inside the Hell In A Cell, as the main event of Hell In A Cell on October 25th. What's surprising about it, is that Lesnar has already wrestled four times this year, in addition to increased television appearances. Clearly, Vince McMahon got a much better deal out of Brock, during March's contract renewal negotiations. Also surprising is the fact that The Undertaker is about to wrestle his third match in the space of just seven months. Usually, he only works once every twelve months. It is unprecedented times, and the reasons behind these bold changes are numerous. They'll be explained in this feature, analysing why WWE had to make Lesnar and Undertaker at Hell In A Cell. As for the match, it should be the best of their recent work. The cell is a great gimmick, perfect for two giants like Lesnar and The Undertaker. It should be fun, and here's why WWE booked it so soon after the last battle of the deadman and the beast.

11. WWE Network Struggles

First and foremost, the WWE Network is a huge factor in WWE's decision to run Brock Lesnar versus The Undertaker in October. The indication would be that Network subscriptions have dropped off significantly since SummerSlam, hence the move to offer a main event that will get drop-offs back on board. Is it a panic move by WWE? It certainly suggests an air of desperation, as if they felt like the cell gimmick and the main roster wouldn't have been a draw on their own. The idea is that Lesnar is the biggest star they have, and Taker is the biggest legend they have, so putting them together will create Network success. The thing is, that sort of booking is unsustainable. October was set to be a dud month, and they fixed it, but what about all the other B show months in the year? WWE are throwing everything they have at maintaining Network subscriptions, but in the long run it is merely a temporary solution.

10. Raw Ratings Struggles

It isn't just Network numbers WWE are struggling with, they are also contending with some horrific Raw ratings. Viewership has been at record lows in terms on non-football / non-holiday episodes. Basically, there's been no reason for fans to tune out, other than lack of interest in the product. And that was before the traditionally lacklustre autumn season even started. Fearing a destruction in the ratings during October, WWE have clearly acted to put in place something that will draw interest over the coming weeks. Lesnar and Undertaker appearing on Raw seems likely. The fact is, had WWE saved Lesnar Taker for WrestleMania, subscriptions and viewers were going to be strong in that period anyway. By booking it in a low season, they've gave a boost to what would have otherwise been stagnant business this October.

9. The 2002 Cell

The Undertaker versus Brock Lesnar is actually a Hell In A Cell sequel. Both men competed against each other inside the cell at No Mercy in October 2002. Here we are, thirteen years later, with the same match in the same month. The match the first time around was good, a narrative driven contest which Lesnar won. Part of WWE's decision to book the match again, is likely based upon how critically well received that first cell match was. Some perceive it as the greatest match in the entire Lesnar / Undertaker rivalry. It makes sense to go back to what has worked well in the past.

8. Failure Of The Feud

Part of the Lesnar / Undertaker cell booking feels like WWE giving up on the feud. It didn't pan out as the WrestleMania bound epic they expected it to be, so they are dropping it off at Hell In A Cell. It isn't that the SummerSlam match was bad, it is just that the creative was abysmal. Far from feeling like an epic feud, it felt more like a forced together narrative. Seeing The Undertaker performing low blows was just baffling. Fans didn't really know how to take the characters, and the SummerSlam finish just didn't have the necessary wow factor to power the feud through to WrestleMania. Aware of the critical problems around the summer showdown, WWE were right to book the story to end sooner rather than later. So far we've had one bad match, a ton of bad creative, and not a lot else. Ending it and moving both men on to better things is the right decision.

7. Hell In A Cell Timing

Hell In A Cell has historically been a place that feuds go to culminate. In that respect, the timing just worked out well for Lesnar versus Undertaker. Rather than extending the feud for months on end, it just made more sense to do the finale match in a finale setting at Hell In A Cell. It is a befitting occasion. The timing also made sense in that Hell In A Cell will be just a couple of months removed from the last Lesnar Taker battle at SummerSlam. It keeps things fresh, giving continuity to what was the biggest feud of the summer. Fans who expected to wait months for a resolution to August's controversial finish, can now see the finale in October, when the drama is still relevant. And nothing closes a feud quite like Hell In A Cell.

6. Los Angeles

Hell In A Cell will be taking place in Los Angeles, and that's an important consideration for WWE booking Brock Lesnar and The Undertaker as the main event. L.A is a hub of media and big business. By putting Brock Lesnar in a major match on the show, it ensures WWE has improved exposure with major mainstream outlets. Lesnar is a draw for big media, and it makes sense to utilise him. The location is also important because it is the Staples Center. It is a major stop on the WWE calendar, and they can expect to fill 14,000 seats. It was also traditionally the home of SummerSlam in recent years, and in some ways, it is like WWE are doing a version of that SummerSlam show but in October for the Los Angeles crowd.

5. Alternative WrestleMania Plans

WWE did think about Brock Lesnar versus The Undertaker 3 taking place at WrestleMania 32. But the value in repeating the match had withered, and there were stronger options on the table for both men. Interestingly, one of the options was possibly Sting versus The Undertaker. Moving Lesnar versus Taker from Mania to Hell In A Cell, and doing Sting versus Taker at Mania, it would have been a wise move. After all, Sting versus Undertaker is one of the biggest matches never seen. But Sting's performance and injury at Night Of Champions looks to have ruled that option out. It is unknown who Undertaker will face at WrestleMania if it isn't Lesnar or Sting, but John Cena could be a great candidate for the spot. As for Lesnar, there's a range of opponents he could have a big match with at Mania. Wrestling Taker in October leaves him free to face the likes of Roman Reigns or The Rock next April.

4. Lack Of Viable Main Events On The Full Time Roster

A big issue that is exposed by the booking of Lesnar and Undertaker, is that the full time main WWE roster is seriously lacking in star power. What else could WWE have conceivably have gone with at Hell In A Cell? Rollins Cena? It would be a fine match, but it wouldn't be the blockbuster headliner that Lesnar and Taker is. WWE went with the two part timers, because they knew that they couldn't offer much in terms of full timers. In fact, this will the be fourth main special in a row to feature a part timer in the show closer. That tells you everything you need to know about the weakness of WWE's main roster. Vince McMahon simply didn't have much else to work with.

3. Preparing The Undertaker For A WrestleMania Retirement?

One theory circulating, is that WWE are featuring The Undertaker extensively throughout 2015 in order to prepare his retirement. It has been rumoured for years now that he'll be bowing out in front of his home state fans at WrestleMania 32. It could be that WWE are preparing the ground work for that. Undertaker's two matches this year have made him even more high profile than usual. The plan in October could be for the third match to really put him over the top, giving him an ultimate victory over Lesnar and setting him up as the biggest star going into Mania 32. An Undertaker retirement tour could be what's going on here, with WWE squeezing every last drop of value from their icon en-route to WrestleMania 32.

2. Establishing Lesnar As The Biggest Star In WWE?

The other theory about Lesnar and Undertaker at Hell In A Cell, is that WWE are wanting to re-establish Lesnar to the level he was at around WrestleMania 31. This would be in preparation for WrestleMania 32, where he's expected to be one of the main draws at the 100,000 capacity show. In putting Brock over Taker in the cell, it would give him the sort of victory that is comparable to a WWE Title win. That momentum would then fire him into Mania as the star attraction, just as he was last year. The difference is, WWE want to keep the title on a full timer, so perhaps a victory over another part timer like Undertaker is seen as a preferable momentum getter for the beast.

1. Protecting Both Men

When it comes down to it, Brock Lesnar or The Undertaker will lose this feud. One of them is going to do a job, and that's going to hurt them. By moving the bout to Hell In A Cell, WWE have protected that damage, at least to some degree. There's a difference between a job on a B show and a job at WrestleMania. The company doesn't want either man to be on the end of a loss, but it can do damage limitation by booking it in October. That then gives the loser time to rehabilitate their image before Mania 32 in six months, when they'll need to be back at their strongest in headline slots. The cell stipulation also offers up a sort of reason for losing. It isn't like this is just a straight up wrestling match, it is a barbaric gimmick that involves chain mesh and assorted weapons. Whoever loses will have been put through a physically draining contest, hence they won't look like a normal loser. Hell In A Cell allows both men to come out looking like fighters.

WWE Writer

Grahame Herbert hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.