11 Things WWE Got Right At Survivor Series 2016
A shocking Survivor Series, a successful Survivor Series.
On paper, WWE Survivor Series 2016 looked like it had the potential to be an immensely fascinating show. In practice it blew that assumption out of the water, producing enough shocking moments and twists and turns to force the reader to attempt to create a more intriguing adjective than 'fascinating'.
The show was full of people's predictions being blown out of the water. American Alpha to be the sole survivors? Nope. Kalisto taking the cruiserweight division to SmackDown? Nope. James Ellsworth causing Dean Ambrose to be eliminated? Nope. Brock Lesnar vanquishing Goldberg? Extremely very nope.
It was the sort of show that people will talk about for months, a show that has increased intrigue in WWE tenfold and makes the Road to WrestleMania even more intriguing than it usually is. Isn't that what the fanbase wants? Reasons to tune in, fascinating developments and storytelling in that unique professional wrestling way? Survivor Series gave the fans what they say they want and they gave it them in spades.
It wasn't a perfect show, far from it, but analysing and reporting on professional wrestling is a process that is often full of gripes and complaints. Starting Monday off with the power of positivity, here are 11 things WWE got right at Survivor Series 2016.
11. Nikki Bella Gets Taken Out
Whilst the acting ability of Nikki Bella still leaves a lot to be desired ("oh, my head it hurts so bad"), removing the now-veteran member of the SmackDown Live women's division was clearly a good move, and for a number of reasons. First things first it allowed Natalya to take her place in the match, guaranteeing added involvement from the crowd with the addition of one of Canada's own.
More importantly this sets up a number of possibilities going forward. Who was responsible for blasting Nikki out of the match? Natalya is one candidate, as it was Nikki who kept her out of the match, and the former Divas Champion was surprisingly quick on the scene.
Was it Carmella, whom Nikki has been locked in a never-ending feud with since the draft in July? Maybe a member of Team Raw, beginning the build towards an inter-brand match at the Royal Rumble or WrestleMania? This was simple storytelling that opens up more intriguing possibilities. Thumbs up.
10. Bayley & Charlotte Survive
From the moment a table failed to break under the weight of poor Sasha Banks at Hell in a Cell, word has spread that Vince McMahon is eager to hotshot the inevitable Charlotte/Bayley Raw Women's Championship feud. Whether or not you think that is the right move is another story for another day, but it made the two women surviving this match somewhat predictable.
Sometimes, predicatable also happens to be right. The night was going to be full of partners turning on each other in the heat of battle, so keeping that until after the match here was a good move and one dependent on the two surviving.
Overall the women's match was good, albeit one that lost momentum frequently thanks to mistimed spots. Nia Jax looked like a beast until a terribly messed up elimination, and Alexa Bliss continues to be one of the most improved performers in the entire company.
Bayley & Charlotte surviving was the right call.
9. The Miz Retains
Going into the Intercontinental Championship match between The Miz & Sami Zayn many people had all sorts of theories floating around regarding how it would end. Many believed the best move was for Zayn to win the IC title but then shockingly defect to SmackDown Live. In a dreamworld that would have happened, but this isn't a dreamworld.
If that was to happen, then moving the title back onto The Miz last week on SmackDown Live would have been utterly pointless. If Zayn was winning and moving, why not have him face Ziggler in a match for the fans? No, Ziggler winning the title was a result of the career stipulation at No Mercy, but the big story is clearly The Miz having a lengthy reign.
The finish was hot garbage, continuing WWE's obsession with submission shenanigans in Canada, but it achieved the goal of continuing Miz's reign and keeping Sami strong in the process. Also, Maryse!
8. Mixing Up The Commentary Teams
Moving away from the action for a moment, WWE kept things interesting and fresh at the announce desk by mixing up the teams throughout the night. The prospect of a six-man booth was somewhat nauseating, so many were relived when the matches were called by four-man combinations of both shows.
This helped the brand loyalty aspect of the show immensely. Hearing announcers working side by side whilst supporting their brand was a nice throwback to the days of the original brand split, where Tazz & Michael Cole would be vehemently SmackDown in the face of JR & The King's Raw. It was a nice touch.
It also continued the relentless bullying of Byron Saxton, a state of affairs that shows no sign of abating. Be a star, WWE.
7. Early Eliminations In The Tag Team Match
In many ways, the 20-man tag team elimination match was the match of the night. The men involved crammed a huge amount into the 20 minutes they had, yet at no time did it seem as though eliminations were being rushed for the sake of thinning out the crowd.
That might seem like a strange thing to say in a match that saw two eliminations in the first 90 seconds, but both eliminations made sense. Breezango are fantastic, but like it or not they are stuck on comedy duty for the near future. Sticking them in the one and done slot made sense, and also made for some great Tyler Breeze drama on the outside.
More shocking was the immediate elimination of The New Day, as Jey Uso annihilated Kofi Kingston with a superkick. It was a genuine surprise, but one that keeps things interesting in the tag team world and shows extreme vulnerability on the part of the champions. It's inevitable that Demolition's record is going to fall, but they can most definitely be beaten.
All it takes is Tyler Breeze dramatically keeping Xavier Woods pre-occupied on the outside.
6. The Tag Team Elimination Match
This match was an absolute riot. Everybody came out of this match with something, but nobody more so than the two teams that battled out the final fall, The Usos and Cesaro & Sheamus. The final stretch of this match was absolutely fantastic, proof if proof was needed that The Usos are a thousand times more engaging as heels.
Cesaro showed once again that he is simply one of the best in the world today. His running wild sequence was embarrassingly fluid, the work of a man so in tune with his artform that it looks simpler than running a tap. The Swiss Superman is a freak of nature.
Gallows & Anderson looked suitably dominant in the middle, American Alpha looked hot in the brief time they got, and every other team brought something to the table. Even Mojo Rawley! An excellent match out of what could have been a mess.
5. The Brian Kendrick Retains His Title
This is most likely a minority opinion, but keeping the Cruiserweight Championship on The Brian Kendrick was the right idea. The match between Kendrick and Kalisto was unnecessarily loaded, an open admittance on the part of WWE that the revamped division on Raw simply isn't working. Most assumed the King of the Lucha Thing would prevail here and bring the division over to SmackDown Live.
Kalisto should certainly be involved in the division, but one does not fix the cruiserweight mess by simply shifting it over to a show that is already an hour shorter than Raw. Kendrick deserves a better run than a transitional reign, and a Kalisto win here would have caused all sorts of mess in the division.
This without mentioning that Kalisto has been somewhat terrible over the last few months. Sure, he's missed time with injury but ever since his infamous 'Lucha thing' promo the masked man has seemed short on confidence. Putting an entire division on his shoulders here would have been a terrible idea.
Although the idea of Baron Corbin trucking cruiserweights and telling them all to go back to Ring of Honor is a delightful one.
4. Braun Strowman
In what was the night's most inevitable method of elimination, Braun Strowman was removed from the big Raw vs. SmackDown Live men's match by countout. It was the safe option but without doubt the right one, and having James Ellsworth factor into it was a nice touch too. Having Strowman subsequently destroy Ellsworth was the icing on that cake.
Strowman looked like a genuine monster once again, and one of the major success stories of 2016 has to be the rise of the Black Sheep. His timing is still somewhat off but then it isn't the role of the most inexperienced individual to anchor everything, and whilst his move-set is limited it continues to grow day by day.
Braun Strowman is a huge man who is simply stronger than everyone else on the roster, and that is how he looked here. The spot that saw him hurl AJ Styles over the top rope was brutal, and the way he manhandled anyone and everyone was a joy to behold. Long live the Abominable Strowman.
3. The Wyatt Family Defeat The Shield Once Again
Bray Wyatt and Randy Orton ended up being the sole survivors of the match, successfully warding off a resurgent Seth Rollins and Roman Reigns thanks to the surprising-but-not-really interference of Luke Harper. Orton and Wyatt continue to have far better chemistry as a team than as opponents, with the former in particular being more interesting than he has been in a long time.
The result of the match also continues the dominance of The Wyatt Family over The Shield. The middle of the match saw a strangely underwhelming Shield reunion, but it wasn't enough to stop a member of the trio falling prey to an eventual Sister Abigail. Whilst we can't rewind the clock and put The Shield vs. The Wyatt Family on the WrestleMania XXX card, it does keep things interesting going forward.
It also gives us another month of debating whether the company will finally give Bray Wyatt the ball or not, before Orton RKOs it out of his hands on SmackDown Live.
2. The Longest Survivor Series Match In History
Many commentators have already put in complaints about the length of this match, and at almost an hour long you can almost understand. But was this not what people have frequently clamoured for? Patient storytelling in matches that maintain the WWE obsession with people looking strong but doesn't do it at the expense of the entertainment?
This was a match featuring 10 of the most important members of the roster. You had your two World Champions in AJ Styles and Kevin Owens, two of the biggest names of the modern era in Randy Orton and Chris Jericho, three of the most successful elevations to the main event in recent memory in the shape of Roman Reigns, Dean Ambrose, and Seth Rollins, the most exciting monster in recent memory in Braun Strowman, a genuine main event performer in Bray Wyatt, and the son of the owner of the company who has spent his in-ring career surviving in an attempt to show he belongs.
If this match would have been 30 minutes long and seen quick eliminations, commentators would have been apoplectic with rage. If Jericho was pinned seven minutes into the match after a Wyatt uranage, we'd all be angry at his poor treatment. Every elimination in this match was precious, and all 10 men looked like stars.
Stories were told throughout, stories that made sense and leave us in an exciting place going forward. It wasn't a Okada/Tanahashi 40 minute wrestling clinic, but this isn't NJPW. This is WWE, and this was as good a WWE storytelling match as you're getting it. If you don't like that, why are you watching?
1. Goldberg Destroys Lesnar
Well, where to begin? In what was one of the most shocking matches in WWE history, Goldberg returned to a WWE ring 12 years after his last match to annihilate Brock Lesnar. In one minute and 25 seconds Goldberg destroyed the man who ended The Undertaker's WrestleMania Streak, the man who squashed John Cena, the man who has conquered all of the young guns in WWE's possession. Two spears and a Jackhammer was all it took.
There are a lot of reasons to be angry at this; WWE hyped a match that ended up lasting the length of a particularly swift micturition, and fans in attendance can justifiably want their money back. There is also the school of thought that says defeating Lesnar should have been saved for someone that will get a rub from it going forward.
The problem with that second idea is that as fans we've thought that about a million things, but it is too risky a strategy more often than not. Remember that once there was a genuine school of thought that said Ted DiBiase Jr. was the right man to end The Undertaker's streak.
Second of all, WWE is running out of nostalgia acts to bring back, so ending one in one night would have been foolish. Goldberg looks more like a beast than ever, despite actually aesthetically looking more like Gillberg than ever. Lesnar clearly underestimated him in the build up, and was made to look like a fool.
Which is also something we've wanted all year. Lesnar had grown stale, grown boring, and by having him so easily annihilated here the man has room for growth. Where he goes next will be infinitely more interesting than where he has been this year.
Finally, the show ended with a grown man and his emotional son celebrating in front of a sold out crowd. Professional wrestling is heroes conquering villains and celebrating in emotional fashion. Sometimes it seems we forget that.