11 Ups & 0 Downs From AEW All Out 2021

AEW All Out 2021, much like headliner Christian Cage, is an instant classic.

Adam Cole
AEW

The build to All Out 2021 - and the first draft of its actual card - was afflicted by travel woes, scheduling conflicts, and the deflating politic byproduct of the Forbidden Door.

Hangman Page had family commitments.

NJPW either didn't want Hiroshi Tanahashi to lose or they needed him in their stricken, freezing cold domestic arm.

PAC was pulled as a result of reported "travel issues".

And to illustrate just how white-hot AEW is, and how much expansive thought is applied to making it white-hot, the build was mostly fantastic nonetheless.

Kenny Omega Vs. Christian Cage didn't patronise the audience; knowing that it just wasn't the same as Hangman's grand emotional moment, AEW instead crafted an hilarious, irreverent story premised on an ancient Christian Vs. Don Callis beef elevated by an undefeated Cage removing the Impact World Title from Omega's waist. If MJF Vs. Chris Jericho felt like a match too far, a phenomenal pair of go-home promos dispelled that feeling entirely. Eddie Kingston and Miro sold their TNT Title match with incredible economy. In just 54 seconds of a pre-tape, they looked like the coolest badasses on the face of the planet.

The Young Bucks were just begging for the Lucha Bros. to make them stare at the lights, they were that obnoxious, and the cage stipulation made sense in U.S. pro wrestling for the first time in decades.

As for the show itself...?


Ups...

11. The Buy-In Match Does The Job

Jurassic Express Best Friends
AEW

And so, mercifully, does the Hardy Family Office.

This wasn't an unqualified success; really; 'The Matt Hardy Vs. The Entire AEW Midcard Feud Must Continue' is a reprehensibly tedious and damning sentence. But continue it must, for some reason. AEW ran its millionth post-match continuation in which Hardy's three - three, for f*ck's sake! - concurrent storylines all tied together. Before the Dark Order, Best Friends and Jurassic Express all came together in a forced-fun post-match scene, the 10-man tag proved effective in its remit as a crowd-pleaser.

It wasn't anything special. At times, and your writer is fairly lenient with daft for-the-sake-of-it spots, this was indierrific in the extreme. Shindieriffic, even. It was however a lay-up for this particular crowd, and Jungle Boy elevated (literally) a boilerplate PWG house style match with moments of genuine creative invention. Elsewhere, it was every overtly cooperative multi-man spot-fest you've ever seen elevated also by a red-hot crowd.

The upshot of a worn genre is that it is so familiar in 2021 that the sloppiness that so often blights the mid versions of these matches didn't creep in to undermine it.


10. Eddie Kingston Fails In Success Of A Sequel Set-Up

Miro AEW
AEW

AEW is a tremendous finish company. It doesn't get enough credit for that. They are operating at prime Pat Patterson levels.

Bryce Remsburg's conscientiousness allowed Miro to blast Eddie Kingston in the balls as he protected his friend from the exposed turnbuckle in a layered use of AEW's holistic universe.

What a flex this was, too; the incompetence of the referees is a valid complaint and has been since AEW's inception. Building a finish around a referee upholding the rules and creating a safe environment while unusual was a very smart means of protecting the beloved Eddie Kingston character as much as it was a well overdue development in and of itself.

The Chicago crowd adored Eddie Kingston as if he wasn't from New York. He is universally beloved and he demonstrated why that is with a gutsy, spellbinding performance. This was a great, strategic story told with a fabulous badass rhythm of defiance and the fury that resented that defiance. Physical and convincing, Kingston's fire-up spots ruled so much that it required something brutal from Miro to get the finish over - and he cleaned Kingston's clock with a fantastic full-force thrust kick.

This might have been Miro's best ever match. His presence and intimidation was unparalleled on the night, and his vertical leap into a dropkick was jaw-dropping.

This has to be ran back at Arthur Ashe stadium.


9. Jon Moxley Wins A Clever, Brutal War; Invites Another

Moxley Kojima

A fun, hard-hitting match positioned well on a card that was sequenced brilliantly, Jon Moxley Vs. The New Japan Dads Must Continue - only with no irony this time, because this genre of match rules.

As witty as it was physical, the wonderful charm of late-period Satoshi Kojima was perfect for the early slot. After winning an early striking exchange, he poked fun at Mox with a titty-pec dance; then, after biting back at Mox's forehead, he retched, as if he couldn't believe what an animal his opponent was. Surly, post-paternity Mox is a delight, and Kojima allowed him to play his f*cked-off tweener role wonderfully. The moments of levity were grounded with tight, lovely, immersive work. Mox set up a hold that Kojima could only trap himself into by kicking out of a pinning combination in a beautiful use of grappling technique. The expected lariats were launched into with proper, uplifting force. Kojima took light-switch flat-backs like he was a young man looking to impress, and not the actual living legend that he is.

Again: AEW is a tremendous finish company. Mox didn't allow Kojima to kick out of the Paradigm shift, but he deployed it twice just to make sure - and to make sure Kojima exited Chicago with his legendary aura intact.

The post-match scene was awesome: Minoru Suzuki arrived to a shock, arena-shaking rendition of 'Kaze Ni Nare' and, after a penetration step no 53 year-old man has the right to do, he choked Mox out to build a killer of a match on Dynamite.

This was magic, unadulterated fan service on a night on which being a fan of pro wrestling was rarely so exciting and rewarding.


8. Dr. Britt Baker Proves Why She's The Man

Britt Baker AEW
AEW

This wasn't the tightest wrestling match of all-time, but it was excellent - and if it wasn't executed perfectly, it was performed perfectly. Britt Baker's body language and intent was fantastic, and Kris Statlander's commitment to putting this match over as a breakthrough, credible title challenge manifested in several unhinged bumps.

The feeling Baker and Statlander generated in this banger of a bomb exchange was more potent than the odd flub. The feeling was so intense and the crowd so amped that those flubs barely registered, much less mattered. This was a cracking story of strength and resolve versus cunning and technique. They proved very complementary opponents; in one awesome spot, Statlander's raw explosiveness was outwitted by a curb stomp launched off the ring steps.

In one of the biggest pops on one of the most ear-splitting nights in pro wrestling history, Orange Cassidy brought the house down by showing more fire than he ever has for himself when urging Statlander back into the ring. Best Friends indeed; this wholesome scene was stirring as hell because it turns out babyfaces should be nice and have friends.

Both women ate sh*t to swing the momentum back in the favour of their opponent, and Baker to a major pop foreshadowed the main event angle with a fantastic use of the Panama Sunrise.

This was focused, motivated, physical - an outstanding improvement on Baker's overcomplicated title win at Double Or Nothing.


7. Literally Everything There Is To Love About Professional Wrestling

Lucha Bros
AEW

The greatest Tag Team Title run in pro wrestling history ended with one of the best AEW matches ever.

Measured against every criteria, this was impossible to dislike in good faith. The Young Bucks Vs. The Lucha Bros. encapsulated the full breadth of all that is awesome and meaningful about professional wrestling.

A fight and insane dream match hybrid worked across that spectrum with a seamless brilliance, the pace was blistering, relentless early. The unreal speed at which this was worked was just breathtaking. Fénix in particular entered an outrageous performance even by his standards, using the cage as a springboard for his impossible aerial offence and as the brutal weapon a cage should be. But Penta, who is the most overshadowed incredible worker of all-time, formed the emotional core of this masterpiece. With his mask torn, and his face shredded and bloodied, he convinced one of pro wrestling's loudest ever crowds to stand up and refuse to sit down until his team put an end to the Young Bucks tyranny.

The pace slowed deep into the match as the heat became incendiary. In a stunning callback to the Buck's most infamous moment of a controversial indie run, Matt Jackson wore a thumbtack-covered shoe and blasted the Lucha Bros. with it. When that PWG video nasty failed to put the babyfaces away, Matt Jackson kicked Fénix right in the dick. Fénix refused to die, and the fans refused to let him.

A nerve-shredding war, this claret-soaked, hate-fuelled, mind-blowing match delivered the most acute of saves elevated by the most keenly-felt desire for justice.

Blood, emotion, excitement, innovation, anxiety, catharsis: this is the match you show a non-fan to make them realise that wrestling isn't a fake pursuit for children.

Pro wrestling is emotionally unbearable art, until it becomes an exhilarating and just morality play.


6. The Women's Division Trends Upwards

Ruby Soho
AEW

The battle royal is inherently unfocused. AEW's convoluted and distracting approach to it is just weird in how it compounds the flaw in the genre by circling back to the messy bit at the beginning.

Still, the women did a mostly every good job of transcending the trappings AEW has inexplicably imposed on itself. Perhaps it was just an electric atmosphere that refused to subside even for this supposed cool-down, or perhaps AEW somehow conspired to transcend a bizarre structure, but this was really good and really over at its peak. It was a mess otherwise. The format is dire. But even the worst of AEW was undeniable on this night.

Fundamentally, a modern battle royal functions to shine up several acts in a staggered match. The Women's Casino Battle Royal did just that.

Red Velvet is an outstanding prospect. She just needs the reps; the hard part, that which can't be taught, is already in place. Her fire on the spear spot was outstanding.

Leyla Hirsch's suplex barrage was awesome.

Ruby Soho's debut was magical, but it wasn't just a pop. Her closing sequence with Thunder Rosa was beyond tense. The sense of peril and anxiety they orchestrated together by the ropes was magnificent.

Beyond the individual showcases, the booking here was clever. Nyla Rose is never squandered as a perennial challenger, and certain shock eliminations while unpopular deepened the atmosphere at least.


5. Isn't AEW Supposed To Be The Promotion Where Nobody Sells?

MJF Chris Jericho
AEW

That's funny, because in a very good and massively dramatic match against Chris Jericho, MJF sold an apron bump like it should have been sold all along.

Without being histrionic about it, the man was wailing at points in the ring. It felt like he was legitimately in agony, and every subsequent beat of the match was informed by his worked injury to lull the crowd into the drama. The selling was fantastic, and it was rendered all the more effective by how shockingly hard both men went. Top-rope powerbombs, face-first Codebreaker counters, apron-bound heat-seeker piledrivers: this was a year in the making, a stunning amount of thought went into their intricate saga, and the sheer physical effort matched up with the creative. None of it resonated as excess nor indulgence. This was worked with a real grudge tone. Every bone-rattling spot was well-earned by the sprawling ambition of the storyline.

The two masters of crowd manipulation played the greatest hits to further absorb the audience, and the crowd was on strings for the Dusty finish.

The two minutes that followed were as hot as anything on this instant classic of a show. The fans lived and died with Jericho as he fought through the Fujiwara armbar, and when MJF caught Jericho with a flash pin immediately after the restart, they thought his career was dead there and then.

Great add-ons, even better core.


4. CM Punk Does, In Fact, Still Have It

CM Punk Darby Allin
AEW

The following is a pedantic take, but it isn't a facetious one: if CM Punk wore trunks, his comeback match is half a star better.

This might be a subjective take. The fans in the arena would have received Punk as a demigod if he wore a burlap sack. He didn't. He wore long tights, and they were distracting. Was he the same CM Punk? He worked the same, after his breathing steadied, but it didn't look like it.

Again, this doesn't matter. He was received as a demigod, and his match with Darby Allin was a very worthy effort highlighted and elevated by a scintillating last five minutes. The story told was logical without being electrifying bell-to-bell - by design. After Allin overwhelmed Punk with his mat work early, Punk in a major mark-out moment for the New Generation Truthers paid tribute to the glorious, seminal Bret Hart Vs. 123 Kid match. From there, Punk sought to ground his younger missile of an opponent. Solid, logical storytelling.

Those aren't words you might have expected from a match as momentous as this, but the actual work was very good. Both men gnashed their heads together in a hammerlock escape spot to subtly put over the realism of the struggle.

As the match paced itself elegantly, Punk used Allin's speed against him to thread the main plot. He was the savvy veteran, and he articulated this with a phenomenally well-timed sit-up spot to avoid the Coffin Drop. This set up another, awesome spike in drama as Allin transitioned into a crucifix pin in a gorgeous counter.

The counters traded down the stretch were fabulous and creative, but really, the best thing about this entire scene is that it was obvious Punk was only beginning to feel it by the end.


3. A Match As Inoffensive As It Was Necessary

Paul Wight
AEW

In the end, despite it being allocated far too much TV time, Paul Wight Vs. QT Marshall was a nothing buffer match promoted purely to allow the audience a breather.

This does not warrant an 'Up' in and of itself. Wight was gassed, nobody was desperate to see QT Marshall eat sh*t, and it's some indictment of the apparent beloved legend role Wight is scheduled to play that everybody received this glorified angle with the exact same take:

"Thank f*ck Paul Wight Vs. QT Marshall lasted about three minutes!"

This didn't die a death - some members of the crowd were happy to play along with the old Big Show schtick - but it was a strategic exercise more than it was a good match.

It nonetheless resolved a core issue that has plagued every AEW PPV other than this, even the amazing ones: they all go too long and are sequenced as if everybody shares Tony Khan's boundless energy. They don't.

That can all be written in the past tense now. The crowd was white-hot for everything that mattered, and on such a life-affirming night, virtually everything did.


2. A Fitting Main Event

Kenny Omega Christian Cage
AEW

A very worthy counterpart to the Rampage match, it was as good, which some might consider a mild disappointment. The expectation was of a blow-away undisputed classic, and while it didn't quite materialise, this was still very much in the ***3/4 - **** range.

Perhaps Christian Cage really is one of the best TV wrestlers of all time, which accounts for the lack of a significant upgrade. TV wrestling is his area of expertise. But this is nitpicking. Despite a slow build and a glaring collector's item of a Kenny Omega botch, this was a tremendous professional wrestling match.

The drama that Kenny Omega and Christian Cage generated in the space between moves was sublime, and it built expertly. The sheer heart-in-mouth anxiety of the counter sequences teased on the apron and on the top turnbuckle was the work of two masters. Two architects.

Christian Cage absorbed some particularly disgusting V-Triggers to orchestrate a frightening atmosphere that used our knowledge of his history of career-ending head injuries.

But the spaces matter more than the moves, and every set-up, struggle and counter was measured brilliantly to hook in the crowd and cast doubt over a predictable outcome. The groundwork laid on the Rampage premiere informed an exceptional Killswitch near-fall towards the finish, and the bananas avalanche One-Winged Angel finish itself was an exceptional way of preserving Christian's future role as a gatekeeper.


1. Professional Wrestling Is The Greatest Medium Ever

Adam Cole
AEW

It's no wonder that none of these guys ever retire. Ever.

Professional wrestling is the best drug.

As Kenny Omega closed the show with his "Goodbye and goodnight" spiel, the lights went out. Bryan Danielson did not appear.

Adam Cole did.

Adam Cole did, and he rejoined his Elite brethren with a beautiful callback to Being The Elite. The super-faction beat the piss out of Christian Cage and Jurassic Express in a wild scene that spawned several dream matches. A white-hot card went ballistic. Everything on this show was so awesome and so special that fears of another overlong, uneven effort proved totally unfounded. If the show ran until next week, they'd still be going apesh*t.

And then Bryan Danielson did appear. And Bryan Danielson was absolutely incendiary in his sh*t-kicking of Nick Jackson. If the show ran until next month, they'd still be going apesh*t.

If pro wrestling is a drug, this was uncut. Wave upon wave of euphoria overwhelmed the arena as AEW spawned wave upon wave of dream matches.

Adam Cole Vs. Jungle Boy. Adam Cole Vs. Bryan Danielson. Bryan Danielson Vs. Kenny Omega. The Young Bucks Vs. Bryan Danielson and Jungle Boy.

Just think about what the next Blood & Guts match is going to look like, holy f*cking Jesus Christ s**t.

A better swerve than anything the Attitude Era gave us.

Pro wrestling in 2021 is better than the Attitude Era.


In this post: 
Adam Cole
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!