11 Ups & 6 Downs From Last Night's WWE SmackDown (Jul 2)

Kofi & Joe wage microphone warfare and Owens turns babyface ahead of Extreme Rules.

Kofi Kingston Samoa Joe
WWE.com

With Eric Bischoff reportedly not set to start as the brand's Executive Director until after Extreme Rules, Vince McMahon fired up the computer housing SmackDown's booking algorithm for an evening of same old, same old last night, yielding a formulaic show relatively low on surprises but with more than enough well-performed content to finish as a net positive.

Raw's explosive start bred hopes of something similar on SmackDown, but alas, the blue brand began as it always does: with a revolving door talking segment. This week, it was Shane McMahon and Drew McIntyre guesting on the Kevin Owens Show. Something interesting was amiss with the host, though, and it resurfaced later in the night, providing SD with a big show-closing turn.

Elsewhere, Samoa Joe and Kofi Kingston met for an in-ring confrontation far greater than such segments typically have any right to be. We also got developments in the tag division as new contenders were crowned and Daniel Bryan did battle with Big E, the latest from Nikki Cross and Alexa Bliss, Apollo Crews finally getting his hands on Andrade, and a vengeful Ember Moon in action against Mandy Rose.

A solid little show. Let's break it down.


Downs...

6. Tuesday Lite Raw

The Raw Lite feel that has consumed parts of SmackDown since the Wild Card Rule came into play remains one of the show's biggest problems, with original writing eschewed for recaps of events that went down just 24 hours prior to go with other needless rehashes.

Last night brought two Raw replays in the first 15 minutes. That's a terrible use of SmackDown's limited TV time, and we didn't need the tiny update on Braun Strowman and Bobby Lashley's conditions or the footage of Shane McMahon and Drew McIntyre running away from The Undertaker. Later, we got a promo from Lashley, a Raw wrestler, claiming he'd send Brock to the morgue the next time they crossed paths.

How about trimming the fat and letting guys like Buddy Murphy do their thing on TV rather than during the commercials? Why is that too much to ask?


5. Bayley & Nikki's Pointless Battle

Nikki Cross Bayley
WWE.com

Last week saw Bayley lose to Nikki Cross in a non-title match, thus punching Alexa Bliss' ticket for a SmackDown Women's Title shot at Extreme Rules. While Bayley's defeat was disappointing, it at least made Cross look like a credible competitor, pushing her relationship with Bliss forward in the process.

Last night, WWE decided to run it back by having Bayley pin Cross in just under three minutes... and, like... why?

The booking doesn't make a great deal of sense. Yes, it gives Bayley her win back, but doesn't that defeat the purpose if putting Cross over in the first place? If you're going to make a controversial move like having a champion at a non-title loss, at least commit to the benefits. In going 50/50, WWE did the opposite.


4. ZZZzzzZZZZZZZzzzzz

Dolph Ziggler Kevin Owens Shane McMahon Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

This week's boring in-ring revolving door opening segment was every boring in-ring revolving door opening segment you've ever watched on SmackDown.

The KO Show began with the host bringing out his guests, Shane McMahon and Drew McIntyre. Owens read from cue cards and replayed footage of the heel duo bailing from The Undertaker, dropping some entertaining lines, mannerisms, and idiosyncrasies along the way, as he always does. McMahon and McIntyre eventually got angry, because of course they did, and Dolph Ziggler interrupted, cutting his usual bullsh*t promo about how he should be WWE Champion, prompting Shane to book them as an odd couple tag team against Heavy Machinery in the night's main event.

These mere box-ticking exercises need outstanding character work or a brilliant promo to stand out. Owens was solid, but not strong enough to pull it into the Ups column.


3. Alignment Bingo

Shane McMahon Kevin Owens
WWE.com

While Kevin Owens performed well in the opening segment (and his face turn felt real by the end of the night), the way WWE randomly decided that he was a good guy during the KO Show was jarring.

Suddenly, with no build, Owens was talking like a face, trading barbs with Shane McMahon and Drew McIntyre. His refusal to read from 'The Beast in the World's' pre-pared script was endearing, as was him constantly standing up to the most reviled heel in the company, and while this may have come off stronger if his apparent turn had already been established, it didn't work in this context.

Coin-flip changes like this never come off well. KO will make it work, because he's brilliant, and the course will right itself, but the transitions need to be smoother.


2. Back To Square One

Last week finally brought some development in Aleister Black's tedious little world, with a mystery assailant answering the Dutchman's calls to knock on his door and pick a fight.

Except they didn't.

Whoever it was did knock, but, as revealed last night, there was nobody there when Black answered. Thus, we're back to square one. These nonsense promos continue down the same old road, and this week's was no better than those that have populated the Downs section of this column for the past month or so.

Aleister challenged the mystery man to meet him at Extreme Rules. Everyone needs to move on from this, so here's hoping it's a proper resolution.


1. This Is Getting Silly

Rowan Xavier Woods
WWE.com

While there were no unrealistically paced 2-out-of-3 falls matches on last night's SmackDown, WWE's contrivances when it comes to avoiding wrestling during commercial breaks (despite breaking this self-imposed rule on Raw) were apparent in the main event.

Heavy Machinery vs. Dolph Ziggler and Kevin Owens began in earnest. Everything was going well until a few minutes in, when a fight broke out between The New Day and Rowan/Daniel Bryan at ringside. It was a wild brawl sparked by Big E and Xavier Woods, and the referee, for some reason, decided it was enough to necessitate a restart, despite none of the active participants being involved.

Obviously, this was done to cut the bout for the commercials. It's nonsense, though. A few weeks ago, the solution would've been calling a bunch of backstage officials out to split the fight up rather than restarting the whole thing, but here we are.


Ups...

11. Shelton Benjamin Does... Something

Last night saw Shelton Benjamin return to SmackDown with what looks like a new gimmick.

An off-camera voice asked him whether he thinks Kofi Kingston or Samoa Joe will leave Extreme Rules as WWE Champion. The former 'Gold Standard' said nothing, opting instead to just cast his eyes around the room a bunch then smile and walk away, leaving everything unanswered.

It was weird, but new people doing new things should always be considered a positive in this company before the wheels fall off, so fingers crossed this is the start of something cool.


10. The Truth Is Here

This week's 24/7 Championship antics were limited. Drake Maverick is on a shoot honeymoon with wife Renee Michelle at the moment, so WWE couldn't deliver any backstage content. Instead, we got Kayla Braxton conducting an interview with the division's ace, R-Truth, which was everything you'd expect from that description.

After watching the clip of Maverick taking his belt, Truth though back to his own honeymoon, saying he had to cancel it because it started raining. He then claimed to have heard that Mr. and Mrs. "Hornswoggle" had gone to San Antonio Texas, saying "Mr. 7/11 European TV Champ, I'm coming for you, and I want my baby back!"

So we're almost certainly getting a skit involving Truth invading Maverick's honeymoon, then. Bring it on.


9. Nikki & Alexa

The Nikki Cross/Alexa Bliss relationship is quietly one of the best storylines in WWE at the moment. Last night's developments weren't as exciting as other recent offerings but still hit the right notes by pushing the dynamic forward, ensuring a great payoff later down the road.

It began backstage. Cross and Bliss were conversing, with Alexa claiming she was about to let Nikki host this week's Moment of Bliss. Overwhelmed, Cross said she'd never hosted a show before, but a little chat with 'The Goddess' got her fired up and ready to go.

The segment led to Cross losing to Bayley later in the evening, and WWE.com published the above video showing a frustrated Nikki looking for her buddy after the fall. This is the first time we've seen the Scot show any kind of exasperation towards the former champion. A significant step forward, and it'll be fun to see how Alexa reacts.


8. Understanding Heavy Machinery

Heavy Machinery are really, really weird, but if you want to glean the most enjoyment possible from their segments, view their relationships like this: Otis is literally (note: not literally) Tucker's pet.

All their interactions make sense when viewed through this lens.

A brief promo saw the big beefy duo react to the news that they'd been booked against Kevin Owens and Dolph Ziggler for a SmackDown Tag Team Title shot later on. It was highlighted by their bond, chemistry, and Otis' outright weirdness. Yes, this is a goofy act, but it's fun. Heavy Machinery are the sideshow we need to counter more serious acts like Daniel Bryan and Rowan and they're improving in all aspects of their performances.


7. A Fool No More

Ember Moon Mandy Rose
WWE.com

It was great to see Ember Moon finally right her wavering course with a solid win over Mandy Rose last night.

The bout itself was routine, but the booking trumps it. 'The Shenom' has been made to look like a chump in recent weeks, first through her childish reaction to Rose and Sonya Deville breaking her Nintendo Switch, then by losing via distraction finish. Neither presented her 'War Goddess' character in the correct light, but this most certainly did.

This is one instance of 50/50 booking working well. Rose and Deville are individuals, but they're to be received on the same level. They carry an identical level of credibility, and in besting one, Ember is essentially gaining revenge over the other following Sonya's fortuitous victory the previous week. Rather than eroding the former Absolution duo, it puts Moon back on the appropriate path.


6. Otis & Tucker Punch Their Tickets

Otis Dolph Ziggler
WWE.com

Though hampered by its dopy restart, the main event pitting Heavy Machinery against Dolph Ziggler and Kevin Owens was a well-worked tag match between an established duo and a thrown-together unit, with Otis and Tucker earning a rightful victory.

The singles wrestlers should rarely win bouts like this. It makes a mockery of tag teams as a concept, so it was good to see Heavy Machinery pick up a credible victory over two wrestlers with good reputations (despite their unflattering win/loss records). Both teams looked good, too. They worked well within the runtime's limitations and the match felt like a mini-showcase for Otis, who spent plenty of time in the ascendancy, splattering Ziggler and Owens with his fun offence, nailing the crowd-popping Caterpillar, then scoring the decisive fall on Owens after 'The Show-Off' had accidentally kicked his partner in the face, leading to the Compactor.

WWE are doing a good job of building Otis and Tucker up, and this entry gets a supplemental Up for Daniel Bryan's commentary work prior to the restart. As for KO blasting Ziggler after the bell? It got over huge. Kudos.


5. Andrade & Apollo Finally Clash

Apollo Crews Andrade
WWE.com

Weeks of build finally made it to the ring as Andrade and Apollo Crews clashed on the midcard. The former Titus Worldwide man had spent most of his recent time searching for 'El Idolo' backstage, leading to a confrontation between him and Zelina Vega last week, with the former Thea Trinidad accusing Apollo of hitting on her. It was done to lure Apollo into Andrade's beatdown, and they took their beef to the next level on last night's SmackDown.

While the duo definitely have a better match in then, this six-minuter was perfectly cromulent. Two of the roster's more athletic wrestlers are always going to craft a few fun spots when booked against each other, and that was the case last night, with the action largely fast-flowing, fluid, and exciting, particularly when Crews was getting his sh*t in.

If Apollo was looking for revenge, he would've been disappointed. Taken out by Vega's signature Hurricanrana from the apron, he hit the announce table hard and was helpless to avoid the Hammerlock DDT, followed by the inevitable 1-2-3. It's back to the drawing board for him, though the feud will almost certainly continue.


4. Bayley: The Voice Of Reason

Bayley Nikki Cross
WWE.com

Babyfaces showing spine was a big theme on last night's SmackDown, and Bayley was one of the most prominent examples.

The current SmackDown Women's Champion talked a lot of sense during her appearance on Nikki Cross' Moment of Bliss. Instead of sugarcoating her thoughts on the Cross/Alexa Bliss situation, Bayley got right to the heart of the matter, telling the Scot that she shouldn't let herself do Alexa's bidding. Nikki was stuck in denial. When she asked with Bayley had called 'The Goddess' a liar, the champ double-down, pointing out that while Cross is out there winning all the matches, Alexa is the one reaping the benefits.

Unwilling to accept that she's being played like a fiddle, Cross demanded a bout with Bayley there and then. This led to their brief singles clash, and in pushing the Alexa/Nikki dynamic forward while presenting Bayley as a smart, switched-on champion, this segment was a success.


3. Bryan Battles Big E

Daniel Bryan Big E
WWE.com

SmackDown's best match came via the current Tag Team Title programme, with Daniel Bryan meeting Extreme Rules opponent Big E in singles action, and it was very solid.

Bryan is a certified wrestling genius who has spent his year getting the absolute most out of every opponent (AJ Styles at the Royal Rumble aside). His layouts are close to flawless, and while he didn't need a great deal of help in making E look great here (the big lad is pretty tremendous himself), there's no doubt he helped elevate the match's quality. Whether selling for E's powerful offence or cutting his shine off with chop blocks, everything he did was on point.

Big E almost took the victory with a splash following the belly-to-belly suplex. It was a close near-fall, and Bryan avoided the diving spear soon after. Posted by Rowan, E was taken advantage of, and with Xavier Woods neutralised, the Busaiku Knee Kick finished the beefcake off.


2. Ali Chases Glory

Well, this was rather tremendous.

Recent weeks have seen Ali portrayed as 'Make a Difference' Fatu reborn by curing alcoholics' addictions and bringing fighting partners back together in a short series of repackaging vignettes. It was decent stuff, but last night's promo was a big step forward.

Ali came off strong and assertive. He claimed that while everyone else was chasing the WWE Championship for "money, power, fame," he wanted to "bring change to millions of minds that have been forced to believe a lie." That lie, he claimed, was that their name, background, and heritage defined them. He wants to smash that perception in two, and when he's announced as WWE Champion, he's going to change everyone's mind.

Ali's delivery, the written content, and the gritty presentation were all on point. He feels fresh, new, and exciting. Props to the man and his undeniable charisma.


1. A Worthy Confrontation

Kofi Kingston
WWE.com

It speaks volumes that this week's strongest Up is a bloody in-ring talking segment, but Kofi Kingston and Samoa Joe did a great job here.

What could have been a lame, routine champion vs. challenger confrontation was taken to a different level by two excellent promos. Joe and Kofi were both on point. In a heavy shot at Kingston's pre-WrestleMania narrative, Joe suggested that his foe is no more than a beneficiary of WWE's extreme generosity, and that while he respected the hustle, he knows the New Day man has been using the people to get ahead.

Kingston refused to let Joe get inside his head. He criticised the big man for sneak-attacking people, then called him out when Joe went down the predictable route of commenting on his family. From there, he told Joe he'd never have a WrestleMania moment like his, and refused to take the bait when the big man went for a handshake, flipping a middle finger as his Extreme Rules opponent talked trash before nailing him with the Trouble in Paradise.

Again, it was good to see another smart, strong babyface performer. These guys can't fall for the heels every single time, and Kingston's great WWE Title reign continues down the right path.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.