11 Ups And 8 Downs From WWE Royal Rumble 2018

Legit surprise returns, deserving winners and a huge debut mark history-making night.

Asuka Rumble
WWE.com

WWE sure loves to make history, doesn’t it? If you don’t believe it, just wait and they’ll tell you all about it.

It’s true though, WWE presented the first women’s Royal Rumble match Sunday, and it actually delivered a better match than the men’s bouts we’ve gotten the past few years, producing good action, plenty of surprise entrants, and a winner that won over the fans.

We also got a huge surprise at the end that nearly completely overshadowed everything else, which depending on your perspective was either great or terrible. Either way, it certainly serves to change the landscape in WWE, which is not something you can honestly say with a straight face very often these days.

We saw most of the titles stay exactly where they were in title bouts that overall were lackluster at best, confusing as hell at worst. We got a hard-hitting WWE Universal Championship match and an energetic WWE Championship bout.

Oh, and the men had a Rumble match as well. There weren’t as many surprises, and there were some dead spaces, but this year’s Rumble exceeded recent years’ affairs, delivering a winner fans loved and avoiding outright trolling fans.

With that said, let’s find out what went the distance and what got tossed in 10 seconds flat. Let’s get to it…


Downs...

8. Stiff Competition?

the revival galllows anderson
WWE.com

WWE announcers are given to using hyperbole and stretching the truth all the time. And we as fans have given to turning a deaf ear to a lot of it, because it would drive us crazy if we pushed for accuracy and truth at all times.

However, we’ve got to ding Michael Cole for a forehead-slapper he told during the kickoff show tag match. Cole noted that the tag team division on Raw was heating up, with the Club, Revival, Bar and champs all in the mix, saying it was “as competitive as it’s ever been.”

Let that roll around in your head for a minute.

Yes, announcers stretch the truth. But come on. The only other notable teams on the Raw roster are Rhyno & Heath Slater, Apollo Crews & Titus O’Neil and the Miztourage. “As competitive as it’s ever been” indeed.

Hell, NXT has a much more robust tag team division.


7. Cruiserweights Fail To Impress

royal rumble 2018
WWE.com

You would think at a time when the WWE Cruiserweight Championship has become vacant due to the champ being fired would prompt a more aggressive approach to showcasing the division. If you were going to put a match on PPV (or at least the kickoff show), you’d want to garner some interest by showing off the talented wrestlers on 205 Live.

But that’s not what happened.

We got a six-man tag match pitting Lince Dorado, Gran Metalik and Kalisto against Jack Gallagher, TJP and Drew Gulak. They went through a match that was more ground-based than you’d expect, only picking up the pace and adding some high-flying moves toward the end. By then, it was too late to salvage a middling match.

It’s a shame, because you know these guys are capable of so much more, and this could have been a reset of sorts. Instead, it was a time-filler of a match put on in a mostly empty arena.


6. Whole Lot Of Nothing

royal rumble 2018
WWE.com

The Royal Rumble is a difficult match to map out. You have to plan for 30 different superstars to enter, so you want certain combinations present at different times, keep others apart, time entrances, and keep fans’ attention during a match that will last for an hour.

There can easily be dead spots during a Rumble match, and that’s exactly what we got during the middle portion of the men’s match. After Finn Balor eliminated Baron Corbin just before the #5 entrant, there wasn’t another elimination until Sheamus was tossed in seconds at #11. And then we got another period from #12 through #17 with only two eliminations.

The match slowed down a lot during that period, perking up for entrances and settling back into the familiar “lay on the ropes or in the corner” motif. It wasn’t bad per se, just dull. The ongoing Heath Slater joke saved it a bit, but overall, it was a snoozer for about one-third of the match.


5. Dull Tag Title Match

Seth Rollins Sheamus Cesaro
WWE.com

Whatever match followed the men’s Royal Rumble was going to have a tough time, but man, Seth Rollins, Jason Jordan, Cesaro and Sheamus were sent out there to die, weren’t they?

Rollins worked the entire match for his team, as Jordan got posted on the outside, leaving him all-but unable to participate (save for a quick tag in and out), while the Bar worked Seth over and eventually finished him off to end the epic five-week reign of Jordan and Rollins.

And fans could not care less about any of that. They must’ve used up their energy cheering for Shinsuke Nakamura, because they sure weren’t reacting to anything that happened during this match. It could have been 10 minutes of paint drying and it might have gotten a better reaction.


4. Ziggler’s ‘Return’

Dolph Ziggler Randy Orton
WWE.com

What in the blue hell was that?

So after walking out on SmackDown last month days after winning the United States Championship, forcing a tournament for the vacant title, Dolph Ziggler returned unceremoniously at the Royal Rumble, entering at #30 and immediately launching a superkick party.

He managed to toss Goldust before being eliminated by Finn Balor about 90 seconds after he entered. And that was that for the Showoff.

So what the hell was the point of that? Sure, there’s a good chance we’ll get an answer of some sort on SmackDown, but that just seemed like a huge waste.


3. Anti-Climactic 2/3 Falls Match

Shelton Benjamin Usos
WWE.com

The SmackDown Tag Team Championship match looked like it was steaming ahead toward becoming a multi-snowflake affair, when fans suddenly had the rug pulled out from under them.

Shelton Benjamin & Chad Gable and the Usos threw everything at each other during the first fall, kicking out of finishers and other high-impact moves, only for Gable to finally fall to a series of superkicks. After all that, fans were looking forward to the next two falls and what could become an instant classic.

Instead, with Jimmy Uso beat up on the floor, Jey rolled Benjamin up about 30 seconds into the second fall for the win, giving the Usos the match in two straight falls. Just like that, Benjamin & Gable were knocked out of contention and right back down the ladder. This could have been a hard-fought, barely survive win that made the challengers look like a million bucks. What we got was something a lot different.

You’ve got to wonder if Gable forgot to shake someone’s hand backstage.


2. Legends Overshadow Roster

Michelle McCool Lana
WWE.com

When the women’s Royal Rumble match was announced as a 30-woman affair, you knew there would be plenty of legends entering the bout.

But what you didn’t expect was that they would turn around and literally eliminate half the field.

You read that right: Hall-of-Famers, legends and barely active women tossed half of the wrestlers in the Rumble. Michelle McCool eliminated five women, including four in rapid succession. Trish Stratus tossed three. Lita ejected two. Molly Holly and Torrie Wilson each eliminated one. And the Bella Twins pitched four women between them.

This is not to say that these women should not have had their moment in the sun and gotten to toss some deadwood. But when Raw and SmackDown roll around this week, none of those women (save maybe for Nikki) are going to be there. So what was gained?

Again, this isn’t a criticism of having them get involved and toss a couple women, but when seven women who have wrestled exactly one match in WWE in the last 10 months eliminate 16 of the 29 women from the Rumble, that’s a glaring problem.


1. Rousey Upstages Asuka

Ronda Rousey Charlotte Flair Asuka Alexa Bliss
WWE.com

This is easily the most controversial thing that happened at the Royal Rumble. Depending on your perspective, you either agree or think the frustration is misplaced.

But Ronda Rousey’s debut Sunday night was done in about the worst way you could script it.

Truth: Rousey is a huge star who could give WWE’s women’s division immediate credibility and crossover appeal. She apparently has signed a fulltime deal and is not going to be a female version of Brock Lesnar, showing up once a month for a paycheck.

That said, Asuka had just won the first women’s Royal Rumble match and was celebrating this historic moment… and Rousey came out, smiled, waved and pointed at the WrestleMania sign repeatedly. Her arrival immediately overshadowed the Empress of Tomorrow and made the moment all about Ronda. (Yes, it wasn’t her decision.)

There was no perfect way to debut Rousey, and a PPV that had a lot of eyes on it was an appealing platform. But this is going to go down as a questionable decision for a while.

All that said, Rousey still has the potential to be a huge asset to the women’s division and WWE as a whole, so this is not an indictment on her or her joining WWE, but merely how she debuted.


Ups...

11. Revival Gets Retribution

the revival wwe
WWE.com

As abysmal as the tag team “match” between Balor Club and the Revival was on Raw 25 last week, this writer was comforted by the fact that a lot of what happens on reunion shows are ignored or overwritten later.

That’s kind of what happened Sunday when the Revival picked up a win over Luke Gallows & Karl Anderson by capitalizing on Anderson’s injured knee. The kickoff show match wasn’t anything special, but with Scott Dawson & Dash Wilder just returning to the main roster, they needed a win here. Losing twice like this would have sent them down the pecking order.

It’s a shame Gallows & Anderson had to lose as they had only recently gotten their footing under themselves again, but they can fall back on being part of a bigger thing with Balor Club and recover from the loss easier.


10. AJ Pulls A Rabbit

AJ Styles Sami Zayn
WWE.com

It’s doubtful anyone was seriously buying Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens toppling AJ Styles for the WWE Championship – not because they aren’t worthy, but because Styles has been on an incredible roll and seemed on course for WrestleMania.

But beating two top superstars and making it look like you escaped can be tricky, and that’s exactly what AJ did. Styles had to deal with KO and Zayn tagging in and out frequently, often after the champ landed a couple moves. One of the best moments early on came when AJ blocked Owens from his corner, so he rolled outside, ran around the ring and dove back in by his corner and tagged Sami.

AJ managed to inflict enough damage on both (and took a bunch of punishment too) that he really capitalized on tossing Sami and reversed a Pop-Up Powerbomb into a rollup for the win.

Meanwhile, the two Canadians have a grip about a phantom tag the ref saw, so their battles with Shane McMahon will presumably continue.


9. Power Of Pancakes

kofi kingston royal rumble
WWE.com

Every year, fans wonder how Kofi Kingston will tease an elimination or stave off being tossed from the Royal Rumble. Through the years, we’ve seen him walk on his hands, use a chair as a pogo stick, and jump all the way from the guardrail back to the ring.

Sunday, Kingston was about to become the third member of New Day to get tossed by Jinder Mahal, but one of his feet landed on Xavier Woods. Big E promptly got a plate of pancakes, which prevented Kofi’s foot from touching the floor.

But with Mahal blocking his access to the ring, Kingston turned to his buddies to provide an assist – and an alley-oop, as they launched Kofi from the floor over Jinder in the ring. And then Kingston eliminated Mahal with a Trouble in Paradise.

Kofi isn’t going to win a Rumble, but his ongoing run of crazy moments avoiding elimination is a great tradition each year.


8. Surprise Return, Men’s Edition

Rey Mysterio
WWE.com

In recent years, WWE has been lacking when it comes to surprise entrants into the Royal Rumble. Sure, we’ve seen Diamond Dallas Page and Bubba Ray Dudley return, but you’re not going to be talking to your friends about that the next day.

But when Rey Mysterio showed up at #27, fans lost it. Rey hadn’t been in a WWE ring for nearly four years, with one of his last appearances coming at the 2014 Rumble, where he was booed out of the building for entering last – and not being Daniel Bryan.

Sunday, Mysterio hung in there and tossed Adam Cole, making it to the final five. He looked pretty good during that short run and hit several of his signature spots along the way. It’s not clear if this was a one-off or the beginning of one final run in WWE, but it provided a great little moment.


7. Hard-Hitting Triple Threat

Brock Lesnar Bruan Strowman
WWE.com

Although it did not close out the PPV, the WWE Universal Championship triple threat match was set up to be a massive collision between three super-heavyweights. The announcers joked that they needed to reinforce the building, but that’s exactly what needed to happen.

Brock Lesnar, Kane and Braun Strowman wasted no time with a feeling-out process and got right to attacking each other and demolishing everything around them. Tables were broken, chairs were bent, and steel steps were hurled. The match itself barely lasted 10 minutes, but they squeezed a ton of action into it from bell-to-bell.

To make it even better, they managed to possibly set up another confrontation, with Braun standing in the ring and yelling at a victorious Brock that he didn’t pin him.


6. Bad Luck Slater

Big E Heath Slater
WWE

Sometimes a running gag during the Royal Rumble is horribly unfunny. And sometimes it hits just the right notes.

Kudos to WWE for a great ongoing joke during the early stages of the Rumble, with Heath Slater drawing #5 and taking about 10 minutes to enter the ring. Baron Corbin leveled him on the entrance ramp, where he laid until Elias kicked him at #6. That started a trend, as everyone got in on the gag and took swings (or in Big E’s case, offered pancakes) at Heath on the floor.

The payoff was perfect, with Sheamus coming in at #11 and tossing Slater into the ring, only to enter himself and immediately get clotheslined out by Heath. Of course, Slater was quickly tossed by Bray Wyatt, but it was a perfectly amusing joke for fans that didn’t distract from the match itself.


5. Callbacks For The Women

Beth Phoenix Natalya
WWE.com

Given the number of returning legends and Hall-of-Famers in the women’s Royal Rumble match, there were bound to be some rekindled friendships and rivalries, and thankfully, WWE did not miss two of them.

The first was the reuniting of Natalya and Beth Phoenix (who looks like she could still run roughshod over the women’s division), real-life best friends who teamed up as proto-anti-divas during their run together. They hugged in the center of the ring – and then Nattie turned on her and eliminated Beth.

Then, as the match was winding down, everyone was knocked out except for Trish Stratus and Mickie James. Fans immediately recognized that as one of the better women’s rivalries of the 2000s. Mickie debuted as Trish’s biggest fan-turned-stalker, beating Stratus for the Women’s Championship at WrestleMania XXII. The two squared off, with Trish getting the better of it and tossing Mickie.

Those were a couple great moments, both of which worked really well.


4. Nakamura Triumphs Over Chosen Ones

Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

One of the favorites going into Sunday’s Royal Rumble had to be Shinsuke Nakamura, and his betting line had to get better when AJ Styles successfully defended his WWE Championship.

Entering at #14, Nakamura tossed Sami Zayn right away and then hung around until the end. When the ring started thinning out, fans realized he still was in there and chanted for him throughout. It got dicey when it was down to Nakamura, John Cena and Roman Reigns, with fans understandably worried that one of the two men who have main-evented a ton of WrestleManias were en route to yet another.

In that way, it was smart booking to have Shinsuke toss both of them to win, as fans were uneasy, making his victory even more satisfying. And now fans will get a true dream match at Mania between two of the best wrestlers in the world.


3. Here Comes The Hedge

Ronda Rousey Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

So after bashing the manner in which Ronda Rousey debuted, let’s be clear that her addition to the roster, especially as a full-time superstar, is a huge deal for WWE.

Rousey has not been shy about how big of a wrestling fan she is, right down to her “Rowdy” nickname and MMA Four Horsewomen group. She very clearly was happy to be at the Royal Rumble Sunday night, and when she spoke about the experience afterward, it was obvious that she wants to do this right and for the right reasons (not just a paycheck).

So while her debut itself might get a lot of (deserved) criticism, it should not negatively color the fact she’s joining WWE.


2. Predictable, But Unexpected

Charlotte Flair Asuka Alexa Bliss
WWE.com

Going into the Royal Rumble, both Shinsuke Nakamura and Asuka were on people’s short lists of who would win their respective Rumbles. But who would have expected that both of them would win?

Seeing the two of them win was a strange moment, in a very good way. Consider, we’re now going to get Nakamura/AJ Styles at WrestleMania for one of the most prestigious titles in professional wrestling. And we’re going to see Asuka battle for a women’s championship in what will hopefully be a coronation for the undefeated Empress of Tomorrow.

But after years of guys like Batista, Roman Reigns and Randy Orton winning the Rumble, it was a welcome sign to see Shinsuke and Asuka – wrestlers the fans really have taken to who aren’t WWE products – reach the mountaintop.


1. Women’s Rumble Delivers

Sasha Banks Trish Stratus
WWE.com

Despite a few negative moments (including the aforementioned legends’ dominance), the first women’s Royal Rumble was pretty well booked.

Going on last after another Rumble match and a bunch of other title matches, the women’s bout could have been completely overshadowed and lost the crowd. But the string of surprise entrants kept fans involved and into it. The match never got too crowded, and most of the notable women got a chance to shine.

We saw the first female Kofi Kingston, with Naomi walking the guardrail and using a chair to wheelbarrow her way back into the match. Old rivalries were renewed. Friends – and siblings – turned on each other. And the right woman won the first women’s Rumble.

So while there were some hiccups, hats off for a new milestone for WWE, and hopefully they build off of it.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.