11 WWF Title Challengers No One Remembers
How the heck did any of these jobbers get a shot at the company's top title?!
The WWE title still stands as one of the most prestigious belts in wrestling history. Mere mentions of the name causes images of legends like Shawn Michaels, Hulk Hogan, The Rock, Bret Hart, and John Cena to flood the mind of even some of the most casual fans.
Just as strong as the list is of people that have won it, is the list of wrestlers who had gotten so far, but were never able to grab that brass ring. Jon Morrison, who held top gold in just about every promotion he worked for, could never break through. Neither could Razor Ramon, one of the best wrestlers in the Kliq.
While many legends have challenged for the belt and never won it, even more perplexing is the WWE title's history of challengers who were just some guy, random midcarders and jobbers who got their push to the spotlight as quickly as they would lose it. Some worked a title match simply as a filler defence between major shows, came in as odd one-offs that happened in front of a TV audience, or just looked like extras in a stacked multi-man match.
Whichever way it might have been, all the challengers on this list left a lot of people scratching their heads wondering why they were there in the first place.
11. Carlito
People often forget just how vital to John Cena's push Carlito was. He was the first wrestler to really put a dent in Cena, hitting him with the chain necklace to steal the US title. He also ended Shelton Benjamin's long reign with the intercontinental championship, holding it for 90 days himself before losing it to Ric Flair.
When Cena hit his high point, riding as Raw's top man with the WWE title, he was set to face his biggest challenge up to that point, taking on his old rival Carlito, and three other former world champions in the Elimination Chamber at the 2006 edition of New Year's Revolution.
Carlito was a house on fire that match, eliminating three of the six men before finally succumbing to Super-Cena, who used every ounce of his power to overcome the odds.
Even after winning this match, Cena would still lose the title, becoming the first victim of the Money In The Bank cash-in at the hands of Edge.
Carlito still managed to have a decent career for himself after this match, despite never getting close to the main title again. He and his brother Primo would go on to make history in the WWE as the first unified tag team champions, uniting both the tag titles from Raw and SmackDown.
10. Chris Masters
Also in the Elimination Chamber with Carlito and Cena, was The Masterpiece, Chris Masters.
Masters was the recipient of a monster push with the often used body-building gimmick, making him a narcissistic heel in the vein of wrestlers like Lex Luger or Ravishing Rick Rude. While Carlito got a lot out of being in that match, Masters only split one elimination with Carlito, with both them dog piling on Kane. Masters didn't even get anyone to submit to his fabled Master-lock, which had been put over as nearly unbreakable up to that point.
While everyone else in that match enjoyed continued success in WWE, with Cena staying the top dog of the company, Shawn Michaels entering a blood feud with Mr. McMahon, and Kane getting to hold both the ECW title and World Heavyweight Championship. Masters would never hold a single title with the company, getting released in the post-Benoit steroid controversies.
Masters would spend some time on the independent circuit, cleaning himself up, before having an absolute dud of a return in 2009, leading to his release two years later. It's a shame. Considering that he had the look and presence of a fantastic heel as well as some decent technical ability, Masters could have at least had a dominant run in the midcard.
9. Spike Dudley
The runt of the Dudley litter, Little Spike Dudley was able to squeeze as much success out of wrestling as anyone of his size ever could. He had two tag team title wins with Balls Mahoney and Tazz in ECW and WWF, before having a nice singles career winning European and Cruiserweight gold.
Spike is remembered for being one of the smallest full-time wrestlers that the WWE has ever employed. Because of his meager stature, he was able to bump like the best of them, making sure everyone in the audience knew exactly how painful the moves are to a normal person. He'd writhe in pain and fly through the air like a rag doll since other wrestlers could toss him around with such ease.
But many forget that he did in fact challenge for the top title on an episode of SmackDown while he and Molly Holly feuded with a heel Stone Cold.
The stage was set for what could have been an engaging match that at least teased the upset every now and then like with Jeff Hardy's ladder match against The Undertaker. Instead, the entire match was used to put over Stone Cold as he was preparing to be a key player in the Invasion angle.
8. Ted Dibiase Jr.
The son of the Million Dollar Man was one of the six men set to open the 2010 Elimination Chamber show, and of those men - also including John Cena, Kofi Kingston, Sheamus, Triple H, and Randy Orton - Ted Dibiase Jr. would be the only one not to win a world championship.
He did manage to do something of note in the match though, retrieving a lead pipe from his partner in Legacy, Cody Rhodes, accidentally hitting Randy Orton with it, and then deciding to pin Legacy's leader anyway.
This mishap would eventually lead to the end of Legacy, a stable composed entirely of the sons of wrestling's greats. The three members would drift apart, leading to a climactic triple threat match at WrestleMania XXVI in Arizona, which, unfortunately, Randy Orton won.
Ted seemed to have the brass behind him, as WWE decided to have him be the lead actor in their film, The Marine 2. They had also given Ted a dedicated push in a babyface role, with him losing the isolation of his upper class background to tailgate with fans, calling them the DiBiase Posse. Even with all that going for him, Ted would go on to decide that wrestling just wasn't for him, leaving the business in 2013.
7. Goldust
When people think about Goldust, he's often lumped in with other midcard acts of WWF's New Generation era. It was never unreasonable to see him challenging for, or holding the Intercontinental title against guys like Razor Ramon, Hunter Hearst Helmsley, or Owen Hart.
Fans forget just how close he was to breaking through that glass ceiling. He was practically breathing on it. He and Shawn Michaels main-evented a special edition of Raw called Raw Championship Friday. Unfortunately, the match didn't thrill that many people and simply felt like a standard singles encounter, with the bout not even approaching fifteen minutes. The most notable thing about it was Shawn winning with a moonsault rather than his signature superkick.
Goldust would get opportunities in several dark matches and house shows, one in Madison Square Garden, and another at Toronto's Exhibition Stadium, again against Shawn, this time in a ladder match.
His final televised shot at the gold would come against Stone Cold Steve Austin on the same night that DX invaded WCW. Goldust took a backseat in the match's story, as this was all about the feud between Austin and Mr. McMahon. Vince attempted to stack the deck against Austin with his corporate stooge Gerald Brisco as the referee, who was blind to the interference of Dude Love, but Stone Cold knocked out the ref, leading to a no-contest.
6. Papa Shango
Charles Wright has shown a great deal of range with his characters in WWF. The Godfather and Kama both left an impression in wrestling history, but his Papa Shango character ended up getting the biggest push by far. Though his voodoo aesthetic may have seemed too hokey for the older members of the audience, it was certainly taken seriously by the booking staff, who gave him a role in the return of the Ultimate Warrior at WrestleMania VIII - even if he did miss his cue.
Despite having one of the biggest botches in WrestleMania history, Vince and company were still high on him. Months after his disastrous botch, Shango would end up headlining an episode of Saturday Night's Main Event against Bret Hart.
Bret was still getting used to his role as the new top dog of the company. He and Shango put together a match that didn't pass ten minutes, and failed to impress both fans and critics alike, with Shango tapping out to Bret's Sharpshooter. If Bret Hart can't carry a wrestler to three stars, something has to change.
Still, there was plenty of success to be enjoyed after that, as Shango would become Kama, before later joining the Nation of Domination. He'd go through another metamorphosis and become The Godfather, getting the Intercontinental title with the Ho Train following close behind.
5. Virgil
Virgil isn't remembered for much other than losing, lying, and being cheap, and that's a reputation that followed him in just about every promotion he worked for.
Formerly the man servant of WWF's top heel, The Million Dollar man, Virgil would turn face in genuinely one of the hottest moments any wrestler could have. Unfortunately, once he was on his own, the cracks in his facade began to show. He had a limited moveset, no real physical charisma, and a lack of conviction whenever he was on the microphone. This combination created a character who fans couldn't get behind, and one that the booking team could easily throw out there whenever they needed someone to take a loss.
His short loss against Bret Hart during a Superstars taping was just as forgettable as all his other matches.
Virgil would go on through the rest of his career without any real direction or momentum. He'd continue eating pins and tapping out in the WWF before switching over to WCW, putting on the nWo t-shirt and continuing his losing ways down south.
If nothing else, Virgil is still held in some high regard by fans, if ironically, for his persistent appearances at wrestling conventions, and his bombastic Twitter profile.
4. The Patriot
All that The Patriot is remembered for these days is that his theme song would later be used by WWE Hall of Famer, Kurt Angle, albeit without the sleigh bells. In a previous era, The Patriot could have been a successful character, but the time for masked super heroes who were the physical embodiment of truth, justice, and the American way, was long over in the WWF. This type of character would be one that WWE would openly critique and satirize with Kurt Angle and Mr. America.
Just as a sign of how dated he was, this is one of the wrestlers that Jim Cornette would tirelessly lobby for during booking meetings with Jim Ross, Vince Russo, Kevin Dunn, and Vince McMahon.
It's a shame his gimmick never did manage to catch on, because he was a decent enough wrestler, as evidenced by his work in both WCW and AJPW. He was just saddled with a bad gimmick. He would take on Bret Hart in a losing effort, with Hart still being a viscous pro-Canadian heel in front of the Louisville crowd. Things stayed bad the Patriot as he would go on to take more losses at the hands of the Hart Foundation, before quietly leaving wrestling
3. Hardcore Holly
Ironically the biggest push of Hardcore Holly's life happened after Brock Lesnar broke his neck.
Up until that point, Holly had been seen as a lowly jobber, firstly working a lame NASCAR gimmick as Sparky Plugg. He later enjoyed some success in the lower card, much of it related to the Hardcore title, but never anything serious.
Fueled by real life heat, he returned to action helping secure a victory for Team Benoit against Team Lesnar at Survivor Series 2003. Holly would then go on to challenge Brock for the title at Royal Rumble 2004 in a quick match that didn't even go past seven minutes.
Oddly enough, that wouldn't be the end of Hardcore Holly's shots, as he would later get a chance against JBL in a street fight on a fun episode of SmackDown which was taped in England. Predictably, it was a hardcore affair, with Holly even breaking out a cricket bat in an effort to dethrone the champion. But JBL, thanks a to a well-placed chair shot, managed to keep his reign of terror alive.
Holly stayed with the company for quite a while, bouncing around between SmackDown, ECW, and Raw, always respected as a leader of the locker room. His last big push came as a tag team champion with the young Cody Rhodes.
2. The 1-2-3 Kid
Most fans remember X-Pac's ill-fated shot at the WWE title against The Rock, where Shawn Michaels betrayed his Kliq-mate to side with The Corporation. Few people though can remember that the 1-2-3 Kid, X-Pac's original gimmick of a young and scrappy underdog, actually had himself a title match against Bret Hart on a 1994 episode of Raw.
Kid has always had a reputation of being a solid worker, capable of matches that go beyond exceptional. His athletic style, combined with his martial arts move-set made him a great opponent who could mesh with a variety of different wrestlers.
The two would be given plenty of time to work, going beyond 20 minutes with JR and Macho Man Randy Savage calling the action. Dave Meltzer would rave about the match, giving it a 4.5 star rating. It's a forgotten Raw classic.
The Kid would continue to have competent matches his whole career. He left the WWF, joining his Kliq-mates in the nWo, helping light up the cruiserweight division, before switching promotions again so he could become one of WWF's best midcarders as the emphatic X-Pac. He'd even help out in TNA's early days, working a couple phenomenal matches with AJ Styles.
1. Taka Michinoku
WWF didn't have much in the way of cruiserwieghts during the Attitude Era, but they did have Taka Michinoku, who could wow fans with his fast pace, athletic style, and diverse moveset. He had already been well established to hardcore wrestling fans thanks to his work in both the major Japanese promotions, as well as ECW.
Once he partnered with his countryman in Funaki though, it felt like he would never amount to much and simply ride out his time in WWF as a comedy jobber, save for one crazy episode of Raw in south Florida.
Taka made his way out, with his KaiEnTai teammate by his side, as well as the Acolytes at his back. He challenged Triple H for the WWF title, with his crew chasing out the members of the McMahon-Helmsley partnership. What followed was a chaotic match where Taka kept receiving help, and even managed to take advantage of The Game's hot head. Unfortunately though, with enough interference, Triple H still retained.
Taka would finish out his WWF career without much to show for it before coming back to NJPW for a successful run there as respected veteran and member of Suzuki-Gun. He also played a big part in establishing a new star, working as Zack Sabre Jr's hype-man, helping to get him over to Japanese fans before eventually starting his own wrestling school.