12 Perfect Ways To Retire Current WWE Gimmicks (And How)

Time for Cody Rhodes to say goodbye to Goldust.

At the same time that Ronda Rousey and Conor Macgregor are knocking people out in UFC, there's a adult-sized eight-year old female and soccer hooligan with chin braids running around in WWE. As much as this may be reflective of WWE's desire to attract multiple demographics, it's also incredibly stupid sometimes, too. For WWE, it may be time to retire some, if not all of these unfortunate gimmicks, and be more reflective of modern times. For every Sasha Banks, there's a Bayley, for every Undertaker, an Ascension. If WWE can fix these obvious errors in creative judgement, it might be a way for the company to get on the road to financial sustainability. As well, from an in-ring standpoint, which would you rather see? Selfie-obsessed fashion model versus '80s metal fanatic, or talented grapplers with a grudge over an attractive woman? Here's 12 WWE gimmicks that need to die...and moreover, how to get that done.


12. Dolph Ziggler

"'80s metal dude" Dolph Ziggler is a fail. Of the many things that are failing Dolph Ziggler, let's consider that the fans being disallowed from having some sort of character connection to him is a problem. From "Zack Morris and 'Saved By the Bell'" knockoff to "'80s rock guy," neither of these characterizations actually feel like they're organically Dolph Ziggler in any way. They say that the easiest way to get a character over is to be yourself turned up to 110%. Yes, Dolph like metal. But WWE (and maybe Dolph too) are undercutting Ziggler's potential. The idea of Dolph coming out one week as just being a really awesome wrestler who wears tights and boots and is a witty promo? That could work. Some wrestlers don't need to be packaged as anything more than awesome wrestlers to be great. The best example of that in the modern age? Dolph Ziggler.

11. Baron Corbin

There was an outstanding TV promo in which Baron Corbin told the NXT Universe that he was a millionaire ex-football player who wanted to crush people's dreams. At that point, the whole, "motorcycle bar brawler" gimmick that Corbin had should've died, and there should've been expensive suits, silk ties and maybe even a haircut added to Corbin's look. The main problem with Baron Corbin in NXT is that we're consistently not given a reason to care about the exact reason that he came to NXT. In a wacky case of creative NOT listening to what the talent are saying as opposed to what box they want to put them in, valuable opportunities to make a superstar out of a performer that THEY WANT TO MAKE A SUPERSTAR are being missed.

10. The Ascension

Vince McMahon has no idea what the "Illuminati" is, so the Ascension are solidly f***ed in their current gimmick. Evil dudes who believe in the Illuminati is cool in like, e-wrestling feds and as a part of the Ministry of Darkness. However, neither of those things exist at-present in the WWE. Thus, the Ascension need something more. In a manner similar to what happened with The New Day, maybe putting Konnor, Viktor and Bo Dallas on the road together as "Bo and the Bolievers" could be something. Bo Dallas confronting the pair and asking them to be his bodyguards would be either comic gold or develop into a solid midcard heel trio. Anything's better than what any of those three are doing right now, right?

9. Jack Swagger

Ex-World Heavyweight Champion Jack Swagger is a talented guy who was unfortunately paired with approximately 7,000 year (I'm joking, lol) territory veteran Dutch Mantel and Cesaro (aka one of the world's best wrestlers) and thus overshadowed into complete WWE obscurity. His "Real American" gimmick was great, it's just that Zeb Colter was greater at getting it over than Swagger was at getting heat with it in the ring. Sending Swagger back down to NXT perhaps in the headgear and singlet would be cool. Swagger with developing tag team of Chad Gable and Jason Jordan is a formidable stable that could be developed into something truly great on the black and gold brand.

8. Bull Dempsey

Bull Dempsey is a top territory heel from 1975 trapped in sports entertainment in 2015. The "entertaining fat guy" "Bull-Fit" gimmick is a one-note joke that always feels one step away from his eventual release though, which is unfortunate as he works hard. However, there's a way to save him. NXT's big on tag team wrestling. The idea of WWE potentially finding a super-jacked performer or just another rotund grappler to pair with Dempsey could be something to help Bull at least get over and get some traction in NXT. Bull having a "Bull-Fit" trainer or a fellow "Bull-Fit" disciple isn't much, but at least it's something more.

7. Tyler Breeze

I know, I know. Tyler Breeze just debuted on the main roster. Thus, it's easy to say that he has no problem with his gimmick and he should be able to get over, right? Wrong. A bad guy with a selfie stick gets over in NXT because it's a cute and relevant character quirk that feels unique. However, on the main roster, where performers with multiple dimensions to their character get the opportunity to grow and evolve, Breeze is missing everything to do that. There's an easy solution, though. I like the idea of actually having the very first feud for Tyler Breeze end with a "selfie stick" match between Dolph and Breeze. Yes, this is up there with putting Judy Bagwell on a forklift or fighting over Japanese shampoo contracts, but, yeah, it goes somewhere. Tyler Breeze being a guy who just believes he's hot because his HOT GIRLFRIEND TELLS HIM HE'S HOT works. In a similar manner to Shawn Michaels losing his full length mirror, Breeze has to lose that selfie stick ASAP in order to evolve as a performer and hit the next level.

6. Bayley

OK. Bayley just wrestled in a 30-minute ironman match and has had a series of hard-hitting matches against top competitors throughout 2015. The idea of this now grizzled women's wrestler dressing like an eight-year old girl might be done. The moment that Bayley stood in the ring with ACTUAL eight-year old girl Izzy, her gimmick as adult-sized child passed its peak effectiveness. The time has come for Bayley to look like an adult, and in doing show show little girls everywhere that when they grow up, that they can eventually become adult-sized adult heroines like Bayley. Imagine Alexa Bliss coming out one week and burying Bayley's gear and bearing down the current NXT Women's CHampion to the point that she makes Izzy cry. Bliss bullying Bayley into standing up for herself "like a real WOMAN" and reflecting this by dressing like one, would be a necessary character development point. As ground-breaking as Bayley's character is, there's going to either be a point where she gets too old for this adult-sized child thing to keep holding weight. It needs to stop now.

5. Sheamus

Jesus. Sheamus looks stupid in a bad way, right? Like in a frustratingly hard to connect with him in any other way than "JESUS MAN, YOU LOOK SO INCREDIBLY STUPID I DON'T WANT TO BOO YOU" sort of way, right? We're in agreement here, right? In an ideal world, stealing Cesaro and Chris Hero's indy wrestling tag name of the Kings of Wrestling and applying it to Barrett and Sheamus as a tag team is the best idea. Hell, Sheamus can keep the mohawk, but the nose ring and chin braids? Yeah, that's gotta go...

4. Roman Reigns

Roman Reigns is a bad dude from the bad side of town with a heart of gold. Instead, he's a flak jacket wearing superhero. If the WWE Universe is divided on John Cena as a superhero in gym clothes, why would anyone in WWE think that Roman standing there in a flak jacket with what's basically a Superman breastplate was going to work any better? Roman walking down the aisle one week without the flak jacket but in cargo pants and jackboots? That's an idea worthy of consideration. But this superhero s**t has to stop. Immediately. It's lame and I'd wager that very few WWE fans believe that it's a "cool" look or gimmick for him.

3. Stardust

If Lana and Rusev can get engaged and shatter kayfabe completely, then why in the hell is Cody Rhodes still doing a David Bowie impersonation when he's a cool guy with a smoking hot wife, "bizarre" older brother, and dad who was one of the most iconic wrestlers of all time? Like, WE ALL KNOW WHO HE IS (and he should be allowed to run with it). Cody Rhodes is absurdly talented at many things. He's a classically trained actor and a damned great pro wrestler. As well, his brother is Goldust, his dad is Dusty Rhodes and his wife is the Smackdown ring announcer. Could a run of promos with Cody Rhodes calling himself "the most interesting man in the world" and pulling the curtain all the way down about his character be something worthwhile? Of course. Cody Rhodes has had approximately 100 million gimmicks during his run in WWE. Maybe just letting Cody be himself (and only himself) turned up to 110% is the answer. It's certainly worth a try.

2. John Cena

I'd actually pay good money to be there live to see John Cena in tights and boots, wrist tape and something other than a crew cut run down to the ring on Raw, give a celebrating Sheamus an Attitude Adjustment, win the World Championship, then promptly hand the championship belt to Vince McMahon. The next week? I'd love to see a re-debuting Sami Zayn pin "heel John Cena" clean in the middle after a Blue Thunder Bomb for the United States Championship, but still have "heel John Cena" in boots and tights as World Champion. On a larger level unrelated to this article, the one WWE legend who needs to make a comeback is Vince McMahon. Vince creating a stable of say, Cena, Batista, Team Bella and Eva Marie would be GOLDEN. The idea that "visionary wrestling promoter Vince McMahon has the answers" -- and that the "answers" are these five people -- oh my, that's HEAT. Heel Cena and Heel Batista against a returning Tyson Kidd and Cesaro or The Usos? That'd be a lot of fun.

1. King Barrett

There's a plethora of more high-profile championship runs and possibly a WrestleMania main event performance in Wade Barrett that's being literally trapped inside of him by the crown he's wearing on his head. There's a crop of talent at-present in WWE that's busting their asses on the mid-card, and are almost all pretty much saddled with some of the worst gimmicks ever. Aside from the aforementioned Stardust and Sheamus, it's the fact that being King of the Ring has gone from a gift to a curse for Barrett that makes it unfortunate. Anyone else want to see Wade Barrett throw his crown in a river? Wade Barrett looks great, wrestles well, cuts a solid promo and is deserving of MUCH, MUCH more than being some sort of cartoonish "king."

In this post: 
Cody Rhodes
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Besides having been an independent professional wrestling manager for a decade, Marcus Dowling is a Washington, DC-based writer who has contributed to a plethora of online and print magazines and newspapers writing about music and popular culture over the past 15 years.