12 Ups & 0 Downs From AEW Dynamite (23 Nov - Review)
Kenny Omega & The Elite troll CM Punk in Chicago, House Of Black return, Thunder Rosa stripped.
Chicago is still the king of wrestling crowds.
This was proven on last night's Dynamite, as AEW entered CM Punk's domain for the first time since Brawl Out. That The Elite were on the card opposite Death Triangle heightened the situation. Context meant that the audience's reactions to that specific match was the most interesting question heading into the show, even with two title fights on the lineup - and what transpired made for some of the most compelling weekly programming of the year.
Dynamite, in general, was superlative. Some segments soared higher than others but Tony Khan's cooking hasn't tasted this good in a while. Full Gear's positive energy carried through the weekend and into Wednesday night, with The Elite, House Of Black, Jamie Hayter, Orange Cassidy, and more highlighting an electric episode.
Some of the biggest things that happened on this show will spark fierce, impassioned debate. Good. That's the point. Dynamite's boldest moments were wild and provocative. Kenny Omega releasing an interview asking fans to move on from the CM Punk saga and then stoking the fires himself within 12 hours wasn't an accident.
Workers working. The essence of the sport.
Let's light the fuse...
Ups...
12. Top Flight & FTR Shake On It
Spoilers for this week's Rampage are out there if you want them. If you've read them, you'll know what comes of Dynamite's segment with Top Flight and FTR.
Nonetheless, this was a good bit of business to pit one of the tag teams of today against a tandem of tomorrow. Back in the company and full of confidence, Darius and Dante Martin challenged Dax Harwood and Cash Wheeler to a respectful ROH Tag Team Title match. The two sides put each other over, agreed to the bout, and shook on it.
Wrestling doesn't always need elaborate, complex construction. This combination was put together for FTR to give the up-and-coming Top Flight some shine in a likely defeat, which was reflected here.
11. Jade Cargill Clashes With Bow Wow, Loses A Baddie
Jade Cargill and Bow Wow's confrontation was underwhelming. Seconds in length, it saw Cargill and her Baddies pulled away from a blazing argument with the rapper, who barely featured. Was it worth advertising? Debatable, but probably not.
Nonetheless, Jade had moves to make afterwards. Dismissing Bow Wow as a "wack ass rapper" that she refused to give more clout to, Cargill thanked the returning Red Velvet for helping her but dismissed her other Baddies, Kiera Hogan and Leila Grey, for being of little use against Nyla Rose at Full Gear.
This led to Mark Sterling being brought in with a legal document for Hogan to sign, acknowledging that she hadn't lived up to her end of the deal and was therefore no longer needed in The Baddies. Velvet is back, Gray remains, and Hogan is gone.
And next week, the trio celebrate.
10. Wardlow's Gonna Kill Joe
WarJoe's coming together and quickfire split could perhaps have used more time on the stove - but what has come of it looks promising.
Samoa Joe stealing the TNT Championship win at Full Gear was the right kind of shock. Blindsided on the pay-per-view, Wardlow reacted last night, cutting a good, authoritative pretaped promo in which he let Samoa Joe that he isn't the most dangerous man in the room, nor is he the TNT Champion - and Wardlow is coming back for the belt.
Winter Is Coming or ROH Final Battle could fit the bill for another title change, where AEW will use Joe to put the younger, more over babyface over and continue Wardlow's run.
Which is exactly how a guy like Joe should be booked in 2022.
9. Keith Lee & Swerve Strickland Keep It Private
Another quick and easy backstage segment here, with Keith Lee and Swerve Strickland literally palming the camera away for their awkward conversation, opting instead to have it in private.
Lee decided he'd finally had enough of Swerve at Full Gear, turning his back on his partner and effectively costing them the World Tag Team Championships. Lee, who would believably have stayed away from Swerve all week, barely wanted to speak with him here - and only consented to it without the cameras.
This character dynamic deserves more time. It looks like it's about to get that. The Acclaimed's natural, organic rise and explosion in popularity is one side of the tag division's supremacy at the moment, with this the other.
8. Jeff Jarrett Is Out Of His Damn Mind... Again
The Acclaimed are probably going to fight Jeff Jarrett and Jay Lethal in 2022.
What a year.
This came about when Max Caster and Anthony Bowens came down to a monster pop. Caster rapped about Full Gear, mentioning Jarrett and Lethal's defeat to Darby Allin and Sting, while Bowens confirmed his shoulder has healed. Billy Gunn, meanwhile, unwrapped his hands and got ready for a scissoring for the first time in weeks, which proved the perfect point for the heel interruption.
Lethal, Jarrett, and Sonjay Dutt want the babyfaces to keep their names out of their mouths. Chicago, bless them, gave Jeff a "TNA SUCKS!" chant.
Scissoring eventually happened, the crowd rejoiced, and a fun filler title defence appears to be in the works. The Acclaimed and Daddy Ass are currently so over that they could likely spend five minutes doing literally nothing and it'd still be received well by those in the arena.
7. Jake Hager Loves His Hat, But Loses To Orange Cassidy
Comedy is subjective, doubly so in professional wrestling, so there's little wrong with not enjoying an All-Atlantic Championship match centered largely around men trying to put a purple hat on. Subjectively, it isn't for this reviewer - but it'd be wrong to argue against its existence when it is so over.
The point of wrestling is to engage the crowd. Orange Cassidy and Jake Hager did then tenfold, working comedy spots around moments of genuine craft on their contrasting strengths and weaknesses, with the Jericho Appreciation Society, Best Friends, and Rocky Romero as the supporting cast.
Once the comedy subsided, good counter-wrestling led to the eventual finish, with finishing moves and signatures dodged, countered and finally executed. An Orange Punch preceded the Cazadora, the pin of which led to another successful defence for Cassidy.
And a great post-match angle. More on that later.
6. Ricky Starks Topples Ethan Page, Advances To MJF
Matches like this demonstrate Ricky Starks' value as a week-to-week television wrestler.
It's not that 'Absolute's' battle with Ethan Page was one of the best of the year, but that it was extremely effective. This was a neat, tidy story wrapped in a 13-minute runtime, playing on recent events to establish the victor as a hotter title challenger than when he walked in.
Starks was feeling the impact of facing Lance Archer and Brian Cage in quick succession. Beaten down by Archer before their match then put through the meat grinder, he walked out with half his torso taped up. The psychology, therefore, was Page, the bully, going after the clear weakness, dominating for long periods, and Starks making fiery comebacks. Ricky sold like a pro for his part, entering a superb defensive performance before sparking back up, reduced primarily to hope spots for long, long periods.
It took three Spears to eventually put 'All Ego' down. Going to these lengths sold Ethan as a credible pillar for Ricky to topple, meaning Page lost nothing in defeat - particularly as manager Stokely Hathaway was ejected halfway through.
Starks now emerges a stronger babyface for having fought such adversity. He is well-positioned to face MJF at Winter Is Coming, though it's hard to tell how audiences will receive
5. Jamie Hayter, Interim Women's Champion No More
Thunder Rosa is no longer AEW Women's World Champion. As confirmed by Renee Paquette, the injured star has relinquished the belt for it, AEW, and the division's own good, with her recovery still uncertain. Best wishes to her - and here's hoping she's back before long.
This was the right decision and one that should perhaps have come sooner. Nonetheless, Jamie Hayter can now shed the "Interim" tag and enjoy life as a full-on World Champion.
Hayter's next move was booked immediately after the announcement. Britt Baker snatched the microphone away from Jamie before she could speak, using "we" when talking about the belt, rather than focusing on her "friend." Hogging the spotlight, Baker was self-centered throughout, planting the first seeds for what should be a long-term story about the division's biggest star struggling with the idea of the person she brought into the company being above her in the pecking order.
A solid enough three-way tag followed. Baker and Hayter - The Killer and The Pillar - defeated Tay Jay A.S. and Willow Nightingale/Skye Blue in a fine battle that was window dressing for the new story, with Baker scoring the pin via stomp. This improves her position in the relationship and should empower her to keep being overbearing until Jamie decides enough is enough.
4. All Rise For The House Of Black
The House Of Black's return to AEW television was appropriately impactful.
What people want most from this awesome group is for them to wreck people. On Dynamite, they wrecked everybody in sight, disposing of Best Friends, Orange Cassidy, Rocky Romero, The Factory, and a host of extras in their first appearance in two months. Afterwards, Malakai Black got on the microphone and asked "please rise," surrounded by his crew of killers.
Danhausen's Full Gear Zero Hour entrance came to mind as soon as the microphone cut out and the lights dipped during QT Marshall's post-Hager/Cassidy promo. Skilled subversion followed when Julia Hart, not Danhausen, appeared on the ramp, soundtracked by indomitable death-metallers Deadboy. Cue: Brody King, Black, and Buddy Matthews entering the ring, smashing the babyfaces. When The Factory tried to applaud this, they died too. A stream of "security guards" and preliminary wrestlers then came down the ramp, running right into the woodchipper.
The number of people dispatched and the way the House took care of them landed like a blast beat. Complicated personal situations in the rearview, they're back, and seemingly deadlier than ever.
3. Jon Moxley Spares William Regal's Life
William Regal opened Dynamite, attracting mega-heat from Chicago in his first appearance since betraying Jon Moxley and costing him the World Championship at Full Gear.
Name-dropping MJF drew cheers from an audience that later yelled "REGAL SUCKS!" and "F*** YOU REGAL!" at the top of their lungs. The veteran heel delayed their gratification by saying they'd hear from MJF next week, not this week, when Moxley's music hit.
Only Bryan Danielson separated Moxley and Regal. Mox wanted to tear a man with a papier-mache neck and two brain bleeds to pieces. Danielson was literally on his knees at one point, begging his stablemate not to act on his impulses, slapping sense into him one second and pleading the next. This was played marvellously well. To get his anger out, Moxley had to lock the top rope in a white-knuckle death grip, shaking with fury.
He couldn't strike Regal. For all his anger, that man, at one point, had meant a lot to him. So when he finally got the microphone, his words landed as the hardest thing in the universe. "Lordship, I only want one thing from you," growled Moxley. "I want you to run. Run far away, as far away as you can, and never, ever come back."
And Regal, who will most certainly be back, did just that.
Organic, authentic, and real, this was a near-perfect balancing act. Moxley and Danielson's individual inner turmoil could not have landed this well if not for their respective performance skills.
2. Tomohiro Ishii & Chris Jericho Split Each Other Apart
NJPW's Tomohiro Ishii finally had the blowaway AEW singles match his legacy and reputation demanded last night, falling to Chris Jericho in The Ocho's best ROH World Championship match yet.
Big Tom's formula is immaculate and timeless. That any wrestler in the world, regardless of style, can be slotted into it and not look out of place is testament to Ishii's enduring power. What he does isn't complicated, though he adds just enough variety to each iteration to keep it from going stale. Here, he was as hard-nosed, stoic, and pissy as ever, throwing chops, popping up and crumbling with delayed-onset selling, and finding just the right moment to fire the arena up with comebacks every single time.
It was Ishii adapted for an American television audience. Spots like turning over to flip Jericho two middle fingers before eventually passing out to the Liontamer were products of this. One last act of defiance in the face of certain defeat.
Blood streamed from Jericho's chest during the picture-in-picture break, the product of a Kobashi vs. Sasaki-esque chop battle. A startling visual, but still not the bout's most breathtaking aspect. Try Ishii folding like an accordion after trying to pop up from a second German Suplex, his body unable to mask the pain any longer, selling the cumulative damage.
Nobody conveys a sense of struggle like this man. Time will dull his skills eventually, as it does for everyone. Until then, enjoy Big Tom, the most consistent, reliable, and tough wrestler on the planet.
1. Kenny Omega & The Elite Troll CM Punk In Chicago
One of the best wrestling works of the year unfolded this week, involving The Elite, CM Punk, and the city of Chicago.
It began with The Young Bucks changing their Twitter bio to "Chicago. This will be interesting." early in the week. Then, around 12 hours before Dynamite, a Sports Illustrated interview with Kenny Omega was released. In it, Omega called for fans to let go of the All Out situation:-
“There are things no one can talk about, so I’d encourage people to let it go. It doesn’t change that we want a team effort in AEW. I don’t even mean implicitly myself and my opponent. It also means the referee, the fans, the people who set up the ring, everyone–even a technical error can ruin the memory of a match. I can refer back to the exploding barbed wire death match. So I encourage people to move away from it because there is no information to be released."
This was a calculated move. Kenny Omega is smart, extremely so, and knew exactly what he was doing in calling for peace one second, and then inciting war the next.
When Being The Elite's audio dropped for Full Gear's "F*** CM Punk!" chants to shine, the trio's intention was likely for Chicago to chant the opposite back at them when they faced Death Triangle. Which is exactly what happened.
When Kenny enraptured Chicago by building up a Terminator dive before flipping into a Go To Sleep taunt, he wanted to turn their reaction on its head. Which is exactly what happened.
When Omega hit the Go To Sleep, then hit Twitter to insist he was paying tribute to KENTA, he wanted Punk diehards to be frothing with rage. Which is exactly what happened.
When Matt Jackson deliberately botched a Buckshot Lariat, openly mocking the move's worst execution in history as performed by Chicago's hero himself, it was to rile people up and draw them into their expert heel performance.
Which is exactly what happened.
The excellent trios match that unfolded around all this showmanship? That's what they wanted too.
The Elite vs. Death Triangle was wonderful theatre. Playing villains Punk's hometown, The Elite conducted the audience like pros, then ultimately ate sh*t. Matt Jackson was pinned when Penta struck him with the hammer, allowing PAC, whose broken nose was targeted all bout long, to score the victory. That's how it is supposed to work.
And Chicago were here for it. They didn't rebel, disrupt the show, or try to take over. They were 100% along for the ride, even when rooting for different parties. That the tribalism subsided for a "this is awesome!" chant towards the end spoke not only to the crowd's investment, but their understanding of the expert-tier work unfolding before their eyes.
CM Punk is never coming back.
The Elite are 0-2.
And this was the best Dynamite of 2022.