12 Ups & 2 Downs From Last Night's WWE SmackDown (13 Aug)

Reigns battles Murphy, Owens vs. Shane rumbles on.

Randy Orton
WWE.com

A few bum months aside, SmackDown's quality has genuinely outdone Raw's since WWE brought the brand split back in 2016. It isn't reflected in the viewership, but for the most part, the former 'Land of Opportunity' is a sharper, easier-to-watch show with a far higher floor than the flagship. While it might not always blow you away, SD rarely makes you feel like you've wasted two hours.

The dynamic has shifted somewhat in recent weeks. Mondays have been excellent since the erratic Raw Reunion, pressuring SmackDown to maintain its spot atop the main roster pile. Fortunately, Team Blue's heads remain above the rising tide, and last night was a roaring success.

This excellent show was once again built largely around the Roman Reigns whodunit saga, not only giving us 'The Big Dog' vs. Buddy Murphy, but also strong, strong rebuttals from Daniel Bryan and Rowan. Elsewhere, there were continuations of the Randy Orton/Kofi Kingston and Shane McMahon/Kevin Owens feuds, fresh opponents for Xavier Woods and Big E, and a mouthwatering Ember Moon vs. Charlotte Flair throwdown.

The criticisms, once again, are minor. SmackDown ruled last night. Let's hope the Clash of Champions build stays this strong...


Downs...

2. Knock-uh, Knock-uh, Knock-uh

Forget the content of Aleister Black's dopey dark room promo last night - this columnist has spent more than enough time criticising that over the past few months. Instead, focus on his delivery.

Why is this guy talking like old-school Triple H-uh? Why the verbal tic? Why over-emphasise the last letter(s) on every other word, or worse, add an uh/ih?

Whoever came up with this idea has made Black sound stupid. These promos are unintentionally meme-worthy not only for their repetition but Aleister's vocal idiosyncrasies, which make him stand out for all the wrong reasons. It's as if somebody wants viewers to take the p*ss out of him.

What was the problem with Black's delivery in NXT? He didn't sound like Triple H-uh down there and his words actually had weight. That's no coincidence.


1. The Feud MUST Continue!

Kevin Owens
WWE.com

Your writer is Kevin Owens in the above photograph.

Hands up who wanted to see KO vs. Shane McMahon continue beyond SummerSlam? That match was everything it needed to be. A shenanigan-filled layout gave the babyface plenty to battle against without being made to overcome unrealistic odds and Owens felled Shane (and Elias) decisively. He didn't screw around; he just beat their arses in under 10 minutes, setting him up for what should've been the next chapter in his career.

Yet here we are, two nights later, and the former 'Prizefighter' is still feuding with Shane. Big sighs all-round.

SmackDown's opening segment was well-performed. Owens was amped up the day after his five-year WWE anniversary and spoke of King of the Ring with passion, while McMahon was at his d*ckish best in handing KO his $100,000 fine. Regardless, SummerSlam felt like the perfect place to end this storyline. It was a solid feud with decent heat that regularly brought out the best in both men, but its time has come and gone. Why does everything need to be stretched beyond its natural conclusion?


Ups...

12. Why You Always Lying?

Oh my god, stop f*cking lying.

No, Buddy. Really. It's for your own good.

This guy needs to stop hanging out in locker rooms. Last week saw him bludgeoned by Roman Reigns as 'The Big Dog' attempted to extract information relating to his recent attacks. This week, it was Daniel Bryan and Rowan swinging the hammer and, with both men desperate to clear their name, they convinced WWE's 'Best Kept Secret' into admitting he was lying about Rowan's role in the ambushes after throwing him around like a football.

Viewers might argue that this beatdown sapped much of the momentum Buddy gained through his awesome match with Reigns (more on that later), hence the low positioning. That the Aussie keeps getting his arse handed to him every week isn't ideal. Still, it feels like this is leading somewhere. Murphy came off suitably sympathetic as he fell victim to WWE's most devious heel and his massive bodyguard, and it's not like he's getting beaten up by dorks either: we're talking Bryan, a 6'8"/315lb beast, and Roman bloody Reigns here.

Let's hope the optimism pays off.


11. KO's Mean Street Posse Shoutout

The Mean Street Posse
WWE.com

Kevin Owens referencing this trio of idiots on SmackDown? You love to see it.

Surely it's about time Shane McMahon brought Rodney, Pete Gas, and Joey Abs in for a cheeky cameo? They're an all-time great goober stable and hey, if WWE can bring the Spirit Squad back in 2016...


10. The Only Badass In Town?

Shane McMahon Samoa Joe
WWE

A quick backstage segment began with Sarah Schreiber asking Shane McMahon who Kevin Owens' opponent would be after breaking his television earlier on. Samoa Joe walked in as the former Commissioner said KO had thrown a six-year-old's tantrum, saying that Kev was walking around like "Billy Badass" when he was the only badass in town, which was enough for Shane to decide that Joe would be the man to face Owens.

Not a lot to pick apart here, but a good segment regardless. Of course a man like Joe would take umbrage with someone else thinking they're the big man. He remains WWE's most swaggering bully, despite his recent win/loss record, and should be going after those he thinks are trying to outdo his defining character traits. This is an affront to Joe. Wrestling assholes, like real-life assholes, are driven by their insecurities. For all his badassery, this one is no different.


9. Nice TV You've Got There...

... be a shame if someone put a side table through it.

Kevin Owens took a willing $5k hit on a 4K screen moments after last night's opener, having followed Shane McMahon to his backstage office. This came after 'The Best in the World' had dared KO to swing at him so he could sue him for every dime in his wallet, and out came Kev's bottled frustration, ruining Shane's planned night of watching SmackDown from a weird, neck-straining angle.

Two things:-

1. That's one expensive television.

2. Owen's mirrored the audience's exasperation here. He, like us, thought he was done with Shane at SummerSlam, but there he was, staring a massive fine and weeks (months?) of further f*ckery right in the face. Once more, he is the viewers' avatar. Live vicariously through him.

That's good writing.


8. A Simple Setup

Big E Dash Wilder
WWE.com

WWE established their next SmackDown Tag Team Championship feud in simple, effective fashion last night, beginning with the announcement that Xavier Woods and Big E would collide with The Revival later on.

It continued when Dash Wilder and Scott Dawson were interviewed by Kayla Braxton. They don't like The New Day because they "ruined" tag team wrestling by fannying around with pancakes, then promised to show why they'd never been defeated by the babyfaces. Later, Woods, E, and Kofi Kingston brought their characters out, mocking The Revival's assertions by claiming they'd ruined a few things - dinner, Christmas, an adult circumcision - but not tag wrestling. Later, Dash and Dawson pinned Woods in what became a trios main event.

This is refreshing in its directness. A seemingly random match when tag purists The Revival outlined the differences between them and The New Day, and we're now set to get our first proper feud between the two since spring 2017. Good.


7. Keith Is Upset

Randy Orton
WWE.com

Randall Keith Orton had a few choice words for Kofi Kingston and The New Day ahead of what was supposed to be a tag team main event.

'The Viper' emerged after shots of his SummerSlam match with the WWE Champion appeared onscreen, claiming Kingston had run away from the fight in front of his wife and children. Someday, he claimed, those kids will grow up and ask their daddy why he took the easy way out rather than standing his ground, and Kofi will tell them the truth: he can't beat Orton.

Randy promised to give Kofi the chance to redeem himself there and then, thus making the bout a six-man tag. A very WWE setup, but it worked.

Orton's promo work was strong here, with the former 'Legend Killer' slithering his way into another opportunity and, presumably, a second WWE Title shot. That SummerSlam finish was divisive and the match unspectacular, though last night's content delivered.


6. Joe & Elias Screw KO

Samoa Joe Kevin Owens Elias
WWE.com

Setting aside all concerns re: the Shane McMahon vs. Kevin Owens feud continuing for a moment, KO's bout with Samoa Joe did what it was supposed to.

'The Best in the World' was out to knock Owens down a peg by having his henchman, Elias, screw him after failing to do so at SummerSlam. He succeeded. 'The Drifter' was all over a solid TV scrap that eventually succumbed to hijinx as he pulled the referee out of the ring then took his role, counting super-fast as Joe rolled KO up for the victory. Cue: Owens' rage and Tom Phillips speculating on what this meant for his mindset ahead of King of the Ring.

Some will bemoan the shenanigans and Owens taking the loss here, but that's the way this bout had to go after WWE chose their path earlier in the night. It's another hurdle for KO to overcome; one that he will overcome in time. Patience, chaps. Patience.


5. Not Guilty, Your Honour

Rowan Daniel Bryan
WWE.com

Daniel Bryan might not be a late-'90s/early-'00s pop-reggae artist, but he does bear a passing resemblance to the other famous Shaggy, and last night's message was simple: "it wasn't me."*

Or Rowan.

SummerSlam saw the king of cutoff metal tees batter Buddy Murphy during his Kickoff Show bout with Buddy Murphy, ordering the Aussie keep his name out of his mouth. He and Bryan followed up with a first-hour address in which Daniel vehemently denied any wrongdoing in the ongoing Roman Reigns situation, claiming they had nothing to do with the attempts on 'The Big Dog's' life, calling Murphy a liar.

"Buddy gave the wrong name," Bryan claimed, prompting chants of "it was you!" from the crowd. While Daniel said he hated to disappoint the audience, him and his enforcer just weren't involved - and they'd prove it later on.

Characteristically strong stuff from Bryan here. His promos are as big a sure thing as anything else in the company. If he did, indeed, play a role in all of this, he did a great job trying to convince us that he didn't, the vile, hateful prick.

* hear that? That's the sound of Mauro Ranallo's lawyers picking up the phone.


4. Big Dogs & Revelations

SmackDown's closing scene was short and sweet. The rampaging Roman Reigns arrived in Daniel Bryan and Rowan's locker-room, looking for answers. Bryan demanded an apology, as Reigns had done for Samoa Joe last week, though 'The Big Dog' wasn't budging. This led to Daniel saying that he'd been conducting his own investigation into what's going on and had identified the culprit, though they weren't going to reveal anything until next week.

Fin.

Determining whether a cliffhanger was successful or not was simple: if it made you want to tune in next week to find out what happens, it worked. That was the case here, emphatically.

Scaffolding angle aside, this whodunit has been extremely well done. It may yet lead to the Bryan vs. Reigns dream match that was originally reported for SummerSlam. That's a bout worth waiting for, and discovering who was really behind Roman's recent attacks is a big hook for next week's show.


3. Big Match, Big Fun

The Revival Randy Orton Big E
WWE.com

A trio of matches complete this week's SmackDown Ups and Downs. That was one of the show's greatest strengths: excellent in-ring action highlighting elite talents from an elite roster, with no doubt overstaying its welcome.

Randy Orton and The Revival versus The New Day was a breeze, and a near-perfect microcosm of the show as a whole. Fast, fun, and watchable, it accomplished everything you could possibly want from a bout of this nature in this position, and that it ran for just 12 minutes is another plus. Nobody needs to see these things spiral out of control when they're primarily designed to bridge two feuds.

The conclusion, as is often the case with WWE TV matches, was great. It saw Xavier Woods fighting valiantly against the heel force with just a single arm, having had the other limb destroyed throughout the match. He ultimately fell. The Revival took advantage of his weakened state, downed him with the Shatter Machine, and scored the three.

A post-match beatdown saw every babyface laid out on the canvas, as Orton rounded things off with an RKO buffet. He didn't score the pinfall but still looked like the man in the end. Great presentation.


2. Ember Reignites Against Flair

Ember Moon Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

Two nights removed from a disappointing clash with SmackDown Women's Champion Bayley at SummerSlam, Ember Moon came back to life with a great showing against Charlotte Flair, who defeated Trish Stratus in a legacy pay-per-view match.

Quality-wise, this was a big leap forward for the 'War Goddess.' She looked great against 'The Queen.' Igniting the bout with hyper-athleticism and her flashy, high-impact offence, Moon reminded the audience that she's a firecracker between the ropes, despite falling short at SmackDown.

The bout's reason for existing was simple. More than a mere exhibition, this was Charlotte's shot at revenge after Moon blasted her with the Eclipse in lead-up to SummerSlam. That move saw Flair, aghast that she'd been left out of the main title programme, sow the seeds for her clash with Stratus. Regardless, the lust for retribution never leaves a mind as petty as hers, and she got it here.

There's a point to be made about Moon losing again after WWE had systematically failed to prevent her as a threat in the Bayley feud. That's a shame, though it's secondary to the match's real goal: giving Flair closure and potentially setting her up as the next title challenger.


1. Of COURSE This F*cking Ruled

Roman Reigns Buddy Murphy
WWE.com

Well, duh.

Roman Reigns vs. Buddy Murphy was awesome. The epitome of a modern TV banger, it was an elevated version of those great Murphy Cruiserweight Championship matches, only with a beefier opponent. In 'The Big Dog,' Buddy had an opposite number capable of slugging with him, and slug they did, breaking out all manner of big bombs throughout a beautifully competitive clash.

Buddy paid tribute to Kota Ibushi and Kenny Omega at one point, first blasting Reigns with a transitional version of the latter's V-Trigger, followed by a Kamigoye, then a Brainbuster into a pin attempt. Earlier, his spectacular Meteora got another close two. This was a theme throughout the match, with Reigns giving his opponent boatloads of offence in his first TV match since joining SmackDown, ensuring that even in defeat, Murphy got over (no mean feat in today's WWE).

In 14 minutes, Murphy was allowed to show almost everything that makes him such an explosive proposition between the ropes. He absolutely deserves better. More matches of this calibre will go a long way to establishing him on SD, though he had the ideal opponent in Reigns: an underrated athlete and a strong action fighter who spaces his big spots out like the elite Sports Entertainer he is.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.