12 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Dynamite (Oct 2)

AEW fires a strong opening salvo in the Wednesday Night Wars.

Jon Moxley Kenny Omega
AEW

So here we are.

13 months removed from All In, nine from AEW's grand Jacksonville unveiling, and a shade under five from the TNT/WarnerMedia announcement, the first episode of Dynamite has hit the airwaves. After all the hype, everything The Elite went through to get here, the WWE potshots, the highs (Double Or Nothing), the lows (the UK TV deal), and everything in between, it was time for Tony Khan, Cody, The Young Bucks, and co. to shut up and deliver.

How did they do? The numbers in the title tell the story. This was a very, very good pro-wrestling show, and likely an accurate reflection of what fans can expect from Dynamite going forward, but not the all-out banger many thought they needed on night one. Not by a longshot.

Though lacking that one huge, game-changing angle, Dynamite nonetheless delivered a cluster of good-to-great matches, a Lex Luger on Nitro moment, and one particularly nasty act of violence perpetrated by that rascal Jon Moxley. Elsewhere, the first AEW Women's Champion was crowned as Riho met Nyla Rose, Brandon Cutler fought for Dungeons & Dragons' honour against MJF, and Tony Schiavone joined the announce booth for the first time.

Let's dive into it...


Downs...

4. "Card Is Subject To Change"

Jon Moxley
AEW

All Elite Wrestling promised that Jon Moxley would be given a live microphone on Dynamite. The 'Purveyor Of Violence' was going to speak, we were told. After missing out on his All Out match with Kenny Omega following a staph infection, Mox would break his silence, spit hot lava, and set things up for their Full Gear match.

This didn't happen. Rather than cutting a promo (something the show could really have done with), Moxley was limited to interfering in the main event. We'll cover that later in the column, but this was a total WWE move from AEW, who failed to deliver on something they'd advertised.

The whole thing felt cheap. Here's hoping they don't do this again.


3. This Ain't It

Angelico Jack Evans Jason Mewes
AEW

Jack Evans and Angelico confronted Kevin Smith and Jason Mewes as Dynamite returned from its second commercial break, and it was really, really weird.

The actors were there to hype their Jay and Silent Bob revival. Angelico and Evans spat a few lines, playing up their new heel status, before Mewes mocked them for failing to win an AEW match so far. This led to Private Party weirdly turning up in the crowd to share a little bit of the bubblay with Mewes and Smith, then the whole thing just sort of ended.

This felt like filler, though Evans' rant was at least entertaining. Coming straight into it from a commercial was an extremely rough transition, too, and the show would've lost nothing had it just been cut out entirely.


2. Commercial Breakdown

AEW Dynamite
AEW

British AEW fans were undoubtedly screwed when the company unveiled their far-from-ideal TV plans last week and while the FITE.tv viewing experience was generally good, the way they handled the commercial breaks detracted from the viewing experience.

Most breaks were filled with long shots of the building from a high vantage point, with the house microphone still connected. That's fine, but you know the in-arena awkwardness that ensues as soon as a live show goes to ads, leaving the fans twiddling their thumbs and the wrestlers just kinda hanging around in the ring? FITE's approach brought this to stream viewers.

Curiously, Dynamite's first commercial break was filled by a continuation of Chris Jericho's beatdown of Cody. This saw the angle stretched far beyond its natural end, leaving 'The Painmaker' with too much time to kill and, as entertaining as he is, it showed. It was as awkward as it was unideal.

This is something AEW and FITE will likely work on over for future shows, but their night one execution wasn't great.


1. Total Collapse

AEW's decision to completely abandon any semblance of logic in Dynamite's main event was maddening.

Jon Moxley interfered in Kenny Omega, Ortiz, and Santana vs. The Elite. He struck after just a few minutes, with the brawl quickly taking him and Omega out of the ring and through the crowd. A hot little angle, but why wasn't he disqualified? He put his hands on an active competitor! It would've been a fart of a finish, but this is supposed to be the "real sport" wrestling promotion and they're out here ignoring blatant DQs on night one of television, just because.

Another problem with the Moxley angle was that TV viewers couldn't see any part of what was going on in the ring while it was happening. That's what happens when you try to do two things at once. Jericho, the former LAX, and The Young Bucks could have been sat in a circle singing Kumbaya and nobody would have been any wiser. Completely abandoning it for 2-3 minutes didn't work out.

And to make matters worse, the crowd were noticeably colder once the focus shifted from Omega and Mox back to the match. This was always going to happen after a man was suplexed through a glass table, of course, but this should've been accounted for.

There was plenty of good in this match and angle too, though these problems were immersion breakers.


Ups...

12. The Worst Town

Who knew that Scorpio Sky possessed such an on the money Barack Obama impression? What a guy.

SCU were on good form in their mid-show segment. It began with a quick skit in front of a Washington, DC backdrop, before Tony Schiavone interviewed them at the top of the ramp. They ran through their "worst town" shtick then got down to the business, with Sky announcing that he'd step aside to allow Christopher Daniels and Frankie Kazarian to represent the trio in the tag team tournament, before the Lucha Brothers showed up, proclaimed themselves the best in the universe, and brawled with the baldies. End segment.

A solid little way to hype the upcoming tournament (but little more than that), this had plenty of character. It worked, and here's hoping we eventually get to see the SCU vs. Jurassic Express dark match that went down before the taping.


11. Glue Guys

Tony Schiavone Jim Ross Excalibur
AEW

AEW's commentary woes are over. Tony Schiavone was the solution.

The former WCW man was great last night. His reassuring, veteran presence was the glue holding the Jim Ross/Excalibur tandem together. Not that his cohorts haven't delivered good work so far, but Schiavone was so much more adept in his role than the absent Alex Marvez, and his voice was all over Dynamite, too, having knocked it out of the park on his first night as AEW's play-by-play guy.

Also, it's just great hearing Tony's voice back on mainstream wrestling television. He's awesome.

While we're praising AEW's new broadcasters, how about Chris Van Vliet? The YouTube interview demigod came off like a million dollars on national television. Smooth, slick, and charismatic, it was great to see his style and personality come off as well on the big screen as it does on smaller ones. Two thumbs up.


10. Brandon The Broken

MJF successfully p*ssed off every dice-roller on the internet with his c*nty D&D tweet a few weeks ago. Brandon Cutler, who has one of the game's big nerdy dice on his only AEW t-shirt, had the opportunity to shut him up in a match that MJF responded to with a spit-laugh in a hilarious Road To skit. Did he pull it off? Did he smash the jock and score one for nerd culture?

No. No he didn't, but he did show flashes of fire.

The crowd lit up as Cutler dove to the outside then merked MJF with ground and pound. His opponent, meanwhile, reached deep into his bag of heel tricks, screaming "look into the camera and tell your kids you're a bum!" while wrenching the arm. There was some good, good stuff in this short match.

The finish was nice and swift, ensuring the bout didn't overstay its welcome. Cutler wobbled on the top rope. He was having trouble with his knee and the announcers put it over like he'd hurt himself on the tope. Agonised, Brandon made his way across to his opponent but was a wounded animal at this point, and easy pickings for MJF's submission game. He tapped out after just a few minutes to keep the show rolling at a nice, brisk pace, with MJF looking great in victory.


9. Refreshing Presentation

This is another all-encompassing point rather than one relating to a specific match or segment, but one of this show's greatest triumphs is that it felt both refreshing and different.

Dynamite was presented as a true alternative. Tony Khan promised no "invisible camera" backstage segments prior to the broadcast, and while we got a single check-in on the main event participants, this held true. The camera cuts were a lot less mania-inducing than the average Kevin Dunn-produced show. Rather than having an interview robot welcome their guest at this time backstage, Tony Schiavone spoke to SCU on the ramp. There wasn't a tedious heel announcer trying to get themself over rather than calling the action. Stressing the importance of wins and losses was a priority throughout the night, which added stakes to everything. The list goes on.

If they hadn't already, AEW established their identity here. Doing so was one of their most important checkboxes heading into Dynamite's first episode - and they nailed it.


8. MJF Shreds Brandon Cutler

Of course MJF emerged for his match with Brandon Cutler with a microphone in hand. Of course he bloody did. Not having the best talker in professional wrestling spit bile on Dynamite's maiden voyage would've been a huge mistake, and his takedown of his opponent and the DC crowd was rollicking. Short, but rollicking.

The audience absolutely hated Mr. Friendman here. He ripped the "poors" apart, claiming that it was their honour to witness a star being born that night, then turned his crosshairs on Cutler, running with the "loser" narrative he has been pushing throughout their feud. Then came the inevitable D&D burn: "Dungeons and Dragons may not be real, but what is real is the fact that I'm better than you... and you know it."

While these words don't look spectacular written down, they were delivered superbly. Now, watch him really break the internet when AEW give him longer than a minute.


7. Sammy & Cody Tear It Up

Dave Meltzer wrote in last week's Wrestling Observer Newsletter that the first episode of Dynamite would roll straight into a match, with Cody vs. Sammy Guevara getting the nod. AEW reportedly wanted to start the show with killer in-ring action to get people buzzing before the first commercial break and, given Cody's pay-per-view track record, him and Sammy seemed like a safe bet.

The early stages established Sammy's clear speed and agility advantage. He forced Cody to take a smart powder, then posed on the mat, seemingly solidifying the face/heel dynamic in this alignment fluid promotion. Cody fought back with signature offense. The drop-down uppercut, powerslam, and Figure Four came out as AEW's most over star kept the crowd hot. Early on, the pace was more methodical than anything else, with the offense coming in short, sharp bursts until Sammy pulled Brandi Rhodes in front of her husband's dive. Then came the heat.

That Cody went out of his way to float the idea that he could lose his AEW World Title shot in the event of a loss informed the drama. While the match looked like a surefire Cody victory when it was announced, this sowed seeds of doubt. It meant you could allow yourself to buy into Sammy's near-falls without compromise. An excellent, subtle touch from 'The American Nightmare,' and it paid off big when Guevara almost beat him with the top rope Spanish Fly.

A well-paced match concluded with Cody cradling Sammy after getting the knees up on an attempted Shooting Star Press. Not quite the blowaway bout Meltzer's report suggested, but a very good match nonetheless. A solid start.


6. Jake Hager Is... Good, Actually

Look, Jack Swagger was largely lame as hell in WWE. That's indisputable.

But you can't dispute that pop either.

Jake Hager got a thunderous reception when he ran down to destroy every single babyface in the world after Dynamite's main event. He came off really, really well as he killed the Rhodes brothers, showing more fire and urgency than he has inside a wrestling ring in years and the fans were totally into it, with chants of "we the people" filling the building. It's almost shocking how effective this was.

A potential heel stable has emerged in the form of Chris Jericho, Hager, Ortiz, Santana, and Sammy Guevara, who ran down to deck Cody. This came after what turned out to be a very good pseudo-handicap match as the Young Bucks played ultimate survivors with Kenny Omega out of the picture, battling bravely against Jericho and the former LAX until 'Y2J' landed his new killshot, the Judas Effect, for the 1-2-3.

Credit to the performers and AEW for salvaging this after the Moxley/Omega angle almost sent Dynamite careening off the rails.


5. A Complete World Title Turnaround

Contrast last night's crowd reactions to Chris Jericho vs. Cody to those that greeted the AEW World Champion's previous programme with Hangman Page.

'The Painmaker' was cheered as he beat his young opponent down at Fight for the Fallen, with Page's flavourless 19-minute bout with Kip Sabian pouring a big bucket of cold water all over his title challenge. It was lame, lame stuff, and the muted response crept into the eventual All Out match.

Things couldn't have been different with Cody and Jericho. Venom poured from every corner of the arena as the AEW Champion ambushed 'The American Nightmare' following his hard-fought victory over Sammy Guevara, and the babyface pop was just as loud when Cody ran out to even the odds in the show-closing brawl.

We've got a proper World Title programme on our hands, people, and it's heated as hell. Excellent set-up and execution are the reasons for this. Let's hope they're able to maintain it over the next four weeks of television.


4. PAC Bastardises Page

Hangman Page delivered his most impressive AEW performance to date when he wrestled PAC on Dynamite, working with the kind of fire and thunder one would expect from a wrestler cast as a young, hungry future babyface star, though he fell to 'The Bastard' in about 13 minutes.

This was a perfect first instalment in that PAC and Page gave fans enough to sink their teeth into without emptying their tanks, leaving plenty on the table for the next time they meet. It was a real teeth-rattler at times. PAC is such an incessantly mean heel that it's impossible not to feel sympathy for his opponents and everything he threw at Hangman looked like it hurt. Page, meanwhile, fought with an urgency largely missing from the Jericho and Sabian matches, drawing big reactions for his signature offense.

The finish was class. PAC straight-up booted Page in the b*llocks while Earl Hebner was distracted. This led to him scaling the top rope for the Black Arrow to Hangman's back, before locking in the Brutalizer that finished Kenny Omega at All Out. That was enough for Page; he verbally submitted.

Great match, and a great in-ring start to their feud. Next time will be even better.


3. Getting It Right

Pro-wrestling has no truer test of whether or not something is working than crowd reactions and if last night's audience is anything to go by, AEW's creative team is getting almost everything right at the moment.

Every wrestler got the correct response last night. At no point did it feel like the audience was being "smart," going into business for themselves, or trying to get themselves over. They weren't cheering heels and booing babyfaces. Chris Jericho was reviled when he beat Cody down, and Hangman Page was finally over as the babyface AEW need him to be. Even Brandon Cutler, an undercarder, got big pops when he fired up against MJF. Speaking of MJF, the guy's so incredible on the microphone that it'd be easy to cheer in recognition of this, but no. He was booed out of the building.

This is vital, because American wrestling crowds aren't necessarily what they used to be. WWE shows often play out to library-like atmospheres with bored fans throwing out contrarian reactions. That's a creative fault and one that AEW doesn't have - at least for now.


2. Monster Hunter

Few could have predicted relative unknowns Riho and Nyla Rose would be in this spot when AEW announced plans to crown their first Women's World Champion on Dynamite's TNT debut. Names like Britt Baker, the now-absent Kylie Rae, and Bea Priestley may have come to mind, so credit to All Elite for going with the 'Native Beast' and the diminutive joshi prodigy, and credit to them for building on the Fyter Fest hook of Riho's shock roll-up pin of Rose.

This turned out to be the best match on the show. Really, the only major downer was Baker's inexpressive, colour-less performance as a guest commentator, with the good doctor invoking the spirit of the banished Alex Marvez. There were a couple of sloppy moments too, but Riho and Nyla worked hard to overcome them, and in the end, the bout had too much good about it to nitpick.

While both have plenty still to learn, they're both excellent at nailing the things that make their character tick. For Riho, the undersized underdog, that means selling, bumping, and showing fire from beneath. For Nyla, it's brute force and impeccable monster heel timing. See the moment when Rose effortlessly caught the flying Riho on the outside before dropping her with a backbreaker for evidence of both.

Excellent spot-to-spot escalation culminated with Riho somehow nailing an avalanche Northern Lights Suplex towards the end. A spectacular moment, and she eventually put Rose away with a double stomp to become the first AEW Women's World Champion, having weathered a deadly storm to do so. A much more interesting story than the big scary monster getting her win back.


1. Glass Shatters

Jon Moxley suplexed Kenny Omega through a glass table on a mainstream American wrestling show.

I repeat: Jon Moxley suplexed Kenny Omega through a glass table on a mainstream American wrestling show.

Unbelievable.

While this angle's timing did derail the main event, the Omega/Moxley brawl was still ridiculously effective. It took them from the ring to ringside, then through the crowd, with the duo bringing all kinds of weaponry into play. Kenny nodded to his old 'Cleaner' life by hitting Mox with a mop. A nice little easter egg, though he paid for it when the brawl entered the "VIP area" and glass shattered beneath his neck and shoulders.

AEW have done a great job of establishing Moxley as an agent of chaos. The dude's out of his goddamn mind and proved it with this shockingly violent moment, escalating this budding rivalry to blood feud status. It's on, brothers and sisters. Hop aboard this crazy train before it mows you down.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.