12 Ups & 5 Downs From NJPW The New Beginning In Osaka 2019
'Switchblade' shocks the world (and Hiroshi Tanahashi) in Osaka.
New Japan Pro Wrestling's New Beginning tour concluded in Osaka today, headlined by rising star 'Switchblade' Jay White challenging company ace Hiroshi Tanahashi for the IWGP Heavyweight Championship he'd taken from Kenny Omega at Wrestle Kingdom 13.
This was an important show for countless reasons, both business and creative. The global pro-wrestling landscape is changing. The Elite are gone, AEW has rewritten the rulebook without holding a single show, and the free agent market has spiralled out of control. It's a time of great turmoil, and never has the 'New Beginning' name been so apt for the world's second-biggest promotion.
Booking decisions are subjective, and only time will tell how the bold choices made on this show pan out, but the event felt like a big, big deal. The filler matches varied in quality, but many came with important storyline considerations. Further up the card, the two major title fights (Tanahashi vs. White, Taiji Ishimori vs. Ryusuke Taguchi) delivered and then some, Bad Luck Fale and Kazuchika Okada exceeded expectations, and a surprise Kota Ibushi appearance brought the evening's most important announcement.
A big, ballsy show that left nothing on the table, The New Beginning In Osaka will prove divisive, but there was plenty to dissect throughout its three-and-a-half hours...
Downs...
5. The Lack Of Chris Charlton
The best version of NJPW's revolving door announce booth has Kevin Kelly on play-by-play, Don Callis on colour, and Chris Charlton running translation duties while adding important historical context. We got two-thirds of that team last night, and the missing piece left a gaping hole.
Charlton is fantastic. Though he's still sharpening his broadcasting skills, his vast knowledge of all things New Japan Pro Wrestling and translations make him one of the promotion's most important accessibility tools. Boatloads of English-speaking NJPW supporters owe much of their fandom to the work he has put in over the years - whether through his books 'Lion's Pride' and 'Eggshells,' Twitter translations, podcasts, or, more recently, his work in the announce booth - and it's a shame he wasn't there last night.
The young boy NJPW roped in to take his place did a serviceable job, but not like Charlton. Here's hoping he doesn't miss any more major shows going forward.
4. Spreading It Thin
NJPW's decision to hold three major New Beginning shows as opposed to one mega-card is understandable. It's a money-driven move, and with it, the company draw three strong crowds as opposed to one. This means we can't criticise it from a business standpoint, but we absolutely can from a creative POV.
The New Beginning In Sapporo shows were thinner than your author's hairline. While Osaka was an improvement, this hefty Ups-to-Downs ratio belies the show's quality. This was a good show, but not a great one, and it's all because the tour's biggest matches were spread too thin.
Fans have come to expect top-loaded New Japan pay-per-views with skippable undercards, and while NJPW threw some important angles down early in the night, that's pretty much what this was. Take the Yoshinobu Kanemaru/El Desperado vs. Shingo Takagi/BUSHI and Zack Sabre Jr./Minoru Suzuki vs. EVIL/SANADA Sapporo tags onto this card and it'd be a different matter. Alas.
3. Killed Be Repetition
New Beginning's Los Ingobernables vs. Suzuki-gun six-man tag was fine, and strong enough to finish as a lower-tier Up if taken in isolation. It was a solid, well-worked pro-wrestling match. The problem is that we've seen this combination (or variations thereof) put together dozens of times over the past few months. It's stale as hell, and while everyone in this clash is entertaining, they couldn't transcend repetition in Osaka.
Suzuki-gun, in a shocking move nobody could've seen coming, jumping their opponents at the bell. The brawl eventually gave way to a more conventional six-man. Neat, tidy, well laid-out action, but nothing we haven't seen countless times recently, and in the end, it yielded 11 skippable minutes.
Shingo Takagi belted Yoshinobu Kanemaru with a Pumping Bomber late on, facilitating Tetsuya Naito's victory via Destino. Naito and Sapporo opponent Taichi then traded barbs, before Roppongi 3K attacked Takagi and fellow IWGP Junior Heavyweight Tag Team Champion BUSHI on the ramp, setting up their next defence. That match should rule, so at least we got a positive development from this tiresome bout.
2. A Turgid Journey To A Worthwhile Destination
We'll talk about the ongoing Takashi Iizuka storyline later (spoiler: it isn't a Down), but the opener, predictably, didn't hit the mark.
It was Iizuka and Suzuki-gun stablemates Minoru Suzuki and TAKA Michinoku versus Hiroyoshi Tenzan, Satoshi Kojima, and Jushin 'Thunder' Liger. Average age: 49 years old. No disrespect to these guys - each has had a long, successful career, a handful are legitimate legends, and some can still go - but their combination isn't exactly a recipe for an action-packed opener.
Storyline considerations aside, the bout was stodgy. Suzuki was content to dog it. He barely broke a sweat, and while Kojima and Tenzan showed fire, it wasn't strong enough to save a subpar scrap between six New Japan dads, all of whom have seen better days.
The DQ finish keeps the Iizuka/Tenzan story going, but the 13 minutes it took to get there were tough.
1. Honma & YOSHI-HASHI Labour To Defeat
There's no other way of putting it: YOSHI-HASHI and the ghost of Tomoaki Honma versus Yujiro Takahashi and Chase Owens was rough. Really rough.
Honma can't go anymore. It's sad, but the beloved underdog hero isn't even a shadow of his former self, and as heartening as it was to see him return to the ring after his brush with paralysis, he's so far below the New Japan working standard that he probably shouldn't be doing anything other than 10-person tags in Korakuen Hall.
He was ropy here, but so did YOSHI-HASHI. Having recently returned from his own medical scare, YOSHI has looked pensive and jittery over the past few weeks, and it manifested here in a particularly clunky exchange with Owens. Though Chase worked hard, he couldn't get anything out of his struggling opponents, though he did eventually score the pinfall with a Package Piledriver on Honma.
While YOSHI will get back to where he was, Honma is a different matter. If his deficiencies can't be hidden in a 9-minute tag match, it's hard to justify his inclusion on shows like this, particularly as - and this is the worst part - he's still building matches around Kokeshi diving headbutt spots after 16 months on the sidelines. It's not easy to watch.
Ups...
12. Welcome Back
It was great to have Don Callis back in the New Japan announce booth last night, taking his rightful place as the promotion's chief English-language colour guy after a string of failed experiments with Andy Boy Simmonz, Mavs GIllis, and others.
The former Cyrus is always missed when he's away. An outstanding announcer who adapted to the product very quickly upon appointment, he brings personality to proceedings, but never at the expense of the story the wrestlers are supposed to be telling. In short, he knows when he needs to call the action and when to heel it up. This understanding of his role makes him the best colour guy in the business today, and he has outstanding chemistry with Kevin Kelly, too.
Callis' busy Impact Wrestling schedule has kept him away from New Japan more than many fans would like over the past year. That's understandable, though we hope to hear more from him in 2019.
11. G.O.D.'s Gonna Cut You Down
Billed as a number one contendership scrap, the Guerrillas of Destiny/Most Violent Players tag match was more of a glorified angle than anything else. The Bullet Club affiliates battered Toru Yano and Togi Makabe as they made their entrance. No longer the 'Good Guy,' Tama Tonga and Tanga Loa gained an insurmountable advantage over the opposition, and were never in danger of losing after the bell had rung, surprising anyone who'd expected a straight-up tag between these two teams.
It wasn't any kind of "great match," but it worked. G.O.D. came off suitably dominant. Their mauling of Yano and Makabe was effective, particularly after the 'Good Guy' story, and that New Japan don't often book tags like this meant it felt fresh even after Tama's troublesome G1 Climax run in 2018.
Tonga and Loa should now go on to face EVIL and SANADA for the IWGP Tag Team Championships, having lost the straps to them inside the Tokyo Dome. With their current moment, and with what happened to other Bullet Club members on the show, they should be considered the favourites.
10. A Country For Old Men
Takashi Iizuka retires later this month, drawing a line under his 33-year career with a farewell show on 21 February. It has been a long time coming. 'The Great Betrayer' is a fun character, particularly when muzzled and led to the ring by one of his Suzuki-gun stablemates, but he's been one of the worst wrestlers in the company for a long, long time. The man with the iron glove needs to hang it up.
NJPW have weaved a great little story around this. Hiroyoshi Tenzan, his former tag team partner, has been trying to unlock the good that was seemingly lost in this crazed old man when he turned on the 'Fierce Bull' 11 years ago. The fans are dying to see it happen. Though neither of these guys can go anymore, they've gotten this story over, and the veteran duo gave us more to nibble on in Osaka.
A pre-match promo saw Tenzan come out in one of their old t-shirts, then tell Iizuka they'd team again. They brawled during the match, but the conclusion saw Iizuka stop Minoru Suzuki from nailing Tenzan with a chair, only to do it himself and prompt the DQ. Hiroyoshi ate the iron glove after that. Iizuka teased that maybe, just maybe, his old partner was finally getting through, but the 'Crazy Bouzu' overcome his inner Bruce Banner once again.
No matter what happens, that retirement match is going to be hot.
9. Young Lions Impress In Defeat
The way NJPW build and develop their Young Lion trainees is always one of the most satisfying aspects of following this promotion long-term, and as two of the current class' most exciting prospects, Ayato Yoshida and Shota Umino have been gaining traction as a team lately.
They went winless in December's World Tag League tournament, but overcame Yota Tsuji and Toa Henare (clearly their senior) on 30 January. Yoshida and Umino have since come close to defeating veterans Tiger Mask and Manabu Nakanishi on a couple of occasions, overcame Tsuji and Hiroyoshi Tenzan on 9 February, and faced IWGP Tag Team Champions EVIL and SANADA in a fun, spirited bout last night.
Here, their slow journey up the rankings continued. Yoshida and Umino never looked like beating the LIJ duo, and it was barely even teased, but that's exactly what this match needed to be. There's a ladder to climb in NJPW. The Young Lions are doing it, but doing it slowly.
Those who didn't catch this match live need only watch it for completionism's sake, but Yoshida and Umino made it worthwhile.
8. Fale Vs. Okada Overdelivers... Again
Bad Luck Fale and Kazuchika Okada always have good matches together. Always.
This pairing won't ever trouble your 'Match of the Year' ballots, but they know what they're doing with each other. Their chemistry is palpable, Okada is a surprisingly effective underdog despite being a 6'4" physical specimen himself, and he and Fale know how to lay out a match that makes the 'Rogue General' look good.
This was the case again at New Beginning, where Okada and Fale overcame a lacklustre build to produce a fun in-ring dynamic. There were smoke and mirrors, but we expect that from Fale bouts, and they didn't hamper the scrap in any way. Appropriately, the big man bullied 'The Rainmaker' for much of it. Working from beneath, fiery babyface Okada looked excellent, and although the former IWGP Heavyweight Champion eventually triumphed with a couple of Rainmakers, Fale lost nothing in defeat.
After failing to win last year's G1 Climax and falling to Jay White at Wrestle Kingdom 13, Okada needed that one. His character arc should now be one of the most interesting to following in all of wrestling in 2019.
7. Big Match Taguchi
The New Beginning In Osaka proved that the beautiful phenomenon of Big Match Taguchi is alive and well, as the 'Funky Weapon' fought out of his skin versus Taiji Ishimori, resulting in the kind of bout this undercard jokester has always been capable of when positioned in a big spotlight.
Taguchi doesn't get these opportunities often, but never disappoints when he does. He knows how to step it up. A two-time IWGP Junior Heavyweight Champion, his time in the spotlight is likely over, and there was little chance he'd walk away with the belt in Osaka, so it speaks volumes that he was able to make the crowd bite on several pinfalls versus Ishimori. He remains, on his day, a world-class professional wrestler.
The 'Funky Weapon' will now slide back to the undercard, where he'll resume his day job as NJPW's most popular preliminary novelty act. Hordes of people once again forget how good he really is, until New Japan finally throw him another bone, and the cycle repeats. It's a great role for him at this stage in his 17-year career.
6. 'The Golden Star' Is Staying Put
A spot of extremely encouraging news came after the conclusion of Chase Owens/Yujiro Takahashi vs. Tomoaki Honma/YOSHI-HASHI, as Kota Ibushi pledged his allegiance to New Japan Pro Wrestling in the midst of heavy All Elite Wrestling speculation.
The 'Golden Star' hadn't been seen since Wrestle Kingdom 13. Concussed in his brutal war with Will Ospreay, there was talk that the former NEVER Openweight Champion might be done with the company. He isn't, though, and after thanking the fans for their concern, Ibushi confirmed that he's staying in NJPW, he isn't going anywhere, and will be involved in the upcoming New Japan Cup competition.
This is big. NJPW have lost enough major pieces over the past few months, and while Ibushi has never been positioned as anything close to a top guy, he's one of the absolute best in the world, and a guy who'll almost certainly step into a bigger role with Kenny Omega and co. gone. Good for him, and good for NJPW for convincing him to stick around.
5. Ishimori's Fiery First Defence
A quality IWGP Junior Heavyweight Title clash enhanced by the challenger's gusto, Taiji Ishimori vs. Ryusuke Taguchi was on-point throughout, and the spr srs rasslin' match it needed to be after the banter was dispensed with early on.
Taguchi got the better of Ishimori early on, taunting him with his Sailor's Dance. The new 'Bone Soldier' then turned the tides, shook his hips himself, and the duo turned up the heat. Though his trademark hip attacks were thwarted, Taguchi downed his foe with a beautiful dropkick, then nailed a tope to the outside, firing the crowd up. He'd continue to push Ishimori to the bring with a Bomaye knee strike and, later, the Dodon for a near-fall at 2.9999, though he wasn't able to sufficiently stifle his opponent's signature sharp, snapping offence to gain a strong enough foothold.
Although his opponent had fans hooked on an upset, Ishimori fought off a second Dodon attempt to hit the Bloody Cross for the 1-2-3. An outstanding first defence for former Pro Wrestling NOAH stalwart, who remains at the head of what could be one of New Japan's most exciting divisions in 2019.
4. Jushin Liger Steps Up
Taiji Ishimori's next IWGP Junior Heavyweight Title defence came to life seconds after he had felled Ryusuke Taguchi.
Still buzzing with adrenaline, 'Bone Soldier' took the middle of the ring and shot his gaze to ringside, where the legendary Jushin 'Thunder' Liger sat in the announce booth. He called him into the ring. Liger hesitated momentarily, selling his surprise at the situation, before eventually getting up, rolling inside, and answering the obvious challenge.
Per the live translation, Liger promised that Ishimori would regret calling him out, then told him he was willing to face him "any time, any place." Thus, the match is effectively confirmed.
This should be fun. Liger is 54 years old and hasn't fought the belt since losing to KUSHIDA back in May 2016. On top of this, his last Best of the Super Juniors run (2017) ended with just a single victory. In kayfabe and real-life, he isn't the performer he used to be, but he's still great in the surly, p*ssed-off veteran role, and should be able to make magic with the hyper-athletic Ishimori.
3. Tanahashi Vs. White II Delivers
Hiroshi Tanahashi and Jay White's first singles match bombed.
Thrust into a spotlight he wasn't at all ready for, 'Switchblade' floundered in his role as a Wrestle Kingdom 12 heater. He hadn't found his feet as a pushed heel commodity, was struggling with the character, and couldn't pull the audience in with his work. The result was a mechanically solid bout with no real technical flaws, but one that created a moon-like atmosphere in a deathly quiet Tokyo Dome.
13 months later, the duo brought the house down in Osaka, yielding not only one of the most shocking results in modern New Japan history, but the best singles match of White's career.
White excelled as a ruthless, knee-destroying heel, and Tana, the master storyteller, was his perfect foil. The Ace sold that joint as if his leg were about to fall off. His comebacks were as well-built and impeccably timed as ever, and he had the crowd enraptured with every knee-snapping Dragon Screw and attempted High Fly Flow, and yet none of it mattered in the end. Tana's superior experience, skill, and popularity were helpless to stop NJPW's new alpha villain claiming his scalp and the IWGP Heavyweight Championship.
There's a lot to unpack here, but as a match, this was a textbook New Japan big-theatre main event with all the usual hallmarks, from the gradual build to the big move kickouts. The outcome need not cause concern, either...
2. Risk & Reward?
On 4 January 2012, former Young Lion Kazuchika Okada walked back into New Japan Pro Wrestling, felling the lowly YOSHI-HASHI in a sloppy, botchy undercard match before inexplicably challenging company ace Hiroshi Tanahashi for the IWGP Heavyweight Championship at the night's conclusion. He'd defeat Tanahashi for the belt five weeks later at The New Beginning, and nobody - nobody - was convinced that it'd be anything other than a grand disaster.
It worked out.
A similar fate met AJ Styles in 2014. Fresh off his TNA release, 'The Phenomenal One' returned to NJPW at Invasion Attack, assaulting Okada to cricket chirps after revealing himself as Bullet Club's new member. He'd then defeat Okada for the IWGP gold at Wrestling Dontaku a few weeks later, thanks to interference from Yujiro Takahashi.
Again, nobody was convinced.
Again, it worked out.
That's why Gedo deserves your trust when it comes to strapping Jay White out of the blue. It feels shocking right now, but there's a precedent for this, and while there's no way of credibly guaranteeing 'Switchblade' will succeed as a top guy, NJPW's master booker knows what the f*ck he's doing with these things. He wouldn't have given White the most prestigious belt in wrestling if he wasn't utterly convinced he'd prosper. We should probably trust creative at this stage...
1. New Japan Is Fine
While the New Beginning tour didn't yield an abundance of Match of the Year candidates, the overwhelming feeling coming out of this series of shows is that this promotion is going to be absolutely fine, and rumours of a post-Elite demise have been greatly exaggerated.
The two Sapporo shows outdrew last year's offerings, and that's with f*cking Taichi on top. Osaka scored a 5,500 sellout.
Jay White is the best heel in wrestling at the moment. 'Rainmaker' Kazuchika Okada is back, and it won't be long before he's back in a main event spotlight. Kenny Omega and Chris Jericho could yet walk back through the door. Kota Ibushi is sticking around. Tetsuya Naito's coronation as 'The Guy' is still on the horizon. Taiji Ishimori looks set to lead a new-look IWGP Junior Heavyweight division for much of the year. Hiromu Takahashi is coming back. The still-unpinned Shingo Takagi is going to kill it when he turns on Los Ingobernables de Japon. Heavyweight Will Ospreay is a thing. The list goes on.
The Elite will be missed - of course they will - but things are looking mighty exciting in for the 'King Of Sports' right now. Trust Gedo, trust the process, and trust NJPW to endure the challenges of this new wrestling landscape.