12 Ways WWE Would Have Different If Brock Lesnar Hadn't Quit

What if Brock Lesnar never left WWE in 2004?

One of the biggest WWE stories of this century is Brock Lesnar abruptly quitting in March 2004. That decision had an enormous impact on the world of sports entertainment, not just in the WWE, but also ultimately in the UFC. The result was WWE business going to hell in the immediacy of Lesnar's exit. Especially the show Brock had anchored, Smackdown, which suffered a steep decline in the months after he left. House show attendances and television ratings were in free fall. Although Smackdown continues to survive to this day, it really hasn't been the same since. It had once been the best part of WWE, nowadays it is just an after thought that is used to promote Raw. Although WWE suffered for a few years after Lesnar's departure, they did eventually create new stars and found new success. Things worked out for Brock, too. He found a new home in the UFC, where he ended up becoming Heavyweight Champion and the biggest pay per view draw in their history. That ultimately made him a much bigger star, which allowed him to make a triumphant return to WWE in 2012. This past year he's been the biggest star in the company, for which he continues to be paid $5 million for limited dates. But let's stop to consider how different it all could have been. What if Lesnar hadn't left in 2004, what if Vince McMahon had been able to hang on to his prized asset?

12. Lesnar Destroys Bill Goldberg At WrestleMania 20

The first thing to consider is that Lesnar quit right in the middle of a feud with Bill Goldberg. As a result of that sudden notice, McMahon booked Lesnar to do the job to Golderg in a dire 13 minute match at WrestleMania 20. But if Lesnar had been staying, he would have been the winner. Goldberg was also leaving, but he'd had the decency to give a proper notice, so he ended up being the one booked to go over that night. But if things had gone to plan, if Lesnar hadn't decided to quit, it would have been the youngster's night to celebrate. It would have been a major victory for Brock, no doubt about it. Goldberg is a major scalp and it would have been one of the biggest results on the entire Mania 20 card. It would've been a quick affair, five minutes of Lesnar just smashing Goldberg, then an F5 and pin. It would've solidified Brock's star credentials, with the narrative that he beat Bill Goldberg out of the WWE.

11. Wins Title Back From Eddie Guerrero And Maintains Smackdown's Popularity

There's only one place to go after beating a major name like Bill Goldberg, and that's back to the WWE Title scene. The next Smackdown pay per view after Mania 20 was May's Judgement Day. Due to Lesnar quitting, the WWE were stuck with a lack of heel opponents for Champion Eddie Guerrero, so Bradshaw was made a heel and became the challenger. That never would've happened if Lesnar had stayed. He'd have been the one going for the title that he lost to Eddie just a month before Mania 20. The result would have been a DQ at Judgement Day, enabling Eddie to continue his title run a little longer. But by The Great American Bash in June (where JBL ended Eddie's reign), it would be Lesnar triumphing and getting the WWE title back. Eddie and an array of other babyfaces would have challenged heel champion Lesnar throughout the rest of 2004, which would have helped to maintain Smackdown's popularity in television viewership. Instead, with Lesnar gone from the company, JBL reigned for almost a year, causing Smackdown's popularity to shrink.

10. Lesnar Vs Cena At WrestleMania 21

The inside story is that Lesnar versus Cena at WrestleMania 21 was WWE's plan going all the way back to the end of 2003 when Cena first started to show babyface potential. After a long heel reign through 2004, Lesnar would be doing the job that JBL did at Mania 21, putting babyface Cena over as the hot new star. The fact is, whether Lesnar stayed or didn't, WWE always intended to make Cena their big star. He was more of an all round sports entertainer than Brock and had impressed Stephanie McMahon. Lesnar would have put Cena over in 2005, most likely taking a short break afterwards.

9. The Beast Vs The Animal

Over on Raw, Batista became the World Champion at the same time as Cena won the WWE Title. Lesnar leaving or staying with Smackdown wouldn't have impacted Batista's rise. But what might have been different is the WWE 2005 Draft. Instead of swapping Batista and Cena between Raw and Smackdown, perhaps Lesnar would've been drafted over to Raw to feud with Batista. He would've been on Smackdown for years at that point, so it would have made sense to get him on Raw and leave Smackdown to the new next big thing in John Cena. Once Lesnar was on Raw, WWE would've almost certainly done a big summer feud of The Beast versus The Animal. Both Lesnar and Batista look like monsters, so it would be the kind of visual spectacle that would draw. An all out warring brawl would be won by Lesnar at SummerSlam, re-establishing him as the company's top heel.

8. Best Matches Of His Career With Shawn Michaels

Following the Batista feud, Lesnar would match up with Shawn Michaels. It would be a classic story of young aggression versus the experienced veteran. It'd also work with a david and goliath aspect, as Michaels would look so small next to Lesnar's massive frame. Those type of matches can be fantastic. The big guy versus small guy dynamic allows for some great spots, and Michaels loved that kind of chemistry, look no further than his feud with Undertaker for evidence of that. It would quite possibly be the best matches of Lesnar's career. Michaels was such a great worker and Lesnar is a fine athlete. They could've created something as good as what Michaels did with Kurt Angle. You can just imagine Lesnar suplexing him, or HBK jumping out of an F5 and nailing sweet chin music. The victor would of course be Lesnar.

7. Turns Babyface Against Triple H In WrestleMania 22 Feud

For the first time in years, Lesnar would've been turned babyface at the start of 2006. The purpose of that would be to accomadate him in a major singles feud with Triple H. This would be built around WrestleMania 22, where Triple H in reality faced John Cena. A match between Hunter and Lesnar would've been a more memorable main event. Both would be in their prime and battling for contention of who the best wrestler in WWE was. It is a matching of two heavyweight names. The title would also inevitably be involved, as Lesnar would still be one of the top stars, and Triple H was still revolving around the title scene constantly in that period. The set-up could have been Triple H stealing the title in December 2005, perhaps in some sort of fatal four way scenario. Lesnar would win the Royal Rumble 2006 and then chase his revenge, ultimately defeating The Game in the show closer of Mania 22.

6. Feud With Orton

The summer of 2006 would be the time to put Brock Lesnar against Randy Orton. It would definitely be a better feud than the lame Hulk Hogan mess that Randy had to endure that year, which culminated in a measly 11 minute match at SummerSlam. Instead, WWE could have been tempted to do Orton and Lesnar in a high stakes feud for the August show. It wouldn't even necessarily need the belt, as both would be big names and it'd be a first time ever. It is in fact a match that fans have never seen to this day. They worked together in OVW and had some early Smackdown / dark matches, but never in their main WWE careers. As a first time ever, there's still definitely some value in doing it one day. But back to the alternate 2006, Orton would be the cowardly heel going against the retribution of Lesnar's powerful force. It'd give them months worth of good pay per view matches, in which both men could get over in exchanging victories.

5. Shelton Benjamin Is A Bigger Star

Shelton Benjamin was one of Brock Lesnar's good friends in WWE. Their camaraderie actually goes all the way back to their days together at the University Of Minnesota, where they regularly trained together and developed interest in professional wrestling. Lesnar actually requested that WWE sign Benjamin, that's how much he thought of his friend. If he'd have stayed around WWE past 2004, chances are he'd have also had his friend's back in other instances. Brock would have been a top guy and would have had significant stroke with Vince. It's a safe bet that he'd have protected his buddy and lobbied for him to have a better spot. In a WWE universe where Lesnar stayed, Benjamin may well have ended up a solid upper mid-card guy.

4. The Streak Would Have Ended A Lot Earlier

If Lesnar had stayed with WWE, chances are the streak would have ended a lot earlier. It could have been as early as WrestleMania 23 in 2007, which would have served as the right time for Lesnar to work Taker on the grandest stage of them all. We know that Taker wanted to lose the streak to someone legitimate, and wanted to give the streak to Lesnar in both 2011 and 2014. The idea was that Taker wouldn't look weak in losing to a genuine tough guy. Chances are he'd have felt that way in 2007, too. It would have been likely he'd be matched with Lesnar before 2014, and also likely that he'd have done the job. It would have robbed us of moments like the classics Shawn Michaels had against the streak in 2009 and 2010.

3. UFC Wouldn't Be As Strong As It Is

Before Brock Lesnar turned up, the UFC was already a solid two years into a MMA boom. But Brock undoubtedly helped to make the brand even bigger, going on to become their top box office draw with UFC 100 (1,600,000 buys) and UFC 116 (1,160,000 buys), in addition to drawing over a million buys for two other cards he headlined. He was the baddest man on the planet and it was like UFC had found their Mike Tyson of the MMA world. But unfortunately, bad health, and a limited skill set, meant it wasn't a long career with UFC. They've yet to find another star who can match his PPV numbers. If he had stayed with WWE, those record breaking UFC shows would never have happened. The company would have still just broke the million barrier with a few other shows, but nothing like to the extent and regularity of Lesnar's accomplishments. He helped to make the brand significantly bigger. If he had never left WWE, UFC wouldn't be quite as strong as they are today.

2. Putting The Next Generation Over

Following the win over the streak, Lesnar would ride a wave of momentum. However, it is worth remembering that 2008 - 2010 saw him debilitated by diverticulitis in the UFC. That would have also blighted him in the WWE, limiting his career in the period after 2008. By the end of that decade he'd be getting jobbed out to help the next generation of talent. That was actually the plan for Lesnar after beating The Undertaker's streak in 2014. He was meant to use that to put over the next generation (Roman Reigns) at WrestleMania 31. Given that he'd have won the streak as early as 2007 if he'd stayed with WWE, it is conceivable that he'd have been putting over guys in 2008, 2009 and 2010. The likes of Jeff Hardy or CM Punk may have been given wins over Brock, as WWE looked to develop fresh stars in that period.

1. Fan Apathy, Loss Of Value, Semi Retirement

By 2010, Lesnar would have been suffering from the same problem that blighted Batista in that period, fan apathy. It would have dented his value somewhat, and like Batista, he may have considered semi retirement. The fact is that he'd have been wrestling for ten years straight at that point. Wrestling fans are some of the most fickle people on earth, and have turned on almost every wrestler who has been a regular for that long. The Brock Lesnar of this alternate universe simply wouldn't have the same value of the real Lesnar. Sticking with WWE would have ironically diminished his value, as the UFC was responsible for making his perception so much bigger. If he stayed with WWE, he simply wouldn't be the star that he is today. He'd have had some great moments between 2004 - 2010, as detailed in this feature, but by the end of the decade he'd be used up and just another one of the guys. He'd do a Batista and take off, coming back for the occasional big match. But it would be nothing like his current part time deal. The Lesnar who stayed with WWE in 2004 simply wouldn't have developed the leverage that Lesnar achieved from his UFC glory days.

WWE Writer

Grahame Herbert hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.