12 Worst WWE Pay-Per-Views Without A World Title Match

Untitled.

kane wyatts
WWE.com

It's a little early to suggest that Sunday's Payback pay-per-view could be one of the least-anticipated in company history, but the lack of interest in just about everything at the top of the card doesn't bode well for 2017's post-WrestleMania supercard.

Whilst failing to arm the card with a selection of intriguing matches and/or relatively fresh WrestleMania rematches, the company has also neglected to feature the WWE and Universal Title in any capacity. This will mark the first time since Brock Lesnar's 2014 run with the WWE World Heavyweight Title that a champion hasn't been present on the monthly show, but the situation feels inexcusable considering the presence of two top titles since 2016's Brand Extension.

It's Lesnar again accounting for one of the empty chairs, but WWE Champion Randy Orton won't be putting up his newly-won prize against Bray Wyatt as the pair prepare to enter the mysterious 'House of Horrors' match. This may afford Wyatt a rare victory, though it will theoretically rob him of a contractually obligated rematch in the process.

The company has strayed from the usual format in offering supercards without championship showdowns in the past, but often the gamble has proven foolish.The lack of the 'big fight' has left many a show feeling lightweight and deprived, with an undercard unable to carry the load in the absence of the top strap.

Reliving some of 'horrors' of old, here are the 12 worst WWE pay-per-views without a World Title match.

12. Fastlane 2015

Roman Reigns Daniel Bryan Fastlane 2015
WWE.com

The last pay-per-view of Brock Lesnar's 2014/15 title run, Fastlane couldn't touch the drama of a divisive Royal Rumble a month earlier or superb WrestleMania that followed it.

A lack of conclusive finishes struck the killer blow on a tepid filler show that did little to alleviate the growing dissent behind the babyface push of Roman Reigns at the expense of sentimental favourite Daniel Bryan.

Victory for the 'Big Dog' ensured his place as WrestleMania 31 Number One Contender, with the company attempting to make good on his horrifically-received Rumble victory a month prior.

Murky conclusions to the Intercontinental and United States title matches damaged the credibility of both at a crucial time of year, whilst the return of Randy Orton, a Sting/Triple H confrontation and the one-sided Bray Wyatt/Undertaker feud all failed to inspire ahead of major WrestleMania clashes.

Though the Bryan/Reigns main event was excellent, the malaise surrounding the forced elevation of the former Shield member hung over the entire event, with the crushing realisation that the company had taken back totalitarian control of their main event after the giddy thrills of the WrestleMania 30 build.


11. Tables, Ladders, Chairs & Stairs

Big Show Erick Rowan
WWE.com

2014 was a transitional year for WWE, with the ascension of Daniel Bryan foreshadowing an in-ring quality turnover enhanced by Seth Rollins, a revitalised John Cena and future NXT call-ups. But when the company reverted to old habits, dark days briefly reemerged.

The absence of WWE World Heavyweight Champion Brock Lesnar from pay-per-view that winter should have forced management to tackle the unique situation with creativity and innovation. Instead, they added steel steps to the tired Tables, Ladders and Chairs show and insisted The Big Show and Erick Rowan work a match around the gimmick.

As with an abysmal Hell In A Cell supershow from earlier that year (more on that later), the stipulations overruled the the conflicts, leading to a weak set of contests saddled with weapons after some embarrassing exposition in the build-up.

John Cena's Number One Contenders tables victory over Seth Rollins was rendered meaningless on television weeks later after an Authority-driven insertion of 'The Architect' into the Royal Rumble main event, Bray Wyatt and Dean Ambrose contested the worst main event of the year in a TLC show-closer, and Ryback and Kane's Chairs match belongs in the same waste disposal unite as the aforementioned Stairs affair.


10. No Way Out Of Texas

Savio Vega Owen Hart Steve Austin Billy Gunn No Way Out 1998
WWE.com

Before WWE literally used the phrase as a show title, the February pay-per-view was often considered an unhelpful roadblock in between the company's surge to WrestleMania via January's Royal Rumble.

This was never more apparent than in 1998, when the company were forced to assemble a palatable card whilst desperate to maintain the purity of some crucial pairings that would help assemble one of the most important shows in company history the following month.

No Way Out of Texas (with the awkward 'Of Texas' added thanks to mild WCW litigation fears around the NWO initials WWE uncharacteristically couldn't be bothered to fight) combatted the situation by presenting an 8-man tag combining WrestleMania's three top matches.

It was a smart move, teasing possible physicality between all eventual opponents without having to deliver too much more than a Stone Cold Stunner to one of the heels for a crowd-pleasing finish.

But without the knowledge of all concerned parties, disaster had already stuck.

WWE Champion Shawn Michaels was in daily agony having cracked his back against The Undertaker's casket during their Royal Rumble war. With the severity becoming apparent, it was judged best to rest him as much as possible in order to ensure he was fit enough for the crucial 'Show of Shows' torch-passing to Steve Austin.

His replacement in the 4-on-4 main event? Savio Vega.

Coincidentally, Vega was once chosen as a babyface hope in place of Shawn Michaels (more on that later) too. As a heel, it predictably flopped just as hard.


9. WrestleMania 1

Wrestlemania 1
WWE.com

It's somewhat unfair to lump WrestleMania 1 into this list considering that the historical significance of the show was destined to outweigh any in-ring action, but without meaning to be caustic, it isn't half a slog.

Vince McMahon's vision of professional wrestling was still taking shape as his product attempted to add manufactured glitz to a North East model that had served Vince Snr for the decades that preceded his son's hostile takeover.

The national expansion was still a work in progress, but the relationships fostered with MTV, mainstream America and the New York bourgeoisie required Junior to present all things to all fans in order to deliver on hefty promises made in the dramatic television build-up.

A prototypical 1980s supercard, it exposed the world to virtually every worthwhile talent the company had, and loaded the main events with stars. The reason people reminisce on main events featuring the likes of Hulk Hogan, Mr T, Roddy Piper, Wendi Richter, Andre the Giant and others is because those were the draws.

History has shown how well the strategy worked, but with multiple documentaries and WWE Network projects highlighting all that elsewhere in the era of content on demand, sifting through snoozers featuring David Sammartino, Greg Valentine et al is truthfully not worth the work.


8. No Way Out 2007

No Way Out 2007 Tag Title Match
WWE.com

Despite several Raw and Smackdown superstars sneaking on to single brand cards in 2006, No Way Out marked the end of the original brand extension's show-only pay-per-views, and justified the decision with a chronically dull WrestleMania curtain raiser.

Outside of a novel main event featuring WrestleMania title match opponents teaming up against one another, the card was a dreadfully dull affair with so little consequence considering what a vital time of year it was supposed to be for the talents.

It highlighted just how far the blue brand had fallen after years of talent raids in favour of Monday Night Raw and an over-reliance on Undertaker and Batista to carry the entire brand with such a dearth of credible superstars underneath.

Emblematic of the state Smackdown was in, nothing was actively bad but so little was particularly good.

A six-man tag featuring Chris Benoit and The Hardy Boyz against MVP and MNM was serviceable, but the characters had so little going for them on the Friday night wasteland. Ditto for yet another Cruiserweight Open and the continuation of Paul London and Brian Kendrick's lengthy tag team title reign.

The financials bore out the dissonance. Disconnected almost entirely from the product, the show drew 218,000 buys. Under half of that year's Royal Rumble number, the buyrate represented almost a million less than the rampantly successful WrestleMania 23 just one month later.


7. Fastlane 2016

The Wyatt Family fastlane 2016
WWE.com

The second consecutive February pay-per-view without a World Title match was again designed to give Roman Reign necessary shine ahead of his WrestleMania championship showdown. Again, it failed.

Taking the place of Daniel Bryan this year were Dean Ambrose and Brock Lesnar, who had experienced wild spikes in popularity thanks to Ambrose's own challenge for the title in January's Royal Rumble and Lesnar's chaotic feud with The Undertaker and lingering problems with the Wyatt Family.

Reigns won because of course he did, but neither of his foes had the nuance and wherewithal of a Bryan to try and help present the now-former WWE Champion as a credible contender the vocal majority of the audience had to get behind.

As it turned out, Ambrose and Lesnar would ride the wave of momentum in a match against one another at the 'Show of Shows', when Brock's planned match with Bray Wyatt collapsed under the weight of another predictable decline for the backwoods hillbillies. Losing on this show to makeshift triumvirate The Big Show, Ryback and Kane, the family couldn't have looked any weaker before their leader's supposed money clash with 'The Beast'.

Elsewhere, a chronic Edge & Christian 'Cutting Edge Peep Show' segment with the New Day in one of the lamest skits all five have ever been involved with and a Curtis Axel/R-Truth match felt like a cruel joke at the audience's expense.


6. Fully Loaded: In Your House

Sable Bikini Contest Fully Loaded 1998
WWE.com

A show with Vince Russo's fingerprints literally all over his two favourite things in the company, Fully Loaded is almost fantastic in spite of itself with a red hot Attitude Era crowd carrying most matches over the line with unwarranted heat and excitement permeating through the broadcast.

Watched on mute it's a different story, and with 2017 eyes, the whole product is just a painfully dated.

The Rock and Triple H were capable of captivating a crowd for over an hour in 2000, but weren't able to manage it half the time two years earlier despite endless run-ins and distractions attempting to elevate their interminable 2-out-of-3 falls encounter.

The show is remembered fondly for the Sable/Jacqueline bikini contest, but the seemingly endless titlation in the build up to her...reveal drags horribly on rewatch.

Meanwhile, Owen Hart and Ken Shamrock have weird-but-dull brawl in the Hart Dungeon, Steve Austin and The Undertaker contest a surprisingly dull tag team main event with Kane and Mankind, and the worst of WWE's limited midcard are hung out to dry in dire encounters.

The likes of Faarooq, Scorpio, Terry Funk, Bradshaw, Mark Henry, Vader, Skull, 8-Ball and the Legion of Doom had less than nothing going for them underneath the raucous main event scene, and time-filling matches at this time were a scourge on WWE's overall presentation on an almost monthly basis.


5. Hell In A Cell 2014

John Cena Randy Orton Hell in a Cell 2014
WWE.com

Hands down the worst offender from Brock Lesnar's 2014 championship vacation, Hell In A Cell 2014 is a rotten exhibition of modern WWE mundanity outside of a passable main event that still suffers the indignity of a woeful finish.

Crudely unsupported by a lacklustre undercard, fans were less than impressed with a double main event inside the steel featuring John Cena and Randy Orton's twenty-fifth match together on pay-per-view and a maiden visit to the top of the card for Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose that trundled along acceptably until a farcical conclusion.

Having been hoofed from heel unit The Authority just before the show, Orton was a newly-minted babyface against perennial good egg John Cena which knackered the traditional dynamic they had fostered through their endlessly tiresome encounters.

Cena prevailed with an Attitude Adjustment through a table to become Number One Contender to Lesnar's gold, but would ultimately fight again for the privilege before getting that shot several months later.

Meanwhile, Rollins and Ambrose brawled atop the cell to kick off their main event, but succumbed to Wyatt Family silliness when a hologram appeared in the ring to distract the 'Lunatic Fringe' shortly before he curb-stomped Seth through a cinder block.

Wyatt's sudden attack during the diversion brought the contest to a screeching halt, allowing Rollins to sneak a pin then p*ss off out of shot to allow for some staring and empty contemplation.


4. Armageddon 2006

MVP Kane Inferno Match Armageddon 2006
WWE.com

It's telling when a card is considered so poor on paper that a spontaneous four-team ladder match is added midway through the show, and even less ideal when that last minute contest results in an injury so horrific that the performer develops a painkiller addiction that briefly loses him his job.

That's the story of Armageddon 2006. An admittedly brilliant spotfest featuring The Hardy Boyz, MNM, Paul London, Brian Kendrick, William Regal and Dave Taylor tried in vain to save the rotten December pay-per-view, but the infamous smash to the face sustained by Joey Mercury ensures the contest will never be held in lofty esteem alongside the TLC matches of old.

Time is kind to the line-up, with an Inferno Match between MVP and Kane, the alliance of World and WWE Champions Batista and John Cena taking on King Booker and Finlay, and The Undertaker terminating his feud with Mr Kennedy in a 'Last Ride' match all sounding like enjoyable enough ways to spend time watching wrestling.

However, just two weeks earlier, the company had presented ECW December to Dismember. Fingers were burnt by one of WWE's most disastrous pay-per-views, and suddenly 'enjoyable enough' didn't look an acceptable standard. The disdain towards the product following that show lingered for weeks, and Armageddon 2006 was cruelly caught in the crossfire.


3. SummerSlam '88

Megapowers Hulk Hogan Randy Savage SummerSlam 1988
WWE.com

There was no reason for the inaugural SummerSlam not to perform as well as all the other 1980s WWE supercards, but despite doing a healthy number commercially.

In keeping with Randy Savage's excellent numbers as WWE Champion, the show drew just short of half a million buys as WWE persisted with the phenomenal Mega Powers angle, and the Madison Square Garden setting normally lends itself to a frenetic atmosphere.

The company left the crowd cold however, short of the star-laden main event and the epic Intercontinental Title destruction of the Honky Tonk Man by the Ultimate Warrior.

Resembling titanic bore WrestleMania 4, the card dragged mercilessly, with the house show-level singles matches rarely leaving first gear as the bulk of WWE's touring crew appeared exhausted by the increasingly tough schedule.

Tag team matches featuring The Hart Foundation, Demolition, The British Bulldogs and the Fabulous Rougeaus were unusually dull, and protracted singles squashes for The Big Boss Man, Bad News Brown and others did as little for the winners as the losers.

Furthermore, whilst Hogan and Savage's headliner with Ted Dibiase and Andre the Giant had bucketfuls of heat, the middle section saw a lengthy beatdown hamstrung by Andre's common limitations of the era.

Thriving nearly 30 years on from the launch, SummerSlam is lucky to still be around after such a moribund debut.


2. Royal Rumble 1989

Savage Hogan Royal Rumble 1989
WWE.com

The first Royal Rumble on pay-per-view after the roaring success of the 1988 televised special included the final cracks between Randy Savage and Hulk Hogan ahead of their dramatic split just weeks later, but very little else of note.

Utilisting an additional ten superstars for the battle royal allowed for the match to foster several big angles as the company marched forward to WrestleMania 5, but a turgid end sequence leading up to Big John Studd's anticlimactic victory hasn't withstood the test of time in comparison to early Rumble highlights.

The show overall is hampered by a rotten undercard that saw ageing babyface Harley Race work against the grain in a dreadful match with Haku to determine who was the real 'King' of the company and a useless Woman's title match between champion Rockin' Robin and challenger Judy Martin that's only saved by Sensational Sherri tearing strips off both competitors on commentary.

Unlike other pay-per-view from the era, the Royal Rumble usually has the ability to circumvent the ravages of time with an entertaining snapshot of the roster of the time and enough quickfire activity to keep the viewer engaged. 1989's edition is a monotonous exception.


1. King Of The Ring 1995

King Mabel
WWE.com

The lowest creative point of the company's commercial nadir, King of the Ring 1995 remains the WWE pay-per-view to match all horrific shows against.

2006's December to Dismember is worthy of similar disdain, but was swallowed hole by the collapse of a relationship between Vince McMahon and Paul Heyman and the former's desperate attempt to magic wand a WrestleMania main eventer in Bobby Lashley. Big Bobby at least made a small impact on the monolithic 2007 'Show of Shows', but King Mabel was long gone in under 12 months after failing to even inspire fans to stick with that August's SummerSlam.

The pay-per-view not only played host to a disappointing Jerry Lawler/Bret Hart contest and an awful tag team main event featuring Diesel and Bam Bam Bigelow brushing past Sid and Tatanka, but also offered fans three matches with Savio Vega (four if you watched the pre-show) and only one with Shawn Michaels, the company's most dynamic and versatile performer.

Edited from the WWE Network edition, Shawn infamously tried on the crown during his entrance, but as a piece of tat custom-built for Mabel's ample dome, it wouldn't rest on his head. Like just about every aspect of Vince McMahon's product in 1995, the prop was another ill fit.


In this post: 
Kane MVP
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.