12 Wrestlers Who Did Their BEST Work In TNA & IMPACT

Impact Wrestling: where a WWE midcarder can become a genuine main event superstar.

EC3 Impact Wrestling
IMPACT

Long before it was the ugly duckling of modern American professional wrestling promotions, TNA was a place where under-utilised and unappreciated talent thrived, where talent led to results led to professional fulfilment. Legacies were established and careers were made in the Impact Zone, and don’t you forget it.

After years of largely overlooking anyone with "TNA" on their CV, WWE has softened its stance on workers who plied their trade down in Florida. Impact’s descent into irrelevance has a lot to do with it, but a mass of men and women made their name in TNA before taking those skills to WWE to become some of the biggest names in the industry today.

RAW, SmackDown and NXT are all full of performers who made an impact in TNA, so to speak, professional wrestlers who honed their skills in the occasionally raucous and occasionally morose surroundings of that fabled Impact Zone.

But not everyone gets to be AJ Styles, not everyone gets to be Samoa Joe. WWE barely knows how to book its own stars, let alone those made elsewhere.TNA has been the highpoint of many a performer’s career, believe it or not.

12. Matt Morgan

Matt Morgan TNA
Impact Wrestling

While TNA was generally a promotion that was more accommodating to smaller workers, it remains curious that a big man with limitless potential had to go there to catch a break. Matt Morgan did that, and 'The Blueprint' was a staple of TNA’s television through the good, the bad, and the losing tag titles to 2010 Scott Hall and Kevin Nash.

That latter memory was one of Morgan’s rare negative moments in TNA. From the day he came into the company in 2007, Morgan was heavily featured in singles and tag team competition on both sides of the ledger, feuding with Abyss, Kurt Angle, AJ Styles and the rest. His run came to an end in 2013, notwithstanding a number of brief returns in years since.

Morgan was a relatively protected star in TNA, portrayed as a dominant physical presence with more than his fair share of mental faculties. In WWE, Morgan was saddled with a stuttering gimmick, which got over just about as well as one presumes. In an attempt to salvage it, Morgan was also given the honour of hitting Big Show with an F-5 (during Brock Lesnar’s time away from the company), but the whole stuttering thing was too big a hurdle to overcome.


11. Jaxson Ryker

Tna Impact Gunner
ImpactWrestling.com

First things first, nobody in their right mind spells Jackson that way. Not even the people in their wrong mind. No word on the planet should be spelt "Jaxson." Even at the height of the Attitude Era, when wacky spellings were 10-a-penny. "Jackson Ryker" would be fine. Jaxson is an abomination.

Besides, everyone knows him as Gunner anyway. It is still early days in the big man’s WWE career but only the most ardent of Gunner Guys would hold out hope that his run in Stamford is going to top his work in TNA. In DixieLand, Gunner was a big overachiever. He started off as a member of a security tag team, only to flourish and find himself as a badass in the upper reaches of the card.

TNA never fully pulled the trigger on Gunner (pun very much intended) but they understood his value enough to use him as a threatening member of the roster in both singles and tag team competition. Gunner’s tenure in TNA is probably best remembered for a lengthy feud with his partner-turned-foe James Storm, reminding everybody that trusting James Storm is a fool’s errand.

Can Gunner succeed in WWE? He could have, but Jaxson? Come on.


10. Elijah Burke

D'Angelo Dinero TNA
ImpactWrestling.com

Elijah Burke had charisma, cut a great promo, was above average in the ring and had a real presence about him. Despite these attributes he never made any headway in WWE, his best work coming on ECW before his 2008 departure. A case of "what could have been."

In TNA, D’Angelo Dinero was a star. It didn’t happen straight away, as the 'Black Pope' was introduced as an unsuccessful X-Division heel, but when this wrong was righted TNA had a new hero on its hands. Dinero turned face in late 2009 and had some real momentum behind him, helped no end by his hugely charismatic character. Dinero had "it."

TNA’s decision to go head to head with WWE on Monday night in 2010 was disastrous. Idiotic. Nonsensical. Very, very dumb. That period is rightly remembered with scorn and mocking, a silly move by naive management that was led astray by the combined egos of Hulk Hogan and Eric Bischoff.

Dinero was one of the few highs during this time, riding a wave of momentum straight into the World Heavyweight Championship scene, challenging AJ Styles for the title on pay-per-view. Dinero was unsuccessful but more importantly, he picked up an injury in the match, sidelining him for a couple of months and cutting his momentum at the legs. What could have been, once again.


9. Austin Aries

Austin Aries Tna
TNA.com

It is easy to forget that Austin Aries was in WWE.

'The Greatest Man That Ever Lived' was actually with the company for a few years, but his run was overshadowed by bigger names and forgettable matches. An undeniably talented performer, Aries is best remembered for feuding with Neville, arguably the only decent Cruiserweight Championship feud of that time. Well, that and an absolute barnstormer with Shinsuke Nakamura.

Aries has done a lot of excellent work outside of WWE, but his best run was undoubtedly his ascension to the TNA World Heavyweight Championship in 2013. Aries went from midcard heel to beloved main event babyface in a matter of months, doing so through a succession of great matches and a work ethic that will always inspire adoration.

Modern wrestling is plagued with performers winning titles and claiming that they will be the one to restore credibility to said title, before doing approximately bugger all with the belt. Aries is the exception, as he single-handedly dragged the X-Division from irrelevance to importance over the course of 301 days.

Aries eventually vacated the title in exchange for a chance at Bobby Roode’s World Heavyweight Championship, a chance he grabbed with both hands. Austin Aries has been a pro wrestling standout for well over a decade, but this was his finest run.


8. Mr. Kennedy

mr anderson tna champion
ImpactWrestling.com

There is a parallel world in which wrestling is still one of the most popular forms of mainstream entertainment. In that world. Mr. Kennedy is the top star. The multi-time World Championwas always going to be a star, but the decision to book him as Vince McMahon’s illegitimate son was a masterstroke, establishing Kennedy as a top heel before a babyface turn saw an iconic feud with Triple H captivate an entire generation of fans. Repeating your name has never been this cool.

Except parallel worlds don’t exist, at least not to collective knowledge. Kennedy didn’t become the biggest star in wrestling, he became another lost cause. What should have been world titles became fantasy booking nostalgia. Kennedy was let go by WWE in 2009, only to be snapped up by TNA less than a year later.

TNA wasn’t about to sleep on the rechristened Mr. Anderson, and he was soon thrust into the promotion’s main event scene. Anderson went on to win two world titles in TNA, headlining pay-per-views as both a heel and a babyface before sliding down the card. He wasn’t the business mover that TNA hoped he was going to be, but that had more to do with the company than the performer.

Mr. Kennedy is one of the great ‘what if?’ stories of modern professional wrestling. He may have been a bust as a top guy in WWE, he may have been a generation-defining star, he may have been just fine. He didn’t stay long enough for us to see.


7. Eric Young

Eric Young TNA
TNA.com

Not a difficult one. Eric Young’s WWE career consisted of leading a stable of unheralded performers on NXT before doing approximately jack cack on the main roster, primarily losing to Akira Tozawa, No Way Jose and Cedric Alexander on Main Event. In his entire time in WWE, Eric Young won a grand total of three main roster singles matches.

You don’t really need to compare this to his tenure in TNA. Young was there from the very beginning, working for the company for 12 long years and doing all there was to do in the process. Young is one of only five men to win TNA’s version of the Grand Slam, an honour he holds along with AJ Styles, Samoa Joe, Austin Aries and Abyss. Young was a comedy babyface, an evil heel, a consistent performer inside and outside the ring. He was one of TNA’s most important performers for a very long time.

In WWE, he made wacky faces and lost. It isn’t out of the question that Young will return to WWE once this whole plague thing is all over, but you need to be an obsessive fan to believe he’ll have a singles run to match his work in TNA.


6. Bubba Ray Dudley

Bully Ray
TNA.com

Bubba Ray Dudley has had quite a career. The Queens native has wrestled for every major promotion under the sun, primarily as part of the iconic Dudley Boyz tag team, winning championship gold in WWE, WCW, ECW, TNA, NJPW, NWA and WWF. No other team can lay claim to such a feat. A 23-time Tag Team Champion, Bubba also has a place in the WWE Hall of Fame.

Bubba Ray has had a number of singles runs in promotions across the globe, but nothing comes close to his long tenure as Bully Ray in TNA. It was one of the promotion’s few success stories during a difficult time, as Ray took the lemons of another Dudley Boyz break-up and reinvented himself, cutting tremendous promos and proving himself as a top tier singles competitor. For a number of years, Bully Ray could lay claim to being the top guy in the number two promotion in the US.

He will forever be remembered for his tag exploits, but it is difficult to look past the Bully Ray years as the best that this veteran has produced. Both as a face and a heel, though primarily the latter, Ray was at the top of his game at that time.


5. Bobby Lashley

Bobby Lashley Impact Grand Champion
Impact Wrestling

Bobby Lashley and WWE should be a match made in heaven. Built like the proverbial Greek God, Lashley is a legitimate fighter with an untouchable look, carrying himself with a credibility that cannot be manufactured. Despite all of these positives, WWE just never seems to know how to book Lashley, largely because a performer of this calibre doesn’t really work as another cog in the wheel.

In TNA, Lashley was the wheel, the monolith that the cogs were trying to get closer to. His first run wasn’t much to write home about but all of those wrongs were corrected during his second, a four-year tenure that saw Lashley begin to realise all of that magnificent potential. It was this run that put him back on the pro wrestling map, reigniting his career and eventually bringing him back to WWE.

Lashley won the TNA/Impact World Heavyweight Championship on four occasions, beating some company icons in the process. He feuded with everyone who was anyone in the promotion, men like Kurt Angle, Bobby Roode, Drew Galloway and the rest. He was positioned as the ultimate athlete that he is, an unbeatable presence with legitimacy for days.

As Lashley contends with the sister and sham marriages that WWE writes for him, he can be forgiven for looking back at his TNA run with a tear in his eye.


4. Gail Kim

Gail Kim TNA
IMPACT Wrestling

If you only know Gail Kim from her numerous WWE runs, then you don’t really know Gail Kim. In fact, her time in WWE is arguably best remembered for a match she played no part in, a battle royal that she couldn’t care for and thus decided to immediately eliminate herself. It was one of the finest pieces of insubordination in modern WWE history. A few days later, Kim announced that she was done with the company.

If this is all you remember about Gail Kim then the time has come for reeducation. In TNA, Gail Kim was a trailblazer, the most important individual in the women’s wrestling revolution that went on to become such a vital aspect of today’s WWE. Kim was the inaugural TNA Knockouts Champion, and her series of title matches with Awesome Kong went a long way to changing the perception of women’s wrestling at a time when the form was all but dead.

Kim’s first TNA run was hugely influential but it was arguably topped by her second, a tenure that brought a further six Knockouts Championships and a place in the TNA Hall of Fame, the first female to be inducted. Hers is an influential and important career, one that amounts to much more than kissing Daniel Bryan and eliminating herself from the opportunity to face Kelly Kelly.


3. Bobby Roode

TNA Impact Bobby Roode
ImpactWrestling.com

There was a moment when it seemed as though WWE had faith in Bobby Roode. The Glorious Canadian was given a banger of a theme tune and a monster push in NXT, winning the NXT Championship fairly quickly and defending it against a variety of top opponents. He then went to the main roster and won the US Championship, although the hope of a big-time WrestleMania match with Randy Orton went out the window when the creative team remembered that getting everyone on the card was more important. A shame.

Roode has done okay in WWE. Give him a C+. In TNA? A*, all day long.

Placed as the muscle of Team Canada but clearly one to watch, Roode a potential top star who needed a little more experience before becoming The Man.

It all came together in 2011. Roode won the very first Bound for Glory series, earning himself a shot at Kurt Angle and the TNA World Heavyweight Championship. Fans were shocked when Roode came up short at Bound for Glory, but it worked out. James Storm beat Angle for the title before losing the strap to Roode, who turned heel. It was marvellously done, and Roode was set for life.

Bobby Roode was the defining TNA World Champion of his era. He carried himself like a star and was booked like one too, an old-fashioned heel champion who talked the talk and backed it up with style and panache. His WWE run pales in comparison, no matter how glorious that entrance theme is.


2. Christian

christian cage
ImpactWrestling

A controversial one maybe, but TNA did what WWE was never willing to do with Christian. He was one of the first to jump ship at a time when TNA was becoming the standout number two promotion in the US. Christian (billed as Christian Cage in TNA) moved across in 2005 and was immediately booked as the guy in the promotion, a main event star, and fully deserving of that position. Within three months of joining TNA, Christian was the NWA World Heavyweight Champion.

It is difficult to accurately describe the wrestling landscape back in 2005. WWE was settling into its position as the only mainstream game in town, tightening its grip on an industry that was struggling to survive from year to year. TNA was offering fans something different, a less-hokey style that focused more on athleticism than aesthetics, although it too suffered from the nepotism and favouritism that has plagued WWE since forever. More importantly, TNA in 2005 had a bucket full of goodwill from fans.

Christian moving to TNA was a big deal, and he was treated as such. It was a far cry from the midcard purgatory he left in WWE, a midcard purgatory that he returned to in 2009. Yes, Christian went on to win world titles in WWE, but he was never portrayed as a big deal. He was Edge’s brother, Edge’s mate. In TNA, Christian was the man.


1. EC3

EC3 TNA Champion
ImpactWrestling.com

For reasons that will never be entirely clear, WWE has always booked Michael Hutter as though he owed them something. They did it when he was Derrick Bateman, and oh boy did they do it when he returned as EC3. The former displayed more potential than most at a time when NXT was a wretched gameshow. The latter had "WWE Star" plastered all over him but was relegated to whatever came below enhancement talent. It felt as though WWE signed EC3 out of spite and was happy to leave him to rot.

Not so in TNA, where Ethan Carter III became a genuine star. He was given a big push from the get-go and didn’t let the side down, riding on his classic looks and natural charisma to get over as the biggest heel in the company, embarking on a character arc that did more for Dixie Carter than anything previous and made Rockstar Spud a legitimate star in the process.

In TNA, EC3 was a two-time World Heavyweight Champion, picking up the Grand Championship along the way as well. He was a major success on both sides of the booking ledger, garnering massive heat as a heel and adoration as a face. He was every bit the star that his ability and charisma demand.

EC3 returned to WWE just two weeks after his final Impact appearance, immediately slotting into the upper echelons of NXT. There was hope. Expectation. Excitement. Would WWE finally do right by Michael Hutter? We all know the answer to this story, a ‘no’ that should be in capital letters. Stripped of his promos and not given any in-ring time, EC3 was the afterthought of an afterthought, a vague memory of something that may or may not have happened but doesn’t really matter either way.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Born in the middle of Wales in the middle of the 1980's, John can't quite remember when he started watching wrestling but he has a terrible feeling that Dino Bravo was involved. Now living in Prague, John spends most of his time trying to work out how Tomohiro Ishii still stands upright. His favourite wrestler of all time is Dean Malenko, but really it is Repo Man. He is the author of 'An Illustrated History of Slavic Misery', the best book about the Slavic people that you haven't yet read. You can get that and others from www.poshlostbooks.com.