13 Unluckiest WWE Wrestlers

Just in time for Friday the 13th, superstars who were snakebitten in some way.

If anything is to be gleaned from the €œStone Cold€ Steve Austin podcasts with Vince McMahon and Triple H, it€™s that there is no magic wand that can be waved to make someone a massive star overnight. The way a wrestler becomes a superstar varies in each executive€™s eyes €“ Vince references reaching for €œthe brass ring,€ while Triple H talks about the X or €œIt€ factor €“ so it€™s clear that there is an intangible quality that WWE looks for in tapping its next big stars. Conversely, there sometimes are situations that pop up that derail a wrestler€™s career. For whatever reason, a WWE superstar was at the top of his or her game or on their way up the ladder when something halted their push, whether it was an injury, a wellness violation, a backstage incident or other unforeseen situation. Once they were sidetracked, it became difficult for them to recover. With 2015 boasting three months with a Friday the 13th, let€™s explore some of the unluckiest WWE wrestlers who saw their careers drastically altered from where they appeared to be heading. Part of what determines how €œunlucky€ they were is how big the plans/push for them was and how far they fell. Some recovered, but never made it back to that level again.

Honorable Mention: Triple H

It seems really odd to consider 13-time world champion and current storyline WWE COO Triple H as €œunlucky,€ but for a period of time earlier in his career, The Game was the recipient of a pretty serious punishment that could have derailed his career for good. In 1996, Triple H participated in the Madison Square Garden Incident with Kevin Nash, Scott Hall and Shawn Michaels. The kayfabe-breaking incident was a major no-no in professional wrestling, and with Nash and Hall departed for WCW and Michaels holding the WWF Championship, the punishment fell squarely on Helmsley. Originally slated to win the 1996 King of the Ring tournament, Triple H would lose that spot to Steve Austin and go on to lose most of his matches for several months. Triple H would go on to win the 1997 KOTR tournament, so it was merely a delaying of his push. But seeing how he bore the brunt of the punishment for the MSG incident, it was a pretty notable situation.

13. Evan Bourne

No one would ever think that Evan Bourne was destined for the main event in WWE, but the high-flying superstar saw his pushes repeatedly stunted by injuries and suspensions during his tenure with the company. Bourne was starting to make waves shortly after his debut in 2008, wrestling for the ECW Championship and winning a Slammy for Best Finishing Maneuver. But he injured his ankle that October, which would keep him out of action for five months. Bourne returned and was involved with some high-profile angles with Chris Jericho, John Cena and Randy Orton, but he would again be sidelined by injury. It looked like Bourne got back on track in 2011 when he and Kofi Kingston formed a tag team €“ dubbed Air Boom €“ and won the WWE Tag Team Championships, but he would be suspended twice in a three-month span for violating the company€™s wellness policy. While out on suspension in 2012, Bourne broke his foot. He never returned to television before being released in 2014.

12. Kofi Kingston

Today, Kofi Kingston looks like he is destined to play out his WWE existence in the midcard, being called upon when necessary to deliver a solid match or Royal Rumble elimination tease. Recently, he€™s been relegated to being part of a lower-midcard stable, The New Day, competing on PPV pre-shows and rarely seen on Raw. He€™s become more of an afterthought than a human highlight reel. But back in late 2009, Kingston was poised to become a major breakout star. He engaged in a heated feud with Randy Orton, delivering a huge Madison Square Garden moment that put him on the map and seemed to indicated that Kofi was on his way to the main event, hitting a Boom Drop out of the stands, driving Orton through a table. The chants and cheers for Kingston were deafening. A week later, Kingston would be the sole survivor in his Survivor Series match, last eliminating two world champions, CM Punk and Orton. That seemed to solidify his standing as an up-and-coming main eventer. But one incident would change all of that: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N-kxxFjiD6s Kingston apparently botched the ending to a January 2010 match against Orton, getting up when he was supposed to be in position for a punt to the head. Orton switched to an RKO and then had a mini-meltdown in the ring with the cameras rolling. Instead of Orton being punished for his public temper-tantrum, Kingston was de-pushed and has not reached anywhere close to that level on the card since.

11. Kharma

Triple H€™s early days as head of WWE Talent Relations were marked by two fateful signings: Mistico and Awesome Kong. Mistico would become Sin Cara, whose WWE career and downfall has been well-documented. Kong would be renamed Kharma and looked like she was poised to become the new face of the Divas division. Kharma spent several weeks in May 2011 decimating females and establishing herself as a monster heel before she broke down crying, later revealing that she was pregnant. Just like that, Kharma€™s momentum was gone. She would return at the 2012 Royal Rumble, but that would be her only official match in WWE, as she was released from the company that summer. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8eWP95fAQaw It€™s tough to call something as natural as becoming pregnant €œunlucky,€ but Kharma€™s WWE career was undeniably derailed in the aftermath of that announcement. It€™s a shame that she never got to run roughshod over the Divas division, and at age 37, it€™s unlikely that Kharma will get that chance.

10. Lex Luger

Lex Luger will long be remembered in professional wrestling for having tremendous potential that was never fully realized. He had the look and could hang in the ring when motivated. When the WWF got behind him in 1993, it should have launched his career into the stratosphere. Instead, Luger would lose his €œone and only€ WWF Championship match against Yokozuna at SummerSlam, then saw his next big chance at the Royal Rumble disintegrate into being co-winners with Bret Hart. Luger would lose his WrestleMania X title shot due to a weak DQ (touching referee Mr. Perfect) and shuttle down the card. There have been rumors that Luger was going to win the WWF title at Mania but ruined it by telling people beforehand about the plans and thus lost by DQ. Regardless, Luger€™s WWF career has been judged a dismal failure due to the circumstances surrounding his title opportunities.

9. R-Truth

For the majority of his WWE career, R-Truth has been little more than midcard fodder and a jobber to the stars who will dance and rap for the crowd. He has gotten a couple small pushes here and there, but nothing like he did when he turned heel in 2011. After losing his number one contender€™s spot to John Morrison, Truth turned on his former partner, becoming a serious bad guy. He defeated Morrison and Rey Mysterio, becoming more and more unhinged as time went on. He memorably dressed as a Confederate soldier on Raw in Richmond, Va., and tried to secede from the WWE, coining the €œLittle Jimmy€ phrase that helped exemplify his paranoid persona. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xhtrJ7KD6Ao R-Truth would form a team with the Miz, Awesome Truth, that would terrorize WWE for a couple months before they lost to John Cena and the Rock at Survivor Series. Immediately after that defeat, Awesome Truth broke up as R-Truth was suspended for a wellness violation, thus ending Truth€™s viability as a top heel. When he returned 30 days later, Truth turned face and the paranoid €œLittle Jimmy€ references became €œcomical,€ with Truth acting as though €œJimmy€ was an invisible kid who accompanied him to the ring.

8. €œDr. D€ David Schultz

This is one of the best (worst?) examples of circumstances conspiring against you. David Schultz is not known to a lot of wrestling fans today, but in 1984, he was on the cusp of becoming something pretty notable. Schultz was brought in to the WWF and became a top heel in the company just as the Rock €˜n Wrestling connection was being forged. It looked like he could be an important component of the WWF€™s explosion into the mainstream. And then it all fell apart. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zrX9Ca7LSyQ During a backstage interview with John Stossel of 20/20, Schultz delivered two open-handed slaps to the reporter on camera after Stossel asked Schultz if wrestling was fake. Stossel sued WWF and Schultz was fired just as WrestleMania was taking hold. He missed out on being part of one of the biggest boom periods in wrestling history as a result of €œdefending the business.€

7. Brian Pillman

When he left WCW in early 1996, Brian Pillman was on the verge of breaking through as a singles competitor. His €œLoose Cannon€ persona was working at making him one of the most-talked about performers of the day. But Pillman would be involved in a horrific car crash in April 1996 that shattered his ankle, ending his high-flying in-ring style and leaving his ankle fused in a walking position. Pillman would wrestle in pain for the remainder of his career. Just a couple months later, Pillman signed with WWF. About a year later, he passed away from a heart condition. Had Pillman not shattered his ankle, he would have been able to enter the WWF as an in-ring performer (he spent several months as a commentator while he healed) and might have had a more successful career. It€™s tough to predict how exactly things would have played out, but a major injury like Pillman€™s drastically altered his career trajectory.

6. Mark Henry

Few WWE superstars have had a longer, rockier journey to the top of the card than Mark Henry. Debuting as a green powerlifting champion, Henry would go through countless iterations, such as joining the Nation of Domination, becoming Sexual Chocolate and dating Mae Young. He toiled throughout the 2000s as a €œmonster€ who never quite made it to the top. In 2011 though, WWE and Henry struck gold €“ literally €“ with his Hall of Pain gimmick, during which the World€™s Strongest Man injured Big Show, Kane, Great Khali and Vladimir Kozlov and captured the World Heavyweight Championship from Randy Orton. He was on the biggest roll of his career and was a legitimate threat to any opponent. However, injuries would derail Henry€™s momentum in quick succession. He lost a month to a hyper-extended knee in early 2012, returned for three months and then was out for nine more months due to surgery. Since his return in early 2013, Henry€™s career has been full of stop-and-start pushes, both as a face and a heel. Sadly, it doesn€™t appear that he will reach the heights of his late 2011 push again.

5. Dolph Ziggler

While it€™s true that Dolph Ziggler still has plenty of time to ascend to the top of WWE, it€™s tough to deny that he has seen multiple pushes stunted for one reason or another. Sometimes, he seems to put his foot in his mouth. But the biggest brick wall Ziggler ran into came in the form of a concussion. At the end of 2012, Ziggler won arguably the biggest match of his career at that point, beating John Cena in a ladder match to retain his Money in the Bank briefcase. He also gained a girlfriend, AJ Lee, who brought along an enforcer in Big E. Langston. Although Dolph would lose matches here and there, having a mini-stable helped establish Ziggler more as a serious competitor. On the Raw after WrestleMania XXIX, Ziggler cashed in his MITB briefcase to win the World Heavyweight Championship from Alberto Del Rio to a massive crowd reaction. It looked like Ziggler had finally arrived. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MKqtFqpRLEk Just a few weeks later, Jack Swagger inadvertently kicked Dolph in the head, causing a concussion that knocked him out of action for more than a month. When he returned, he lost the WHC to Del Rio and would be shuttled down the card. By the end of 2013, Ziggler was losing to the likes of Curtis Axel, Damien Sandow and Fandango. Although Dolph closed 2014 strong, he has not fully returned to where he was right after WrestleMania XXIX.

4. Bad News Barrett

Despite his character€™s gimmick of delivering bad news, it seems like poor Wade Barrett has been on the receiving end of bad news more often than he gives it out. Bad News Barrett is one of WWE€™s natural heels, something the company seems to be short of these days. But he also has been snakebitten when it comes to his career. Barrett has been pegged for bigger and better things, but various issues have knocked him out of position each time. In early 2012, Barrett was beginning a singles push with the €œBarrett Barrage,€ but he was knocked out of action for six months with a dislocated elbow. He returned after adopting more of a €œFight Club€ persona, channeling his backstory as a bareknuckle brawler. After a year of treading water in the midcard, Barrett was barred from competing in the U.S. due to work visa issues, once again knocking him off television. During this absence from television, Barrett developed the Bad News Barrett gimmick that he then inexplicably got over, turning what should have been a one-note joke into a legitimate character. He won the Intercontinental Championship and seemed poised to finally break through€ until Jack Swagger threw him into a barricade, separating his shoulder and sidelining him for five months. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6enu56FaNjU Barrett has returned to action and is once against the IC champ, but can he capture lightning in a bottle again?

3. €œDr. Death€ Steve Williams

Few wrestlers have had the legitimate tough guy image that €œDr. Death€ Steve Williams did during his career. Williams had a solid football and amateur wrestling background and built a reputation during his time in WCW and All Japan Pro Wrestling. In 1998, he was brought in to the WWF as a possible world title contender. But first, he entered the ill-fated Brawl for All tournament, which he was pegged to win. The theory was that Williams would win the tough guy tournament, which would set him up for a world title shot against €œStone Cold€ Steve Austin. However, things took an unexpected turn when Dr. Death got injured during a bout with Bart Gunn (the eventual winner of Brawl for All) and then got knocked out, severely damaging Williams€™ tough guy image. Dr. Death would be out of the WWF months later, never getting his hands on Austin or the world title.

2. Rob Van Dam

A lot of the guys who have made this list had their pushes snuffed out before they made it to the mountaintop, but in the case of Rob Van Dam, circumstances led to his downfall while he held the richest prize in the business. When he debuted in WWF/E in 2001, RVD almost instantly became one of the most popular wrestlers on the roster. However, it took several years before he would finally break through to the top of the card, cashing in his Money in the Bank briefcase and winning the WWE Championship from John Cena in June 2006. Van Dam would be christened the new ECW champion as the extreme branch re-launched, but his adventure as a dual champion would be short-lived. Just a few weeks later, RVD got busted for drug possession, and he would quickly lose both titles in back-to-back matches on Raw and ECW before being suspended for a month. Less than a year later, Van Dam left WWE and would not return outside a surprise Royal Rumble appearance for six years.

1. Daniel Bryan

It is nearly impossible to script a better underdog story than the journey of Daniel Bryan from late 2013 through WrestleMania XXX last year. Bryan reached the absolute top of the company against all odds, becoming arguably WWE€™s most popular hero and winning the WWE World Heavyweight Championship after beating Triple H, Randy Orton and Batista in one night. In the span of the next two months, Bryan tumbled right off that mountaintop. Days after Mania, his father passed away. When he returned from mourning, he engaged not in a logical feud with Orton or Batista, but in a cartoonish and groan-inducing battle with Kane. But even that could be forgiven if Bryan was indeed on a trajectory to face Brock Lesnar at SummerSlam as was rumored. That would have been a great David versus Goliath story to tell. Instead, Bryan landed on the shelf for the rest of 2014 with various neck and arm injuries. He was forced to surrender his world title, and WWE went on without him. The biggest push of his career evaporated in an instant. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KrqUP35yqEg Today, Bryan is once again competing and leading thousands of fans in €œYes!€ chants. It€™s now rumored that he could once again headline WrestleMania for the WWE World Heavyweight Championship, but losing that unprecedented momentum a year ago certainly was an unlucky situation. Can he recapture it? We might soon find out€

In this post: 
Wade Barrett
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.