13 Worst Botches In WWE History

When it goes wrong in pro wrestling, it goes very wrong!

As every fan should know by now, professional wrestling is a scripted and choreographed slice of entertainment mimicking the appearance of a genuine sporting contest. The exact extent of the scripting and choreography that€™s required in advance depends on both the participants and the people running the match. For example, in today€™s WWE almost every interview, promo and match is written and planned in advance, while many indie promotions take pride in their roster being able to execute promos and flawless matches on the fly, as was usual in the days before WWE€™s dominance of the industry. Regardless of the amount of planning involved, when someone makes a mistake, it€™s usually painfully obvious€ sometimes literally so, when the error occurs in the execution of a move that needs to be performed in a certain way to be safe. This countdown is dedicated to the thirteen worst €“ or best, when it comes to the amusing ones €“ botches in recent WWE history.

13. Sin Cara Botches His Entire WWE Career

The first entry in our list is more to get it out of the way, really. An entire article could be written counting down the Mexican wrestling catastrophe Sin Cara€™s many in-ring botches, which eventually resulted in his release from the company. Several of these botches lead to self-inflicted injuries €“ like his failed flip out of the ring at Survivor Series 2011, which left him with a ruptured patella. Watch Kofi Kingston perform the move flawlessly to his left while Sin Cara becomes tangled up in his own incompetence above. Then there€™s the slightly less awkward but possibly more embarrassing Fingergate. Sin Cara had dislocated a finger earlier in a match with Alberto Del Rio, and then exacerbated the problem during a botched tope through the ropes. This was potentially more embarrassing, because Sin Cara immediately beckoned to the referee and had the match stopped, something practically unthinkable in the macho world of professional wrestling.
Of course, there€™s also this gem of a video, in which even some flannel from the announcers and the future Curtis Axel staggering about in the foreground outside of the ring can€™t obscure the fact that Sin Cara has just botched grandstanding in the centre of the ring€ and landed flat on his own face. That€™s right. He was on his own in the ring at the time.

12. Randy Orton Botches RKO On The Big Show

It€™s not often that Randall Keith Orton, one of the most gifted in-ring competitors in WWE history, messes up a move. Promos, yes €“ and if he takes any longer getting to the ring, he might one day forget where it is. But in terms of workrate, the man€™s practically a machine. Which is why it€™s oddly gratifying to watch the above clip, from a February 2012 episode of Monday Night RAW, as he conspicuously fails to deliver his own finishing move to the Big Show, who nonetheless collapses to the canvas as if driven in with a hammer. In the original clip, if you listen closely, you can hear Orton vehemently muttering a naughty word (and, of course, the crowd€™s heartwarming cries of €œyou f**ked up!€) before he and Show run the ropes to recreate the RKO the way it was supposed to be done, and just before Daniel Bryan runs in for the DQ finish.

11. Referee Botches Pin

Articles on professional wrestling mistakes often concentrate on moves going wrong, and not on bog standard errors in judgement from non-wrestling personnel. While we€™re not going to bore you with the number of times that Lillian Garcia has screwed up announcing the participants of a match, or list the mistakes crowding Booker T€™s bowling shoe ugly announcing career, this one€™s a fairly valid inclusion €“ the finish to this match was ruined, because the referee forgot what was supposed to happen. WWE referee protocol goes that the ref should count the pin if the shoulders are down on three, regardless as to whether that€™s the scripted outcome of the match, because to do otherwise would look utterly ridiculous. In this instance though, Jack Swagger was supposed to kick out of CM Punk€™s pinning attempt, and did, in plenty of time €“ but the referee called the pin anyway, seriously confusing both competitors. It was far too obvious what had happened, and WWE decided to roll with it, given that Punk was scripted to win later in the match anyway. The production truck got on with putting together replays, while the announcers discussed the mistake with concern in their voices. Later in the week, the issue was actually addressed on WWE.com, and RAW€™s interim General Manager of the moment, John Laurinaitis, (kayfabe) awarded Swagger a US title shot to make up for the (real) goof.

10. CM Punk Botches GTS On Kane

To compensate for a botch involving CM Punk which wasn€™t his fault, here€™s one that is. More than a few pro wrestling pundits have said that Punk should have a separate finishing move to use on wrestlers who aren€™t the right size, as the Go To Sleep requires him to hoist the opponent over his head to deliver the knee. If they€™re too tall then the knee goes precisely nowhere. In this case, it€™s a little difficult to see exactly what went wrong. Kane seems to go up and over, and lands in the right way to take the knee€ but it looks like Punk€™s knee becomes tangled in Kane€™s arm and, off-balance, he goes down with the bigger man. It wasn€™t the only time in Punk€™s vaunted career that the GTS would prove a problem on larger men, but of course the matter€™s irrelevant if he€™s genuinely retired from in-ring competition now. Perhaps if he makes a comeback somewhere other than WWE, he can dig out the Pepsi Plunge for one last outing.

9. Undertaker/Hogan, And The Worst Chokeslam In History

For some time, Hulk Hogan had had a protected career in WCW before this match with the Undertaker in 2002 at the Judgement Day pay-per-view. The story goes that, frightened of taking too many bumps because of his ongoing and increasing back problems, Hogan and any one booking him had ensured that his opponent knew to coddle him in the ring to minimise injury to his back. In this WWF match (the company ceased using €˜WWF€™ and began the rebrand to €˜WWE€™ a month later, after being beaten in court by the panda), around a year after WCW had folded, the same does not appear to be true. In the full clip, you can see Undertaker going for the goozle but Hogan simply not being ready for it, stumbling forwards. €˜Taker then yanks Hogan back into position again and mutters something to him (which we€™re sure wasn€™t complimentary €“ you don€™t ever sandbag the Dead Man, even if you€™re Hogan). We€™re then witness to the most anaemic chokeslam of the Phenom€™s career, as Hulk jumps approximately six inches in the air. We€™re pretty sure that the Undertaker had more words for the Hulkster backstage after the match.

8. Ryback Botches Shell Shock

When this first botch occurred, the Internet Wrestling Community (which, as everyone knows, is the ultimate arbiter of quality regarding anything in pro wrestling) was up in arms. Did Tensai mistime going up for the Shell Shock? Did Ryback botch his own finishing move? Did Tensai decide to go into business for himself, and sandbag Ryback? One thing everyone could agree on€ it had made the Big Guy look ridiculous. The uploader of the full clip to YouTube has tried to help us all out a little by including a clip from a Ryback/CM Punk match where the same thing happened €“ this time, with Paul Heyman. Unfortunately, it€™s still up in the air. Heyman looks like he€™s trying to help, and definitely hasn€™t sandbagged €“ but he€™s not a pro wrestler, and it€™s been a long time since Paul E. has regularly taken bumps of any kind. Some commentators have blamed the odd twisting motion Ryback uses to lift his opponents for the Shell Shock, and said that it makes lifting someone of greater than usual girth problematic. This would explain his trouble with Tensai and Heyman, neither of whom are slim and graceful gazelles, and explain why he never had an issue lifting two jobbers at once. At any rate, the problem seems to have evaporated, so perhaps it€™s not longer an issue.

7. The Great Mickie James/Gail Kim Botchfest Of 2009

This messed-up ending to a classic encounter is notable for existing in two basic forms online €“ one, like this, that includes the missed crossbody from the second turnbuckle, and one that kicks off straight after it. The latter video makes it seem as if James and Kim are contestants on Diva Search, incapable of setting up or executing moves correctly, or the transitions between them. We see an attempted DDT in which James goes down but Kim stays upright until collapsing under James€™ weight (while commentator Jerry Lawler covers for the audience at home by displaying surprise at Kim blocking the move). We then see Kim stand back upright, James execute a high kick that whistles past Kim€™s face to no reaction, followed by a swift forearm to knock her down for the pin. As experienced viewers can tell, and as the video that includes the crossbody makes clear, Kim was knocked loopy upon landing and was barely conscious for the remainder of the match, hence the botched DDT and the botched selljob for the kick. Scuttlebutt (like gossip after a can of spinach) says that James got it in the neck from road agents after the match for expressing her frustration in the ring at the screwed-up finish, as well as for improvising a listless forearm smash to bring in the pin. Luckily Kim recovered in full shortly afterwards.

6. Batista Botches€ Something.

No one€™s ever been entirely sure what happened here. The original Youtube clip€™s title says Batista Botches Backflip, but that doesn€™t look quite right. About to perform the Batista Bomb on John Cena, the Animal is suddenly interrupted by Mark Henry ambling furiously to ringside. As Batista discards Cena and rushes to intercept, the World€™s Strongest Man hops heavily onto the apron. The Animal punches Henry, who retaliates by shoving him back€ and Batista staggers, rights himself, and then performs a perfect back bump in the centre of the ring, for no reason whatsoever. If he€™d intended the bump to come about as a result of the shove but staggered instead, why did he bump anyway? If the bump was supposed to be for some other reason, then what on earth could it have been? At least if it had been R-Truth up there, the announcers could have blamed it on Lil€™ Jimmy.

5. Wade Barrett Dislocates His Elbow

This is a nasty one from a ten-man battle royal on RAW in February 2012 €“ as we move beyond the hilarious and into the just plain agonising. Big Show presses Dolph Ziggler over his head (badly, from all appearances) and hurls him to ringside. R-Truth and Wade Barrett are there to catch Ziggler and break his fall, and true to form Ziggler sells the landing as if the commission will feed his children. Truth seems fine, but Barrett is bucking and slamming the floor like a madman, and you can definitely hear him swearing like the Preston boy he is. It transpired that, whether caused by the fall or by failing to catch Ziggler correctly, or by Ziggler overshooting the two men€ however it occurred, Barrett had partially dislocated his elbow, and required surgery. Fortunately, Barrett would make a recovery and return to the ring six months or so later. Even more fortunately, his best gimmick €“ as Bad News Barrett €“ was still ahead of him, although he€™s once again sidelined through injury. Perhaps they should rename him €˜Bad Luck€™ Barrett.

4. Brock Lesnar Botches The Shooting Star Press

One of the more famous botches on this list occurred at Wrestlemania XIX in 2003, in one of pro wrestling€™s all time dream matches €“ Brock Lesnar versus Kurt Angle. The bout was set to be an absolutely phenomenal turn to cap a fantastic feud between the two, which had kicked off when Lesnar won the Royal Rumble in January of that year, last eliminating the Undertaker. This was an extraordinarily heated match between two of professional wrestling€™s legitimate all time greats, who also happened to be two legit hard, intense men with proper amateur wrestling and martial arts backgrounds. Both had been called prodigies in regard to the phenomenal speed and ability they€™d displayed in transitioning from real fighting to pro wrestling. But this was it €“ the title match to blow the feud off, on the grandest stage of them all. When Lesnar climbed the turnbuckle, the crowd was confused. Lesnar was a bona fide monster, not a high flyer. Not everyone was aware that the shooting star press had been an occasional part of Lesnar€™s moveset back in his developmental days in OVW. Now, the shooting star press is a fantastic aerial move requiring significant agility and timing to perform correctly, as well as safely. Lesnar had performed the move well in times past. Unfortunately for the audience and for Lesnar, on this occasion he botched it and landed on his head, as you can see above. Fortunately for Lesnar, the inevitable concussion didn€™t affect him too badly €“ he was able to finish the match as planned, with an F-5 to Angle to take the title.

3. Joey Mercury Shatters His Nose

In late 2006, Joey Mercury and Johnny Nitro (together with their manager Melina, known as MNM), were involved in a ladder match €“ a Fatal Fourway between themselves, the Hardy Boyz, Paul London and Brian Kendrick and, bizarrely, William Regal and Dave Taylor, two names not synonymous with the ladder match. Check out the clip to see for yourselves. A ladder match is naturally a spotfest, and a ladder was set up for Jeff Hardy to land on from the top rope, the idea being that it would flip upward and catch both members of MNM in the face. Of course, both men were also supposed to have their arms up to absorb the blow and prevent the ladder actually hitting them in the face.This is professional wrestling, not a demolition derby. Unfortunately, Mercury was out of position and couldn€™t get his arms up in time. The ladder swung upwards and collided straight with his face, which poured blood as he fell from the ring. Astonishingly, given the impact, Mercury only suffered a broken nose. He was taken straight from ringside to the hospital, where it was determined that there was no other serious damage to his face or eyes at all. Orbital bones have been shattered with lesser impacts, but amazingly Joey Mercury was back in the ring only a few weeks later.

2. Undertaker Nearly Ends Shawn Michaels€™ Career

Come the 1998 Royal Rumble, the Heartbreak Kid Shawn Michaels faced The Undertaker in a casket match, having reignited the previous year€™s scorching hot feud. As you can see from the clip, €˜Taker performs a running back body drop on Michaels to the outside of the ring €“ specifically, the side of the ring with the casket in play. Whether the action was too frenetic for Michaels to control the spill out of the ring, or whether he simply mistimed the spin, HBK was to strike the casket itself with the small of his back, at the base of the spine. The match, and specifically this botched bump, left Michaels with two herniated discs and one crushed disc in his lumbar spine. He would find himself unable to compete at the following month€™s pay-per-view, and would drop the WWF Championship to €˜Stone Cold€™ Steve Austin at Wrestlemania XIV at the end of March. Many have cited Austin€™s first ever WWF title win as the true beginning of the Attitude Era. For Michaels, it would mark what appeared to be his retirement. Due to the crippling injury to his back, he would not wrestle again until 2002. Fortunately for HBK €“ and the wrestling audience €“ he would have eight fantastic years ahead of him again, before retiring for good in 2010, ironically choosing the Undertaker as the man with whom he genuinely wanted to end his career.

1. Owen Hart Breaks Stone Cold's Neck

Speaking of €˜Stone Cold€™ Steve Austin, before his first WWF title win in 1998, he would wrestle Owen Hart at Summerslam for the Intercontinental Championship in August 1997. The piledriver is a move now banned in WWE matches, unless your name is Glenn Jacobs or Mark Calaway, that is. Both Kane and the Undertaker, two giant men, have special dispensation from the office to use the tombstone piledriver as one of their finishing moves. Back in €™97, Owen Hart was cleared to use the piledriver during his match with Austin, and you can see the result in the above clip. What you may not be able to see is that Austin€™s head was too low down. Hart didn€™t have anywhere near the size of the Brothers Of Destruction, and when he performed the move, Austin€™s head collided with the mat. Austin€™s neck would be broken in this botched move. Temporarily paralysed, he lay there unable to move while Hart, realising to his horror that something terrible had happened, stalled heelishly for time. Austin recovered sufficiently to make the planned pin to win the title, but wasn€™t able to keep it, having to vacate it shortly afterwards. Austin would be sidelined for around three months, returning at Survivor Series 1997 to win back the championship from Hart, who would capitalise on the notoriety of the injury by wearing a parody of Austin€™s own t-shirts of the time, stating €˜Owen 3:16 €“ I Just Broke Your Neck€™. €˜Stone Cold€™ would go on to become the biggest star in professional wrestling history, but this injury would shorten his career by several years, helping to prompt his retirement in mid-2003. What are your favourite botches from WWE wrestlers? Let us know all about them in the comments€

Contributor
Contributor

Professional writer, punk werewolf and nesting place for starfish. Obsessed with squid, spirals and story. I publish short weird fiction online at desincarne.com, and tweet nonsense under the name Jack The Bodiless. You can follow me all you like, just don't touch my stuff.