13 WWE WrestleMania Matches Where The Wrong Person Won

Given a time machine, what matches at WrestleMania should Vince McMahon change the winners of?

Sting Triple H Wrestlemania Match
WWE.com

Since its inception in 1985, WrestleMania has been the biggest worldwide showcase for professional wrestling. From the very first match at WrestleMania, when Tito Santana defeated The Executioner, to the main event of WrestleMania 37 when Roman Reigns defeated Edge and Daniel Bryan, there have been an astonishing 370 matches to take place at the Showcase of the Immortals.

With a stage as big as WrestleMania, sometimes the results themselves are not nearly as important as the spectacle of the event. With such a large number of contests taking place on such a large stage, there will without doubt be some disagreements on who the correct choice to win each match should be. However, there have been more than a few instances where fans unilaterally agree that the wrong wrestler won on the Grandest Stage of Them All. Some instances have seen a rising star have all their momentum cut out from underneath them. Others have been due to WWE choosing the status quo over a newer, fresher star. Oftentimes, though, it is quite frankly just not giving fans what they want to see at WrestleMania.

While there will always be dissenting opinions, these are 13 clear examples of the wrong wrestler winning at WrestleMania.

13. Becky Lynch Vs. Shayna Baszler - WrestleMania 36

Becky Lynch Shayna Baszler
WWE

Coming into WrestleMania 36, Becky Lynch looked to be in as much danger as she had been as Raw Women's Champion. After defending her title for a year at that point, The Irish Lass Kicker was facing a new challenge in Shayna Baszler.

Following an inauspicious debut, biting the neck of Becky Lynch, The Queen of Spades was treated as an unstoppable force, running through the women’s division and doing something that has never been seen before, or since. The former NXT Women’s Champion walked into the Elimination Chamber, and eliminated every other woman in the match to win and earn her title opportunity against The Man at WrestleMania 36.

In what could have been a defining moment for Baszler, one that crowned a new champion and cemented the arrival of a top star in the women’s division, WWE instead went the safe route. After a good match, especially in the empty Performance Center, Becky Lynch retained her title via a roll up, the same way she defeated Ronda Rousey to win the title a year prior.

Coming into this match, there were more than enough reasons why The Queen of Spades should have walked out of WrestleMania the new Raw Women’s Champion. Following the Showcase of the Immortals, the list would grow, as Becky Lynch would soon vacate her title with the announcement of her pregnancy, not allowing Shayna Baszler to get her win back.


12. Andre The Giant Battle Royale - WrestleMania 31

Big Show Mizdow - WrestleMania 31
WWE.com

Wrestling fans might read this entry and think that the winner of a battle royal on the pre-show of WrestleMania might not be need to be included on this list. That should change when you think about the factors surrounding the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal at WrestleMania 31.

Following several months of being one of the best acts on WWE programming, Damien Mizdow slowly started to tease turning on the man he was a stunt double for, The Miz. After losing their tag team championships and failing to regain them, a match between The A-Lister and his stunt double seemed a sure thing for WrestleMania. However, the pair stayed together, vowing to win the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal instead.

At The Showcase of the Immortals, Mizdow finally turned on his boss and eliminated Miz, to one of the loudest reactions of the night. The only problem was the former tag team champions were not the final two men in the match. Mizdow would be the final man eliminated, by arguably the last person who needed a win at WrestleMania, The Big Show.

Instead of a moment that could have cemented Sandow as a top babyface, he was quickly sent back down the card, being given the awful Meta Powers gimmick alongside Curtis Axel.


11. Michael Cole Vs. Jerry Lawler - WrestleMania 27

Michael Cole Jerry Lawler
WWE.com

Most wrestling fans would agree that the wrong man won this match between Michael Cole and Jerry Lawler. On top of that, most if not all members of the WWE Universe would have been just fine if this match never took place at all.

After being the most unwatchable part of the WWE product for months, it looked like Michael Cole was finally going to get his comeuppance via his broadcast colleague. The King, who was enjoying a mini career resurgence, would have been more than capable of handing Cole a quick beating alongside special guest referee Steve Austin.

As is often the case, WWE decided to go the complete opposite direction in this match. At just under 14 minutes, the fourth longest of WrestleMania 27, fans were put out of their misery when King forced Michael Cole to tap out. However, that was short-lived as one of the worst acts in WWE history, the Anonymous Raw General Manager disqualified Lawler, giving Cole the win. While this match had arguably no business taking place at all, the decision to give Michael Cole the win over a wrestling legend like Jerry Lawler is downright baffling.


10. Miss WrestleMania Battle Royale - WrestleMania 25

Santina Marella
WWE.com

The 2000s in WWE were not exactly the high point for women’s wrestling, and this match is the icing on the cake. Without a match scheduled for WrestleMania 25, WWE announced that there would be a battle royal to honor the history of women in the company, and crown the first ever Miss WrestleMania.

With no participants announced beforehand, fans were left wondering what WWE legends would return to take part in the battle royal. Once the 23 women entered the ring, via a Snoop Dogg mini concert, it was revealed the field was quite underwhelming. With that, there were still several solid options to win the match; returning legends like Sunny, Molly Holly and Torrie Wilson, current stars such as Beth Phoenix, Mickie Hames and Melina, or even the safe option in Divas Champion Maryse.

None of that was to be, as WWE decided to have the match meant to showcase the history of women in the company be won by a man, Santino Marella, dressed in drag. Not a great look for WWE, who were still several years away from the Women’s Revolution.


9. Sting Vs. Triple H - WrestleMania 31

sting triple h
WWE.com

Arguably the biggest name never to have entered WWE, fans nearly blew the roof off the building when Sting debuted at Survivor Series 2014. Having spent much of his time in WCW fighting the nWo, it made sense when The Vigilante came to the aide of Dolph Ziggler to right the wrongs of Triple H and The Authority.

Despite the Stinger's age, WWE rightfully treated his arrival as the major deal that is was. Leading into WrestleMania 31, both Triple H and Sting made it clear that their rivalry was not about rehashing The Monday Night Wars but about The Icon making The Game pay for his dishonourable rise to power. Once the two legends got to Levi Stadium and WrestleMania, all that went out the window.

An admittedly solid matchup soon turned into faction warfare. D-Generation X came to the ring, taking advantage of the No Disqualification stipulation to help their former leader. In response, Sting's greatest rival in WCW, the nWo, came to his defense to fight off DX. Shawn Michaels was the final man to get involved, delivering Sweet Chin Music to Sting to save his best friend.

Once this battle broke out into WCW vs. WWE, it was obvious that Vince McMahon would not let his company look weak by losing, no matter how long ago the Monday Night Wars were. Triple H would win, defeating The Icon in Sting's first and only WrestleMania match.


8. Chris Jericho Vs. AJ Styles - WrestleMania 32

chris jericho aj styles.jpg
WWE.com

AJ Styles had one of the best debuts in WWE history at the 2016 Royal Rumble. He followed that up with solid matches against The Miz and Chris Jericho, creating budding rivalries against the two. The Phenomenal One and Y2J would have three matches, culminating in an excellent tiebreaker at Fastlane where Styles would win the bout and seemingly their feud. The next night, they agreed to team up, forming the comically short pairing of Y2AJ. After three weeks as a team, the first ever Undisputed Champion would turn on the former Bullet Club leader, leading to a blow off match at WrestleMania 32.

The winner of this match, at least on paper, should have been straightforward. AJ Styles, only three months into his WWE career could have really used a big win on a massive stage like his first WrestleMania. On the other hand, Chris Jericho had proven he was able to stay strong even after WrestleMania loses to the likes of CM Punk and even the debuting Fandango in recent years.

With all that, Vince McMahon still went with the decision to have Jericho pick up the win against The Phenomenal One. Thankfully this was only a bump on the road for an otherwise successful run in WWE for AJ Styles


7. Charlotte Flair Vs. Asuka - WrestleMania 34

charlotte asuka
WWE

Following her debut in NXT in September 2015, Asuka would embark on a lengthy, beloved winning streak. Across more than two and a half years, The Empress of Tomorrow won 233 consecutive matches, including the first ever Women’s Royal Rumble match. Awaiting her at WrestleMania 34 was Charlotte Flair, whom she would challenge for the SmackDown Women’s Championship.

Coming into The Showcase of the Immortals, WWE had every reason to cement Asuka's place firmly atop the women’s division. Giving credit where it is due, the two former NXT Women’s Champions more than lived up to the hype, delivering a very good match; arguably the best women’s match in the history of WrestleMania.

Despite this, Charlotte would defeat the former Kana, ending her undefeated streak at 914 days. While The Empress of Tomorrow’s streak would have to end eventually, the decision to do so at WrestleMania was even more puzzling, as not only did Asuka lose, but she was forced to submit for the first time in her career, WWE or otherwise.


6. Bray Wyatt Vs. John Cena - WrestleMania 30

John Cena WrestleMania XXX
WWE

WrestleMania has not been kind to Bray Wyatt, as his match with John Cena in 2014 is the first of a trilogy of bouts that the former WWE Champion should have won at The Showcase of the Immortals.

The Eater of Worlds and the leader of the Cenation told an interesting story, with the Wyatt Family trying to turn Cena into a monster and expose his character as being built on lies. This was arguably a re-enactment of Kane’s 'Embrace The Hate' storyline two years prior, but this was different. Wyatt was not a roadblock for John Cena to get to WrestleMania the way Kane was for Cena to get to The Rock. Bray Wyatt and The Wyatt Family were running roughshod through the entire WWE roster and a win on the Grandest Stage of Them All against the biggest name in the company was the perfect way to cement their dominance.

Even if Wyatt was going to lose to Cena, that was not necessarily the goal. If The Eater of Worlds forced the legendary Cena to embrace his dark side, it would have been just as big a win for Wyatt as if he had pinned his shoulders to the mat. None of that happened however, as Cena resisted the temptation, dispatched The Wyatt Family, and pinned their leader with a single AA.


5. Bray Wyatt Vs. Randy Orton - WrestleMania 33

Wyatt Orton WrestleMania
WWE.com

In the three years following his loss in his debut at WrestleMania, it was more of the same for the often misused Bray Wyatt. Losing the members of The Wyatt Family, losing at WrestleMania to The Undertaker, being embarrassed by The Rock, and a serious back injury plagued the once promising career of The Eater of Worlds.

That all seemed to change when Wyatt was paired with Randy Orton in 2016. The two would be sole survivors at Survivor Series and Wyatt would finally win his first WWE Championship inside the Elimination Chamber. With The Viper winning the Royal Rumble match, a showdown between the former cohorts was set for WrestleMania 33. WWE was finally portraying Wyatt as the unstoppable monster that he was, and it seemed an easy decision to have Wyatt walk out of WrestleMania with his championship reign in tact.

Despite this, WWE decided to have the former Wyatt family leader once again lose at The Showcase of the Immortals. Instead of making the WWE Champion look strong on their biggest stage, they instead showcased their ability to project bugs on the ring canvas. While Randy Orton became a 13-tme World Champion, it once again kiiled all momentum Bray Wyatt had built.


4. Bray Wyatt Vs. Randy Orton - WrestleMania 37

WWE WrestleMania 37 Randy Orton The Fiend
WWE.com

Completing the trifecta of inexplicable WrestleMania loses for Bray Wyatt came only last year. In their WrestleMania rematch four years later, Bray Wyatt, now reincarnated as The Fiend, had returned to WWE seeking payback against The Viper, who had seemingly killed him when setting The Fiend on fire.

Similar to their previous match at WrestleMania 33, this bout was not about the bell to bell action, but was more focused on all the outside forces surrounding the bout. First, The Fiend was transformed back to his original look, shedding the burnt gear he had been sporting to that point. Then, Wyatt made his entrance via a giant jack in the box operated by his assistant Alexa Bliss. The match was also marred by the signature red lights that covered many of The Fiend's matches, pyro going off mid-match, and Alexa sitting on top of the aforementioned jack in the box with black goo oozing down her face.

Like their previous 'Mania clash, all the additions would have been easier to swallow if it had lead to a Fiend victory. But it was not to be, as The Fiend was hit with a single RKO and was down for the count in what would amount to Bray Wyatt's final match in WWE.


3. Randy Orton Vs. Triple H - WrestleMania 25

Randy Orton Triple H WrestleMania 25
WWE

While many of the entries on this list feature both Randy Orton and Triple H, something had to give at the main of WrestleMania 25.

Admittedly, the build up to their match was downright amazing. The Viper and The Game were the final two men in the 2009 Royal Rumble before Orton, with the help of his Legacy cohorts Cody Rhodes and Ted DiBiase Jr., would win. After Triple H regained the WWE Championship, The Apex Predator would go to war with not just his former Evolution leader, but the entire McMahon family. The Legend Killer had all the momentum in the world after punting Vince and Shane, while RKO-ing Stephanie McMahon. In turn, Triple H broke into Orton's home and attacked him, leading to The Kings of Kings being arrested.

With a build as personal as this one, The Viper and The Cerebral Assassin had a chance to have one of the most violent grudge matches in the history of WrestleMania. Yet, once we got to The Showcase of the Immortals, the two bitter rivals had a rather basic wrestling match. Despite being portrayed as one of the biggest heels in the WWE, Randy Orton could not overcome Triple H, even five years after the 'Reign of Terror' was over. While The Viper was far from a new star, a win at WrestleMania would have done much more for him than The Game.


2. Bret Hart Vs. Yokozuna - WrestleMania 9

hulk hogan wrestlemania 9
WWE.com

For the first eight editions of WrestleMania, the show would go off the air with the same man in the ring, Hulk Hogan. Even at WrestleMania 4, when Hogan was not involved in the main event, he still came out to celebrate with new WWE Champion Randy Savage.

Coming into WrestleMania 9, many fans would have been happy to see a fresh main event of Bret Hart and Yokozuna with The Hulkster lower down the card. Obviously this match does not have a place on this list due to Yokozuna defeating The Hitman to win the WWE Championship. While a man the size of the "Japanese" superstar needing to cheat to win did not make the new WWE Champion look great, the true problem came after the final bell rang for the presumed main event.

Seeing the injustice to The Excellence of Execution, Hogan came down to the ring to confront Yokozuna and his manager Mr. Fuji. Inexplicably, Fuji challenged Hogan on behalf of his charge, and even put the newly won WWE Championship on the line. 22 seconds and some poorly thrown salt later, and fans were treated to the same ending of seven of the eight previous WrestleMania's - Hulk Hogan as WWE Champion.


1. Booker T Vs. Triple H - WrestleMania 19

Booker T Triple H Wm 19
WWE.com

If there was ever a match in the history of WrestleMania where the wrong person won, this is it.

During the infamous Invasion angle, Booker T was presented as one of the biggest names opposing the WWE. Following the Invasion, Booker T was still treated well, being placed in feuds against top stars like Steve Austin and The Rock, even eliminating the latter to become number one contender to the World Heavyweight Championship at WrestleMania 19.

In the leadup to their match, Booker T and World Heavyweight Champion Triple H's feud took a turn for the worse. While never outright saying it, the build between The Game and the future King Booker was filled with racial undertones. Triple H referred to Booker's criminal history, threw dollar bills at him, told him to pick up his towels, and controversially said people like Booker T did not get to be World Champion.

While all of this was borderline crossing the line, it all would have been forgotten about had Booker T defeated Triple H. Thoughts of the WCW star not being good enough could have been expelled had he walked out of WrestleMania with the World Heavyweight Championship.

Not only did that not happen, Triple H did seemingly everything possible to make Booker T look as weak as possible. Following a Pedigree, The Game took 30 seconds to crawl over and pin Booker for the finish, seemingly confirming what Triple H said, at least in the eyes of WWE.


Contributor
Contributor

Ryan Berglund, known to many as KendoStickMan on social media, was born in the bright lights of New York City. Being introduced to wrestling at a young age at Nassau Colliseum and Madison Square Garden, wrestling soon became a passion. You can find Ryan on Tik Tok, as well as every other social media platform @KendoStickMan