14 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SmackDown Superstar Shake-Up

In which Roman Reigns shows up and punches Vince McMahon in the face.

Roman Reigns Vince McMahon
WWE.com

WWE's latest Superstar Shake-Up concluded with last night's SmackDown, as swathes of new faces joined the company's most consistent weekly show as part of their annual roster reshuffle.

First, we pour one out for those no longer with us. AJ Styles, the consensus best wrestler in the company, will be missed more than anyone, though Raw's main event scene suddenly looks a whole lot more exciting. The Usos are WWE's greatest tag team, one of the best in company history, and irreplaceable. SmackDown's MVP for much of his run, The Miz leaves a gaping upper-midcard hole. Andrade early-year rise won't continue on Tuesday nights. It was a shame to see Team Blue missing out on Aleister Black and Ricochet, too.

Despite all this, last night's SmackDown delivered on every lofty promise, with a strong set of Shake-Up selections mitigating any damage dealt by the losses. For those enthused by the roster changes, we got to see Vince McMahon getting punched in the face, a fun Kevin Owens Show episode, a couple of entertaining matches, and a new-look women's tag division emerging. What's not to love?

Time will tell how the refreshed SmackDown roster fares, but things look very promising after last night...


Downs...

3. Sasha & Bayley Were Right

The IIconics Billie Kay Peyton Royce
WWE.com

Apologise to Sasha Banks, because she was right about the Women's Tag Team Championships.

The IIconics holding the belts isn't a problem if they're booked like champions. They aren't, though: they're booked like jokes, and after losing to the thrown-together Bayley/Naomi partnership on Raw, they took another pinfall in another non-title bout on SmackDown.

Billie Kay and Peyton Royce were presented as enhancement talents prior to the title win, but that should've changed when they took the straps. Though that isn't to say they needed to become a dominant duo overnight, how is anybody supposed to take these belts seriously when they're around the waists of two wrestlers who can't get the job done, particularly in weird eight-person bouts?


2. Keep This Sh*t On Raw, Please

Bray Wyatt Bird
WWE

That is all.


1. Weren't You On Raw Two Nights Ago?

Lars Sullivan R-Truth
WWE.com

WWE pulled a weird Superstar Shake-Up move last night, transferring Lars Sullivan to SmackDown less than 24 hours after he'd been officially confirmed as a Raw exclusive, thus undermining this week's television and the mini-draft's integrity as a whole.

Lars being on SmackDown isn't an issue in and of itself. He's a solid big man with underrated microphone skills, and can absolutely get over as the blue brand's biggest monster. His ongoing war on ageing veterans who debuted around the turn of the century is good stuff, his beatdown of R-Truth hit the mark, and he'll be protected throughout. This is a good thing, but why bother confirming him for Raw the night before?

Though this is a relatively minor quibble, it presents WWE's writing team as slapdash and amateurish. Such flubs can't be allowed. WWE are the market leaders, and we're supposed to receive them as such, but there are times when it feels like they can't even get the minor details right.


Ups...

14. A Rivalry Reprised

Charlotte Flair Carmella
WWE.com

Former SmackDown Women's Champions Carmella and Charlotte Flair reprised their middling rivalry last night. Lasting little over seven minutes, it was far from blow-away, but a solid, functional, neat, tidy television bout built on a textbook momentum seesaw format, with the right wrestler picking up the victory.

There were near-falls early on, as 'Mella blasted Flair with a Superkick then hit a cross body from the barricade, rolling 'The Queen' inside for another two-count. Later, Charlotte went into full-on show-woman mode. She kipped up, strutted around the ring, and slapped the p*ss out of her opponent, who fought back, only to fall to a chop block, the Figure Eight, and the inevitable tap-out.

The action was basic, but we can call it a success for giving Charlotte her necessary post-WrestleMania rebound victory.


13. The Empress & Princess Unite

Kairi Sane Mandy Rose Asuka
WWE.com

There's probably a joke to be made about Vince McMahon substituting Io Shirai for another Japanese wrestler in Asuka, but screw it: Paige's women's tag team revealed was well-handled and satisfying.

WWE fans had been conditioned to expect the Sky Pirates this week. Instead, new call-up Kairi Sane will be teaming with 'The Empress Of Tomorrow,' who was brought out first as the former General Manager introduced her new tandem. It was a nice little swerve, and good news for all, as Shirai can establish herself as an NXT women's division mainstay, Sane will make her name on the main roster, and it's a great make-good for Asuka, who isn't going to be pushed to Becky Lynch and Charlotte Flair's level anytime soon.

Paige's new besties showed good chemistry in the eight-woman tag, too. This is going to work.


12. We Have A Women's Tag Division

SmackDown women's tag
WWE.com

A perceived lack of depth was one of the biggest concerns thrown at WWE's women's tag division upon its inception. This was understandable. The promotion barely had enough top-level females to fill out two singles groups, let along a tag scene, leading to hasty, unconvincing combinations like Tamina and Nia Jax.

WWE seemed to address this in the Superstar Shake-Up, with SmackDown eight-woman tag brawl effectively a preview of the division to come. The IIconics are champions, Kairi Sane and Asuka are going to be a full-time duo, Mandy Rose and Sonya Deville are still together, and it looks like Bayley and Ember Moon will be buddying up for a while. That's a solid core, even if a couple of them have been thrown together.

There's still a lot of work to do. The belts (and champions) need to be strengthened, and we're a couple of tandems short of truly deep division. Regardless, the scene looks a lot healthier than it did a few months ago.


11. Big O = Big Banter

Xavier Woods Kofi Kingston Kevin Owens
WWE.com

Kevin Owens as an honorary New Day member was bags of fun this week.

Big E is going to be out injured for a while, so in came "Big O." He told Xavier Woods and Kofi Kingston that they needed backup against Rusev and Shinsuke Nakamura later in the evening. Woods then insisted he squeeze into a tiny little crop top as part of his initiation, then told Owens to work on his pancake-throwing and gaming skills, as well as the trio's trademark pelvic wiggle.

Wiggle his pelvis Owens did, and well... it was certainly something.

SmackDown's opening segment was solid. Carried by Owens, Woods, and Kingston's chemistry and charisma, it began with a nice twist on Sami Zayn's Raw diatribe. 'The Underdog From The Underground' turning on his home crowd led us to expect Owens to do the same, but he didn't, instead paying tribute to Montreal before putting The New Day over huge during their KO Show appearance, leading to this new alliance.

Ideally, this will lead to Owens turning on Kofi sometime in the next few weeks, establishing him as Kingston's first WWE Title contender.


10. Elias Serves The Swerve

Elias Vince McMahon
WWE.com

Fans should have known Vince McMahon was going to pull an epic troll move the minute he promised "the biggest acquisition in SmackDown Live history" ahead of last night's show, and that's exactly what he did, unveiling Elias as the supposed game-changing pick.

The Chairman put the newcomer over huge. He said although he rarely puts his seal of approval on a wrestler, he was happy to introduce the future of SmackDown and WWE, claiming his subject was a talented performer who exudes charisma. Vince then asked for a drumroll, and out came 'The Drifter.' Cue: "I quit" - Corey Graves.

Elias worked his usual heel magic by sh*tting on Montreal, claiming SD would become "the Temple of Elias" in AJ Styles' absence, then telling the crowd to hold their applause and shut their mouths. The real "biggest acquisition in SmackDown Live history" interrupted him before he could more than a single guitar chord out, but we look forward to Elias pulling more antics like this.


9. New Moon Rising

Ember Moon
WWE.com

Ember Moon quietly returned as part of the WrestleMania Women's Battle Royal, putting forth a middling effort before being tossed out of the ring. It was a disappointingly low-key comeback for a sublime athlete who should be well-equipped to play a big role in WWE's women's division after a bland start to main roster life in 2018.

Missing since the Royal Rumble, 'The Shenom' has now been switched to SmackDown. She was the first wrestler to interrupt Becky Lynch during her mid-show promo, claiming that she had arrived on SmackDown to make a name for herself, and that the best way to do that was to come at 'The Man.' She isn't wrong, though she'll probably have to wait a while before making a serious title challenge.

Ember is another awesome SD acquisition. The isn't the best talker, but she's definitely in that category between the ropes, and her Eclipse finisher is among the sport's most eye-catching. It's going to be super exciting to see what she can do in this, the most stacked scene in the entire company.


8. An Overdue Promotion

F*ck yeah, Buddy Murphy is on SmackDown now.

This rules. Not only is 'The Best-Kept Secret' one of WWE's most consistent performers between the ropes, but he's a fully-formed heel with real personality and a decent talker. There's no reason he can't become a major upper-midcard player over the next year or so, and he was introduced with a quick promo last night.

Murphy was stranded on 205 Live. He was comfortably the best Cruiserweight Champion the company have had since bringing the belt back, and his livewire performances were one of only a few reasons to actually tune in to WWE's most neglected brand, but he was working his backside off for minimal pops. Now, he can finally bring his talents to a bigger stage. The graft he has put in over the past 12 months more than warrants this promotion.

Book him vs. Finn Balor immediately, please.


7. Let Bayley's Rebuild Commence

Bayley Becky Lynch
WWE.com

Completing the new-look SmackDown's women's division is Bayley, who was one of a number of new faces to emerge during the catch-all in-ringer with Becky Lynch.

That the Montreal crowd decided to boo 'The Hugger' speaks volumes of the hatchet job WWE have done on her character over the past few years. Once one of their most valuable babyface commodities, Bayley's main roster run has seen her marginalised and undermined. Becoming one of the first Women's Tag Team Champions brought hopes of a revival, but her and Sasha Banks' reign ended after a single month. It was another knockback for a hyper-talented star, and few performers needed a fresh start more than Bayley.

Let's hope SmackDown's writing team do a better job than Raw's, who didn't have a clue what they were doing with Bayley at times. She should be someone they can build up to the same level as a Becky Lynch or Charlotte Flair, whom she came up with in the first place, though creative have much work to do if they plan on repairing Raw's damage.


6. 8-Woman Madness

Kairi Sane Elbow Drop Peyton Royce
WWE.com

An eight-woman tag unfolded soon after the clusterf*ck segment. These matches are often pointless, but this one worked, with the babyface side looking particularly strong in victory.

Highlighting Kairi Sane and Asuka was a clear priority. The Japanese stars showed great cohesion as they worked together for the first time on main roster television, battering Mandy Rose with a coordinated double-team assault. Big dives and high spots followed as the bout moved into the next gear. The heels got their heat after that, cutting Bayley off as Mandy, Sonya Deville, and Peyton Royce ground her down, before the signature move shoot-out kicked in during the closing stretch, culminating with Asuka drilling Royce with a DDT followed by Kairi's Insane Elbow and the 1-2-3.

That an IIconic took the pin is problematic, but we've already dived into that. Deville or Rose should have fallen here. Regardless, Sane and Asuka looked strong, and they'll almost certainly be presented as The IIconics' first true title challengers now.


5. Who Needs Big E Anyway?

Kofi Kingston KEvin Owens
WWE.com

The night's second multi-person bout took place in the main event, as The New Day and Kofi Kingston cemented their alliance with a victory over the heel combination of Rusev, Shinsuke Nakamura, and Cesaro (where the hell was Sheamus, by the way?). A cut above most other matches on the show, it was every bit the entertaining, crowd-pleasing encounter it was supposed to be, with each participant looking good throughout.

There were slow portions in the first action, then again when we returned from commercials. Regardless, it finished in exciting fashion as Cesaro locked Kofi Kingston in a Sharpshooter in Montreal, before Owens booted his head off. A brawl broke out. KO came in and took Rusev down, so Kofi dived on 'The Bulgarian Brute,' then hit a Trouble In Paradise to set up Owens' Stunner and the victory for this new alliance.

It remains to be seen where this New Day/Big O partnership is going, but this was a great first night together. They were entertaining in their various segments, worked well in the ring and picked up the victory. How could anyone ask for more than that?


4. Big Blue Balor

Finn Balor
WWE.com

Raw and SmackDown effectively swapped their midcard champions last night.

Although the flu forced Samoa Joe to pull out of a scheduled Raw appearance, all signs pointed towards the United States champ moving to Monday nights sometime within the next few days. With him gone, SmackDown had a void to fill, and they did so by bringing in Intercontinental Title holder Finn Balor, who, just 24 hours prior, looked to be entering a new feud with Raw's Andrade.

The Irishman came out to a big reception from the Montreal crowd. Fans have been pining for him to come over to WWE's strongest booked main roster brand for a while, and it became a reality in SD's first hour. It should, theoretically, be a great move. Undermined so often throughout his main roster run, Balor will now benefit from Team Blue's tighter writing and presentation, avoiding terrible programmes like the Bobby Lashley and Bray Wyatt debacles and, hopefully, pushing himself back towards the main event scene.

We'll take a workrate-heavy IC reign before that, of course.


3. Finn Balor Vs. Ali Delivers

Finn Balor Ali
WWE.com

Speaking of workrate, Finn Balor and Ali killed it last night, delivering a fast, fluid opening scrap that was exactly what you'd expect from these two, with both wrestlers playing the hits, popping the crowd, and setting the tone for the next few months on SmackDown's upper-midcard.

Ali was the ideal opponent for this spot. Balor needed a rebound after losing to Andrade on Monday, and while the former 205 Live man's stock has risen since he joined the main roster, he isn't above clean defeats to guys like Finn. They're on different tiers, and that should be established.

The wrestler formerly known as Mustafa still looked good, though. He was allowed to work through the majority of his signature stuff and even came close to winning, though he whiffed on the 054. This allowed Balor to hit him with a shotgun dropkick, scale the top rope, and nail the Coup de Grace for the victory, after which he and Ali showed mutual respect with a handshake.


2. Big Dog, Bigger Acquisition

Roman Reigns
WWE.com

When WWE.com posted that Vince McMahon would name "the biggest acquisition in SmackDown Live history" in this year's Superstar Shake-Up, it had to be Roman Reigns. Had to be.

'The Big Dog' needed to escape Raw. He was an unwanted spectre looming over Seth Rollins' Universal Title reign. Fans would have spent the entire time on edge, expecting Reigns to step up and steal their favourite wrestler's belt at any moment. Splitting these former Shield brothers not only removes that threat, but it means that Roman is no longer the focus of WWE's "flagship show" for the first time in forever, thus reducing the chances of his post-return crowd reactions turning around again, and also presents him with all kinds of fresh, exciting possibilities inside the ring and out.

Make no mistake, this was the Superstar Shake-Up's best move. Reigns is a star, a tremendous sports entertainer, and exactly what SmackDown needed after losing AJ Styles. He debuted with an awesome Superman Punch to Vince McMahon's mouth, and he'll probably end up battering Elias at Money In The Bank, after which he'll become one of the brand's most valuable players, and a great opponent for guys like Daniel Bryan and Kofi Kingston.

This is 'The Big Dog's' yard now; everyone else is just playing in it.


1. SmackDown Wins... Again

Roman Reigns Elias
WWE.com

Just like last year, SmackDown absolutely trounced Raw in the Superstar Shake-Up, mitigating the losses of AJ Styles, The Miz, and The Usos with a series of high-quality acquisitions that, if presented correctly, should help put an end to the notion that this is somehow still the B-show.

As someone who is paid to break the blue brand down every week, your writer is obviously over the moon at this. The prospect of seeing people like Roman Reigns, Finn Balor, and Buddy Murphy mixing it up with existing SmackDown stars is mouth-watering. Then there's the women's division, which was already stacked with Asuka, Becky Lynch, and Charlotte around, but has now been boosted by Ember Moon, Kairi Sane, Bayley, and Mickie James. Lars Sullivan is going to be a great monster in the future. Elias rules, too. This whole Shake-Up rules!

Say what you will about the slapdash way in which WWE pulled the 2019 mini-draft off, but SD looks mighty healthy ahead of their new season of programming. Expect this to continue as we race towards October's billion-dollar TV deal.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.