15 Biggest False Narratives In Wrestling History
You've been lied to this whole time: featuring Goldberg, Hulk Hogan and more...
Wrestling is like anything: it is discussed by anybody with an opinion, and opinions, famously, are “like ***holes”.
Certain narratives persist when they were only ever true of a certain time period. Certain narratives persist because people simply wish to believe in them, even if they aren’t true. Certain narratives persist because some people were so influential in the space that their opinions have taken root and cannot be shaken.
Wrestling is sometimes so unspeakably bad that the alternative is considered the solution. The key example here is WCW dinosaurs in the main event = bad, ergo push the cruiserweights to the top of the card.
It was never that simple, but because it seemed that way for so long, a narrative persisted even when it made little sense: WWE should present authentic, exciting junior-style wrestling. This take was echoed long after the junior and heavyweight styles blurred into one another, making the former virtually obsolete.
Tribalism predates the formation of AEW. Opinion is often so extreme that it gets in the way of logic. This is true, sadly, in every walk of life.
Pro wrestling is no different…
15. The Booker Ruined This Wrestler’s Career
Vince McMahon broke the way in which pro wrestling is received. His dire legacy haunts every conversation surrounding the medium, even indirectly.
This is a broad false narrative to unpack, but because Vince was so atrocious at his job for so long - by wilfully destroying careers through his inability and unwillingness to create new stars - the onus on whether or not a wrestler gets over these days is placed entirely on the booker. If a popular wrestler stagnates, in the eyes of the public, it is very rarely that wrestler’s fault.
Consider Wardlow.
Wardlow was awesome as an explosive emerging force between 2019 and 2022. Wardlow was AEW’s Batista, in storylines, and was almost equally as good at conveying his motivations through understated body language. Tony Khan did kill the credibility of the character by not going with him when CM Punk was forced to vacate the World title in the wake of Double Or Nothing 2022 - but would it have gone all that well?
Wardlow was more Goldberg in the ring when tasked with the longer form main events demanded by the AEW audience. His recent Big Business match with Samoa Joe was eye-opening. Wardlow’s offence looked limp. It didn’t look like Joe was in much trouble when Wardlow went through the motions of an attack on the outside.
That might have worked, had Wardlow still possessed something in the way of aura, but the point remains: the booker is not always at fault. Wardlow as TNT Champion wasn’t particularly great, either, and that’s fine. There’s no shame whatsoever in being a fun midcard attraction.
Evolving into a true tippy-top main event act is very difficult.
14. The Two Man Power Trip Was Great
Nostalgia is the most powerful force, and its power intensifies as the years drag by and the world becomes a more awful, irreparable place.
The Two Man Power Trip of Steve Austin and Triple H is often held aloft as one of pro wrestling’s biggest missed opportunities; if only Triple H didn’t tear his quad, 2001 might have been saved…
How true is this?
This is a subjective opinion more than a demonstrably false narrative, yes, but compare the PPV buy amounts between WrestleMania X-Seven and Backlash 2001. The former (headlined by The Rock Vs. Steve Austin) drew 1,040,000; the latter (headlined by the Two Man Power Trip Vs. the Undertaker and Kane) drew a pathetic, terrifying 375,000. This is the steepest drop-off in the history of WWE on pay-per-view.
The legacy of the Two Man Power Trip is artificially elevated by the incredible match, against Chris Benoit and Chris Jericho, in which Triple H suffered said injury.
Otherwise, it was a punishing heavy heat bore of a storyline that wasted - to nothing short of a business-killing extent - the appeal of the Stone Cold Steve Austin character.
WWE is often appraised by its own fans on its commercial success. On that basis, the Two Man Power Trip was almost objectively a disaster.
13. Goldberg Should Have Been So Much More
Yes, WCW hastened the demise of the Goldberg character through its staggering incompetence - but da narratives surrounding Da Man are very much myopic.
An idea persists that, between them, in the late ‘90s and early 2000s, WCW and WWE totally botched Goldberg. And it’s not remotely untrue - but what’s lost is that Goldberg wasn’t blameless. Goldberg, done dirty, would have been done regardless.
Goldberg worked precisely two great extended back-and-forth matches that crept up to the 10 minute mark (Vs. Diamond Dallas Page, Halloween Havoc ‘98, Vs. Scott Steiner, Fall Brawl 2000).
Goldberg’s appeal was as explosive and sudden as his spear.
Not every wrestler is Hiroshi Tanahashi. Not every wrestler has an enduring appeal and the ability to craft an intricate, lengthy in-ring masterpiece. Not every wrestler becomes more sympathetic the more physically thrashed they are. Not every wrestler can work on top for a very long time.
Goldberg, ultimately, was a fad mutilated by bad creative - but even a great booker would struggle to do much with him after a couple of years in a post-territory landscape.
12. Wrestling Used To Look Realistic
No it didn’t, not once.
Well, perhaps once. The UWF-i league promoted ultra-realistic shoot-style wrestling, and was for a few incandescent years a hot property.
Beyond that…
The worked punch was once as ubiquitous as the reviled superkick, which is meant to be bad on the basis that, if you can’t kick somebody in the head and put them down, you mustn’t be a very tough dude.
The practitioners of the old punch must have been soft as sh*t, then. You couldn’t hope to keep count of how many of those were thrown in every other match promoted in the 1980s.
The Canadian Destroyer looks too cooperative, many people decry. Welcome to professional wrestling, in which every move is and looks cooperative, even the hallowed body slam. If you can’t see a wrestler post for it, you’re not looking. And that’s precisely the point: you aren’t meant to look. If you look too deeply, everything looks silly or at least illogical.
Even in much fetishised grapple-heavy matches, there’s not much preventing a wrestler using a free arm to elbow somebody in the ribs to break free of a submission hold.
11. ‘X-Pac Heat’
It is absolutely true that X-Pac, across 2000 and 2001, played the same bratty character he had throughout 1998 and 1999. It is also true that Sean Waltman - who incidentally never receives due credit for revolutionising the stylistic shift across the ‘90s - had, in the wake of Chris Jericho, Kurt Angle and the Radicalz debuting, been lapped as the guy fans could rely on for a nice dose of state-of-the-art action on undercards. X-Pac was passé. He felt dull and fans let him have it.
So while ‘X-Pac heat’ is hardly a false narrative, it’s nonsense that his good name is forever associated with the phenomenon.
Countless more wrestlers were infinitely more boring for a much longer stretch of time than X-Pac ever was.
X-Pac didn’t hang around for anywhere near as long as, for example, the Miz or Dolph Ziggler, whose ceaseless runs were amongst the most tedious byproducts of WWE’s tedious monopoly era.
The phenomenon could and should be named after somebody else. How about ‘Jericho Heat’?
The awld carny could even slap that on a t-shirt (if he hasn’t already).
10. WWE Did Not Make Wrestling ‘Big’
Wrestling, before Vince McMahon monopolised it, was not - in the infamous words of Paul Levesque - “this tiny little thing happening in bars”.
Levesque, who patterned much of his act around the work of Ric Flair and Harley Race, should know better than anybody that the classic NWA World’s Heavyweight title matches didn’t take place in the Rose & Crown.
Wrestling was huge on a splintered, regional basis before Vince McMahon embarked on his expansion project. In fact, when Vince McMahon was just a tiny child - an actual tiny child, and not just in his personality and demeanour - pro wrestling was a massive early hit on this newfangled thing called “television”.
Vince best capitalised on the game-changer that was cable television in the 1980s, but he didn’t pioneer the medium: Dusty Rhodes, one of the first stars of cable television irrespective of his profession, did. Hell, the (W)WWF itself sold out Madison Square Garden countless times before Junior ever “bought” the promotion.
The WWF made itself bigger at the expense of what it left behind of the industry. If anything, the average attendance of pro wrestling events in the states declined when the WWF went national.
This is a total lie dreamed up to position WWE “above” tawdry wrasslin’, which is anathema to the advertising industry.
9. Wrestler X Should Have Been World Champion
Paul Levesque has grasped one thing above all else, and that one thing happens to be the most important: being a World champion truly matters, and should represent the pinnacle of achievement in the business. He has his favourites, and might be guilty of breaking his “the belt shouldn’t make the man” maxim with Damian Priest, but mostly, he gets it.
It’s eye-watering how often you’ll fire up X and see some kind of engagement bait post asking who was never WWF World champion, but should have been: Mr. Perfect, Jake Roberts, Ted DiBiase, or Roddy Piper.
You know who should have been World champion at that time?
Hulk Hogan. He was the top draw, he convinced the most punters to part with their cash and buy a ticket, and that’s how the business operated at the time.
This is all well-intentioned, of course, but it’s odd how often this sort of conversation occurs.
Mad as it may be to read now, there was a weird online initiative - after 2010! - to give Kane “one last run” with the belt.
Conflating favourite wrestlers with champions and insisting they get the belt is one of the nicer false narratives, but it’s still just…wrong. In general, there’s a strange mentality in which being a valuable midcard asset is a bad thing.
AEW is in some ways a victim of this. Everybody should be headlining, apparently, which is less than ideal, since they have around 50 incredibly gifted upper midcarders.
8. WWE ‘Beat’ WCW
The WWF did not defeat WCW, not exactly.
WWE’s self-serving revised history is thus: the villainous WCW stole their old talent, got lucky with an angle, got hot through that New World Order angle, and was then offed via justifiable homicide by the great Vince McMahon, whose creative genius was such that he didn’t need the stars of old to win the wrestling war. He just needed his own genius, his own brilliance, and the twisting of karma’s knife right in that plagiarist Ted Turner (who in reality had employed the exact same tactics Vince had in the early-to-mid 1980s).
Vince had “stolen” Sid from WCW itself; the only difference between that signing and WCW’s signing of Hulk Hogan is that one worked, and one didn’t, and Vince threw a childlike tantrum.
The story is much too complex to cover in one listicle entry, but WCW went out of business because it was systemically inept to a laughable extent, failed to retain its own sizeable and viable audience because the creative was so wretched, and because Turner Broadcasting chief Jamie Kellner (in part) didn’t believe that WCW’s audience - despite Thunder dwarfing everything else on TBS at the time - could attract the “right” advertisers. Alarmingly, Fox recently elected not to renew Friday Night SmackDown for the exact same reason.
The general public’s attitude towards pro wrestling had as much to do with the death of WCW as anythin
7. AEW Must Appeal To The Casual Fan
This is a load of rubbish on two levels.
1 - No, AEW does not need to appeal to the casual fan. A24 is an independent company that produces film and TV not intended for a mass audience. They exist - as do countless record companies - to grab those who are passionately into a niche medium or genre. The idea is to be great at something fewer people like.
Why can’t this be true of pro wrestling? Especially when, as AEW has proved by positioning itself as an established, successful #2 by throwing Jun Akiyama in a TV main event in 2024, it evidently is true of pro wrestling?
AEW should not aim for WWE’s audience; a not considerable audience beyond WWE’s reach already exists, and AEW’s core base rejected the promotion’s WWE-style leanings so heavily last year that Tony Khan apologised via the Continental Classic.
2 - There isn’t such a thing as the “casual fan”. Sure, there are fans who drop in and out and who won’t commit to watching religiously every week, but the idea that hundreds of thousands more people would watch AEW if AEW would only, say, do what Eric Bischoff says, is preposterous.
AEW has its own audience. The monopoly has broken many a brain in many different ways - the way in which industries actually function is just one of them.
6. Wrestler X Does Not Know How To Sell
There is more than one way to sell.
Limb selling is the traditional way of going about it, and as such, if a wrestler shakes off something that may look devastating in that context, it is automatically assumed by some fans to be bad.
The “delayed” style of selling imported from puro is something that some western fans struggle with, but it’s arguably a more accurate reflection of the modern athlete in legitimate sports. In football, a flying wide forward can get his ankle raked, cutting open a hole in his sock, and continue the match more or less as normal without on-field treatment. A strong blow to a body part doesn’t necessarily affect somebody for minutes and minutes on end. That’s just wrestling logic. Adrenaline can and in real sports actually does drive recovery.
What’s particularly odd about this take, which resurfaces on a monthly basis at a minimum, is that it only holds true depending on your preferred promotion. Will Ospreay was hit by the “doesn’t know how to sell” tag following his war with Konosuke Takeshita at AEW Revolution. A mere eight days later, in a WWE Raw gauntlet match, Ricochet and JD McDonagh enacted the exact same selling philosophy to zero discourse nor controversy.
Tribalism has not merely poisoned the way in which pro wrestling is analysed. It has even poisoned the way in which it is actually watched. People sometimes just don’t see things that are literally happening in front of them.
5. Dave Meltzer Is Biased Against WWE
He really isn’t.
When Dave Meltzer heavily criticised WWE in 2019, frequently comparing it to WCW in 2000, is it not possible that WWE was indeed awful in 2019?
It’s very possible; after all, the narrative these days is that Paul Levesque saved WWE two years ago and that WWE-leaning critics and fans are immensely grateful for that. To draw on just one of many examples of this new consensus, every time WWE executes a cool production flourish - like the way in which Logan Paul was shot before putting Cody Rhodes through a table at King And Queen of the Ring - many fans express their gratitude that the Vince McMahon and Kevin Dunn regime is over.
So Dave was right, then?
Dave’s importance in this space can never go overstated, nobody would be here if he wasn’t, his best work is completely peerless. He does however, especially in recent years, approach wrestling with a weird slant that sort of makes sense but also doesn’t.
He almost dispassionately analyses pro wrestling on a volume-first basis, as if it’s not an art form but rather a fire alarm. Any noise is good, even if that noise is the performative result of what a good match is “supposed” to look like.
He is biased in favour of loud noises and numbers. For Christ’s sake, as NXT ratings improved in 2023, he encouraged his reader base to consider voting Shawn Michaels for Booker of the Year.
Michael Hickenbottom is not All Elite!
Dave enjoyed NXT under Levesque more than he did AEW for much of late 2019. He threw stars at the peak TakeOver brand like a giddy child armed with snowballs.
He thinks Paul Levesque is a better booker than Tony Khan right now as you read this!
4. Tony Khan Needs Somebody Experienced To Help Him
Tony Khan promoted All In: London - the show that drew the largest paid attendance in pro wrestling history. Tony Khan promoted this event several years deep into his career as a wrestling promoter. He is, thus, an experienced and hugely successful booker.
Objectively!
This concern trolling might have made sense, once, in December 2019 - a few weeks after which Khan took on more responsibility himself as AEW flourished.
While anybody could have booked a good, action-heavy show with the talent roster available to him in May 2019, Tony Khan booked that killer closing angle with Jon Moxley terrorising Kenny Omega and built MJF as a super-entertaining future mega heel. He did this on his very first show. All Out 2019, built around the Mox Vs. Omega match (which was only later postponed) sold out within 15 minutes. Khan was immediately, demonstrably very good at his job. He really could do with an editor, and has made several errors over the last two years, but until those impressive pay-per-view buys begin to drop, his audience is literally buying what he’s selling.
Moreover: who has experience in pro wrestling that actually could “help” AEW?
A writer with experience working for WWE?
Jennifer Pepperman is hardly drawing raves for her collaboration with Mercedes Moné.
Delirious wouldn’t help; AEW’s pay-per-views are long enough as it is. Bully Ray somehow contrived to do a worse job with Ring Of Honor (allegedly…).
Eric Bischoff’s stint in TNA at a minimum disqualifies him, as does his inability to articulate what a story actually is. Jim Cornette?
A great mind once, he hates modern wrestling, saw nothing in the Young Bucks, Kevin Owens nor Sami Zayn when overseeing Ring of Honor, and once fantasy-booked the Road Warriors Vs. Dudley Boyz when asked to put together an alternative card for WrestleMania X8. That was in 2002.
Imagine booking that washed-up act against Hawk and Animal?
3. Wrestling Matches Aren’t Important
Readers added context you may wish to know: wrestling matches are, in fact, important.
It really is astonishing how the truth is most often found between two colliding, dogmatic opinions. There are two extremes, and helpfully, for illustrative purposes, AEW and WWE have occupied each at various points across 2024.
AEW has promoted countless moderately heated, well-worked matches on Collision this year that served no compelling narrative purpose beyond handing a name wrestler a win - so much so that the Saturday show has been stigmatised as utterly missable and inconsequential.
WWE meanwhile promoted Jey Uso Vs. Jimmy Uso at WrestleMania: a match so actively atrocious that not even the preceding, acclaimed Bloodline storyline could make the fans in the stadium care about it.
Wrestling evidently can’t just be about stories; nor can it just be about matches. This should not be especially difficult to grasp, but hop on X for a few minutes. Matches apparently do not matter. If they’re bad, so what?
It’s almost a shame that Hulk Hogan Vs. André the Giant happened at WrestleMania III. The take was true precisely once, and the exception, to some, has become the rule.
2. Hulk Hogan Was Not A Great Wrestler
Hulk Hogan is a bad human being, but he was a superb professional wrestler.
The idea of what constitutes a great wrestler is warped in general. While there’s no such thing as an objective truth about an art form, the other extreme is easily reached. Bryan Danielson is for example obviously a better pro wrestler than Tom Magee.
Dave Meltzer often takes this viewpoint a tad too far, but the only true way of measuring a wrestler’s ability on anything approaching an objective level - while still flawed - is in how much noise they generate.
Hulk Hogan generated overwhelming noise and emotion. His stuff in the US looked basic and legitimate. He convinced crowds everywhere that he, despite being a physical monster, was in mortal danger in his matches. Many of those matches were against obvious foe-of-the-month style losers, and yet Hogan was still able to conjure overwhelming drama.
He was a bit awkward and janky in his movements and very, very corny with his theatrical approach to crowd psychology, but he was a master at the craft of working the crowd and, obviously, was a colossus of a drawing card.
Hogan just got it in a way very few other wrestlers did.
1. The Brood Was An Intimidating, Iconic Stable
Ahead of and at AEW Double Or Nothing 2024, Adam Copeland did that which he had done during his hardly rave-reviewed WWE return: he attempted to present ‘Brood Edge’ as an alter-ego.
He soaked Malakai with fake blood in a very corny wrestling angle. If it was meant to be real, how did Copeland procure it?
And if it was meant to be fake, how was it meant to be remotely intimidating?
The Brood are a Mandela Effect nostalgia act. The entrance was great - so great that obscures just how actively bad that act was. Infamous for stilted, terrified delivery in their promo segments, Edge and Christian only got over when they escaped the trappings of the gimmick. No Mercy 1999 was their breakthrough moment. Nobody was ever scared of nor intimidated by the Brood at the time. Bob Holly certainly wasn’t. The Brood were barely even treated as a threat by WWE, much less the fandom.
The idea that Copeland treats Brood Edge like something akin to the Great Muta lacks credibility; if anything, the opposite is true.
Adam Copeland doing this particular self-referential bit really is bizarre. It’s not unlike Roman Reigns using a Leakee alter-ego, or even Cody Rhodes bringing back Stardust on occasion.
The. Brood. Were. Never. Over.
Best of luck to Copeland as he endures a difficult period of rehabilitation - but perhaps Brood Edge is best left as a nostalgia entrance, and not a character that is meant to be intimidating.