15 Great Wrestlers Lost In WWE's Mid-Card

Just how long do we have to put up with Stardust?

One look at the current World Wrestling Entertainment roster reveals a wealth of talented young men and women the likes of which the company has never seen. More so than at any time in the past, every Superstar from the opening match acts to the main event stars are talented and capable performers. Any, if given the chance, can steal the show at any given time. Unfortunately, with such a wealth of talent populating the roster, there are only so many prime spots available. Stars such as Seth Rollins, Roman Reigns, Daniel Bryan and Bray Wyatt have ascended to the top of the card, regularly competing in high profile pay-per-view bouts and cementing their status as the future of the industry. Other young performers have not been presented as many opportunities to succeed at the next level as those aforementioned stars. And, if they have been, they were inexplicably dropped down the card, becoming lost in the midcard. For them, their hard work and dedication to their craft leaves them without much in the way of momentum. They never move upward or downward, are beaten on television one week and celebrated the next. In many ways, the WWE midcard is a purgatory for men and women just outside of the main event scene, an inescapable life of repetition. Which Superstars and Divas are lost in the midcard, their prospects for a run at the top or even the opportunity to showcase their skills outside of Superstars and Main Event incredibly low? Take a look for yourself.

15. Fandango

Anyone who has ever watched a match involving Fandango can tell that the man behind the ballroom dancer is a talented in-ring performer. After all, there is a reason CM Punk named him a "wrestlers' wrestler" in a 2013 WWE.com article and Chris Jericho certainly would not have opted to compete against him at WrestleMania 29 had he thought him anything other than a capable wrestler. The fact is that Fandango has become bogged down in the midcard through no fault of his own. The lack of opportunities for increased mic time, and a gimmick straight out of 1996, has left him with nowhere to go. He comes to the ring for his matches, wins or loses, and heads to another town to do it all over again the next day. There is no character progression, no ability to get himself over in interviews and the slower and darker turn that occurred last fall hurt the crowd's ability to help him get over by taking away the so-called "Fandangoing." A very solid professional wrestlers, whose matches are rarely bad, Fandango is a Superstar lost in the midcard that certainly deserves a greater opportunity to advance his character and, as a result, his career. A spot in the WrestleMania ladder match would have been ideal for him.

14. Goldust

The Bizarre One has fallen deep into the WWE midcard, thanks to a split from brother Stardust and a lackluster performance in the sibling's match at this past February's Fastlane pay-per-view. Since that night, he has appeared almost exclusively on WWE Superstars and Main Event, with the rare Raw appearance coming one night after WrestleMania XXXI, when he was squashed by an infuriated Rusev. A veteran of the squared circle for nearly three decades, Goldust has accomplished just about everything there is to accomplish at this point. With rumors suggesting that he is about to hang up the black and gold in favor of a job as a producer, it appears unlikely that Goldust will be used in anything even remotely meaningful going forward. Thus, there is solid reasoning for the former intercontinental and tag team champion being lost in the shuffle. With that said, it still would be nice to see someone who has contributed so much to WWE go out with a bang, rather than the whimper he is headed for at this point.

13. Emma

When Emma left NXT, she did so as the most over female performer on the developmental roster. Her quirkiness and clumsiness helped set her apart from the rest of the girls and enabled her to connect with the audience in ways the others could only dream of. Her bubble popping, foot stomping entrance, complete with struggling to get in the ring, was original and only added to the persona she had created for herself. Upon making her way to the main roster, Emma faded quickly. Presented as a comedy act, the romantic interest of Santino Marella, she disappeared from the airwaves upon the revelation that Marella would be forced into retirement due to a neck injury. A real life legal issue sent her deeper into the dark abyss of the midcard, where she remains now. The silver lining in Emma's otherwise blackened storm clouds is the fact that, based on what fans have seen during recent episodes of NXT, as well as her social media accounts, is that the Aussie appears to be undergoing a character change. Dismayed by what her career has been to this point, she has repeatedly pointed out that the fans of NXT lie, that their cheers fail to prepare the Superstars and Divas for what awaits when they venture onto Raw and SmackDown. That could make for a quality character at some point in the near future but for now, she easily ranks as the Diva lowest on the totem pole. Yes, even lower than Cameron.

12. Tyson Kidd

No Superstar proved themselves in 2014 more than Tyson Kidd. Doing nothing of note on the main roster, he approached the opportunity to be a star on NXT with great passion and excitement. The lead heel on the brand throughout the year, he developed into a controlling douchebag, repeatedly talking down to wife Natalya and expressing great jealousy over her success, all the while obsessing over the NXT championship. A big fish in the medium-sized pond, he was able to develop his character and, thus, thrive. His return to the main roster has not been as fruitful. While he appears regularly on Raw and SmackDown, has captured the WWE Tag Team Championships and still flashes hints of rudeness toward his lovely significant other, Kidd is essentially just "a guy" on a roster full of them. Granted, he is a wildly talented guy, probably one of the most underrated workers in the entire industry, but he is very much a guy WWE Creative feels they can easily replace if the situation arises. Though a current champion, he and partner Cesaro float aimlessly throughout the midcard, defending their titles against countless teams, never really gaining or losing ground.

11. Curtis Axel

Curtis Axel is a Superstar in the middle of the hottest run of his career, thanks to ridiculous story involving his non-elimination from the Royal Rumble and the explosion of AxelMania. He has demonstrated an ability to capture the attention of the fans, especially the so-called "smart" ones, through over-the-top promo declaring his greatness. He then proceeds to lose squash matches to his fellow Superstars. WWE Creative took an idea Axel laid the groundwork for at the end of the Rumble broadcast and turned it into a delusional character who gains more and more momentum every time grabs hold of a live microphone. Outside of an in-ring confrontation with John Cena, though, Axel has been unable to parlay the surprisingly over character into anything resembling a push. For all the waves he has made, both on social media and live television, he continues to be trapped in the midcard, with no real upward movement to speak of. There was a time when WWE would capitalize on the buzz surrounding a character but in today's WWE, it feels very much as though no character will ever get a deserved push if management did not intend for it to get over.

10. Jack Swagger

Jack Swagger is a former world heavyweight champion. Let that sink in for a moment. Commentators like Michael Cole and Byron Saxton will remind fans of such an accomplishment but for whatever reason, it never really garners the respect it deserves, at least in the Real American's case. In fact, a lot of what Swagger does and is capable of goes unrecognized and underappreciated by management and fans alike, leading to his spot on this countdown. Despite repeatedly proving himself as an in-ring performer, most notably in recent matches with Rusev and his 2013 rivalry with Alberto Del Rio, Swagger remains firmly entrenched in WWE's midcard, lost in the shuffle and stuck competing in meaningless matches on WWE Superstars. When he does finally make it onto Monday or Thursday night programming, he does so as the punching bag for the Bulgarian Brute, who apparently never gets tired of beating on the former amateur wrestling star. It may be too little, too late for Swagger to ever be a sustainable main event star. His 2013 run-in with the law suggests he is not the most trustworthy of stars, given the fact that he was en route to a huge world title match when he was arrested for driving under the influence and possession of marijuana, but that does not mean he cannot be used in a much more meaningful manner than he currently is. A run at the intercontinental or United States titles, perhaps even starring as backup for a main event star like Roman Reigns or Randy Orton, would be solid use of a guy who still has a great deal left in the tank. A performer still in his athletic prime, wasting Swagger on the lower midcard is a tremendous misuse of his talents.

9. Natalya

Natalya is, without a shadow of a doubt, the most technically gifted worker on the Divas roster. She is also one of the best female wrestlers in the entire business. No matter how many times she impresses inside the squared circle, or how many fans she garners while doing so, she is never really allowed to enjoy the fruits of her labor. Oftentimes overshadowed by the more marketable AJ Lee or Bella Twins, Natalya has repeatedly found her pushes cut off at the knees, stopped before she was ever allowed to achieve greatness. Now filling the role of modern day Sable, the subject of husband Tyson Kidd's berating and wearer of skin-tight leather (author's note: YES!), her television exposure is consistent, and she has appeared regularly between the ropes. But wrestling El Torito in "mixed species" matches isn't exactly how Natalya saw her wrestling career playing out. The third-generation Diva, daughter of Jim Neidheart and granddaughter of the late Stu Hart, she deserves the opportunity to showcase her considerable talents between the ropes. At NXT Takeover, Natalya proved her abilities when she battled Charlotte in a legitimate NXT Match of the Year contender. Until WWE opens up opportunities for more of its female talent to shine inside the squared circle, she will continue to be one of the brightest stars lost in the company's midcard.

8. Damien Mizdow

Damien Mizdow is a character that never should have gotten over to the extent that it has. He was a living, breathing cartoon character, completely over the top and comical. He was the lovable sidekick of The Miz, the one who garnered sympathy because of the mistreatment he endured at the hands of the former WWE champion. Though a talented in-ring competitor during his run as a heel years earlier, he was a comedy act at best. Every time he bumped at ringside, performing one of The Miz's trademark maneuvers on air, the cheers grew louder for the man once known as the Intellectual Savior of the Unwashed Masses. And as the pops for his arrival increased in volume, Mizdow continued to find himself lost in the midcard. There was no real growth from his increased popularity. Instead, WWE Creative dragged out the breakup between he and Miz. When it finally happened at WrestleMania, during the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal one could not help but think it would have been much hotter had it come two months earlier. Now, Mizdow remains in the midcard, battling Miz over...well nothing, really. And with a logjam of talent vying for a top position in WWE, the likelihood that Mizdow makes it out of crowded midcard is slim. No matter how popular he is.

7. Cody Rhodes

Stardust will never, ever be anything but a midcard character. And therein lies the problem. On the April 6 episode of Raw, the bizarre, face-painted lunatic wrestled John Cena in a United States Championship match and never was it more apparent that the character belonged nowhere near a franchise player like Cena. While the man behind the face paint is an immensely talented individual, Stardust is a character that has zero shelf life past the midcard. And that is unfortunate for Cody Rhodes, who has routinely taken awful gimmick ideas and made the absolute most of them, yet still remains lost in the deep, dark abyss that is the midcard. The "Dashing" Cody Rhodes gimmick was straight out of the 1980s, but he made it work thanks to his devotion to the character. The deranged side of Rhodes made for television and stands the test of time as his finest work to date, a disfigured pretty boy who lost his grip on reality. Even without a gimmick, who proved himself a talented talker and fine in-ring worker, but it is his performance as Stardust that should be commended as he has continuously thrown himself into the role, despite a lack of sustained attention from WWE Creative. How someone who has proven as adaptable and willing to accept any gimmick put in front of him, only to turn it into gold shortly thereafter, has managed to become so entrenched in the midcard is beyond this writer. One thing is for certain, though, and that is that Rhodes will never have the opportunity to sniff the main event if he is expected to continue on with the Stardust character, wasting the prime years of his career on something so blatantly designed for a specific slot on the card.

6. Bad News Barrett

Bad News Barrett is a performer who has been repeatedly done wrong throughout his career. Debuting in 2010 as the leader of Nexus, a group of renegade young stars who had been exploited and treated like jokes while on NXT, he was the guy poised to breakout and become a huge star for the company. Then he wrestled John Cena in a Chairs match at TLC and had anything resembling momentum snuffed out. A 2011 rivalry with Randy Orton did not help any, especially after he lost the deciding match to the Viper at the TLC pay-per-view. In the years that followed, injuries haunted Barrett, as did poor booking. When he finally adopted the Bad News gimmick, he appeared to be getting over more than he had any point in his career. Then, Jack Swagger tossed him shoulder-first into the barricade and Barrett was forced back to the sidelines with a severe injury. Now back inside the squared circle, Barrett continues to be lost in the midcard, competing for a title he has already won on five other occasions and losing more than he wins. While it is clear that Barrett has everything needed to be a main event star in WWE, booking and an apparent lack of faith from WWE suggests that may not be in the cards.

5. Ryback

Ryback is one of the most puzzling cases on this list. At one point, he was an incredibly over babyface who appeared to be on his way to challenging John Cena for the role of top babyface in WWE. Then he was sacrificed in some of the most ridiculous and short-sighted booking decisions in company history. A failed heel turn, disappointing relationship with Paul Heyman and enhancement tag team with Curtis Axel threatened to kill Ryback's character dead. But he returned to great fanfare, battling the Authority and earning the admiration of the fans. Despite a brief push toward the top of the card, he again settled into the midcard, despite possessing the look of a bona fide ass kicker, constantly improving in-ring skills and incredibly popularity among fans. A fringe player in the Authority versus everyone else story, Ryback continues to share the ring with main event players without ever really being one himself. It is a disappointing position to find himself in but if history is any indication, the performer will make the best of his situation in hopes of one day receiving that much deserved shot at headlining pay-per-views as the company's marquee hero.

4. Luke Harper

Since breaking free from the Wyatt Family last fall, Luke Harper has developed into one of the most consistently great workers on the current roster. His matches with Dolph Ziggler were bright spots amid the booking doldrums of last fall, the ladder match between the two at December's TLC pay-per-view excelling as one of the truly great matches of the second-half of 2014. After the IC title feud with the Showoff came to a close, Harper was relegated to WWE's Main Event and Superstars programs. While he occasionally appeared in main event Six-Man Tag Team matches, he was an afterthought, never really gaining anything from the exposure that competing in the headline match of Raw or SmackDown should. And after repeatedly delivering against stars from up and down the roster, be it Justin Gabriel or John Cena himself, Harper continues to wallow in the midcard. At a time when WWE is bereft of legitimate main event heels, resorting to pushing Kane and Big Show to the dismay of everyone, it is incredibly disheartening to see someone as talented as Harper, who continuously delivers, wasted on such meaningless schlock.

3. Dean Ambrose

Last October, ahead of the Hell in a Cell match against Seth Rollins, Dean Ambrose was the hottest wrestler on the planet. Hotter than John Cena, hotter than Randy Orton, hotter than any other star Vince McMahon was promoting at the time. He was wild, crazy and unpredictable. Dubbed "the Lunatic Fringe" by commentator Michael Cole, he was the antihero the fans had eagerly anticipated since the dying days of the Attitude Era. And did WWE capitalize on it?
Instead, Ambrose fell into a feud with Bray Wyatt that left him looking like an over-the-top cartoon character, a Wile E. Coyote to Wyatt's Road Runner. following the exploding television fiasco. Since then, he has been wasted in the midcard, lost in the shuffle without anything interesting to do. He played hot potato with the intercontinental championship, wrestling some excellent matches with Daniel Bryan, Bad News Barrett and even Stardust in the lead up to WrestleMania XXXI. Yet, despite drawing one of the biggest pops of the night at the Showcase of the Immortals, he appears poised for more midcard mediocrity in the form of a rivalry with Luke Harper, another outstanding wrestler in a similar position. Dean Ambrose is a star who should be mixing it up with former Shield members Roman Reigns and Seth Rollins rather than making little impact in the midcard. The antithesis of the cookie cutter characters elsewhere on the card, and particularly in the main event scene, the Lunatic Fringe could be just the injection of adrenaline that WWE programming so desperately needs.

2. Cesaro

There are few wrestlers in the entire world more skilled in their line of work than Cesaro. That may seem like a loaded statement but one look at his in-ring work over the last two years suggests that the Swiss Superman may very well be the best worker in the industry. He has demonstrated the ability to have a Match of the Year candidate with fellow Ring of Honor alumni Sami Zayn or sports entertainer extraordinaire John Cena. Most of all, he does the little things well and remains perpetually over despite some truly pathetic booking on the part of WWE Creative. Cesaro's victory in the inaugural Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal at WrestleMania XXX should have been the start of some monstrous push for the international star. Instead, it was the height of his otherwise disappointing 2014, a year that saw him hurt significantly by his relationship with Paul Heyman rather than aided by it, and left to waste away as a celebrated enhancement act for Superstars on the receiving end of pushes. Now one-half of the WWE Tag Team champions alongside Tyson Kidd, it is obvious that Cesaro deserves more than he currently has. He is so much better than the competitors he shares the ring with. When he competes against the John Cenas and Randy Ortons of the world, he looks at home, easily capable of beating those two industry giants. Is he the most adept talker in the world? Of course not. But that does not change the fact that he is one of the handful of stars capable of working with every wrestler on the roster, regardless of their skills or abilities, and still pull from them a great wrestling match. Another in that same vein occupies the No. 1 spot on this list.

1. Dolph Ziggler

When historians revisit the so-called "PG Era" decades from now, they will repeatedly ask themselves how WWE was stupid enough to waste the talents of Dolph Ziggler. Arguably the most dynamic worker of his generation, the Showoff has the rare ability to make both himself and his opponents look good throughout the course of a match. He is incredibly giving between the ropes and, most importantly, the fans respect him for his hard work and dedication. A character that would traditionally be a heel, Ziggler earned the applause and appreciation of the WWE Universe for his unwavering determination to deliver the best performance and match possible. Has he been outspoken about his dissatisfaction about his place on the card? Absolutely. Has his honesty and openness gotten him in trouble over the last handful of years? Of course. But any punishment he has endured has never hampered his desire to be the best. Every time Ziggler has gotten a chance to run with the proverbial ball, he has excelled, most notably his brief flirtation with the main event this past winter when he became primary opposition of The Authority. But every time he succeeds, he is shunted back down the card, lost in the crowded midcard without any real direction or meaning. Ziggler may one day capture the heavyweight title of the world and succeed as a top star in WWE. But it will be impossible to forgive the number of years he has sacrificed in the midcard, with little or no upward movement, while in the prime of his athletic life.

In this post: 
Stardust
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Erik Beaston is a freelance pro wrestling writer who likes long walks in the park, dandelions and has not quite figured out that this introduction is not for Match.com. He resides in Parts Unknown, where he hosts weekly cookouts with Kane, The Ultimate Warrior, Papa Shango and The Boogeyman. Be jealous.