18 Ups & 15 Downs For WWE In 2023
One of WWE's best calendar years in a generation, with some bumps in the road.
There is no denying that WWE is hotter now than it has been in years, maybe even a decade or two. They regularly sell out arenas, put on solid-to-excellent PLEs, and have maximized mainstream stars in a way not seen in some time.
Numerous characters have personally connected with fans and become central components of the company’s plans. Storylines finally (for the most part) follow linear booking, something that for the longest time was a bug, not a feature of WWE. Fans are more rewarded for their investment in characters and the product than at any point in the recent past.
At the same time, problems continue to persist for the sports entertainment leader. They struggle to book the women’s title pictures consistently well. Their over-reliance on the melodrama of the Bloodline and the desire to replicate it has infected several factions on the roster. Roman Reigns is less visible than Brock Lesnar ever was as world champion and yet is celebrated like the modern-day Bruno Sammartino.
While Triple H deserves a ton of praise for his booking – solid if unspectacular at times – WWE also needs to be judged more critically, and not with the kid gloves it has been for years due to Vince McMahon’s embarrassing last few years at the helm.
This review largely focuses on broader themes than just individual moments. Otherwise, it could run on for days. In some cases, there’s good and bad to a character/act/angle, and that will be reflected in the lists. Overall, this was an “up” year for WWE, and the company and its fans should be really proud, but there always is room for improvement.
Let’s get to it…
DOWNS…
15. (Not) Taking Miz Seriously
Sorry Miz fans, but no matter how many times he reads off his Wikipedia page and lists his accomplishments, it’s utterly impossible to take him seriously.
Miz closed out the year with a babyface turn on the back of being bullied by Gunther, trying unsuccessfully to wrest the Intercontinental Championship away from the Ring General. Some fans heaped praise on Miz for rising to the occasion, while live audiences rallied behind him, sometimes with jingoistic fervor.
But let’s not forget that Miz spent the past several years being little more than a comedy character. One year ago, he was being terrorized by Dexter Lumis in several awful horror-adjacent segments. At WrestleMania 39, he jobbed on both nights to Pat McAfee and Snoop Dogg despite being a host of the event.
Telling fans he’s a two-time Grand Slam champion until he asphyxiates and half-heartedly trying in the ring is not going to suddenly make him a credible wrestler. And one really good performance against Gunther is not going to absolve everything. Pass.
14. Women’s Tag Scene
The WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship is a joke. The title basically has been an afterthought for years.
When Ronda Rousey and Shayna Baszler won the straps this year, it was thought that maybe the two former UFC fighters could lend credibility to the title. Instead, their reign lasted a month and became a flashpoint in Rousey and Baszler’s relationship, the second time this year the titles were a backdrop to double-cross (see Trish Stratus and Becky Lynch).
Merging the titles with the NXT women’s tag titles didn’t spark anything. They’ve been defended once in NXT since then. Makeshift teams have continued to pop up as title challengers throughout the year, with one of the only permanent teams – Kayden Carter & Katana Chance – finally getting a run at the title this month.
Multiple champs have gotten injured, leading former tag champs Alba Fyre and Isla Dawn to suggest the titles are cursed, which has become something of a “meta” joke for WWE.
And despite Chelsea Green doing bang-up character work, it’s worth noting that she and her partners rarely defended the titles during the past five-plus months, which is pretty bad when you consider the titles can be defended on any of the three brands.
13. Rhea’s Disappointing Reign
Rhea Ripley has become an incredible character and face of the women’s division on Raw in 2023. She’s the unnamed – yet unquestioned – leader of the Judgment Day. Her title match at WrestleMania 39 with Charlotte Flair was absolutely tremendous.
And yet, her eight-month title reign has to be defined as nothing short of a disappointment. Since winning the title, Ripley has defeated the likes of Zelina Vega, Natalya (twice), Raquel Rodriguez (twice), and Zoey Stark.
But none of those feuds really qualify as good rivalries. Nattie was basically cannon fodder. Vega was a huge sentimental favorite because Backlash took place in Puerto Rico, but she wasn’t a serious threat. Even the feud with Rodriguez should have felt much bigger than it was, but instead was a dud.
Rhea is undeniably a huge star and gives the Women’s World Championship a lift in stature, but someone who has been such a central figure on Raw should have more memorable title matches and moments than she has had.
It’s important to separate Ripley’s solid overall year from her disappointing title reign, which is probably the one thing dragging her down from having one of the best years in the company.
12. Tropes Continue
For all the praise Triple H has received for his booking this year, it can’t be ignored that the man who sat under Vince McMahon’s learning tree for so many years continues to rely on many of the same bad booking tropes his father-in-law deployed regularly.
Triple H gets credit – maybe too much – for simply booking logical angles with linear storytelling, but he has not been able to shake off the bad habits that define WWE programming: show-opening promo trains that lead to the main event being booked, impromptu matches made during the course of the show, embarrassingly bad dialogue no human would ever utter, DQ and count-out finishes after 15-minute snore-fests, and several others.
There were episodes of Raw this year where literally half the show’s matches were booked during the broadcast. What would have filled the three hours if not for the in-show confrontations?
Bad booking crutches like these show that despite how competent Triple H has been overall, WWE booking is almost a “too big to fail” mechanism, so entrenched in its ways that no one booker can fully unwind the tropes.
11. Nikki Cross
Here’s a stat that might surprise: The talented Nikki Cross has had only 10 televised matches this year (not counting Main Event), with half of them coming before WrestleMania 39.
This is surprising when you realize that Cross has been on WWE programming pretty regularly throughout the year. However, her appearances have been in service of a variety of attempts to portray her as “unhinged” or “crazy.” Cross’ last two matches this year have seen her in an almost-catatonic state, a gimmick played for “laughs” at several points in non-wrestling appearances.
More recently, Cross has been seen stalking Becky Lynch backstage, as if that is the missing component of how to make her a compelling character. Remember that Nikki was stalking Candice LeRae earlier as well, and everyone saw how well that storyline turned out for Cross.
10. NXT Call-Ups
NXT Women’s Champion Indi Hartwell. NXT Women’s Tag Team Champions Alba Fyre and Isla Dawn. Cameron Grimes. Odyssey Jones.
Sure, WWE can tout several success stories about their call-ups from developmental this year, such as Dragon Lee, JD McDonagh, Zoey Stark and the Creed Brothers. But this spring’s WWE draft was a disaster for several NXT superstars who went from popular acts in Florida to little more than warm bodies, or altogether invisible on the main roster.
For all the talk about Triple H knowing exactly what to do with developmental wrestlers because he used to helm NXT, it was astonishing to see how many drafted superstars languished for months after being promoted. You can’t tout a booker’s “brilliance” without holding them accountable for disappointments.
Does this mean that the entire call-up system is broken and these wrestlers are ruined? Of course not. But this wasn’t a one-off problem in 2023, and WWE should be called to task for this.
9. Damage CTRL’s Wasted Year
Damage CTRL should have been a dominant stable in the women’s division throughout the entire year, but as the group reached its first anniversary at SummerSlam, it was readily apparent that the trio was nothing short of a massive disappointment.
Bayley, Iyo Sky and Dakota Kai should have been celebrated heels that wreaked havoc on the roster as the only full-time women’s stable, but they were regularly routed by loose groupings of other women, rarely looking like the force fans envisioned when they debuted.
It wasn’t until Crown Jewel that the group’s fortunes finally improved, but for more than 10 months of the year, Damage CTRL was a massive letdown, and a late resurgence shouldn’t absolve all of the failings.
8. Create-A-Title
Seth Rollins has put in a yeoman’s work in trying to elevate the World Heavyweight Championship into a legit, coveted world title. However, constantly talking about and defending the strap in numerous 3.5-star matches couldn’t on their own overcome the stigma that has persisted around the title.
When Triple H unveiled the new world championship this spring, it merely shone a brighter spotlight on the company’s major failure at WrestleMania 39 to take the unified world title (or at least separate the two titles) off Roman Reigns, who became the ultimate part-time champ afterwards.
Instead, WWE asked fans to accept this new title as an equivalent while acknowledging that it was necessary because Roman wouldn’t be around much to defend the only other world title. It was an embarrassing self-own that the company just pushed through and tried by force of will to make fans accept as a net positive.
To be fair, Sami Zayn’s quest to become a world champion and CM Punk returning and hinting at wanting Rollins’ title have done more in the past two months to elevate the World Heavyweight Championship than anything else prior. But this was an awful debut for something intended to be a major title for the biggest wrestling company in the world, and it should not be forgiven or forgotten.
7. Those Crowds
For the longest time this year, WWE programming has been dominated by a strange juxtaposition: arenas full of fans, piled high to the rafters, sitting silently throughout large portions of the show, only coming to life for entrances, signature spots and finishes to matches.
The crowds seemingly aren’t wrestling fans – not in the traditional sense of fans who appreciate a good technical or high-flying match and respond accordingly when something good is happening right in front of them. Rather, they’re there to sing along to Seth Rollins’ theme, yell “Yeah!” and “Yeet!” and come up for finishing sequences after sitting on their hands for the first 12 minutes of a 15-minute TV match.
This has nothing to do with WWE piping in boos for Dominik Mysterio – sweetening the crowd noise is just a fact of life, and the younger Mysterio will get his praise later for his work.
Fans in recent months have come to life better than they were throughout the first half of the year, but there still are shows where matches and segments play out to a silence that seems impossible in these full arenas. It seems incomprehensible that fans would pay good money to sit in the upper deck of these facilities and act like they’re in church, but it’s been the rule, not the exception for much of the year.