18 Ups & 15 Downs For WWE In 2023

6. Feuding Factions

Imperium GUNTHER
WWE

Never let it be said that WWE didn’t recognize a good thing and tried to replicate it elsewhere. If anything, 2023 showed that WWE is guilty of trying to apply what was successful in one area everywhere else.

The Bloodline’s bickering and implosion powered WWE through the first half of the year, with everything involving Sami Zayn and the Usos as they rebelled against Roman Reigns dominating programming through SummerSlam and captivating fans.

Naturally, WWE saw this success and decided that if this melodrama and internal bickering worked for a faction like the Bloodline, it has to work for every other faction. This gave way to nearly every other stable in the company – Judgment Day, Damage CTRL, Imperium, LWO and the Brawling Brutes – all dealing with differing levels of dissension and tension throughout the year.

In some cases, the instability makes perfect sense for the faction’s story arc (see Damage CTRL and LWO), but in others like Imperium, it just feels like the conflict has been riveted onto the group for the sake of it. This then dilutes the impact of group turmoil – why should fans react for one group blowing up if every other group is facing the same problems?

Just lazy, repetitive booking shortcuts that will inevitably play out to diminishing returns.


5. Waste Of Space

Austin Theory
WWE.com

There is a plethora of arguments one could make to illustrate how big of a waste Austin Theory has been, but one fact might stick out more than the others:

Theory held the United States Championship for more than seven months this year.

Got that? Theory was a secondary champ for the entire first half of the year, including four months on SmackDown at a time when Roman Reigns was all but invisible, making Austin the only men’s singles champion on the blue brand week in and week out.

His WrestleMania 39 win over John Cena should have been a career-defining moment, and instead it shone a spotlight on how inadequate he was, gaining absolutely nothing from it and coming out of Mania with even less momentum.

It wasn’t until he lost the title and partnered with the more talented and entertaining Grayson Waller that Theory became somewhat bearable, which in incongruous with how WWE presented him upon his call-up in 2021.


4. A Hall-Of-Fame Bad Feud

Trish Stratus Becky Lynch
WWE.com

When fans reflect on the Becky Lynch/Trish Stratus feud, they will inevitably harken back to the excellent steel cage match that ended their rivalry, an over-delivery in every way.

But nearly everything that preceded that excellent match was trash, an awful five-month feud that dragged on and stunk up numerous segments on Raw. “Thank you Trish” didn’t quite resonate as a heel mantra the way fans thought it should, and the feud suffered throughout the summer with terrible patter from the Hall-of-Famer.

The only redeeming part of the program – other than the cage match – was giving Zoey Stark a platform to establish herself on the main roster opposing Lynch a few times. But that doesn’t excuse a disappointing and dismal feud that ate up nearly half the calendar year.

Lynch would recover by getting back to basics and challenging up-and-coming wrestlers, while Stratus disappeared and Stark turned face, but that doesn’t excuse the dire program.


3. ‘Bottom Of The 3rd Inning’

Paul Heyman Solo Sikoa
WWE.com

Paul Heyman’s infamous post-SummerSlam quote describing where the Bloodline story was received immediate mockery, and rightly so.

While the Bloodline saga captivated fans for the first few months of 2023, it completely fell apart in the latter half of the year, with Roman Reigns all but disappearing, Jimmy Uso inexplicably turning heel and the once-dominant faction limping into December with Heyman, Solo Sikoa and Uso as the remnants of the group.

It’s obvious that with Reigns’ part-time schedule and Jey Uso leaving the group, the Bloodline was going to face lean times, but Heyman’s analogy becomes laughable when you realize that the middle innings of this game involves basically putting the group in a deep freeze as a secondary act, rather than the ever-present, show-defining faction.

Sure, things will ramp back up with the Royal Rumble and WrestleMania 40 on the horizon, but the Bloodline story was exposed as not having enough juice to remain on the front burner, and hardly was in the “bottom of the third inning.”


2. Roman’s Invisible Title Reign

roman reigns shocked
WWE

Roman Reigns is being celebrated regularly as the greatest champion of the modern era, but he also will close out 2023 making the fewest televised title defenses in the modern era.

The Tribal Chief has put his title up just five times this year, and only twice since WrestleMania 39. That’s an embarrassingly bad statistic considering that WWE merged both its world titles in 2022 and put them on Roman so he could vanish with them.

Then, in an epic self-own, they created a new world title, with Triple H admitting that Reigns never defending the two world titles was the reason they established the World Heavyweight Championship. That’s an astonishing moment, for the company to tell their fans that they know Roman being absent is a problem, but the only possible solution is to create a new title.

Roman’s absence is worse than at almost any point in Brock Lesnar’s runs with the two world titles. It doesn’t help that Reigns’ title matches have become overly melodramatic, paint-by-numbers schemes where you can see the Bloodline interference coming a mile away: Jimmy Uso at Elimination Chamber, Solo Sikoa at WrestleMania, and Uso at SummerSlam and Crown Jewel.

This might entertain a good segment of the fanbase, but Roman’s 1,200-day reign has been operating on smoke and mirrors for some time now, and at this point, they’re just padding out the length of the title run.


1. Story Unfinished

Cody Rhodes rubber chicken
WWE

WrestleMania 39 was headed toward all-time great status heading into the main event of night two, with tremendous matches, perfect outcomes and excellent storytelling.

And then the wheels fell off in the last five minutes.

Bloodline interference (where have fans heard that one before?) muddied everything, but Sami Zayn & Kevin Owens seemed to neutralize the Usos, paving the way for Cody Rhodes to finish the story and vanquish Roman Reigns. But Solo Sikoa’s poorly timed attack put the American Nightmare down, leaving fans with the lasting image of Cody in the ring with a rubber chicken being thrown at him.

The finish was inexcusably bad, and any justifications Triple H and others made afterwards rang hollow. Rhodes was immediately shunted into a program with Brock Lesnar, while Roman pursued tag gold instead. And then WWE unveiled a new World Heavyweight Championship – because Reigns never defended his title(s).

Meanwhile, Rhodes was forced to keep himself and his various side programs over by sheer willpower. Throughout the spring and summer, it was impossible to not envision that Cody’s programs would have been better if he was holding the Undisputed WWE Universal Championship.

Even if WWE wanted to continue Roman’s epic title reign, they could have split the two titles off and had Cody win the WWE Championship, which was the title he coveted from the beginning anyway.

Instead, WWE went the worst route, tanking a wave of good vibes at Mania, making Cody look like a goof, and keeping a soon-to-be invisible champion strapped up, all in the name of continuing the story.


UPS…

18. Gable The Magician

Chad Gable Dominik Mysterio
WWE.com

If WWE isn’t going to reward Chad Gable for his incredible 2023 by having him end Gunther’s historic Intercontinental Championship reign, they should create a new title for him to defend weekly.

Gable long has been a favorite of many fans, despite his piss-poor booking under Vince McMahon (Shorty G, anyone?) and inconsistent pushes. But at some point, WWE started treating Master Gable as a serious threat, first in the tag team scene alongside Otis, and then in the singles ranks by pushing Gunther to the limit.

Along the way, Gable continued to show his versatility by delivering genuinely funny segments. He manages to make magic on Raw every week, maximizing his camera time, whether it’s a five-minute match or a 90-second backstage vignette. He’s proven to be an invaluable member of the roster, and for the first time, it seems like WWE brass has recognized this reality and is treating him better.

Gable deserves acknowledgement for his work this year, and hopefully he will be rewarded with some singles gold in the new year.


17. Viking Rules

Viking Raiders alpha Academy
WWE.com

Hats – well, Viking helmets – off to the geniuses who figured out how to disguise a standard WWE plunder brawl involving the Viking Raiders by just attaching a Viking ship bow to the ring, which was adorned with shields, and giving the match a different name.

The Viking Rules match only made its way to television twice this year, but both instances absolutely ruled, with the Raiders defeating Alpha Academy in July, and then Ivar toppling Kofi Kingston in October. They were tremendous fun, with everyone going all-out to deliver for the fans and produce something memorable beyond the typical hardcore-lite matches WWE traffics in regularly.

By over-delivering on both Viking Rules matches, it’s now become lore for fans in the know, something that when booked becomes appointment viewing. The recent feud between Ivar and Bronson Reed has lent itself to the possibility of a blowoff Viking Rules match, which would instantly become a must-see affair.

While not on the level of the Iron Survivor match, kudos to WWE for making this a fun match type for fans to anticipate.


16. Creed Brothers On The Ascent

Creed Brothers WWE
WWE.com

The WWE roster is full of former NXT superstars whose debuts were grossly mishandled, cautionary tales that a company with its own developmental brand can’t adequately prepare and then book their up-and-coming talent.

But for every few failures, there are some true gems, and one of the biggest has to be the Creed Brothers, who arrived on the scene two months ago and immediately caught on with fans due to their incredible athleticism. Julius and Brutus came up short in their first crack at the Undisputed WWE Tag Team Championship this month, but the brothers have established themselves as serious players in the tag division, with the potential to break out as singles stars in the future.

The Creeds and Dragon Lee brought up the batting average on NXT call-ups for the year, but the brothers deserve special recognition as products of the WWE Performance Center, perhaps an indication that the company could be figuring out how to produce successful superstars.


15. Logan Paul Maximizes Moments

WWE Crown Jewel 2023 Logan Paul
WWE.com

For a celebrity-turned-wrestler who had only five matches this year, Logan Paul probably had the best 2023 possible.

The social media maverick had eye-popping appearances in the Royal Rumble and Money in the Bank matches, battled Seth Rollins at WrestleMania 39, and won the United States Championship at Crown Jewel by defeating Rey Mysterio. But even more than the successes of his matches, Paul was a heat magnet in all his appearances on WWE programming, making him one of the best heels on the roster. Tormenting ring announcer Samantha Irvin during his feud with her fiancé Ricochet was a particularly inspired moment.

For as well as Logan has taken to being a wrestling heel, he still manages to be authentic and sound like himself – meaning he doesn’t sound like a product of the WWE system, and thus stands out even more. WWE deserves credit for not trying to train that natural behavior out of him, which has been their M.O. forever.

In some ways, it’s a shame Paul is a part-timer, because he’s been solid in every appearance, but there’s also the risk of wearing out his welcome and becoming less special.


In this post: 
WWE
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.