18 Ups & 15 Downs For WWE In 2023

14. Dirty Dom Grows Into Role

Dominik Mysterio Rhea Ripley
WWE.com

When talking about most improved wrestlers for 2023, it’s impossible to ignore the growth of Dominik Mysterio this year.

That’s not to suggest he’s become a savant in the ring, but both WWE and Dirty Dom have cracked the code on how to best utilize him given his limited in-ring skills. Rather than trying to convince fans that he’s on par with Hall-of-Fame father Rey Mysterio, WWE has presented Dominik as a spoiled, delusional, hated heel who is everyone’s favorite human punching bag.

Fans mercilessly boo the younger Mysterio the moment he pulls a microphone to his mouth (with some help from a turned-down mic and sweetened crowd noise) and revels in seeing him get his a** handed to him in the ring. His relationship with Rhea Ripley continues to enrage crowds, with Mami fawning over her Dom-Dom and bailing him out when he gets in over his head.

Mysterio’s reigns with the NXT North American Championship illustrates this point, as WWE leaned into the hatred by turning Dominik into a modern-day Honky Tonk Man, an undeserving champion who holds onto his title through outside help and dumb luck.

Don’t expect Mysterio to be a main-event player once Judgment Day runs its course, but kudos to Dom and WWE for maximizing his potential at this stage in his career.


13. Revamped Damage CTRL

Damage CTRL WWE
WWE.com

For all the criticism rightly heaped on Damage CTRL for its failures as a group this year, there needs to be an acknowledgement of the successes of the last two months.

The trio was floundering when Kairi Sane made her triumphant return to WWE at Crown Jewel, helping Iyo Sky retain her WWE Women’s Championship. The addition of Sane immediately jolted the stale group, which then received another shot in the arm when Asuka joined Damage CTRL, making it a powerful quintet that immediately became the focal point of the women’s division.

The change in dynamics also presented a challenge for group founder Bayley, who now finds herself on the outskirts of the faction. The writing is on the wall for everyone – except Bayley – can see: The newly constituted Damage CTRL no longer needs the Role Model, and they’ll soon rid themselves of her. When that happens, it should make for a fantastic story.

These developments don’t excuse the wasted year for the group, but it does close out 2023 strongly and sets the table for a great story leading into next year.


12. Bad Bunny

Bad Bunny Crossbody Backlash 2023
WWE.com

What can you say about the biggest recording artist in the world taking part in one of the biggest matches on a B-show PLE, singlehandedly delivering one of the most memorable moments of the show – and the year?

Backlash always has been a B-show for WWE, and the 2023 edition wasn’t expected to be much more… except that was booked for Puerto Rico, which Bad Bunny calls home. Bunny inserted himself in the Rey Mysterio/Dominik Mysterio feud, which in essence grew into an LWO/Judgment Day feud.

This gave way to former friends and tag partners Damian Priest and Bunny squaring off at Backlash, with two Puerto Ricans tearing the house down. Bunny gave fans perhaps the greatest entrance of the year, with thousands of fans erupting for him. He could have just turned into a safe, narrow performance against Priest and it would have been deemed a huge success, but Bad Bunny went all-in and produced a tremendous match that in part catapulted Damian into a major star, shone a spotlight on the LWO, and electrified the entire event.

Bunny didn’t need to do anything else for 2023 to merit a spot on this list. He’s proven his value to the company as a celebrity who is willing to throw himself into his role and deliver for WWE and the fans.


11. LWO Fractures

LWO Carlito Rey Mysterio Santos Escobar
WWE.com

As a faction, the LWO has been a perfectly fine mid-card act. It’s not a main event stable like the Bloodline, and it doesn’t dominate its brand’s storylines like the Judgment Day.

But the Latino World Order provided a home for the former Legado Del Fantasma while giving them a rub from Hall-of-Famer Rey Mysterio. The group’s high point came during Backlash when Savio Vega and Carlito returned to WWE to side with the LWO and help Bad Bunny overcome Damian Priest and the Judgment Day.

Things finally bubbled over this fall when Santos Escobar attacked Mysterio and left the group over Rey’s embrace of Carlito. Escobar as a jealous, egotistical superstar works well, and a program with Rey when he returns could further elevate the lucha libre superstar.

The fracturing also has opened the door for Dragon Lee to associate with the LWO, giving the new SmackDown star a purpose out of the gate. He’s already received Rey’s endorsement, which carries a lot of weight, and he adds some gravitas to the LWO while Mysterio and Carlito convalesce.


10. Yeah!

Roman Reigns LA Knight
WWE.com

Not even the most optimistic LA Knight fans could have predicted in January that the former Max Dupri would main event a PLE for the Undisputed WWE Universal Championship. After all, his first big feud in 2023 culminated in the godawful Mt. Dew Pitch Black match at the Royal Rumble against Bray Wyatt.

But Knight’s popularity continued to rise throughout the year, despite being left off numerous PLE cards, including WrestleMania 39. He fell short in the Money in the Bank ladder match, but he won the Slim Jim battle royal at SummerSlam, which in reality was meaningless but at the same time felt like a nod to fans that more was in store for the brash superstar.

An endorsement from John Cena proved to further cement the babyface Knight as a top-level star on SmackDown, and he found himself at Crown Jewel challenging Roman Reigns for the title. Like everyone else, LA came up short, but it’s been an incredible journey for the guy who was running a male model agency under a different character name a year earlier.

While it’s unlikely fans will see Knight with a world title around his waist anytime soon, his rising popularity and delivery in the elevated role has hopefully cemented him as a top contributor to WWE in 2024 and beyond.


9. Booking Smart Babyfaces

WWE Survivor Series WarGames 2023 Jey Uso Sami Zayn Randy Orton Seth Rollins Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

During Vince McMahon’s waning years in charge of WWE’s daily operations, the company was beset with countless problems that made the product almost unwatchable at times.

One of those issues was the booking of its babyfaces, as the heroes and heroines were often cast as gullible, dimwitted dopes who fell for heels’ tricks and constantly found themselves overmatched and outnumbered. They celebrated count-out wins and smirked about escaping matches with surprise roll-up wins. To put it bluntly, Vince is a villain himself and had no clue how to properly book his own good guys because he’s not one himself.

Surprisingly, it took one of WWE’s biggest heels during the Attitude and Ruthless Aggression Eras to course-correct that problem, with Triple H finally booking the babyfaces to be smarter. They speak like real people, anticipate villainy from their foes, and they back each other up against heel stables. They have morals and good character and do things for the right reason.

Throw in more linear storytelling and logical booking, and everything falls into place better. It’s a lot easier to associate and empathize with a babyface when you can relate to them, and that’s what happened in 2023. It’s not some earth-shattering move, but it produced such a shift in how fans viewed the product that it deserves high praise here.


8. Jey Escapes The Bloodline

Jey Uso
WWE.com

It’s not unheard of for a longtime tag team wrestler to break out as a singles star. Bret Hart, Shawn Michaels, Booker T and Nikki Bella spring to mind. But for a twin to be recognized as a successful solo act? Bella might have been the most notable example… until this year.

The Usos are arguably one of the most successful tag teams in WWE history, setting the longevity record for a tag title reign and main-eventing the first night of WrestleMania 39 (more on that later). But it was Jey Uso’s journey as a tortured soul that captivated fans who wanted to see him finally break free of Roman Reigns’ spell, which had bewitched him for years.

But it was Jimmy Uso who broke free first, only to eventually run back to the safety of the Bloodline after a couple months. When Jey finally escaped the gaslighting Reigns and made his way to Raw, he began to blossom even more as a solo star, standing on his own and not as Jimmy’s twin or Roman’s cousin.

Sure, Uso has been helped by his association with Cody Rhodes and friendship with Sami Zayn, but his journey on Raw has been his own and not with the crutch of the Bloodline, even as rivals. It’s safe to say at this point that Jey is going to be just fine as a singles act going forward.


7. Gunther Makes History

Drew McIntyre gunther sheamus
WWE

The Honky Tonk Man being the longest-reigning Intercontinental Championship has been a long-running gag in WWE, the irony of what is often classified as a worker’s title record held by a guy who retained the belt through underhanded means.

That 453-day reign fell by the wayside this year when Gunther blew right past it en route to topping 560 days by year’s end. The Ring General reached this milestone as a throwback of sorts, a wrestling champion who has held onto his title through sheer dominance, force and in-ring acumen. He’s had his share of difficult title defenses, but he’s always managed to persevere, often on his own merit.

In doing so, Gunther has defied the odds in modern-day WWE: a no-frills wrestler who has become one of the most popular acts in the company by going out and wrestling. True, his promos and “entertainment” stature has increased during the past year – his promos against Chad Gable and the Miz showed a range not previously detected in his NXT work. But for the Ring General, it’s his work between the ropes that has defined him.

The odds of Gunther making it through 2024 with the IC title still in his grasp are extremely slim, but losing the title should be just the next phase of an extremely successful WWE career, not the end of it.


6. Cody Makes Chicken Salad

Cody Rhodes Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

As previously established, Cody Rhodes should have finished the story at WrestleMania 39, either by beating Roman Reigns for both world titles or splitting off the WWE Championship to allow the Tribal Chief to continue ruling over SmackDown.

The end result of Rhodes failing at Mania could have been a burying of the character and a lack of direction. And while there was a degree of lack of focus, Cody managed to turn a piss-poor booking decision into a successful 2023.

Right out of the chute, he was thrust into a heated rivalry with Brock Lesnar that would have worked perfectly had Cody been the champ, but he nonetheless produced a well-received feud when it was finished at SummerSlam. His longstanding feud with the Judgment Day has been both a high point and a low point as it’s dragged on in multiple permutations throughout the summer and fall with different partners joining him in the battle. Rhodes closed out 2023 ensconced in a rivalry with Shinsuke Nakamura that has played to mixed results.

So why does Cody rate so highly on this list? Quite simply, the American Nightmare has managed to stay insanely popular with fans while keeping himself in the conversation for another go at Reigns’ title at WrestleMania 40. Fans still believe in him, and they’ve bought nearly everything he’s sold during the past year. After the disappointment of Mania this spring, that’s a true accomplishment that needs to be singled out and celebrated.


5. Hell Freezes Over

WWE Survivor Series 2023 CM Punk
WWE.com

The full impact of CM Punk’s improbable return to WWE nearly a decade after walking out of the company won’t be fully known until it’s proven that he plays ball and is a true asset to the promotion rather than just the splashiest of signings.

But for now, it can’t be understated how seismic Punk’s return at Survivor Series was across the wrestling landscape. He quite literally broke the internet and has sparked countless conversations about future matchups, how long he’ll last with WWE, whether other AEW wrestlers will view this as a beacon to jump ship when their contracts expire, and so on.

Punk has the potential to be a true game-changer for WWE, provided he’s willing to be that guy and work within the system. It’s a different system than when he left in January 2014, but it still is sports entertainment, so time will truly tell.


In this post: 
WWE
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.