18 Ups & 15 Downs For WWE In 2023
4. Drew’s Slow Burn
Much has been written in the Raw Ups and Downs columns about Drew McIntyre’s multi-layered, slow-burn heel turn that took place this fall, and all of it is well-deserved praise.
McIntyre has been one of the most well-developed, multifaceted characters WWE has written in years. Rather than simply turning heel because he’s frustrated with his position in the company or just taking shortcuts because he keeps coming up short, the Scottish Warrior has justified his actions the entire way, using reasoning rooted in reality, making him a more believable character.
The well-written arc hasn’t precluded fans from turning on McIntyre, but it’s made them more invested in him, so they’re booing from a position of frustration in him giving in to heelish tendencies rather than jeering because he’s billed as a bad guy.
It remains to be seen where this is going long-term for Drew, whose contract is up in the coming months, but for now, this has been a really enjoyable ride.
3. Judgment Day Runs Raw
A year ago, the thought of the Judgment Day being a dominant faction that’s taken seriously as a main-event threat would be laughable.
After all, the purple-clad group had just survived a disastrous turn with Edge creating and helming the group, then becoming a near-comedy stable as they recruited Dominik Mysterio to join their ranks.
Then, it all clicked.
Rhea Ripley became a central, dominant component of the women’s division, winning the title at WrestleMania in a celebrated match against Charlotte Flair. Dominik Mysterio matured and evolved, leaning into the trolling nature of his character. Damian Priest developed into a potential main-event talent, winning the Money in the Bank briefcase and having a tremendous featured match versus Bad Bunny at Backlash. And Finn Balor was just as solid as ever holding everything together.
At one point, Judgment Day held the Undisputed WWE Tag Team Championship, the Women’s World Championship and the NXT North American Championship, with Priest also holding the MITB briefcase. That was a haul that rivaled the Bloodline in terms of gold, and it lent an air of credibility to the group.
While there might not be a long-term men’s world champion in the group, the Judgment Day deserves credit for an extremely successful year that in turn made WWE programming better.
2. Sami’s Journey
Zayn’s voyage saw him go from a gaslit lackey, desperate to be accepted, to a conflicted and pressured man who became a full-blown rebel. It was a tremendous piece of storytelling that breathed new life into the Bloodline as an entity and as a storyline, fueling months of incredible programming. The Trial of Sami Zayn alone will go down as one of the best segments on television this year.
That says nothing about Sami finally pushed to his breaking point by Roman Reigns, choosing his battered best friend Kevin Owens and pasting the Tribal Chief with a steel chair at the Royal Rumble. Then there was his hometown hero’s performance at Elimination Chamber, trying to unseat Reigns. And finally, it was KO and Sami teaming up to topple the Usos and pry the tag titles off them to close out the first night of WrestleMania 39.
Even what came after Mania – Zayn and Owens defending the titles and contending with a repentant Jey Uso, and Sami coming to terms with being a solo act again to close out the year – was a great piece of business and showed the growth that Sami’s character had undergone throughout this process.
The only way Zayn’s 2023 could have gone better was if he had captured the world title.
1. WrestleMania 39 – Night One
For one night, WWE felt like the perfect promotion, finally unshackled from Vince McMahon’s death grip and allowed to act like it was the biggest wrestling company in the world with the best talent available.
WrestleMania 39 was ambitious as hell with its two-night card and numerous angles all peaking at the right moment. The problem WWE had always faced in these situations was landing the plane – they invariably have struggled to deliver satisfying conclusions to even some of their better storylines.
When everything started falling into place on night one, it gave fans hope that this new era under Triple H would be the realization of everything WWE could – and should – be. Seth Rollins defeated Logan Paul in an excellent bout that exceeded expectations. Rey Mysterio finally put a fatherly beating on Dominik Mysterio in a cathartic match. And Charlotte Flair and Rhea Ripley tore the house down with their title match.
And finally, there was the previously mentioned tag title match between Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens and the Usos, which perfectly capped Sami’s story and closed the book on one major Bloodline story. Even some of the supporting matches were fun and inoffensive (save for the John Cena/Austin Theory match).
For that one night, everything felt right with WWE, and it delivered a near-perfect show. Taken on its own, that was the high point of the year for the company, and it’s very deserving of the top spot.