19 Things We Learned From Nancy Benoit's Sister On Talk Is Jericho
The most intense wrestling podcast ever recorded.
On the nine year anniversary of the Chris Benoit double murder-suicide, Chris Jericho sat down with Sandra Toffoloni, the sister of the late Nancy Benoit, to discuss the tragedy that tore apart her family and left the wrestling world in a state of shock.
Jericho opens in a somber tone, confessing that Sandra reached out to him following Bill Apter's appearance on his show in which the longtime wrestling journalist laid out his personal conspiracy theory that the Benoit family was the victim of a mob-style hit staged to look like it had been committed by Chris.
She was looking to clear up a lot of misinformation that was floating around about the horrific events that took place back in 2007, in what is her first real interview since the incident occurred.
Throughout the episode Toffoloni carried herself with class and handled the incredibly difficult subject with an inspiring amount of grace and composure, and it made for an enthralling listen. She's very open and honest about what took place and covered a lot of ground, from her initial - and bizarre - meeting with Chris, to how much he loved his family and the volatile deterioration of their relationship.
19. Her First Time Meeting Chris
In what has to be considered a classic pro wrestling story, Sandra’s first meeting with Chris took place backstage at the 1996 Great American Bash. It was in the midst of Chris’s feud with Nancy’s husband Kevin Sullivan, which was one of the most heated in wrestling history.
The two had a memorable brawl where they fought all over the arena, and Sandra asserts that the bout was more shoot than work. She says that after the cameras went off Ric Flair came and signaled for her and Kevin’s daughter to come backstage where the two men were still going at it and had to be separated by WCW personnel.
Sandra said everyone was leaving and Chris told her that her sister wanted her to come with him, and she responded that she was leaving with Kevin because he’s her brother-in-law. Chris assured her that wasn’t what Nancy wanted and called her so Nancy could confirm to Sandra that she needed to leave with Chris and she would explain later, saying “I want you to leave with Chris right now. Get out of there.”
18. First Impressions Of Benoit
Sandra says that Kevin Sullivan essentially wrote and produced his own divorce, and adds that it wasn't intentional for Nancy and Chris to end up together, but when they did they fell madly in love and nothing else mattered to them other than the need to be with each other and to start a family.
Jericho asks what her first impressions of him were. She says he was very quiet, a contrast to her loud Irish-Italian family. Her brand of sarcasm didn't translate well to him at first, but after they got to know each other he found her quite funny.
Chris was kind and considerate, quiet and focused; a driven guy but caring who loved her sister and wanted to be around her family. She calls him a stark contrast from Nancy's past relationships who her family had not been close to, saying they had an open door policy in regards to spending time together.
17. Noticing A Change
Jericho mentions that for about the last year and a half of Chris's life he began noticing a change in his friend. He recalls how many of his colleagues referred to Benoit as "Houdini" due to his tendency to disappear, and he also called him "The Loch Ness Monster" because he would surface and reach out, but if you missed contact you wouldn't hear from him for a while. He wants to know if Sandra noticed an increase in the behavior as well.
She says that she definitely did, saying that she'd get a random text from him but would be unable to reach him in return, and Nancy would just brush it off as Chris being Chris.
However, the main difference she witnessed was a sense of paranoia for his family and a feeling that they weren't safe. Benoit would constantly be checking the alarm at his home, drive different routes to his gym, switch cars frequently, etc.
Chris had previously been fairly laid back about that kind of thing so when it started happening it stood out to her.
16. Her Relationship With David & Megan Benoit
The two discuss how Chris had a hard time dealing with the increased celebrity that came with his rising profile within the wrestling world, but Sandra says despite his struggles with that aspect he always treated fans with kindness and respect.
Jericho wonders if she had a relationship with Benoit's children from his first wife, and she replies that she was always close with both David and Megan, treating them the same as she did her nephew, Daniel.
Nancy hated the word "step" when it came to parenting and always wanted Chris's other children to feel welcome. Sandra was close to David in particular because he was of the age where the two of them could have fun together.
Chris says that from what he could tell, both the Benoits were great parents, and Sandra agrees adding that whenever Chris was home he wanted to spend time with his son, and Nancy lived and breathed for Daniel.
15. Introducing Chris To New Music
Sandra says that the two of them bonded through their love of music, and in “the old days when CD burning was a thing” he was constantly asking her to make him playlists, whether it be for traveling the roads or working out.
Jericho wants to know what kind of music she would put on these CDs, and she said that it was a lot of hard rock such as Pantera, Metallica and the Foo Fighters. She also exclaimed that this was around the time that Eminem’s Marshall Mathers LP had been released and Benoit was really into that as well.
Somehow my brain refuses to accept the thought of Chris Benoit jamming out to Eminem, but that somewhat odd thought is suddenly interrupted when I recall that that particular album featured the song “Kim” in which Eminem murders his girlfriend in a fit of rage and the visual takes on an eerie tone.
Sandra was also the first person to introduce Chris to Motorhead and said they were together in the car the first time he ever heard the band’s seminal classic “Ace of Spades".
Benoit was so blown away that he had her put the song on repeat, and after that he became a big fan, something she was reminded of with the recent passing of frontman and bassist Lemmy Kilmister.
14. Did She Sense Anything Leading Up The Tragedy?
Jericho extolls the virtue of his friend, saying that if you had polled 100 people in the wrestling business about Benoit's character, no less than 100 of them would speak highly of him, adding that many of his peers looked up to him. He wants to know what she witnessed in the events leading up to the fateful weekend.
Sandra says prior to that there were a couple of heated moments, but one in particular where Chris had left the house and Nancy had gotten a restraining order against him. Chris didn't get "punch in the face physically violent" but it was intense. He pushed his wife into the island in their kitchen and she had been down that road before and recognized the signs, calling both the police and her sister.
That went on for almost three weeks, and during that time Johnny Grunge came over and tried to get the two to reconcile. He enlisted Sandra in the effort, and after speaking with Chris he convinced her that he was sorry.
She got Nancy to speak to him and they ended up working things out. That was about two years before the murders took place.
13. The Pressure Of The End Of His Career
Sandra believes that Chris was pushing himself an awful lot at work, trying to get the push of being a top guy, and like a lot of wrestlers he was beginning to feel his age and was worried what the future held once his in-ring career was over.
He had no skills outside of wrestling, with that being the only job he'd ever held, and he didn't have a backup plan. Nancy, however was never worried about an exit strategy and already had plans lined up for when her husband's career came to a close.
She was his manager and Nancy had already put plans in place to open a wrestling school in Atlanta. They had even gone so far as to give it a name and have a logo designed, and Sandra confesses that she has about 500 "Benoit Academy" t-shirts sitting around somewhere.
But Chris wasn't ready for that physically or emotionally, and she thinks his fear regarding that started boiling over into their personal life.
12. A State Of Perpetual Bereavement
Sandra speaks on the constant deaths in the lives of Chris and Nancy and how the barrage of loss kept the two of them, Chris especially, in what she calls a perpetual state of bereavement. She mentions how hard he was hit by the deaths of colleagues Johnny Grunge and Victor Marr AKA Black Cat.
Jericho also names Ray Traylor as someone else whose passing had a tremendous impact on Chris, and says that after the former Big Boss Man died, Benoit called him and said he couldn’t take losing any more of his friends.
It was less than a year later that Eddie died.
Sandra talks about how the deaths hit her sister hard as
well, mentioning Miss Elizabeth and in particular Sherri Martel as people whose
loss affected her profoundly. She says that after Sherri passed Nancy called
her and broke down, calling it one of the last real conversation she ever had with her
sister. Nancy called her crying saying "It just won't end. It won't end."
11. Self-Medicating
Sandra says that largely due to the grief that both Chris and Nancy were struggling with, the two had turned to self-medicating through drugs and alcohol. She admits that her sister was no saint and says she’s always been open and honest about her issues, but in the last year or so their abuse had gotten very intense.
She calls it "really next level, especially after Eddie. And I know that, because I was in that house and I saw it." She says it wasn't a secret, and says being around the business as long as she has she's well aware that it's an unspoken truth about the business that many of the performers self-medicated.
However, it had gotten to the point where Chris developed what she called "Judy Garland syndrome" because he was so out of it. She understands, because she sank into that same abyss while struggling with the grief of what happened.
She considers it to be a huge contributing factor to what happened.
10. Does She Feel Concussions Played A Role?
It isn't just her personal opinion that the alcohol and drugs played a role, but actual facts, confirmed by the autopsy as well as her own personal experiences with the family.
She acknowledges the belief that Benoit's concussions and reported brain damage played a large role in his actions, and while she's certain "that maybe played a role as well", she doesn't take the findings as 100% factual.
She discredits the report, saying "Maybe if it had come from MIT or Harvard and not some school in West Virginia." What Toffoloni may not realize is that WVU is one of the top-ranked neurology schools in the world, not some backwater community college. That's not to say she's wrong in her thought.
She claims the autopsy didn't support the claim that he had the brain of an elderly Alzheimer's patient, saying that she knew Chris and he had none of those symptoms.
She gets upset because of the massive push from Benoit's father and others to blame the incident on concussions shifts blame and absolves him of his actions in some people's eyes.
Sandra says it wasn't solely CTE, and while that may have contributed, it was a combination of factors; a grief, stress, a ton of medication and alcohol altering his brain and body chemistry and "possibly yes, also a little bit of brain issue from hitting his head constantly over and over."
She admits she can't definitely answer the question of how big a role that played in what Chris did, but it wasn't the act of someone with brain damage. "It's impossible for that to have been the case."
9. The Need To Find An Explanation
Sandra understands, as someone who is still struggling with loss nine years later, that there's an immense need to come up with an explanation for Benoit's actions. The daily pain of living with not knowing why it happened is crippling.
She gets why his parents and family want to be able to say that Chris wasn't himself, but she doesn't agree with their stance that he wasn't responsible due to his brain condition.
Jericho talks about how he made it a point to do media after the incident to give people a different perspective on his friend from the portrayal of him as a demon. He mentions a psychiatrist who appeared alongside him on one of the shows that said it's impossible to blame his actions on any one single influencing factor.
8. "He Brutalized My Sister"
Jericho says that, while it's horrible, he can understand in a fit of rage how a husband could murder his wife, but he's never been able to grasp how Chris could have killed his own son. It's the one thing about it he's never been able to wrap his head around and he asks Sandra if she has any theories.
She does not, and says she hears people say that all the time. Sandra says that people didn't see how much Chris and Nancy loved each other, but she sets the record straight regarding the "moment of rage" theory.
"If there was a moment of rage on Friday night, to be clear...it was serious rage. He brutalized my sister."
Even though the police report is available on the internet and many people have seen it, they didn't have to see what she saw, and she wants people to understand it wasn't just a case of accidentally hitting Nancy to hard; he brutally murdered her sister.
Once the police had released the crime scene and she entered the house, she couldn't reconcile what she was witnessing with the person she knew.
Jericho is quite taken aback at this revelation, and it must have been hard hearing the murderous actions of his close friend described in such a manner.
7. What Happened With Daniel?
Sandra says she can usually find the vocabulary to discuss anything but when she tries to talk about her nephew she has a hard time putting words together.
The thought of a murdered child is the worst thing ever, but when it comes to Daniel she knew that both Chris and Nancy loved him more than anything in the world, as did she and she can't decipher what was going through Benoit's head and heart when he took his son's life.
Her brother-in-law knew that if anything ever happened to he and Nancy that Sandra would take care of Daniel as if he were her own son, shooting down the hypothesis that Chris did it because he wouldn't have anyone to take care of him once his parents were gone.
All she can think is that it was a selfish last act, but other than that she can't put a reason behind it. She doesn't know how far Chris's thought process was even going, saying he may have been completely out of his mind.
6. A Disturbing New Detail
Sandra confirms that the incident happened over the course of several days, beginning with Nancy being killed Friday evening between the hours of 11:00 PM and 1:00 AM. The following morning Chris murdered Daniel, and then waited until Sunday evening to take his own life.
That means he spent two full days alone in the house with his deceased wife and son, which she says is so disturbing. Jericho says Chris had obviously lost his mind at that point.
Sandra then shares a disturbing detail that hadn't previously been revealed. Someone from the WWE office told her that Benoit called trying to book a flight so he could make it to the show he was scheduled for.
She says it shows that his logic was skipping in and out of reality, and his default mode was to focus on work, which he apparently attempted to do in the midst of this madness, with moments of lucidity flashing in and out during his psychotic break.
5. The Symbolic Method Of Suicide
Toffoloni reiterates that she can't begin to speculate what was going through Chris's head during these days. She then mentions that the search engine on his computer revealed that he had been researching the quickest way to break a neck, another revelation that took Jericho by surprise.
Chris then added that Benoit had rigged up his weight bench to efficiently hang himself. Jericho says that was an exhibit of near-superhuman strength, and Sandra points out that it also shows that his actions were clearly thought out.
Sandra theorized that Chris thought the wrestling business itself was choking him. Between the pressure of being at the top of the industry, the grief he had been dealing with and the physical punishment he had withstood through the years, it was "grotesquely poetic" that he ended up going out that way.
4. Reconnecting With David
Sandra wants to take a moment and silence all the rumors by saying that there was no outside source involved in the murders, specifically mentioning the ridiculous notion that Kevin Sullivan was responsible and staged the entire ordeal.
She talks about what a difficult road it's been trying to come back from this and that there isn't a day that goes by where she doesn't think about Chris's other children.
She recently reconnected with David for the first time since not long after the incident, and that was a big deal for her. She says there were tears on the phone and the question he asked that ripped her apart was "Why did you wait eight years?"
Toffoloni claimed she had tried to reach out several times but it had been thwarted by other family members, and she began to think that it may be too hard for him. She's happy they're back in touch and he'll always be her nephew.
3. Refuting The Fragile X Rumors & Nancy Being Forgotten
Sandra exclaims that she lost her mind and became furious when the district attorney went on record claiming that Daniel Benoit was afflicted with Fragile X syndrome and had been a special needs child. She sought out his medical records to prove that it was false and then demanded that the DA retract the statement.
She says that if that had been the case, Chris and Nancy would have not only gotten him the best possible medical care but they also would have come out as advocates to the condition, rather than trying to hide it and inject him with steroids which was another false rumor that floated around claiming that Daniel's body had trackmarks.
Jericho finds it frustrating that Nancy has become somewhat lost in the shuffle of the story and points out what a great legacy she left in the wrestling business, and Sandra thanks him for saying that admitting that it's been a struggle for her to see her sister's memory fall by the wayside.
2. Erasing Chris From History
Jericho talks about the one positive that has come out of all this is that the seriousness with which head injuries are treated is specifically because of Chris and Eddie Guerrero, adding that Eddie is still treated as a legend by the company while Benoit has been wiped out of existence.
Sandra says she struggles with that, saying that she obviously doesn't want to turn on USA and see a Benoit match because it would probably break her. But Nancy was a very big proponent of forgiveness, and she's tried to deal with her very complicated feelings for her sister's murderer with Nancy in mind.
She doesn't know if it's the right thing for WWE to never mention Benoit again, and doesn't know if she'll ever been in a place where she'd be okay with it.
Sandra says that a lot of people expect her to speak with anger and hatred toward Chris, but she confesses that it's hard to turn off the love and affection that she had for a man who was the father of her nephew and husband of her sister. "It doesn't work that way and it's very complicated."
She stresses that neither she nor her parents were behind the decision to remove him from WWE history, saying they've never made any threats or demands regarding the issue; it was all WWE's decision. She acknowledges that every year when the Hall of Fame rolls around there's a section of fans that call for him to be inducted but says they need to let that go because it just isn't going to happen.
1. What She Misses Most About Nancy & Daniel
Jericho wants to know what Sandra misses most about her late sister and nephew. When it comes to Nancy, she misses just being able to sit with her and have open, deep conversations with someone she could share anything with.
Sandra would go to her for advice on everything from what shoes to wear to her love life, and there's a void there that can't be filled.
The thing she misses most about Daniel is his laugh. She says that once she got him going he wouldn't stop, and she proclaims that her nephew would have made a great wrestler because he would have had his father's in-ring talent and his mother's mic skills.
She says that Daniel would be a teenager now, which she calls her sweet spot with kids, joking that she would have helped him get into just the right amount of trouble without taking it too far.
The one thing she's truly angry about is that she'll never get to see the amazing person he would have grown up to be.
After they wrap up the interview Jericho again brings up the dangers of CTE and says he does believe that played a significant role in Benoit's actions, and again credits the company for their diligence in keeping their performers safe. He says he misses Chris everyday and gives a shout out to his son David before imploring anyone who may be struggling with similar issues to please reach out and seek help.
This was an amazing interview and ranks up there was one of the most captivating episodes of any wrestling podcast. Sandra Toffoloni is an inspiring person for how she's handling the tragedy, and this was absolutely the right forum for her to tell her story alongside someone who knew and loved the Benoit family and had no agenda. Listen at podcastone.com/Talk-Is-Jericho.