2 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Deadly Draw: Women's Tag Team Tournament (Aug 17)
Earnest, progressive women's tournament or overhyped action figure commercial? You decide.
The oft-criticised YouTube portion of AEW's Women's Tag Team Cup Tournament concluded with last night's semi-finals.
As confirmed by the promotion, the finals go down on this Saturday's special episode of Dynamite. This comes after three straight weeks of YouTube shows, starting with a monster 600,000 viewers for the first episode, though the numbers had more than halved by week two, dropping to 299,000. It'll be interesting to see how this week holds up with the elevated stakes.
Ivelisse and Diamante reunited after felling Dasha Gonzalez and Rachael Ellering in the first round, looking to solidify their alliance for what could be a permanent tag team union in AEW. Elsewhere, The Nightmare Sisters of Brandi Rhodes and Allie faced off against Big and Lil' Swole, having defeated Mel and Penelope Ford the last time out, overcoming clear chemistry issues - though Brandi, not Allie, appears to be the problem now.
The finals need to step up in quality. Low on breakout performances and compromised primarily of stodgy, awkward bouts, little of the Deadly Draw has been TV-ready to date. TNT's wider audience necessitates an uptake, so here's hoping the winners can deliver that...
Downs...
3. Short But Not-So-Snappy
This has been true of the Deadly Draw throughout, though last night's post-main event interviews were particularly pointless.
Alex Marvez caught up with the winning teams. The Nightmare Sisters' promo taught us nothing we didn't already know, with Brandi Rhodes playing up her recent heel turn in the face of Allie's protestations. We then heard from Diamante and Ivelisse, who put over their combined 26 years of experience, then said winning the tournament was bigger than both of them, promising to do so for their people.
The interviews were too short to offer anything meaningful. Why not give them more time to talk, here? It's YouTube, there's no time limit, so what would be the harm in giving them 2-3 minutes each, allowing the performers to say something that lands?
2. The Nightmare Sisters vs. Big Swole & Lil' Swole
This was a Jekyll and Hyde bout that was totally fine whenever Allie was working against either Swole, but was unfortunately diminished by her partner's poor performance. Brandi's wasn't good here. She rarely looks like a natural between the ropes, though her stodginess was particularly pronounced as she wrestled the Swoles, lowlighted by a wack Superkick spot that Lil' Swole still sold for a two-count. Disruptive stuff all round, only strengthening the oft-exaggerated criticism that this tournament was established to highlight one of its least complete performers.
The finish wasn't bad. Britt Baker pulled a distraction by yelling at Big Swole with a megaphone, allowing Allie to hit her finisher and score the pinfall. AEW doesn't do these conclusions often and it makes for an effective way to continue that singles feud, with Swole and Baker likely to wrestle at All Out.
1. Lil' Bran Bran
Brandi Rhodes' televised character is all over the place.
One minute she's hogging the spotlight in her tag team with Allie, insisting Shaul Guerrero puts her over as "the only woman in AEW with an action figure" and generally playing up her obnoxiousness throughout. This was a clear, concerted effort to present her as the villain, following on from the recent interview in which her and her partner's roles were reversed with little explanation.
Then, in literally the next segment, Brandi is presented as a real-life babyface in the Heels commercial.
So which one is yet? If one is to be treated as kayfabe and the other "legitimate," they can't be on the show together. Such positioning tells us, explicitly, that the kayfabe stuff (Brandi's heel persona, in this case) is fake, and that the entire presentation of the storyline is so on the nose doesn't help either.
Whether or not the tournament is a vehicle to get her new character over, this isn't connecting. At all. The Nightmare Sisters need a rethink.
Ups...
2. Ivelisse & Diamante vs. Tay Conti & Anna Jay
This was significantly better than the first match, though nothing blow-away. Blow-away shouldn't be expected, though: Anna Jay has only worked around a dozen professional matches and Tay Conti might be an interesting prospect, but she's far from the finished product.
Still, there's something in both teams. Each has a strong dynamic, they have already clicked together, and they have proven themselves capable of wrestling above the tournament's average working standards.
Ivelisse and Diamante ended up taking the victory after shutting down a Conti hot tag. An admittedly sloppy exchange of strikes gave way to bigger bombs as tandem Stunners were hit on TayJay, allowing Diamante to nail Sliced Bread for the win.
1. The Right Finals?
Probably, yes.
While Nicole Savoy (Lil' Swole) looked like the best pure wrestler in this tournament, Diamante and Ivelisse are a fine team with chemistry, complementary styles, and solid work. They can absolutely hold their own in a spotlight like this. Allie and Brandi Rhodes have name value and recognition, meanwhile. The matches haven't always clicked, but at least people know who they are.
It'll be interesting to see how much time this bout gets on Dynamite. The best we can hope for is a breakout performance from Ivelisse and Diamante, both of whom could play roles in the AEW women's division going forward, though this is by no means guaranteed. Still, the scene needs depth. These two can provide it.