2 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE 205 Live (Jan 10)

In which WWE cracks the mystery of love.

Jack Gallagher
WWE.com

On Monday’s episode of RAW, Alicia Fox approached Noam Dar in the backstage area. Dar braced himself for a slap - but Fox bent him backwards and planted a big smacker on his lips. Dar flailed as if he was receiving a weekend visit from grandma; Fox, mirthful, remarked that her boyfriend, Cedric Alexander, was right: Dar couldn’t handle a real woman.

Which begs the question: did Alexander put her up to it? Why would he do that? Dar is clearly a sex pest with zero grasp on the concept of consent. You’re not meant to encourage that behaviour. Did she kiss him of her own volition? Of course not: if 205 Live has taught the world anything, outside of Neville’s geordie idioms, it’s that women are things, incapable of intentional thought.

Elsewhere, Jack Gallagher extended an olive branch in Ariya Daivari’s direction, setting up a segment for 205 Live - one which would have to deliver, were it to live up to the novel duel angle on December 27.

Regrettably, that wasn’t the case - but it was practically emblematic. The show itself could not continue the growing form it had enjoyed since Neville’s scintillating heel turn…


Downs...

3. Seduction For Dummies

Dar Cedric II
WWE.com

If only I’d watched this episode of 205 Live when I was unskilfully navigating romantic waters as a teenager with little in the way of game. WWE, the biggest wrestling company on the planet, have failed for a decade to produce a superstar matching John Cena’s peerless wattage - yet have somehow contrived to write a how-to guide on getting in the pants of an uninterested girl.

The formula is simple: all you need to do is set a target, reciprocated attraction no barrier. Pester her with almost tangible sleaze. Pronounce her name as if you’re auditioning for a skin flick. Undermine her boyfriend. Act incredibly insincere and sleazy, on camera, even if your behaviour is being recorded and can be watched back for the princely sum of £/$9.99.

You might get slapped a few times in the process, but fret not: there’s no such thing as a suspenseful game of will-you-won’t-you seduction. Romance is a war of attrition. Women being women - daft, hormonal creatures defined entirely as objects - will eventually just confuse themselves and fall at your feet.

At the finish of Noam Dar’s match with Cedric Alexander, Fox rescued the Scottish Supernova from the jaws of defeat, sacrificing her boyfriend in a state of hysterical confusion. The poor girl couldn’t help herself.


2. Sean A-Palling

Maluta Kendrick
WWE.com

In fairness to the weak The Brian Kendrick Vs. Sean Maluta match, it at least attempted to craft a story. Kendrick announced beforehand that he would dispatch his opponent far quicker - in “thirty seconds” - than rival Tajiri did the previous week.

The execution betrayed the concept; Maluta, unfortunately, just isn’t anywhere near Kendrick’s level. When Kendrick reacted to one of Maluta’s comebacks with the whites of his eyes peeled back in fear, his facial expression was jarring. Maluta’s rolling thunder was telegraphed with so little poise that it was impossible to believe the man could inspire terror. It was an opportunity for Maluta to show that he was worth more than his lowly jobber status - but he lived down to it in a match which suffered from a lack of credibility, heat and excitement.

Kendrick’s pre-match promo was similarly dubious. He referred to Tajiri as a “sneaky snake and a snaky sneak,” confirming that WWE hasn’t really moved on from Gorilla Monsoon’s unseemly-in-retrospect Pearl Harbour references, Shinsuke Nakamura be damned.

Austin Aries at least provided some comedy at the (merciful) finish. Checking his watch, he adjudged the near five minute match as lasting “twenty nine and a half seconds”.


1. Diminished Returns

Olive Branch Jack Gallagher
WWE.com

On last week’s edition of 205 Live, the debut of Akira Tozawa was astutely teased by a commendation from a man just one notch below Kenny Omega in the internet darling department - Cesaro.

The implication was clear - Tozawa must be awesome because someone more awesome is telling us he’s awesome. This week, WWE attempted to repeat the formula to less-than-stellar effect. There was a heart-in-mouth moment just as the footage rolled. “I hope Rich Swann is used to being a target,” warned Corey Graves on commentary. “Because a new superstar, and a potential game-changer, is taking aim at the cruiserweight division.”

Cut to: Kalisto. For a moment, it appeared as though the man was set to be rescued from SmackDown! obscurity to find his rightful home. Alas, it was not to be. Kalisto was there, in Cesaro’s absence, to put him over. While it was a job to which the man is accustomed - he does little else - it was a good job the interview was pre-recorded. There was little scope for a repeat of the most botched promo of 2016.

Another diminished return saw Jack Gallagher and Ariya Daivari take forever and a day to announce their forthcoming “I Forfeit” match, the name of which, while very creative, was not worth the effort of a flat and heat-free segment.


Ups...

2. An Unseemly Means To A Fine End

Dar Alexander III
WWE.com

In the 2001 science fiction time travel mystery Donnie Darko, Drew Barrymore’s Karen Pomeroy teacher character told her students of the “cellar door” phonaesthetic principle. Those two words, in combination, are the oft-cited example of the most aurally beautiful in the English language. Or at least, they were - for there is nothing as wonderful-sounding as the manner in which Noam Dar pronounces Alicia Furxxxx.

As horrendous a moral lesson WWE have imparted with what is a particularly poor taste storyline, given the wider cultural landscape, the match itself did benefit from the meaning, no matter how dubious, behind it.

It is a credit to both Dar and Alexander that they have chosen to run with something so abysmal; on the night, they transcended the soap opera limitations of the storyline they too must find hackneyed. Infusing their strikes, in particular, with considerable oomph, it was an immersive and believable match which adhered to - and almost excused - the source material.

The finish was a dreadful near-reset of the Women’s Revolution - but that was one aspect of it beyond their control.


1. Addition By Subtraction

Nese Swann
WWE.com

It’s probably no coincidence that an episode of 205 Live on which Neville made only a fleeting appearance was the weakest since his return - but his in-ring absence prolonged the intrigue of his budding feud with Rich Swann. The booking was clever - even if the stakes were treated frivolously when Swann referred to Neville during the closing segment as a “gargoyle” and “Dumbo”. Don’t be a bully, be a star, etc. etc.

Tony Nese entered a very good performance in his main event opposite Swann; preening in the early going, he very quickly adapted his approach to cover Swann like a rash, conveying the serious threat he was confronted with.

That sense of pacing soon diminished. The match sagged at the halfway point - Nese isn’t over enough to generate heat during those WWE-mandated rest hold spots, though he did furnish them with some killer, laser-focused facial expressions - but it recovered to assemble a stiff finishing sequence.

Austin Aries continued his rapid rate of improvement at the commentary desk. Corey Graves praised Nese for clearing three quarters of the ring with an ill-fated springboard moonsault. Barely missing a beat, Aries responded “I get four fifths across the ring, Corey, but it was impressive. He is slowly mastering the careful balancing act of the heel commentator.

It’s a shame the show itself, in contrast, was a regression of past form.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!