2 Ups & 6 Downs From WWE Starrcade 2019

The WWE Network presents a different kind of WCW tradition...

Starrcade Women's Tag
WWE.com

The problem with nostalgia is, like the performers it deploys, it gets old. When WWE joylessly brought back Starrcade as a souped-up house show in 2018, they sapped a good portion of its very meaning in presentation alone.

It was was vintage Vince McMahon, in fact - he'd grown out of his anti-WCW bias a few years after it started making him a f*cking fortune and served as the spine of his streaming service, but using his old rival's most prestigious brand as a house show Network hook almost felt like a degradation to its rich history.

Your writer is no fan of Cody nor his unsubtle affection for Atlanta's archives in AEW, but any longstanding wrestling fan would rather see its history lauded rather than let down. As is usually the case in WWE, the maiden edition at least made a bit of effort, before last year's was reduced to little more than the chopped up house show it was destined to become.

Into year three and with all the airs and graces well and truly shot to sh*t, how much further in interest levels could Starrcade 2019 really even fall? Well...


Downs...

6. Then, Now, For Never

Tom Phillips Byron Saxton
WWE

"Starrcade is live for the first time in 19 years" and "36 years ago Starrcade began" are the sort of lines WWE can feed to their announcers to use in spite of this version of the (original) 'Grandaddy Of Em All' being nothing like its forefather.

This isn't exclusive to WWE of course - Cody and AEW have already done this with the very presence of Tony Schiavone and will surely do the same when they run a Bash At The Beach edition of Dynamite in the New Year, but the cognitive dissonance between southern wrestling sycophancy and the Rusev/Bobby Lashley match in particular was a little hard to swallow.

No wonder All Elite Wrestling's flawed mission statement was to "Change The Universe" - we are still clearly all living in Vince McMahon's world.


5. The Kevin Owens Sh*tShow

Kevin Owens
WWE

"Tumultuous" was the word used by Tom Phillips to describe the last week or so of Kevin Owens' life within WWE, but as usual, the 'Prizefighter' was underserved by his masters.

His fleeting NXT return at TakeOver: WarGames generated one of the decade's biggest pops before the booking of the Survivor Series threatened to flatten it completely. Raw, fortunately, went much better, but 'KO' will always be the cat Vince McMahon kicks when he's p*ssed off with things - what's good now can't be forever.

This, rather fittingly, teed up Ric Flair's appearance at the start of the show. Owens was first to juxtapose the glory of 'The Nature Boy' with the cheap and nasty talk show staging, but Flair said more in the space between his scripted lines than half the words he managed to remember...


4. A Flair For The Sold

Ric Flair Kevin Owens
WWE

Ric Flair doesn't get a live microphone on Raw or SmackDown very often now, with WWE perhaps mindful of some of the wild promos he's been cutting online accidentally escaping onto their carefully curated PG offering...or simply because one of the most electrifying talkers in industry history simply doesn't have his spark.

Like an Alan Partridge ratings graph, this started badly and got worse until we were all left with cheese being smashed into our faces - fans couldn't even hear Flair initially (him not being able to hear their "We Can't Hear You" chant was the sh*tception moment of 2019), and he strolled off message so much that they were probably regretting Kevin Owens swapping the microphones by the end.

What sounded like a noble attempt to put over the product inadvertently buried f*ck out of it - "They give us stuff to talk about, and bullet points...what I wanted to say was, we get a script and we look at it, and we try to cover what's important, but I've found with the product...obviously I'm so thrilled to see my daughter be part of it" was the sort of faint praise WWE often warrants. Flair, kindly, turned to Owens to note "I love what you did Monday by the way", before giving away that he was told to. "I'm hitting the highspots" immediately followed. High spot was right - nothing else of note got mentioned after this incredibly clunky start.

An interruption from The Club set up a surprisingly enjoyable unnancouned match, so that can wait for later in this article. Just ending this wretched opening segment was a mercy kill.


3. Shut Up And Wrestle

Sasha Banks Bayley
WWE

With little else to grab onto on this show, Bayley and Sasha Banks had the opportunity to steal it with a decent bit of backstage banter before the advertised fatal four-way Tag Team Title match. If only 'decent backstage banter' had actually been a thing in the last 20 years or so.

The two supposed top heels of SmackDown did some by-the-numbers bullsh*t about not liking the town before 'The Boss' spat an absolutely stinking line to close it out. In fairness, "Double champs, double pay, double duty 'cause we're gonna slay" was only as cringeworthy as Bayley asking "did Snoop teach you that?!"

Buried by being on screen instead of off, 'The Boss & Hug Connection' are clearly cursed in spite of what happens bell-to-bell.


2. Bait And B*tch

Lana Bobby Lashley
WWE

Bullsh*t.

WWE gave little more than an hour of their WWE Network schedule to the televised portion of Starrcade, and even then they couldn't deliver the match they'd promised.

Bullsh*t.

'The All Mighty' was at least taped up after Rusev battered him on last Monday's Raw, but that was as much as the company were prepared to give the crowd despite advertising this Last Man Standing match when they didn't need to. After a bit of the usual from Lana about festive shagging and that, the 'Ravishing Russian' was used to deliver the news like it was a heel scheme rather than a cheap company cop-out. Restraining order, innit.

Nobody held a gun to WWE's head in prepping this show, nor yours or mine in choosing, foolishly, to watch it. They loaded it and pointed it towards their own face yet again here.

Bullsh*t.


1. False Finish

Rusev Starrcade
WWE

Kevin Owens and Bobby Lashley having an on-the-spot match as the main event of the televised portion of Starrcade felt like a middle finger to the progeny of Dusty Rhodes, not least considering Cody's current propensity for avoiding all of this sort of sh*t in his own company.

"No-one cares about the two of you and your stupid relationship" was the babyface version of Lana's troll material just seconds earlier - characters being used in kayfabe to try and talk around the company's creative deficiencies. It got a pop, just like the announcement from 'KO' that he'd take Rusev's place, but WWE were careful to end one match and start another before this kicked off. Of course they were - it allowed for a disqualification finish in an unplanned replacement match when Rusev broke another restraining order and decked his love rival.

Vince McMahon supposedly prides himself on only providing better replacements when he has to make changes to his televised cards. Company policy even, based on the last few years. Did he forget Starrcade was actually on the air?


Ups...

2. House Party

Street Profits The OC
WWE

Street Profits Vs The OC was house show fodder supplanted onto the WWE Network like the rest of this show, but it was a reminder that house shows are often more enjoyable than television tapings - these guys f*cked around and it was great fun.

Unpicking the formula is pointless because of just how formulaic it was - babyfaces had the advantage, heels took it, babyfaces took it back and went over in just under ten minutes. It's been done a million times before and will be done a million more, but the craic between the four was enjoyable, the sight of Ric Flair seconding Montez Ford and Angelo Dawkins was something unique for the night and the hot Atlanta crowd popped for all of it.

Fun is fun - WWE would do well to remember this when agenting television matches once in a while.


1. Trying Times

Fatal Four Way Starrcade
WWE

"The wrestling was good" has become the faint praise du jour with which to damn modern era WWE - it's the best thing the company does despite such a tiny part of what makes up Vince McMahon's personal dividend. But in the Women's Tag Team Title match (and in spite of huge potential problems), the wrestling was good.

With 15 minutes and four talented teams, the contest never really had time to get stale, not least with every wrestler keen to get their sh*t in in that time. In victory, The Kabuki Warriors further solidified a reign that has thus far hugely over-achieved too.

The first half of the match was made up almost entirely of blind tag back-and-forths. Every combination and pairing got a hot minute or so to flex their best efforts before the two heel teams took over with a brief heat spot on Alexa Bliss.

"Heat" being perhaps a little generous in this case - the crowd didn't really care, but with the sound off or blinkers on, this was very enjoyable. A difficult first year for the Women's doubles division appears as though it will end on a high, and this is entirely as a result of the sort of work on show in this match. In-ring action might yet still be a force powerful enough to get something over, who knew?


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.