20 Biggest Myths WWE Tells About Its History

Bending the truth? Then. Now. Forever.

WWE LADDER MATCH MYTH.jpg
WWE

This may come as a shock, dear readers, but WWE has not been completely honest with you. Leaving aside the predetermined nature of our favourite pseudosport, the world leader in sports-entertainment is also the world leader in fibbing. 

Strong words, I know, but stay with me here...

A combination of carny mentality and a vast tape library means that WWE can very easily package and sell their official version of wrestling history. Sure, we get some truly wonderful things like the Network archives and the Hall of Fame, but we pay for it by allowing WWE to be the custodians of their own history.

The following twenty myths are all promoted by WWE as important parts of their official narrative, their sanitised (they might prefer “streamlined”) version of their history. 

Some of them are relatively small things, like fudged numbers, but some are comparatively huge misconceptions upon which years of stories were based.

Take a look for yourself...

20. WCW Copied WWE

Gillberg WWE
WWE.com

The Myth: WCW attained what success it did by copying what had worked in WWE.

The Truth: This is true in a limited sense, but the opposite is also true.

When it became apparent that WCW had struck upon a winning formula, WWE scrambled imitate their success. For example, when the cruiserweight division became the talk of the wrestling world, WWE decided to start a light-heavyweight division.

Unfortunately, the results were far from great. While WCW had imported Mexican stars who worked a hybrid junior style that combined American, Mexican, and Japanese elements, WWE just started putting AAA guys on Raw, where they went about their business having trios matches and taking floating bumps to the confusion of fans and commentators alike.

When the nWo began teasing a "third man", WWE built an episode of Raw around Ahmed Johnson and Shawn Michaels doing the same, including saying that exact phrase a number of times. D-X was clearly an imitation of (and commentary on) the nWo.

They even went as far as literally promoting Diesel and Razor Ramon cosplayers. Then there's the whole Gillberg thing, but that was all because someone thought that Goldberg was a copy of Steve Austin. The list of similarities and differences and who copied who goes on and on...

Got a headache yet?


19. André The Giant's Undefeated Streak

Hulk Hogan Andre the Giant Piper's Pit
WWE.com

The Myth: André the Giant was undefeated for 15 years before finally losing to Hulk Hogan.

The Truth: André lost dozens of matches over the years. He lost to Antonio Inoki via TKO in 1976 and by countout in 1978, but we've seen elsewhere that WWE has a blind spot for that dude's achievements.

The big guy lost numerous times in Japan, in fact, although mostly in tag matches. Still a notch in his "L" column, though, even if he wasn't pinned or submitted.

That's one of the variants of this myth, by the way: that the giant hadn't been pinned or made to submit in 15 years. That might be true, though I suspect André did his share of under-the-radar clean jobs before filming shows became commonplace.

However, some versions of the myth have gone so far as claiming that the giant hadn't even been knocked off his feet in that 15-year span. That is utterly ridiculous, especially given what we'll learn later on about André's history of getting slammed.

And no, I'm not talking about the 118 beers story.


18. Steve Austin Started The Attitude Era

Goldust - Attitude Era
WWE.com

The Myth: Steve Austin was the star who ushered in the Attitude Era.

The Truth: The Attitude Era style is most strongly associated with the edgy violence of Steve Austin and the juvenile raunchiness of D-Generation X, and they're usually heralded as the twin prongs of that period’s unprecedented popular appeal.

However, it's not fair to credit either of those two entities with breaking that ground.

In 1995, Goldust arrived in WWE. A psychosexual stalker dressed like a living Oscar statuette, the former Natural was a revelation in a promotion still trying to make a go of the New Generation.

Goldust had perhaps the most quintessential Attitude Era match you can imagine -- a street fight that involved attempted vehicular manslaughter, transvestism, and a way-past-topical OJ Simpson parody -- in March of 1996.

Keep in mind that, on the same night Goldust was trying to dry hump Roddy Piper, Steve Austin was trading chinlocks with Savio Vega at the behest of Ted DiBiase, Triple H was getting squashed by the Warrior and Shawn Michaels was living out his squeaky clean boyhood dream.

Speaking of which . . .


17. HBK's Boyhood Dream As Champion

WrestleMania 12 Bret Hart Shawn Michaels Iron Many Match Finish
WWE.com

The Myth: Shawn Michaels’ first title reign was a storybook tale of self-fulfillment.

The Truth: Shawn’s reign started in controversy, traveled through several months of lacklustre defenses, and ended when the fans turned on him, hard.

Shawn had a full hour to defeat Bret Hart, and couldn't. For some reason, despite the champion literally always retaining in case of a draw, the match was restarted by Gorilla “Deus Ex Machina” Monsoon and Shawn became champion. He had a phenomenal defense against Diesel right after WrestleMania, and then things took a hard left.

Shawn was accused of propositioning Diana Hart, and was subsequently forced to wrestle Davey Boy Smith. He briefly got to show real fire in a feud with Mankind, but derailed into constant, sometimes-onscreen hissy fits as he tangled with Vader.

None of this was helped by Michaels’ clear self-importance and Vince McMahon absolutely salivating over the guy on commentary. The fans started to Reigns on HBK, and things only got worse.

Overbooking in Michaels matches began to approach Hogan-in-WCW levels to protect the champ. In damage-control mode on commentary, Vince made it his mission to personally disagree with HBK’s critics, but the more he tried to convince the fans that they loved Shawn the less willing they were to do so.

This all reached a crescendo at Survivor Series 1996, when Sid (SID!) got a massive babyface reaction for going on a video camera-swinging rampage against both Shawn and José Lothario, winning the WWE Championship in the process.

Worse, it's 1996, so Vince can't send Triple H to cut a passive-aggressive promo about his friend Mark. Instead, he chose to open Raw with a bizarre editorial about how HBK was GREAT and a REAL MAN and DESERVED A REMATCH.


16. Eddie Guerrero's Final Title

Eddie Guerrero Batista No Mercy 2005.jpg
WWE.com

The Myth: Eddie Guerrero was going to win the World Heavyweight Championship right before his death.

The Truth: WWE never really made this claim, but they did imply it super hard.

On the Eddie Guerrero memorial SmackDown, Stephanie McMahon mentioned that, while Eddie’s WWE Championship reign had ended when he felt that the pressure might reawaken his demons, she knew that he would have been champ again someday.

The episode ended with Batista leaving his World Heavyweight Championship behind on the hood of one of Eddie’s trademark low riders.

In reality, there were no plans to take the title off Big Dave. He was pencilled in for a long reign, even longer than his record-holding 282 days. As for Stephanie’s statement, she likely meant that, as SmackDown’s most beloved character and arguably best worker, it was a given that Eddie would find himself champion again down the line.

Given that Batista had to relinquish the title due to injury not long after Eddie's death and Kurt Angle, Randy Orton and Rey Mysterio were thrust into the main event in response, it's not easy to guess where Eddie's run would have been, but it definitely wasn't going to be back in November 2005.


15. WCW Was Foolish To Release Austin, Foley, And HHH

Triple H Wcw
WWE.com

The Myth: WCW was foolish to release Steve Austin, Mick Foley and HHH.

The Truth: It is so, so hard to predict who's going to be a megastar. It's kind of like that Pokémon trope where you never know how powerful someone’s final form will be.

Just remember, though; WCW didn't cut Stone Cold, Mankind, and Triple H from their roster, they cut Stunning Steve, Cactus Jack and Jean-Paul Lévesque.

Of the three, Cactus was closest to his maximum potential when he was sent packing. He'd already had main event feuds with Vader and Sting, but WCW’s product was trending toward safety. Weapons and blood were less welcome on Turner networks and, without sock puppetry to fall back on, Foley had little to offer.

Austin would have been huge and definite world title material in the old NWA, but he became a victim of WCW’s next mission statement: mimic late 80’s WWE. Hogan was coming, and with him would come his cronies and their working style.

Austin wasn't going to have the kinds of matches he'd had with Ricky Steamboat with, like, Jerry Sags. Plus, WCW was no longer a place where wrestling a 20-minute epic could move you up the card. When he got hurt, I'm sure it seemed like an obvious move to cut him.

And Triple H was jerking curtains feuding with Alex Wright and attempting a truly terrible French accent. Releasing him would be like releasing Damien Sandow, except a version of Damien Sandow that couldn't get his goofy gimmicks over.


14. King Kong Bundy's 8 Second Match

King Kong Bundy
WWE.com

The Myth: King Kong Bundy defeated S.D. Jones in 9 seconds at WrestleMania I.

The Truth: First, let’s marvel at the fact that Special Delivery Jones made it onto the first WrestleMania card! Well done him. Second, the timekeeper for that show couldn't count, despite that being literally his only job.

On commentary, Gorilla Monsoon insisted that Bundy trounced Jones in 9 seconds, which was record time. Thanks to the magic of the WWE Network, I can personally verify that the match went at least 16 seconds.

Not that that’s any more impressive, really, but it seems strange to fudge a number that you have complete control over.

There were precisely four moves in the match: a bearhug, a corner ram, a corner splash, and a standing splash. If you're dead set on 9 seconds, you could cut literally any of those four maneuvers and been right there.

Did someone panic at the last minute and decide we needed to protect Special Delivery fargin’ Jones in a record-breakingly short squash? Because I'd buy S.D. Jones being rendered comatose by a hard stare.


13. Pat Patterson Won A Tournament In Brazil To Become First Intercontinental Champion

Pat Patterson
WWE.com

The Myth: Pat Patterson won a tournament in Rio de Janeiro to become the inaugural Intercontinental Champion.

The Truth: Almost everything about this story is a lie. Let's start at the beginning: in 1979, Pat Patterson was the reigning WWF North American Champion.

He had defeated a very young Ted DiBiase for the title, but there was no lineage to speak of. In fact, the title was just invented and given to Ted when he signed with the company four months earlier.

Perhaps in an attempt to give Pat (and the title) more credibility, on 1 September of ‘79 it was declared that Pat had won a tournament in Brazil, and, in the finals, unified his title with the WWF South American Championship.

He then vacated his North American Championship on the perfectly reasonable grounds that a two-continent championship outranks one of its constituent championships. It was won by Seiji Sakaguchi and retired shorly after.

Strangely, this did not free up the South American Championship to be won by Tiger Chung Lee or whoever, and WWE simply moved forward with the IC as its secondary title.


12. HHH Ruled The Attitude Era

triple h king of the ring 1997
WWE.com

The Myth: Triple H was a powerful main event force that dominated the Attitude Era.

The Truth: Sorry, no.

There's no denying that Triple H was an important part of the Attitude Era, including some of its biggest moments. He was a player, no doubt. But to suggest that he was a major player - on par with Steve Austin, The Rock, even Mick Foley - is nuts.

Triple H cut his teeth as Shawn Michaels’ heterosexual (?) life partner in D-Generation X, and assumed the mantle of leadership when HBK slipped into temporary retirement.

He got to “invade” WCW, and feud with Nation-era Rock over the Intercontinental Championship. He did eventually win the WWE Championship a few times, and even became the first heel to close out WrestleMania as champion.

However, these title reigns were nothing compared to the domination he'd exert starting in 2002. With Austin, Rock and Foley gone and Undertaker and Kurt Angle on SmackDown, Triple H ruled Raw like a feudal estate.

But that was the Ruthless Aggression Era, characterized by the lack of Attitude Era megastars. No disrespect to Booker T or Rob Van Dam, but they're a little bit easier to “rule over” than Rock and Austin, you know?


11. The Attitude Era Was A Golden Age

Attitude Era, Raw
WWE.com

The Myth: The Attitude Era was an unparalleled period of commercial and creative triumph.

The Truth: This one is half true. 1998-2001 saw pro wrestling reach unparalleled heights of popularity, absolutely. Creatively, it had peaks and valleys; the high points were high indeed, but man were the lows low.

WWE has always aimed for low-hanging fruit, but never as consistently as they did under the aegis of “crash TV.”

The flip side of Steve Austin being allowed to flip people off was Mae Young giving birth to a rubber band, Droz vomiting on demand for fun and profit, and Road Warrior Hawk threatening to kill himself on television. Big Boss Man killed Al Snow's dog and fed it to him, which led to a match where "vicious attack dogs" had sex and defecated live on PPV.

The match quality suffered as well. Television matches rarely went for more than a few minutes, although that was probably for the best. Today, we're used to a Raw where Sami Zayn can wrestle Chris Jericho for 15 minutes, but nobody needed to see Crash Holly work an armbar on Bull Buchanan for a quarter hour.


10. Undertaker Was Always Great

Giant Gonzalez Taker
WWE.com

The Myth: The Undertaker was a special performer from the very beginning, leaving behind an entire career of wonderful matches.

The Truth: ‘Taker always had presence, yes. You couldn't have sent, like, Dan Spivey out there in purple kitchen gloves and expected it to last 30 years. But the first third of his career wasn't much more than presence.

He wasn't bringing great promos to the table, and he surely wasn't having great matches. For years (years!) all we saw from the guy was no-selling and slow-motion mummy strangling.

Take a look through any list of great Undertaker matches. Not the ones put out by WWE; those are made to perpetuate the myth we're currently busting, so they'll tell you the Deadman trying to shove Ultimate Warrior into a body bag was thrilling athleticism.

Any non-kayfabed list basically begins at Badd Blood 1997, with performances continuing to improve throughout the American Badass period. Just don't go back to the Undertaker's 1992 matches with Ric Flair and expect it to be anywhere near as good as their crazy old man fight at WrestleMania X-8, you know?


9. Hogan Slams The Giant At WM III

Hulk Hogan Andre The Giant Body Slam
WWE.com

The Myth: When Hulk Hogan slammed André the Giant at WrestleMania III, it was an unprecedented feat; the Giant had never before been lifted and slammed to the mat.

The Truth: André took many slams over the years, some of which were even caught on film.

Long before his climactic WrestleMania showdown with Hulk Hogan, André was slammed by NWA champion Harley Race, lucha libre legend El Canek, puroresu ace Antonio Inoki, terrifying gaijin juggernaut Stan Hansen, and friggin’ Kamala. It wasn't exactly an exclusive fraternity back in the day.

If you were thinking, “Sure, but at least Hogan hadn't slammed him before WrestleMania III”, you're wrong on that count as well. During his run as a top heel in the very early 80’s, Hogan picked up André and put him down repeatedly, up and down the eastern seaboard of the United States.

‘86 Hogan remains the baldest person to execute the move, however.


8. Bob Backlund's Lengthy Reign

Bob Backlund
WWE.com

The Myth: Bob Backlund’s first WWE title reign was the second-longest in history.

The Truth: Everyone’s favorite living Howdy Doody officially reigned from 20 February, 1979 to 26 December, 1983. Within that span, however, a lot of fishy stuff happened.

Backlund was defeated by Antonio Inoki in Tokushima, Japan, and he lost a subsequent rematch 6 days later. However, the title was vacated following that match.

Despite losing TWICE to Inoki in one week, Backlund defeated Bobby Duncum in a Texas Death Match to regain the championship. Apparently a tiny baby Vince Russo booked this, I don't know.

WWE doesn't recognize Inoki’s reign on the grounds that he vacated the title, but that's asinine; brother vacated it after winning the REMATCH under sketchy circumstances, but that doesn't erase his squeaky clean win over Opie the night before.

Like, when Daniel Bryan beat Randy Orton and the title was subsequently held in Abeyance™, that didn't mean Randy Orton was never champion.

And so, if we bisect Bobby B’s reign to account for all this foofarah, his longest clocks in at 1,470 days, just four days short of Hulk Hogan’s.


7. HBK And Razor's Groundbreaking Ladder Match

Shawn Michaels Razor Ramon Ladder
WWE.com

The Myth: Shawn Michaels and Razor Ramon had an unprecedented, groundbreaking ladder match at WrestleMania X.

The Truth: Razor and Michaels did indeed have a wonderful ladder match at WrestleMania X.

However, it wasn't the first ladder match in WWE history. It wasn't even the first ladder match in Shawn Michaels’ history: HBK and Bret Hart had the company’s first ladder match on an episode of Wrestling Challenge, of all things.

I know that's like finding out that the first Hell in a Cell match was between Todd Grisham and Ivory on an episode of WWE Experience, but here we are.

In fact, it makes sense that Bret Hart would be the man to bring ladders into a WWE ring: the ladder match had first been contested nearly twenty years earlier in Calgary’s Stampede Wrestling. Baby Bret even wrestled one himself, back in 1984.

If you're interested in learning more about Bret’s role, specifically how he deserves more credit than Shawn, ask Bret himself. He'd be happy to tell you about it. At length.


6. The Streak Was Totally Epic

The Undertaker 21-0 WrestleMania 29
WWE.com

The Myth: The Undertaker’s 21-year run of WrestleMania victories was uniformly epic, and always treated as a big deal.

The Truth: It's not like Undertaker spent two decades putting away Shawn Michaelses and Triple Aitches. His list of victories includes such unimpressive conquests as A-Train, Giant Gonzales, and Big Boss Man.

A lot of the early matches have pretty rancid finishes, too; Undertaker started off strong by Tombstoning Jimmy Snuka with authority, but then he followed that up by beating Jake Roberts by count-out, pinning King Kong Bundy with a clothesline, and, no joke, defeating Giant Gonzalez by DQ after being knocked out by a chloroform-soaked rag.

To make matters worse, WWE didn't even really make the Streak into a big deal until 'Taker faced off with Randy Orton at WrestleMania XXI. That was the first time WWE put together a little retrospective of Undertaker's vanquished foes in an attempt to make the Streak into a real thing they meant to do, not just a piece of trivia they stumbled upon.

Oddly, none of those videos show the part where Undie is laid low by a 9-foot tall naked sasquatch using chemistry.


5. André's Size Lies

andre the giant
WWE.com

The Myth: André the Giant was 7’5” and 500 lbs.

The Truth: André was a huge man indeed, but never approached these incredible numbers, especially not simultaneously. André was at his tallest in his youth, before the twin ravages of acromegaly and age caused his spine to deform and compress, shrinking him.

When he was young, however, he was also lithe, and lacking the hulking presence we associate with him today. At 24 years of age, the young André was measured by a decidedly non-kayfabe French athletic commission at 6’11”.

Even in his late 30’s, when he cut his most impressive figure, plenty of tricks were employed to make André look bigger than he was. He'd stand on a phone book during interview segments, for example, to further dwarf Gene Okerlund and make him seem almost supernatural.

That's why, despite being the same shoot height as Colin Cassady, he's like ten feet tall when he shows up in WWE video games.


4. The WrestleMania III Attendance Record

WrestleMania III
WWE.com

The Myth: WrestleMania III drew 93,173 fans.

The Truth: The true number is disputed, and we may never know how many people crammed into the Silverdome that fateful day. WWE loves trumpet the attendance record held by its biggest show of the 1980's.

Gorilla Monsoon read off the "official" number during the show, noting the sea of humanity hanging from the rafters. In recent years, however, questions have been raised.

For one thing, the maximum occupancy of the Silverdone is listed at 80,311, 12k fewer than supposedly attended WrestleMania III. That number doesn't account for temporary seating set up on the football field, and without knowing the space allotted to each seat it is difficult to say whether 12,000 humans could have crowded in.

Then there's the fact that Zane Bresloff, one of the men who promoted WM III, came forward in later years to claim that the number was inflated. By his account, the show drew no more than 78,000 fans.

Unless someone plans on actually trying to count attendees one by one, the truth may never be known...


3. WCW Was Killed By Bad Booking

eric bischoff vince russo
WWE.com

The Myth: WCW’s incompetence rendered their product unsalvageable and left the company on death’s door.

The Truth: WCW had a spectacularly poor couple of years leading up to their purchase by WWE. The once-dominant company was hemorrhaging money to the tune of $5 million per month by the end of 1999, with PPV buyrates and TV ratings plummeting to match.

However, the situation was hardly hopeless.

Greed, WCW’s final PPV, ran a .10 buyrate, which translates to something like 50,000 total purchases. For comparison’s sake, only one show in TNA’s history (Bound For Glory 2006) was that successful, and that company still continues to limp along a decade later.

Further, while the final Nitros sported low ratings for the time, they aren't too much worse than today’s Raw ratings.

WCW, with competent booking and a little luck, could have rebuilt their fanbase. Wrestling was still hot enough, and they still had a fantastic television deal.

That's why the true nail in the coffin wasn't driven in by the bookers, but by AOL/Time Warner. The architects of that merger wanted a more upscale feel to their television properties, and decided to yank Nitro from primetime.

Without the ability to keep eyes on the product, WCW truly was dead in the water.


2. Ric Flair's 16 World Titles

Ric Flair WCW Champion
WWE.com

The Myth: Ric Flair won 16 world championships over the course of his illustrious career.

The Truth: In this case, the official figure is no exaggeration. In fact, it woefully undersells Flair’s achievements. By the Nature Boy’s own reckoning, he's been to the top of the mountain more than 20 times.

Flair has, without dispute, the following reigns under his (big gold) belt: NWA World Heavyweight Championship (9 times), WCW World Heavyweight Championship (8 times), WCW International Heavyweight Championship (2 times) and WWE World Heavyweight Championship (2 times). That count places him at 21 world title reigns.

However, there's even more to the story than that. In January and February of 1983, Flair toured the Caribbean, losing his title to Jack Veneno, Carlos Colon, and Victor Jovica. In each case, Flair won back or was awarded the title by the NWA before returning home.

A year later, Flair traded the title back and forth with Harley Race during a tour of the South Pacific, an exchange recognized by WCW but not by NWA or WWE.

Bottom line: no one is really sure how many titles Flair has won. Even if WWE decided to recognize ALL of these reigns, Ric would just bring up the time the NWA sent him to space to trade the title with Moo-Mar of the Moon Men.


1. Austin 3:16 Launched Steve Austin Into The Stratosphere 

Austin, King of the Ring
WWE.com

The Myth: The Austin 3:16 promo immediately launched Steve Austin to superstardom.

The Truth: 22 June, 1996 was a huge night for Steve Austin. He defeated Jake Roberts to become King of the Ring, and then instead of getting draped in a Halloween Express ermine cape, he cut a furious promo about how God is dead because of !*$%-whippings.

It was clear to anyone watching that this was a true watershed moment and that Austin was destined for greatness.

Anyway, on the following Raw, Austin wrestles The Undertaker but gets disqualified when Goldust attacks the Deadman. The next week, he's on commentary for a Marc Mero match.

The next week, he is not on the show. The week after that, he is also not on the show. Or the Raw after that. All told, Austin didn't appear on a major show again until In Your House: International Incident on 22 July.

It's not like these mid-’96 Raws were stacked. While Austin was hidden away on Superstars, they had time to foist T.L. Hopper matches, transvestite Sunny impersonators, and THE GOON on us.

So, the next time WWE puts out a documentary that implies that Austin 3:16 happened on a Sunday and he was throwing hands with Mike Tyson in a fully-formed Attitude Era on the next Raw, don't forget the month of Smoking Gunns matches we all had to sit through.


Contributor

Long-time fan (scholar?) of professional wrestling, kaiju films and comparative mythology. Aspiring two-fisted adventurer.