20 Former WWE Stars Who Should Return For Brand Split 2016

Revitalizing Raw and Smackdown with some talented hands from the past!

shawn Davari
WWE.com

By now, everybody knows that the WWE brand split is coming back. On July 19, Smackdown will go live on Tuesday evenings with what the company has described as a unique roster and storylines, meaning that prior to that date, the promotion's roster will be divided in half. Raw and Smackdown will each be presented as separate promotions on TV.

Each of the new brands will need more talent. Some wrestlers will be brought up from NXT (meaning the developmental territory will need its own influx of talent), but recently, news has spread that the company is also looking for former stars to return to the roster.

There's no shortage of former WWE employees who would make great additions to the current company. Due to cost-cutting measures and a skewed eyed for talent, dozens of superstars have been let go without getting a chance to reach their full potential, and many of those men and women would still be able to contribute today. Here are 20 such wrestlers who should make their return for the brand split.

Just a note: I've purposefully left off wrestlers who are under contract to other major promotions, so Shelton Benjamin, Trent Barreta, and others aren't on the list. Likewise, I've left off stars who have retired or have been out of the business for several years.

20. Chris Masters

Chris Masters
WWE.com

When Chris Masters debuted in WWE in 2005, fans weren't impressed. He was another generic muscleman whose skills were questionable. In his TV debut, he proved his worst detractors right by badly injuring Stevie Richards with a Polish hammer. Still, his body won him a lot of opportunities, and he was put into a feud with Shawn Michaels.

After WWE's wellness policy went into effect, Masters lost a lot of weight - and his push. He was released in 2007. In 2009, Masters was rehired, but the company had no interest in using him as anything other than an undercard worker. It was a shame, because by then, he had improved a lot. Masters had good matches on Superstars until he was fired again in 2011.

Many have expected "The Masterpiece" to get another shot by now, but it hasn't happened. Still, he's only 33, and he could still contribute to WWE. He's currently listed as working for Global Force Wrestling, but provided he's legally able, he could make a familiar and beneficial addition to WWE.


19. Super Crazy

Super Crazy Tajiri
WWE.com/PWI

During the later days of ECW, luchador Super Crazy emerged as one of the company's most exciting talents. A feud with Yoshihiro Tajiri put both men on the map, and in 2000, Crazy even had a brief run as ECW Television Champion.

After the company closed, Super Crazy went to work for a variety of independent and international promotions, but in 2005, he signed with WWE. Originally teamed with Juventud Guerrera and Psicosis, Crazy eventually made his way into singles competition. Though he never achieved much success, he was popular and could be counted on for an exciting match.

Today, Super Crazy works for Lucha Libre Elite, an offshoot of CMLL. Still, the fact that he rarely works main CMLL cards seems to indicate that he hasn't signed an official deal with the promotion. Odds are that WWE could snatch him up, and "The Extreme Luchador" could once again thrill crowds stateside - maybe as part of a reborn cruiserweight division.


18. Katie Lea Burchill

Katie Lea Burchill
WWE.com

English competitor Katie Lea Burchill debuted in WWE a little too late - or just late enough, depending on how you look at it. She was introduced as the storyline sister of Paul Burchill, who had already been through several failed gimmicks of his own.

This one would take the cake - Vince McMahon wanted to run an incest angle, and the Burchills would be his canvas. There were hints dropped between the couple, but before things could get too far, WWE switched to a PG product.

The entire incest idea was dropped, which was good for the fans, but meant that creative had nothing for either Burchill. She puttered around for a couple of years, scoring the occasional shot at the Women's Title, but was largely an afterthought. In 2010, she was released.

Burchill turned up in TNA as Winter, and had more success in that company. Still, her tenure didn't last long, and she was soon back on the independent scene.

With today's renewed focus on the women's division, Burchill (with a different name, most likely), could be an asset to the company. The division should expand, and the path to a Women's Tag Team Title or Money in the Bank match starts with more talent.


17. Carlito

Carlito apple
WWE.com

After months of vignettes, The Shining Stars - Primo and Epico - finally made their Raw debut, taking on a pair of local competitors. Reaction to the repackaged tandem was muted, and in the month since the match, the pair has only appeared via more vignettes.

Primo and Epico are both talented stars, but no matter what their gimmick, they've always had trouble connecting with the fans. The same can't be said for former Intercontinental Champion Carlito, who happens to be Primo's brother and Epico's cousin. Even though he was never a main event star, Carlito was capable in the ring and had a charisma that meant fans typically cared about him - especially when he was a heel.

Since being released from WWE in 2010, Carlito has largely worked in Puerto Rico. There have been impasses when it comes to a WWE return, but if he can prove he's gotten personal issues under control and WWE offers the right money, there's nothing standing in the way. After that, Carlito, Primo, and Epico can join the company's thriving six-man tag scene.


16. Nunzio

Nunzio Juventud Guerrera 2005 No Mercy.jpg
WWE.com

As Little Guido, James Maritato spent over a decade in ECW, helping give the promotion a reputation not just as a hardcore wrestling paradise, but as a place where talented stars could ply their trade as wrestlers. The Billy Robinson-trained Guido may have had a comedy gimmick, but he still got to show what he could do in the ring.

In WWE, he was reintroduced as Nunzio, but he still had the same Italian-American stereotype gimmick. He reformed the Full Blooded Italians stable with Johnny Stamboli and Chuck Palumbo, then captured the Cruiserweight Title twice. He joined the ECW brand when it was revived in 2006, then was released in 2008.

That was it for Nunzio in WWE - apart from a brief run as a referee from 2010 to 2011. Still, Maritato continues wrestling to this day, and though he's in his mid-40s, his highly-technical, submission-based style ensures that he can compete at a high level despite his age. Nunzio could easily return to WWE as an undercard talent, working with up-and-coming stars to help them improve.


15. Joey Mercury

JOEY MERCURY
WWE.com

Unlike almost every other star on this list, Joey Mercury already works for WWE. He's been a producer for the company for the last several years, and from 2014 to 2015, he and Jamie Noble made a return to TV as Seth Rollins's bodyguards, J&J Security. They were largely cannon fodder for Rollins's babyface opponents.

During Mercury's original run with the company, though, he was one of the best workers in WWE. As part of MNM, he and Johnny Nitro became three-time WWE Tag Team Champions, and while Nitro always seemed to be the more pushed of the pair (and was considered a future star), Mercury was the ring general. When the team split, Mercury was never pushed, but his matches were still excellent.

Though he debuted nearly 20 years ago, Mercury is still a month shy of his 37th birthday. His run last year showed that he's still capable of taking the bumps associated with pro wrestling, and odds are he still knows what it takes to make a great match. Though the J&J gimmick damaged his credibility, introducing him under a mask would solve that problem.


14. Percy Watson

Percy Watson
WWE

Many WWE stars have been called up to the main roster and given a terrible gimmick by the creative team, one which dooms them to failure. As frustrating as that can be, it's even worse when men and women spend years in development, then get cut without even getting the chance to compete in front of a larger audience.

That's what happened to Percy Watson, who was first signed to WWE in 2009. He was part of the cast of the second season of NXT, but he was one of the few contestants who didn't get a shot on the main roster. While Husky Harris and Michael McGillicutty would join The Nexus and Alex Riley and Titus O'Neal would eventually find their own way, Watson returned to NXT when it became a developmental territory. In 2013, he was released.

Watson has continued to wrestle since then, and another shot - or a first shot - in WWE could lead to his breakout. After four years of development, he's earned it.


13. Low Ki

Kaval WWE Survivor Series 2010
WWE.com

Speaking of the second season of NXT, it was that run which completely cemented the competition as a joke. Independent star Low Ki filled the role Daniel Bryan had in season one, making him the experienced world-class talent who needed to learn to show personality (or was chosen to be humiliated, depending on your perspective). As Kaval, Low Ki was mentored by Michelle McCool and Layla El.

Kaval ended up winning the entire competition, then suffered repeated losses on the main roster. He earned a spot on the Smackdown team at Bragging Rights 2010, but lost it to Tyler Reks. In the title shot he earned from winning NXT, he lost to Intercontinental Champion Dolph Ziggler. Less than four months after his NXT win, he was released.

It was Low Ki's size which held him back, but things have changed in the company. Men like Neville and Austin Aries have been allowed to show their talent despite their height, and if Low Ki is willing to come back to the company, WWE would be wise to give him the same opportunity.


12. Stevie Richards

Stevie Richards WWE
WWE.com

Stevie Richards has almost 25 years of experience in the ring, but the 44-year-old star is ageless. He proved that last year in a surprise return to Ring of Honor and valiant runs at Jay Lethal and Roderick Strong.

WWE fans would likely react well to Richards, as not only is he an ECW original, but he spent nearly a decade with Vince McMahon's promotion. He debuted during the Attitude Era as a comedy character who would dress like other stars, but he soon became one of the most hated heels in the company when, as Steven Richards, he formed the Parents' Television Council-inspired Right to Censor. Richards wasn't pushed, but he was hated.

When the RTC disbanded, Richards stayed an undercard heel, only turning face when ECW was brought back. At that point, Richards played the veteran underdog, still losing matches but getting a great reaction when doing so. He was released in 2008 and has been active since.

Given that Richards can still go and is guaranteed a good reaction, there's no reason for WWE to overlook him. Odds are he won't be challenging Roman Reigns, but he can still be a valued part of the roster.


11. Zach Gowen

zach gowen matt hardy
WWE.com

Zach Gowen was only 20 when he debuted in WWE, but as a one-legged cancer survivor, the company knew they had a ready-made underdog. Unfortunately, Gowen was pushed too hard and too soon, and fans lost interest during his feuds with Vince McMahon and Brock Lesnar. He developed addiction issues and reportedly had a bad attitude, and in 2004, he was released from the company.

Gowen never gave up, though, and in the years since his firing, the 33-year-old has improved by leaps and bounds. He's also overcome his demons. His work across a variety of independent promotions has earned him a great deal of praise, and if he gets re-signed, a wiser Gowen and more judicious booking could lead to success.

The star is also currently receiving some attention in the mainstream media, as he recently competed on American Ninja Warrior. The show features an ultra-difficult obstacle course through which contestants must navigate, and Gowen's disability made his attempt all the more inspiring. Though he didn't complete the course, his impressive showing has earned him another 15 minutes of fame. WWE would be wise to strike while the iron is hot.


10. Melina

Melina 2
WWE.com

There aren't too many women's stars from the mid-to-late 2000s who are still wrestling. A lot of the women around whom the division was built - Beth Phoenix, Candice Michelle, Kelly Kelly, and Michelle McCool - have been out of wrestling for years. The one outlier, though, is perhaps the most successful star of the era - two-time Divas' Champion and three-time Women's Champion Melina.

Melina first came to WWE as the manager for MNM, but she soon began participating in matches. The former independent standout used a unique style that got a lot of attention, and while she wasn't as good as, say, Sasha Banks or Charlotte, she still made a fine centerpiece of the division. Like many of the female talent of the era, though, she was hurt by bad booking and repeated shifts in focus, and was released in 2011.

Though Melina retired from the ring in 2012, she returned to action in 2015, competing for Japanese promotion Stardom. If she's interested in a full-time comeback, and if WWE is interested in giving her a shot, the brand split presents a unique opportunity.


9. Brian Kendrick

brian kendrick hardcore holly
WWE.com

Like some of the other men and women on this list, Brian Kendrick has actually racked up multiple stints with WWE during his career. The then-23-year-old first joined WWE in 2002, using his independent wrestling name of Spanky. He briefly teamed with Paul London, but left the company in early 2004. The following year he was back under his real name and teaming with London once again. The two held the WWE Tag Team Titles for 11 months, and when London left the company, Kendrick was repackaged as a singles heel. It didn't last long, and in 2009, he was gone.

Following his release from WWE, Kendrick worked for TNA and New Japan Pro Wrestling. He was also highly critical of WWE in interviews and that - combined with rumors that he was repeatedly fined for using marijuana during his tenure with the company - made a comeback look unlikely. Nevertheless, he returned as a trainer in 2014 and has occasionally competed on NXT shows.

Earlier in the week, Kendrick was announced as a competitor in the company's upcoming Cruiserweight Classic tournament. That could easily herald a full-time return to action for the 37-year-old, if he's interested.


8. Paul London

paul london.jpg
WWE.com

If Brian Kendrick's return to WWE was unlikely, Paul London's would be downright bizarre - but not impossible. Like Kendrick, the ultra-talented London could have been a huge star, but despite racking up a few title reigns during his tenure with the company (including a four-month run as Cruiserweight Champion), he was largely underutilized. Fans of Velocity likely remember London's classic series with Jimmy "Akio" Yang, but more casual viewers who only watched Smackdown may not have many memories of the star.

London was released in 2008 following a year of poor use that was rumored to be due to the fact that he smiled at Vince McMahon during a serious TV angle. London confirmed those rumors in subsequent interviews, and painted a very vivid picture of just how unhappy he was with the politics in WWE. He relayed stories of run-ins with the likes of McMahon, Triple H, Chris Benoit, and Jamie Noble, and as recently as last month, mentioned how miserable he was in the company.

Is it possible that things have changed? Is it possible that the backstage environment would be better for London now than it was when he left? There's no telling, but from WWE's perspective, he's talented enough to warrant a phone call.


7. Damien Sandow

damien sandow
WWE.com

It's never too soon to admit you've made a mistake. Last month, WWE released several superstars, and while most - like Hornswoggle, Zeb Colter, and Santino Marella - weren't of any real use to the company, others were missed opportunities. The most surprising name on the list was Damien Sandow, who had remained a hugely-popular star despite a year without a real storyline.

Sandow joined the company in 2012 as a snooty intellectual, and his microphone work made him a hated heel. In 2014, though, the former Money in the Bank winner shifted gears and became The Miz's stunt double. Though ostensibly still a bad guy, his impersonations of the former WWE Champion were so amusing that he became hugely popular. Miz got jealous, Sandow stood up for himself... and then lost their showdown.

After that, there was nothing for the star to do. He began to imitate Randy Savage, but that went nowhere. His television appearances became more seldom, but he still got great reactions - including at WrestleMania 32. Sandow was admittedly disappointed with the way his career ended, but WWE has the chance to undo their mistake. With two rosters in need of filling, Sandow would be a great addition to Raw or Smackdown.


6. Daivari

shawn Davari
WWE.com

Despite a reputation from the indies as a good worker, the diminutive Shawn Daivari was brought into WWE as a manager - specifically as a manager for Muhammad Hassan. That gimmick didn't last long, but it made Daivari a hated heel to the WWE Universe. He would go on to manage Kurt Angle and The Great Khali during main-event programs for both men.

After his managerial tenure ended, Daivari spent a bit of time as a wrestler, but he struggled against opponents like Paul London and Brian Kendrick and was unable to stake a claim to the Cruiserweight Championship. After a brief feud with Jim Duggan on Raw, he was released from the company.

Daivari was praised for his microphone work and his dedication to wrestling, but he never got a chance to really show what he could do in the ring. Since his firing, he's competed on the indies and done work for TNA, ROH, and Lucha Underground, keeping his skills sharp. His younger brother has been announced for the Cruiserweight Classic, so maybe the time is right for the 32-year-old Daivari to return (minus the "evil foreigner" gimmick).


5. MVP

mvp wrestler.jpg
WWE.com

MVP debuted on Smackdown in 2006 and before long, he made a huge impact. He won the United States Championship from Chris Benoit and proceeded to hold it for nearly a year, and during that reign, a partnership with Matt Hardy produced a run with the WWE Tag Team Titles. Like most of the stars on this list, though, bad booking cost him momentum. A losing streak gimmick did him no favors, and even another U.S. Title run and a face turn didn't help him. In 2010, he requested his release from WWE.

MVP then started working for New Japan Pro Wrestling, becoming the first-ever IWGP Intercontinental Champion. He stayed with the group for two years, then joined TNA for a run. An association with Lucha Underground ended prematurely, and MVP is available again.

When he left WWE, the rumor was that the door was open for an eventual return. If the company is looking for former stars, MVP should be at the top of the list. His work in WWE was always top notch, and the thought of him tearing it up with some of the stars of the new era is too attractive to pass up.


4. Trish Stratus

Trish Stratus
WWE.com

Trish Stratus first came to WWE in 2000 as the manager for Test and Albert, but before long, she began training for a career in the ring. At the 2001 Survivor Series, she captured the vacant WWE Women's Championship, kicking off a run that saw her improve dramatically. By the time Stratus retired in 2006, she was a seven-time Women's Champion and synonymous with the term "WWE Diva."

Trish has come back for a couple of bouts here and there, including one at WrestleMania 27, and she was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2013, but she's largely kept away from the business. Still, Stratus herself has talked about the door being open for some sort of return. In recent interviews, she's expressed interest in both a run as a heel manager or one more singles match with either Sasha Banks or Natalya.

Even in a limited capacity, a return by Stratus would be huge news. Either as a manager or as a wrestler, she could put a spotlight on an up-and-coming talent and boost several careers in the bargain.


3. Rob Van Dam

Rob Van Dam thumbs 2002
WWE.com

When Rob Van Dam came to WWE following the closure of ECW, he took the company by storm. Even though the Invasion angle was a flop, RVD became one of the most popular men in the promotion. Nevertheless, WWE refused to strike while the iron was hot. They kept Van Dam in the midcard and in tag teams, finally putting the title on him in 2006. That reign came to an abrupt end when RVD was arrested for possession of marijuana, and his push never returned. The next year, he left the company.

Van Dam made a much-hyped comeback to WWE in 2013, but as he was only going to be around for a limited time, the company didn't invest heavily in him. A poorly-booked feud with Alberto Del Rio produced some good matches, but did little else. RVD came back for another run in 2014 to muted fanfare.

RVD has been critical of how his recent returns to the company went, but with two separate rosters, it's possible that the former WWE Champion could find himself in a better spot. Like Chris Jericho, Van Dam could reinvent himself and get other stars over in the process, and either Raw or Smackdown would benefit greatly.


2. Goldberg

goldberg wwe
WWE.com

Goldberg was one of WCW's top stars, but his WWE tenure was less memorable. During his year with the company, he was never used to his full potential. It seemed like WWE's decision-makers were more concerned with making him look inferior to Triple H than they were with making money.

There was antipathy on both sides after Goldberg's contract ended, with "Da Man" specifically vocal about how much he hated his time in WWE. Over the years, though, his tone softened - citing an interest in performing for his young son, he said he was open to returning to the company if the money was right. Still, those in power (specifically Triple H) didn't seem interested in doing business with him.

Something's changed as of late, as last month, the company revealed that Goldberg would be featured prominently in the upcoming WWE 2K17 video game. That has sparked rumors about a return to the ring.

Goldberg, who has stayed in great shape, has mentioned that he could come back for another run if he wanted - one involving "50 matches," in his own words. If WWE coughs up the cash, Goldberg is theirs - let's just hope they'd use him right.


1. Kurt Angle

Kurt Angle 2004
WWE.com

Kurt Angle's tenure with WWE was marked by hills and valleys. He was one of the fastest-rising stars in company history, and within a year of his debut he was a main-eventer for life. He could be counted upon to play any role, and his matches were always top-notch. At the same time, though, he racked up numerous injuries and developed an addiction to painkillers that ultimately ended his WWE tenure.

In the ten years since his departure, he's become a multi-time champion in TNA, and while his drug issues seem to be under control, his injuries have only gotten worse. His physical condition has kept WWE from pursuing him in recent years, despite Angle's own admission that he's interested in a return to the company.

Angle doesn't have to wrestle to be an asset to WWE, though. Reprising his old role as Smackdown's General Manager would be the perfect use of the star, and would kick off the new Smackdown on a newsworthy note. Plus, if he can get cleared for one more match, a WrestleMania showdown against Brock Lesnar would be a major selling point for the show.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott Fried is a Slammy Award-winning* writer living and working in New York City. He has been following/writing about professional wrestling for many years and is a graduate of Lance Storm's Storm Wrestling Academy. Follow him on Twitter at https://twitter.com/scottfried. *Best Crowd of the Year, 2013