20 Spookiest Ever Wrestling Characters

Witch doctors, escaped convicts, undead zombies, evil clowns and more...

Professional wrestling lends itself well to melodrama. The very definition of that word is, "a sensational, dramatic piece with exaggerated characters and exciting events intended to appeal to the emotions". Reading that sentence makes it clear the word goes hand-in-hand with the industry. Indeed, it almost reads like Vincent Kennedy McMahon's vision for what wrestling should be. Long before McMahon was dreaming about a grander plan for WWE, there were creepy characters in wrestling. Of course, there are those infamous ones that made a splash in the company. This article aims to explore 20 of the most prominent examples. Not all of these people went on to become WWF/WWE stars, but that doesn't invalidate their claims of being amongst the most scary to ever grace the ring. Many names will be familiar, but it could be in the ones many younger fans don't know about that the real spooky vibes sit. That fear of the unknown is what many of these names used during their careers. From shaman witch doctors and evil clowns, to those who follow the occult and others who threaten to carve opponents limb from limb, they're all here. There's no end to the spooky atmosphere surrounding these characters, and that's what makes them so perfect for examination during the Halloween season. There are even some choices thrown in out of left field, making this quite the menagerie of menace. This is definitely one of the spookiest collection of characters ever to be assembled!

20. Gene Snitsky

What better way to kick this list off than with a baby-kicking deviant who also happens to have a foot fetish? Gene Snitsky may not be the most immediate choice for wrestling fans discussing the most spooky, but he certainly had his moments. Debuting mainly to interfere in the ongoing romance saga between Kane, Lita and Matt Hardy, Snitsky caused Lita to have a miscarriage on his very first Raw appearance in 2004. During a match against Kane on the program, Snitsky hit his rival with a steel chair, causing him to topple onto the Diva. In storyline, this killed the child, which is definitely a harrowing angle for a wrestling show. According to the man himself, Snitsky was only supposed to work one night on Raw, specifically for the miscarriage story. WWE officials liked his performance so much that he was kept around. Later, the character would develop a love of women's feet. Not so strangely, this failed to get him over with the fans, who were utterly baffled by what creative were trying to achieve. Throughout his entire run, there was something unnerving about Gene Snitsky, especially when he formed a tag-team with John Heidenreich, another nut. Heidenreich specified that he liked what Snitsky 'did to babies', harking back to the miscarriage angle.

19. Abdullah The Butcher

To this day, Larry Shreve has deep scars on his forehead from working as the wild man 'Abdullah The Butcher'. Taking part in some seriously violent and bloody matches, Abdullah was no stranger to the practice of blading during his bouts. By his own admission, the man didn't cut any corners - so to speak - when it came to doing so. Instead of risking a small blood flow, Abdullah genuinely carved his flesh. So wide were the cuts that he was even able to place gambling chips from casinos in between them. Obviously, this is a gruesome image, but it pales in comparison to some of the things Abdullah The Butcher practiced during his crazy brawls across the globe. For example, it wasn't uncommon for him to make use of forks to draw blood, legitimately sticking them into the foreheads of his opponents. Upon Abdullah's induction into the WWE Hall Of Fame in 2011, 'Superstar' Billy Graham asked to be removed from the hall. Graham explicitly stated that he didn't think a "bloodthirsty animal" like Shreve should have been inducted. This shows that even some of the man's peers were authentically grossed out by his antics, proving Abdullah belongs on this list.

18. Kevin Sullivan

In the mid-1990's, Kevin Sullivan was more commonly referred to as 'The Taskmaster' in World Championship Wrestling. Leading 'The Dungeon Of Doom' in their efforts to destroy Hulk Hogan, Sullivan's character was very cartoon-like. The same cannot be said for his work throughout the 1980's. A top heel in Florida, the guy was terrifying as part of the 'Army Of Darkness' stable. In the early-80's, wrestling was a very different world. Vince McMahon Jr hadn't yet undergone a radical transformation of the World Wrestling Federation, and thus business was great across many territories in North America. In Championship Wrestling From Florida, Kevin Sullivan played the gimmick of a devil worshiper, and it helped him get over hugely. Even though he was never the biggest wrestler, Sullivan had a unique chemistry about him. Names such as Jim Ross and even Steve Austin have spoken highly about Sullivan. In addition, before he passed on, the legendary 'American Dream' Dusty Rhodes said he enjoyed his feud in Florida with the man. Carrying snakes to the ring and threatening to disembowel opponents, Sullivan had fans hoping their babyface heroes could get rid of him. During one shoot interview, Sullivan laughed as he recalled the look of horror on people's faces anytime he appeared.

17. Gangrel

A blood-drinking vampire, the character of Gangrel had modest success in the WWF during the 'Attitude Era'. For years, David Heath had worked a similar gimmick away from the company. Known as the 'Vampire Warrior', the man honed his character and worked briefly under different guises for both WCW and ECW. In 1998, he was given the call by Vince Russo to work the persona in the WWF. Emerging amidst a ring of fire, Gangrel was bathed in red light. His haunting entrance music was menacing, and he carried with him a goblet full of blood. As if this wasn't creepy enough, the wrestler would perch on the ring steps and take a drink of the substance, before spitting it all over fans around ringside. Naturally, people recoiled, even though they knew the liquid wasn't actually plasma. Gangrel was huge in the development of stars such as Edge and Christian. Forming 'The Brood', the vampire gimmick served the trio well. One of the most spooky aspects of the character was the 'Blood Bath' stunt he'd perform. The lights would darken, and ghostly breathing would play over the PA. When the house lights came back up, a rival was dripping in blood. It was quite the striking visual, and just one reason why Gangrel was so effectively freaky.

16. Nailz

Kevin Wacholz wouldn't have the best end to his career with the WWF. Upset over apparent false promises from Vince McMahon, Wacholz legitimately attacked his boss, choking him out and supposedly threatening to kill him. There was no going back from that point, and the man was never seen again. For the short period he played the character of Nailz however, Wacholz terrified everybody for a different reason. Nailz was brought in specifically to feud with The Big Boss Man in the early-1990's. As a former corrections officer, the Boss Man had mistreated Nailz in prison - at least according to the criminal - and the ex-inmate wanted revenge. Of course, this was exactly the kind of hokey storyline fans had come to expect from the WWF, but Wacholz played the gimmick perfectly. Almost foaming at the mouth, he promised to hurt Boss Man and gain vengeance for how he had been treated. Coming across as a complete psychopath, Nailz was also aided by a cunning post-production trick by the WWF. Lowering and deepening his voice, the production staff added even more horror to the character. In interviews, his brutal tone made people's eyes widen, and he had the look of a man who could snap at any point.

15. 'Mad Dog' Vachon

The origins of the 'Mad Dog' character can be traced back to the early-1960's. Never an especially tall or remarkable looking man, Maurice Vachon nonetheless had fire about him. During one match in Portland, he started going wild, using various brawling techniques. When a policeman stepped in front of him, Vachon even hit the officer. Backstage, promoter Don Owen assessed that the grappler looked like "mad dog". Seeing money in the idea, Vachon decided to move away from standard wrestling nuances and carve his own legacy. Becoming the archetypal heel, 'Mad Dog' would bite, claw and attempt to maim his opponents. Many years later, the man himself would state that he revelled in the idea that people were very much afraid of him. Fans were deathly scared of what might happen anytime Vachon appeared, which was very lucrative for the guy. Just like Freddie Blassie before him, Vachon filed some of his teeth to a point, and would do the same with his fingernails. This added a visual threat to his performances, and fans desperately wanted to see the villain get his comeuppance. Right up until he retired in the mid-80's, Vachon kept his real life personality separate from his wrestling one. This helped the 'Mad Dog' character become legend.

14. The Sheik

There was a lot of mystique surrounding Ed Farhat's character of The Sheik. The original idea for the gimmick was that he was a wealthy businessman from Syria, who hurt people simply because he could. There's something chilling about that concept, and pro wrestling fans agreed. The Sheik was notorious for refusing to break submission holds, rather being disqualified than doing so. Farhat manufactured a guise that was so reckless and only interested in causing pain. During matches, it was common to see him use everyday items such as pencils to stab opponents. Of course, babyfaces would often gain possession of the pencil, jabbing it into The Sheik's own forehead. Much like several others on this list, Sheik was therefore left with many scars on his face. It's a real credit to The Sheik's aura as a villain that fans loved seeing him get some of his own medicine. Even when Bruno Sammartino mauled his arm with a sharp pen, people went wild. This was payback for all the punishment Sheik had handed out. The fact the character rarely spoke also only upped the creep factor. Blood and violence were his languages, and the gimmick became infamous as a result.

13. Bray Wyatt

The most modern example of a spooky character on this list, Bray Wyatt nonetheless belongs in this company. As 'Husky Harris', Windham Rotunda was going nowhere in the WWE system. Making the bold decision to reinvent himself in 2012, Rotunda created the guise of Bray Wyatt. Appearing as a foreboding preacher who warned about the 'end of all things to come', Wyatt also unnervingly talked about 'Sister Abigail'. Now, he's known as 'The New Face Of Fear' on the main roster. Quickly outgrowing the NXT developmental system, Wyatt was shunted up the ladder onto shows like Raw and Smackdown in 2013. Since then, he has thrived, becoming known as one of the better promo men under contract. Talking with real confidence, Wyatt's hushed delivery can often be chilling. There's a cult-like vibe to The Wyatt Family. Bray is the leader, brainwashing the likes of Luke Harper and Braun Strowman. Mind games will become more prevalent as this list progresses, but Wyatt is the most current user of that tactic on WWE television. His general appearance is creepy enough, but look at the faces of adults in the front few rows when he performs his upside down spider-style walk. That's genuine fear.

12. Ox Baker

How many pro wrestlers carry a stretcher to the ring with them? Not many, but that was a tactic employed by Ox Baker throughout his career. The idea was simple, Baker was coming to mutilate opponents to the point that they would require the stretcher to leave the arena. His catchphrase was also relatively straightforward, being nothing more than, "I love to hurt people". A star during his prime, Ox worked everywhere from the WWWF and the NWA, to the AWA and even the World Wrestling Council in Puerto Rico. A bald head and distinctive facial hair helped Baker stand out, as did the way he'd wax his eyebrows before performances. Curving upwards, the brows added a lot more menace to the wrestler's appearance, making clear his heelish intentions. Ox Baker's finishing move was designed to elicit maximum sympathy from the watching audience. Known as the Heart Punch, the move literally did as it described. During promos, Baker would routinely state that his rival wouldn't be going home to their family, because he'd stop their heart with one strike. This created a lot of fear around the man, who deserves recognition as one of wrestling's greatest ever villains.

11. The Great Kabuki

Certain wrestling enthusiasts may remember The Great Kabuki from the WWF Royal Rumble in 1994. That was the man's only real in-ring appearance for the company, but he was also one of the heels responsible for taking out The Undertaker during his match against Yokozuna. As memorable as that appearance was, it was in World Class Championship Wrestling that Kabuki really spooked people. The Great Kabuki came from the mind of Gary Hart. The manager gifted the gimmick to the incoming young Japanese wrestler, Akihisa Mera. To his immense credit, Mera took the persona and very much made it his own. People were impressed, yet also wary, of his skills with nunchuks before matches. Further to that, the mask he wore, surrounded by fiery red hair, was a ghoulish, threatening sight. Once the mask came off, Kabuki wore horrific facepaint. As if things couldn't be scarier, he also covered much of his face with his hair, looking not unlike something people may acquaint with a Japanese horror movie. The Great Kabuki revolutionised the idea of Japanese wrestlers using 'mist' to blow into the faces of opponents, another horrific trend that frightened people.

10. Mankind

Vince McMahon's initial idea for Mick Foley in the WWF was to call him 'Mason The Mutilator'. Foley was not a fan, fearing that he could go the same way as the likes of Mantaur or Phantasio in the promotion and be hampered with a terrible gimmick. Agreeing to wear the mask McMahon proposed, Foley instead came up with the idea of calling the character 'Mankind', and nothing else. At first, officials were frosty on the premise, but allowed Foley to debut under the name. Due to his incredible passion for performing, Mankind became arguably the character the man is best known for, even topping Cactus Jack. One original trope for Mankind was that he was a childhood genius, yet had a terrible need to hurt people. The phrase, 'doesn't play well with others' summed up Foley's view for the guise. Mankind grew into one of the best-loved characters on WWF television, but it was genuinely freaky at first. Aligned with Paul Bearer and chasing The Undertaker, Mankind would tear at his own hair and scream loudly at both the fans and the camera. The character lived in a boiler room, only adding to the chill factor surrounding him. It's remarkable that Foley was able to take such a scary gimmick and turn it into a cherished babyface.

9. Doink The Clown

Many people have an irrational fear of circus clowns. In fact, almost everybody sees something legitimately terrifying behind the garish, colourful face paint and outfits clowns wear. There's also genius, especially when it comes to the world of professional wrestling. It's been said that it was actually Road Warrior Hawk who first envisioned the idea of a heel wrestling clown. The idea was perfect for Matt Osborne. A talented wrestler in his own right, Osborne needed something special to help him stand out from the crowd in the jam-packed WWF. Debuting in 1992, the man was known as Doink The Clown. Smoking a cigar and playing tricks on the audience, Doink was tremendously eerie during his first appearances. His music didn't hurt, being a cacophony of screams and laughter. It's been said that Osborne actually wanted to take the gimmick further than it went. Proposing Doink become even darker and feud with The Undertaker, he was sadly also going through a lot of personal problems. These troubles would eventually lead to his departure from the company, and Doink was turned babyface. Played by various other wrestlers, it would never again be as vital as it was when rogue.

8. Goldust

Unlike many others on this list, Dustin Runnels didn't use obvious fear tactics to make Goldust a success. Instead, the man played off homophobia and utilised mind games to unnerve people. Incredibly, the character was so powerful when it first arrived in the WWF, that many wrestlers had reservations about working with Runnels. Scott Hall was one of those people, more than a little weirded out by the 'Bizarre One'. Adorned in a platinum blonde wig and decked out in resplendent gold outfits, Goldust was the very definition of a wrestling freak. Speaking in riddles about his connection to Hollywood, he wasn't adverse to rubbing his hands all over himself and using sexual overtones to rattle rivals. Again, this was something Hall was apparently uncomfortable with, being 'touched up' by Goldust. Blowing kisses at the crowd and threatening to 'come out there and personally kiss' the fans, Runnels played the gimmick to a tee. Eventually, he'd turn babyface, but the initial appearances still stand tall as some of the most ominous in WWE history. It was impossible for people to turn their attention from the man, Goldust was entirely different to anything else many fans had ever seen.

7. Kamala

Towards the end of his run in the WWF, Kamala was cast as a well-meaning babyface looking to integrate himself into normal society. Rescued by the Reverend Slick, the character was popular as a mid card good guy. Before that, 'The Ugandan Giant' was a freakish beast who favoured cooking people in a pot and eating them. The cannibalistic Kamala was hair-raising, because Jim Harris, the man behind the character, was awesome at playing it. Incredibly, it was Jerry 'The King' Lawler who helped create the gimmick. Realising that Harris wasn't the best in-ring worker and lacked amazing verbal skills, the persona of Kamala was designed to help him succeed. It really did exactly that, and led to a run in the WWF. Signed in 1984, fans were alarmed to see the face-painted behemoth strolling down to ringside. Slapping his belly and gurning for the cameras, Kamala's cause was helped by announcers like Gorilla Monsoon. The commentator brilliantly outlined the dangerous nature of the wrestler, covering up for his lack of proper wrestling ability with comments about his background. Fans were terrified of Kamala, because cannibalism is such a taboo (and scary) subject.

6. The Boogeyman

Marty Wright very nearly never made it to WWE, due to lying about his real age on one episode of Tough Enough. The age limit for the competition was 35, but Wright was actually 40. Nonetheless, he informed company management that he was 35, and it caused him to be cut from the show. Despite this, he was eventually signed, and went on to play the bloodcurdling character of The Boogeyman. A take off of the 'Bogeyman' character that has scared children for generations, the gimmick had a lot in common with a later witch doctor-style guise on this list. The general gist of The Boogeyman was that he'd show up unannounced, playing on the fears of other wrestlers. In a gross piece of decision-making, Wright even chowed down on live worms whilst performing under the persona, which was grotesque. Striking face paint and ghastly movements were huge parts of The Boogeyman's success. He'd gyrate in a grim fashion, moving his limbs explosively and chanting out children's nursery rhymes as he did so. The Boogeyman made his debut in 2005, during an era when WWE were obsessed by realism. For that very reason, he appeared more nightmarish.

5. Seven

As creepy as Goldust was, it wasn't even the most sinister character played by Dustin Runnels. Admittedly, the gimmick was cut short by a baffling piece of 'worked shoot' storytelling by World Championship Wrestling. In 1999, vignettes started to air for the new character, known simply as Seven. Standing outside a child's bedroom window, Runnels wore ghostly white facepaint. Dressing in similar fashion to The Undertaker, Seven literally floated to the ring during his first appearance on Monday Nitro. It was a shocking way to debut, and there was intrigue surrounding where Runnels and WCW would take things. In predictable fashion, the company spoiled the entire thing by having the wrestler cut a promo tearing down the idea of portraying the character. Just like that, Seven vanished. For the brief period he existed on WCW television however, he was undeniably spooky. Top brass in the promotion feared people would label Seven a child snatcher, should he continue staring through bedroom windows at kids. That's understandable, but it's still a shame fans never got to see what Runnels could have made of the gimmick. There was something horrid - in an interesting way - about the entire concept.

4. Paul Bearer

Even though Paul Bearer was smaller in height even than most fans, many would have likely chosen to stay away from the portly pale manager if they had the chance. Introduced in February, 1991, Bearer began managing The Undertaker. Very quickly, he became utterly essential to 'Taker's gimmick. Doing most of the talking, Paul had a high-pitched voice that was suitably haunting. Carrying an urn, said to be containing the source of Undertaker's power, everywhere he went, Bearer excelled in the role. When The Undertaker was a heel, there were few who had better facial expressions and mannerisms than the manager. Even when 'Taker started to turn babyface, there was still something creepy about the funeral worker. His shrill delivery was malign, and he just came across as a wholly strange dude. Eventually, Bearer would turn on Undertaker and align himself with the likes of Mankind and The Executioner. A rebirth of sorts was experienced when Kane was introduced, giving Bearer an altogether more evil personality. Dying his hair black for the role, the guy also used white makeup to make his face more pasty. Everything added together to make a package that was grisly.

3. Papa Shango

Long before The Boogeyman, there was Papa Shango. Charles Wright (no relation to Marty) was recommended to Vince McMahon by The Undertaker, and he ended up playing a similar supernatural character in the promotion. As time would tell, Shango didn't have the lengthiest of runs in the company, but he is still remembered to this day. Debuting in 1992, there was just something compelling about the character. Papa Shango was a witch doctor who possessed opponents, it was classic early-90's WWF drama. Looking like something pulled out of a nightmare, the wrestler had ghoulish face paint and carried a smoking skull to the ring with him. The look was based off of Baron Samedi, a Haitian practitioner of Voodoo. Known as 'The Master Of The Dead', Samedi was ripe for influence, and Wright used a lot of nuances associated with the Loa. Infamously, Papa Shango caused The Ultimate Warrior to start convulsing. From there, Warrior started vomiting, due to possession techniques the shaman had used on jobbers during his very first appearances. A huge man with big muscles and eye-catching tattoos, Wright should have experienced more success under the gimmick. Strangely, even though it was gone by 1993, Papa Shango still has an enduring legacy.

2. Kane

An entire generation of wrestling fans will recall looking on in awe as Kane made his presence felt. Making his first appearance at In Your House: Badd Blood in October, 1997, the masked man was instantly frightening. Interrupting the first ever Hell In A Cell bout between Shawn Michaels and The Undertaker, Kane hammered the latter with a Tombstone Piledriver and cost him the match. Ripping the cell door clean off, Kane came across as an indestructible monster. During the early months of the character's introduction, the WWF did a grand job of making the gimmick a terrifying demon. When the lights dimmed and the arena was bathed in dark red, there was a sense of foreboding. Kane was on his way, and fans knew they were going to see destruction. Based on the Michael Myers character from the popular Halloween series of films, Kane also had a gruesome backstory. Burned severely in a fire said to be set by The Undertaker in his youth, there was a lot of mystique as to what Kane looked like underneath his mask. Time would change this original story significantly, but there were few more scary than 'The Big Red Machine' upon his debut.

1. The Undertaker

Today, The Undertaker isn't all that freaky. In the modern era, the character has become unique on the WWE landscape. Yes, 'Taker does still dress in black and emerge to funeral music, but he's simply regarded as a standalone legend in the company. Things couldn't have been more different when the gimmick was first conceived, The Undertaker was the scariest man in wrestling. Making his debut at the Survivor Series in 1990, Undertaker was said to be the 'Grim Reaper' of the WWF. Pasty white and walking slowly to the ring, children were instantly afraid whenever the guy was around. The original incarnation of the character was an undead zombie, one who could not be killed. Therefore, in the minds of many - child and adult alike - he could not be stopped. It was brilliantly simple, and unbelievably spooky. The funeral dirge that signalled his arrival on the scene sent chills running up and down the spines of everyone in attendance. The Undertaker just had an incredible presence, even in his most early showings. As aforementioned, the character would evolve into something entirely different, but that doesn't take away from the impact 'Taker had when he first arrived. What other spooky wrestling characters can you think of? What are your memories of the ones listed here? Let us know what you think down in the comments section below!

Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.