20 Times WWE Was An Absolute Mess In 2020

RETRIBUTION, Rey Mysterio's eyeball, Rowan's spider, and other stupid ideas from bad WWE creative.

Lana Bobby Lashley
WWE.com

You may consider 2020 to be a bad year for professional wrestling, a disaster, or indeed, an absolute mess, but Vince McMahon almost certainly does not.

The pandemic has been shockingly good for his company's bottom line. Trading the astronomical costs of a weekly road schedule for the stationary ThunderDome will help WWE to record-breaking profits this year, despite the ghoulish assertion that April's needless roster cuts were necessary to keep the group in the red (a claim proven false by Wrestlenomics' Brandon Thurston days later).

The current setup also allows McMahon to do something he has yearned for for years: control the narrative. When every crowd reaction is determined by a button beneath his fingertips, rogue audiences are a thing of the past. In replacing actual human beings with a soundboard, the WWE Chairman has become the dystopian overlord of an increasingly artificial Sports Entertainment world, operating without fear of in-arena backlash.

Fans will return, WWE will hit the road again (albeit on a reduced schedule), and the other parts of the Old Normal will come back as well, but while the average fan may feel deflated by COVID-era wrestling, Vince is too busy Scrooge McDucking.

WWE's financial reports are rock solid. Its product, however? For much of 2020, a shambles.

Let's relive some of the year's biggest disasterpieces...

20. Keith Lee's Fireball Facial

Keith Lee Fireball
WWE.com

NXT, once promoted as a workrate-centric alternative to Raw and SmackDown's wacky Sports Entertainment trappings, had Scarlett kiss a fireball onto Keith Lee and Karrion Kross' match contract, which then exploded in the NXT Champion's face as he tried to ink his signature.

Kross and Scarlett's presentation has been big, bombastic, and somewhat over the top since they arrived, but turning the duo into supernatural spellcasters? That's WrestleCrap, baby.

And yes, The Undertaker exists. We know this. Stop bringing the legendary 'Deadman's' name up as justification for every bad supernatural angle since his debut.


19. Lana Vs. The Table

Lana lol
WWE.com

Nia Jax driving Lana through the announce table for nine consecutive weeks was p*ss-funny, outside of whatever damage was being done to Lana's body by the clumsy 'Irresistible Force.'

The bit would have made it onto this list if not for WWE's justification, though, as it was reported that the promotion was systematically burying the former 'Ravishing Russian' as a way to get her over as a top babyface in the women's division.

WWE believes that having Lana repeatedly fall victim to one of the worst wrestlers on the roster would build surging support for her. Rather than doing this, they made themselves and Lana objects of ridicule.


18. Tank Girl

Shotzi Blackheart
WWE.com

Shotzi Blackheart is a charming performer whose wild, give-no-f*cks energy gives her unique presence in WWE, where everything is so safe, sanitised, and cynical. Her willingness to throw caution to the wind and throw everything into every performance will get her over huge in the future. For f*cks sake, the woman stapled her own chest to prepare for a match with Io Shirai.

She rules.

The tank gimmick most certainly does not, however. Before TakeOver: WarGames 2020, Blackheart, a grown woman, flew into a full-on temper tantrum because Candice LeRae, another grown woman, broke her toy tank.

Blackheart is 28 years old.

And she cried.

Over a broken.

Toy.

Tank.

NXT in 2020, ladies and gentlemen.


17. Erick Rowan's Spider

Erick Rowan
WWE.com

All that build, and the payoff was a wacky animatronic spider picked up from a toy store on the way to the arena? Incredible patter, really, and an early contender for Worst Storyline of the Decade.

Even funnier was Drew McIntyre smashing said animatronic spider to bits the very next week, which led to absolutely nothing.

"I think it's alive!", yelled Byron Saxton when the spider was unveiled, a few weeks after the thing had drawn blood by biting somebody on Raw.


16. Otis As Mr. Money In The Bank

Otis AJ Styles Money In The Bank 2020
WWE.com

A cute idea, this, but ultimately a step too far for a novelty midcard wrestler whose 2020 should have peaked with the well-played Mandy Rose storyline.

Otis capturing Rose's heart at WrestleMania 36 was an earnest feel-good moment in a dumpster fire of a year. He never should have won Money in the Bank, though. While the former Heavy Machinery man is a fun personality with good audience connection, him grabbing the briefcase was the equivalent of booking the Bushwackers for a lengthy run as Tag Team Champions. Having goofball comedy characters in the orbit of World Titles (and tickets to World Titles, like MITB) undermines them greatly: at MITB 2020, WWE once again reduced the briefcase to a joke.

Things have scarcely improved since then, with Otis fading from the spotlight before dropping the case to The Miz, who is now booked like a glorified jobber on Raw. The clock is ticking ahead of his inevitable failed cash in.


15. The Plague Of Rubbish Cinematic Matches

WWE Extreme Rules 2020 Wyatt Swamp Fight Fire
WWE.com

Boneyard Match? A riot.

The Firefly Fun House? An unexpectedly deep, subversive dissection of one of WWE's most divisive characters.

Every cinematic match since then? A different shade of sh*t.

From the hokey Swamp Fight spookfest to the masturbatory, self-fellating "theatre" of One Last Beat, WWE has run the concept of cinematic wrestling matches into the ground, crushing something that could have drawn the right kind of interest for years had the company shown restraint. Instead, they spammed them to death.

Each new cinematic match yields increased diminishing returns for WWE, who have fortunately dialled back on them since summer.


14. The Dismantling Of Rhea Ripley

Rhea Ripley crying
WWE

An incredible late-2019 run established Rhea Ripley as one of the most believably badass wrestlers on WWE's roster and a unique force in the NXT women's division, setting her up for an incredible, career-best 2020.

Unfortunately, WWE dropped a bollock as the clock struck midnight on 1 January. Transformed from a take-no-sh*t hardnut with fire, presence, and a backbone, Ripley turned into the dreaded Generic WWE Babyface Champion through her feud with Charlotte Flair. All smiles, she gave off strong "I'm just happy to be here!" vibes when she should have stayed an ass-kicker.

Losing to 'The Queen' at WrestleMania 36 was recoverable with the right booking. Instead, WWE had Ripley responded by literally crying on a locker-room floor. Weeks later, her aura still in tatters, Rhea took the pin in a Triple Threat with Charlotte and Io Shirai.

Now, 12 months after felling Shayna Baszler to become NXT Women's Champion, Ripley has never felt so irrelevant.


13. Eyeball Stuff

Rey Mysterio eyeball
WWE

Really, the entire Horror Show at Extreme Rules pay-per-view could have slotted in here, so absolute were its messes, but we'll stick with the worst of the worst.

The only positive of Seth Rollins' extended feud with the Mysterio family was that it helped establish Dominik as a full-time televised performer. To reach that meagre accomplishment (Dom's athleticism and gumption would have gotten him over regardless), we had to wade through knee-high piss puddles like the Eye for an Eye match, which concluded when a comedy eyeball was popped from Rey's socket.

"It's out," mumbled Samoa Joe, spewing fake gravitas through your speakers.

It's not just that WWE promised a level of violence they couldn't realistically delivering heading into the pay-per-view, but also that the eyeball looked like a table tennis ball coloured in with felt-tip pen. Oh, and WWE undermined the stakes by having the bloody thing "heal" after the show.

Cool.


12. Running An Abusive Teacher Storyline After #SpeakingOut

Timothy Thatcher
WWE.com

In June, the beleaguered victims of professional wrestling's culture of abuse bravely came forth through the #SpeakingOut movement, pushing for change in an industry that had not only let them down, but systematically failed to protect them from vile, criminal abuse perpetrated by manipulative scumbags in positions of power. Many of these allegations came from former students whose trainers had used said power to inflict disgusting assault on their trainees.

This coincided with WWE opting to run the Thatch-as-Thatch-Can storyline in NXT, through which Timothy Thatcher inflicts ritual punishment on young hopefuls looking for a break in WWE.

The optics of this are objectively terrible. Even if #SpeakingOut wasn't in WWE's mind when putting the Thatcher idea together, it should have been abandoned straight away, though perhaps we shouldn't expect a company that still books and promotes Velveteen Dream and Riddle to show such self-awareness.


11. Shayna Baszler: Vampire

Shayna Baszler
WWE.com

Shayna Baszler arrived on WWE Raw by ambushing Becky Lynch in the ring, biting into the back of 'The Man's' neck to draw worked blood. Just like that, the shoot badass ostensibly became a vampire because lol, Vince McMahon

Open mockery followed. Here is USA Network hilariously using an example of it as promotional material during the following week's episode:-


10. Raw Underground

RAW Underground Shane McMahon
WWE.com

The great Japanese shoot-style promotions of the '80s and '90s died for a reason. As visceral, realistic, and intricate as peak Battlarts and UWFI bouts were, there wasn't a sustainable market for such products long-term.

So why WWE tried to revive this in 2020 is anyone's guess.

The idea was impossible to start with. "Gritty" doesn't work through WWE's lens, because WWE's lens is the total opposite of the word. Underground was never going to capture the feeling it was looking for, and while the likes of Arturo Ruas and Dabba-Kato at least felt fresh, the quality of work just wasn't there, with matches playing out like Battlarts tribute pantomime performed by bad, unconvincing actors.

Shane McMahon, the man with the worst worked punches in wrestling history, hosted this "underground fight club."

That's like asking Will Ospreay to host a seminar on good social media practices.


9. Rob Gronkowski's Existence

Rob Gronkowski Mojo Rawley King Corbin
WWE.com

WhatCulture's Michael Sidgwick called Rob Gronwkowki's wrestling sojourn "the worst WWE career ever" earlier this year. He was right.

Signed in March, Gronko was gone by June, opting to join the NFL's Tampa Bay Buccaneers rather than continuing his experimental run as a wrestler. In fairness, it's hard to begrudge any athlete with experience working for another professional sporting institution for catching one whiff of Vince McMahon's mania and fleeing the carnival, but regardless, the run was a farce.

An obnoxious, unlikeable jock from the moment he first danced out on SmackDown, Gronk hung out with Mojo Rawley, wore sh*tty jackets, "dived" from a raised platform at WrestleMania 36, won the 24/7 Championship, and quit while still holding the belt.

So much for the "one big, crazy match" the NFL tight end claimed he wanted to work.


8. Ninjas!

Akira Tozawa 24/7 Title
WWE

Imagine casting a Japanese man as the leader of a comedy ninja clan on professional wrestling television in 2020.

In fact, imagine being a WWE writer, taking a wrestler who got over huge as a human charisma machine in Dragon Gate, and deciding that the best way to give him "character" was this.

Hackneyed, jingoistic toot, and it came just a few weeks after the equally gross "roman noodle Moonsault" incident.


7. Ivar Gets Eaten By A Bin Monster

Street Profits Viking Raiders
WWE.com

On the night Akira Tozawa's ninja group was born, the Street Profits and Viking Raiders battled the crew in a woeful cinematic effort as an extension of their ongoing Raw Tag Team Championship feud.

The "match" culminated in Ivar, Erik, Montez Ford, and Angelo Dawkins all falling into a skip, awaking a bin monster that had them fleeing for their lives, with the implication that poor Ivar was on the verge of being devoured whole.

Months later, Tozawa himself was gobbled by a shark on Raw.

Jesus f*cking Christ.


6. Lana, Bobby, & Rusev

lana bobby lashley rusev liv morgan wedding
wwe.com

That the storyline that effectively spelt the end of Rusev's WWE run spilt over from 2019 into 2020 was bad enough, as this "love square" was an objectionable shambles from start to finish, but the damage done to each of its participants puts it over the top.

It took the fantastic Hurt Business stable to save Bobby Lashly from the muck as WWE spent months bumbling the giant powerhouse into a role as the second most important personality in his relationship. Liv Morgan was introduced as an apparent lesbian fling then completely forgotten about. Rusev vanished from television soon after, failed again by a broken creative team, while Lana was quickly cast aside by Lashley when MVP came calling.

Wedding angles generally pop ratings, but let's hope WWE never tries anything like this ever again.


5. Dog Sh*t

King Corbin The Usos Roman Reigns
WWE.com

Speaking of programs that should never have bled into 2020, what an omnishambles the extended Roman Reigns vs. Baron Corbin feud was.

With its sleepy and unengaging matches, laughable dog food payoff, and one of the worst versions of Reigns' babyface character ever prevented, there wasn't a single positive moment among this storyline's offerings this year. Not one.

Thank God for the 'Tribal Chief's' reinvention.


4. Drink Up, Fella

Jeff Hardy Sheamus Urine Pee
WWE.com

Exploiting a performer's real-life addictions for storyline heat is unquestionably tasteless, regardless of whether or not said performer publically claims that he is cool with it or not, as there will be thousands of people watching at home who have suffered from similar afflictions feeling justifiably put out by WWE's cack-handed portrayal. Crass, tasteless, and without merit, grabbing this low-hanging fruit puts heat on the writers, not the heel.

The Sheamus vs. Jeff Hardy feud was particularly awful and hit a low with the piss test segment, in which Sheamus made Hardy, a recovering alcoholic, provide a urine sample before he'd agree to face him. Minutes later, the 'Celtic Wearing' was wearing said pee.

Off-camera, Vince McMahon was probably laughing himself hoarse.


3. The Use Of Bill Goldberg

WWE Super ShowDown 2020 Goldberg Bray Wyatt
WWE.com

That Bill Goldberg still pops quarter-hour numbers and generates interest for his returns means WWE should keep booking him, at least until it stops making business sense. Still, their use of the former WCW Champion was calamitous in 2020.

Say what you will about Bray Wyatt and his 'Fiend' character, but the gimmick was hugely popular at the time of Super ShowDown 2020, with online fans particularly vocal in their support and merchandise flying off the shelves. The whole deal was over. Booking the murder clown in a murdersquash loss to a 53-year-old in steep decline (for the Universal Championship!) was therefore a terrible idea that should never have escaped the creative room.

The silver lining to this grey cloud was Goldberg's feud with Roman Reigns, which started with suitable intensity until the pandemic prompted Reigns to remove himself from television. Wyatt, meanwhile, hadn't looked so useless since his 'Eater of Worlds' days.


2. Actually, Just Super ShowDown In General

WWE Super ShowDown 2020 The Undertaker AJ Styles
WWE.com

Was this the worst show WWE has ever held in Saudi Arabia? No, but lets at least consider the evidence:-

1. The absurd, boring, and drawn-out gauntlet match for the Tuwaiq Mountain Trophy, which the announcers ridiculously put over as a grand, prestigious prize, despite it not even existing until a few weeks before Super ShowDown. The Undertaker wasn't even supposed to be involved in the match but somehow booked himself to win, apparently inheriting General Manager powers from beyond. Stupid.

2. Kofi Kingston taking a ridiculous, career-shortening bump to the outside, needlessly, in a third-gear SmackDown Tag Team Title match with The Miz and John Morrison, to no pop.

3. The least interesting version of an Angel Garza vs. Humberto Carrillo singles match imaginable.

4. Uhh, apparently Seth Rollins and Murphy wrestled The Street Profits. Anyone remember that one? No? Okay, me neither.

5. Diminishing returns on Mansoor, who is a regular on these shows for the hometown pop, but got next to nothing for his efforts against Dolph Ziggler.

6. Ricochet, lol.

7. Roman Reigns and Baron Corbin working one of the safest and most pedestrian Steel Cage matches in WWE history.

8. The tedious "world-changing" narrative surrounding Bayley and Naomi, which was again presented as a sign of progress in a nation that only started allowing women to drive in 2018.

9. Bray Wyatt vs. Goldberg.

What say you, Jeff Goldblum?


1. RETRIBUTION. Just RETRIBUTION.

RETRIBUTION WWE
WWE

The worst-booked stable in modern WWE history (and maybe ever), RETRIBUTION have been an omnishambles from the moment they first arrived on Raw, throwing bricks through production room windows, fiddling with the lighting, and harmlessly setting fire to equipment in the parking lot.

These toothless, gurning idiots promised to bring WWE to its knees, but were completely ineffective in doing so. Coming off more like petulant schoolchildren rather than agents of chaos, the group were given ridiculous monickers, booked like goobers, and cut nonsensical, rambling promos, the likes of which we haven't seen since Bray Wyatt was at his absolute worst.

Mustafa Ali's unveiling as RETRIBUTION's leader could have sparked an upturn, but no. The stable was still being booked to lose. Fast-forward a few weeks and RETRIBUTION now looks set to split, with Ali publically admonishing Reckoning and Slapjack on consecutive episodes of Raw.

There's a whiff of a good idea in a group of aggrieved WWE castoffs banding together to smash the system, but RETRIBUTION ain't it, chief. While none of this is the fault of the performers (save T-Bar, Twitter's most gotten-to "I'm not owned!" meme), this stable needs to be given the Men In Black treatment. Hit us with that bright flash of light and pretend the whole thing never happened.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.