20 Worst Wrestlers In TNA History

TNAwful.

Tna Worst Wrestlers Feature
ImpactWrestling

I was, as I'm sure many of you reading this once were, a big fan of TNA wrestling. I was first introduced to TNA during the 'Asylum' years, when TNA taped weekly pay-per-views at the Nashville fairgrounds. Although some of it was pure trash, I was drawn to the cutting-edge X Division action and a few familiar faces from the past, such as Jeff Jarrett and Ken Shamrock. I then watched as TNA organically grew, moving on to getting a TV deal and taping at Universal Studios.

In 2005/06, I genuinely believed that TNA had the potential to become very successful and actually (at one point) felt as though TNA had a far more exciting roster of talent. Guys like Samoa Joe, AJ Styles, Christopher Daniels, Abyss, LAX, Monty Brown, and then Christian, Rhyno, and Kurt Angle and co. really made you want to watch the product from week to week.

Sadly, however, I began to lose interest and faith in TNA as the years went on, to the point where I stopped watching the product altogether. A lot of that had to do with the fact that they made some truly bizarre signings. Indeed, TNA became well-known for promoting guys and gals that had no business being near a wrestling ring, let alone wrestling on television and PPV. And while no promotion has a perfect track record when it comes to talent, TNA seemed to hire a lot of green, clueless, washed-up or otherwise useless performers.

These are, in my opinion, 20 of the absolute worst.


20. Puppet The Midget Killer

We kick things off with one of the worst wrestling names ever, 'Puppet the Midget Killer', who was himself an actual 'midget' (not exactly PC, but we're talking early 2000s TNA here so just go with it). Determined to establish themselves as low-rent Southern rasslin' right from the off, TNA of course featured a heavily-promoted midget division, which also included such luminaries as the obese Meatball and the hardcore Teo.

They were awful, but not quite as awful as Puppet. What was so bad about Puppet? Well, pretty much everything, but his masturbating into a trashcan pre-match and asking interviewer Goldylocks if she wanted some of his 'porridge' is probably up there with the worst. Other Puppet highlights include him pulling a gun on Jeff Jarrett (kayfabe) and 'wrestling' comedian/actor Tom Arnold. Mascarita Sagrada he ain't.


19. Jonny Fairplay

Jonny Fairplay was one of the first of many failed attempts to garner publicity with 'celebrity' appearances. Fairplay was a contestant on reality TV series Survivor, dubbed 'the most hated man in America' because he - get this - lied about his grandmother's death during a challenge in order to garner sympathy. Christ almighty.

With a moral compass as strong as that, he was the perfect fit for the world of wrestling. Only, he wasn't, because he was absolute red reels and nobody really cared about him. Fairplay was a lifelong wrestling fan and at least a little enthusiastic, but does that justify TNA's decision to pay $350,000 (plus health insurance) for his services? He showed up intermittently, seemingly never being used for any other reason other than to say, "hey, look it's Jonny Fairplay! That guy who was on Survivor that one time. Remember?"

Regarding his illustrious time in Dixieland, Fairplay had this to say:

I signed a $150,000 contract with TNA Wrestling for a year. I ended up making eight appearances for 40 minutes. Then I signed a second contract and they didn'€™t use me. So, I€™'d like to thank them for $300,000 for 40 minutes€™ worth of work.

Fair play, Jonny. Fair play.


18. Orlando Jordan

ImpactWrestling.com

Orlando Jordan was not good in WWE. Lack of charisma, awful timing and a lack of gimmick: OJ (didn't) have it all. On his best day the most he could hope for was to be mediocre or, at a stretch, passable. The fact that Jordan couldn't have a decent match with Chris Benoit, who could probably have carried a broom to three stars, is telling.

Still, he was a former WWE 'star' and had youth and a good physique on his side, so TNA (or more accurately Hulk Hogan) decided to hire and push him in January 2010. The results were not pretty. Jordan debuted a bisexual gimmick which was more wrestlecrap than envelop-pushing or, heaven forbid, progressive.

Orlando didn't stay long in TNA. Not long enough to have anything approaching a good match, anyway. He was released by the company in July 2011. Since then, Jordan has apparently opened up a couple of wrestling schools in Sydney, Australia where he currently resides. So he can teach the next generation of Aussie grapplers how to be just as mediocre as he was.


17. Randy Savage

Let's take nothing away from the legendary Macho Man Randy Savage: he was one of the greatest workers of all-time and had countless epic feuds and matches throughout his illustrious career. A bonafide legend of the highest calibre, some fans refused to recognise WWE's Hall of Fame until Savage was put in it in 2015. When Savage turned up in TNA in 2004, however, it was clear that his best years were very far behind him.

Savage was a great worker as late as 1997/8, when he had a series of excellent bouts with the likes of DDP and Bret Hart. After that it was clear the years of injuries and wear-and-tear had broken him down beyond repair. Savage's TNA run was a disaster. He not only refused to do anything other than throw a few punches during the end of his scheduled six-man tag mach at the Turning Point PPV but he also demanded to win the Heavyweight Title in his second match. Oh, and he also nearly had a backstage fight with Hulk Hogan, who was visiting with friends.

Wearing all-black, body-concealing attire and sporting a huge beard, Savage was virtually unrecognisable from his WWE or even later WCW days. Watching him lumber around the ring and reading about his backstage behaviour at the time was just sad.


16. Junior Fatu

Rikishi was undoubtedly a huge star (literally) in the early 2000s but, by 2007, he was totally washed-up and had very little to contribute to mainstream American wrestling, besides his giant thong-clad backside. Anyone who had watched him on the indies or for the barmy Hustle promotion in Japan since his release from WWE in 2004 could attest to that.

The Hall of Famer had ballooned in size by the time he waddled into the Impact Zone in September. He made his WWE self look positively slim in comparison. Rikishi's TNA run was not a particularly long one - he essentially came out for a cheap nostalgia pop and delivered a stinkface or two. He was gone in just over a month. The source of his release? He and TNA could not agree on a pay raise. Yes, even though he moved with all the speed of a glacier (and completely fluffed several interviews including one time calling Bobby Roode 'Rick Rude'), the 'Kish felt as though he was worth more than TNA were paying him - which was probably a lot more than their homegrown stars were getting. TNA shouldn't have been surprised: they had wanted the big Samoan to start with the company in August but his wage demands were way too high.


15. Rellik

ImpactWrestling.com

It's 'Killer' backwards, get it? This weird demon-masked gimmick was played by former WCW and WWE man Johnny Stamboli. 'The Bull' was thought to have been a wrestler of some potential in the early 2000s but a series of injuries halted his development and he never really became the superstar that many predicted. He still had the 'WWE aura', though, which made him of some interest to TNA.

He made his debut for the company at Genesis in November 2007 and mostly wrestled in awful garbage matches with the likes of Black Reign (Goldust), Raven, and Abyss. Realising how useless he was, TNA started jobbing the not-so-fearsome Rellik out soon after. This was his role for his last few months in the company. After being used as an enhancement talent in dark matches, he must have seen the writing on the wall and left TNA in May 2008.


14. Black Reign

impactwrestling.com

His career might be coming to a close now, but Dustin 'Goldust' Runnels has done a damn good job of leaving a positive lasting impression before hanging up his blonde wig and aureate tights for good. It really has been refreshing to see a guy of Dustin's age see out his remaining years with so much dignity in tact.

Of course, just a few short years ago in TNA, Runnels was an overweight, uncoordinated mess, stinking out the joint as Goldust rip-off 'Black Reign'. He wore a black and silver suit, black wig, and carried around a pet rat. Oh, the rat was re-named Terri by Kaz, in a reference to Goldust's ex-wife and former WWE diva Terri Runnels. Nobody cared. The gimmick sucked, his performances sucked, and the feuds with the likes of Rellik (Hey, that's 'Killer' spelled backwards!') sucked too.

Runnels/Reign really outstayed their welcome, eventually leaving the company in April 2008. About six months later, Goldust found himself back in WWE. I cannot for one second believe Vince and co. hired him again based on his half-baked performances in TNA.


13. Mahabali Shera

ImpactWrestling.com

Look, I tapped out on watching TNA a looooooong time ago, but somebody alerted me to this guy and oh my, is he something. There's nothing wrong with trying to tap into the Indian market by pushing a big, green guy on your television show (*cough* Great Khali *cough*) but... no, wait, what am I talking about? There is something wrong with that. When the guy you're promoting can barely do anything right, whether it's swinging a chair or trying to run the ropes properly, then there is definitely something wrong.

Shera, who wrestled as Khoya, was clearly only signed due to his size and the fact that the company has something of a presence in India due to the Ring ka King thing from a few years ago. Incredibly, Shera has been wrestling since 2011, which means he has been a pro for six whole years. Six years and not a thing learned.


12. Erik Watts

One of the great beneficiaries of nepotism, the son of Cowboy Bill Watts has made more money and received more opportunities in the wrestling business than anyone of his ability level should have. He was hired by WCW in 1992 because his Dad was booking, despite only having three months of experience in the business at the time.

After leaving WCW (once his Dad wasn't around to protect him he wasn't long for the chopping block), Watts had spells in the WWF (Tekno Team 2000), WCW again, and in ECW and Japan. They were never very fruitful. He joined TNA in 2002 and managed to stay there for almost three whole years, if you can believe that. He formed a stable with David Flair and Brian Lawler, known as the Next Generation, based off having fathers who completely overshadowed them. It was rubbish.

Other 'highlights' of his TNA run included feuding with his on-screen girlfriend Goldylocks and an utterly crap feud with a clearly bored Raven. He left TNA in February 2005. Nobody missed him. Nobody cared.


Contributor
Contributor

Student of film. Former professional wrestler. Supporter of Newcastle United. Don't cry for me, I'm already dead...