20 Worst WWE Matches Since 2000

Vince McMahon's little shop of horrors.

kane khali
WWE.com

WWE are the most inconsistent promotion in the world when it comes to the in-ring product.

Pure wrestling has never been their main focus, but even in the modern era, when athletic standards are higher than ever before, Vince McMahon's company still deal in unwatchable dreck. This is unfortunate, because their roster has never been short of exciting talent - WWE just don't get the best from them between the ropes.

This is partly by design. WWE's PG rating, in-ring restrictions, formulaic main event style, and soap opera melodrama means they'll never churn out ****+ bouts with the regularity of an NJPW or PWG. Regardless, there's no excuse for some of the atrocities that have gone down under their banner since 2000, many of which sit amongst the most cringeworthy content the sport has ever produced.

Some of these bouts veer towards "so bad, it's good" territory, while others are so abject they'll drain your very soul. Whatever the case, none are anywhere close to the standards one should expect the from the biggest promotion in the world, and only warrant a re-watch if you absolutely hate yourself...

20. Finlay & Little Bastard Vs. Boogeyman & Little Boogeyman (No Way Out 2007)

Finlay Little Boogeyman
WWE.com

WWE fans quickly learned to expect unrepentant nonsense whenever Hornswoggle stepped through the ropes, but this Extreme Rules 2007 clanger was bad, even by his standards.

Said 'Little Bastard' spent much of his time hiding beneath the ring, terrified of The Boogeyman. This left Finlay (the bout's token good wrestler) alone against the worm-guzzler and his portly midget sidekick, and while watching the notoriously hard-nosed grappler batter the life out of Little Boogey was worth a chuckle, it was the kind of comedy skit designed to pop Vince McMahon and nobody else.

The future 'Swoggle was eventually coaxed out of his safe space. Boogeyman stalked him around ringside, and Finlay took advantage of the distraction, cracking his more diminutive opponent with a shillelagh for the victory.

The Wrestling Observer's Dave Meltzer was quick to damn this contest with a -*** rating, and while his word isn't the be all/end all, it's easy to see why. This farce of a tag bout was only a shade or two below Survivor Series '94's Clowns R' Us vs. Royal Family midget brawl in terms of outright stupidity.


19. Bayley Vs. Alexa Bliss (Extreme Rules 2017)

Bayley Alexa Bliss
WWE.com

A match between two performers as talented as Alexa Bliss and Bayley shouldn't really belong on a list like this, but here we are.

Their 'Kendo Stick On A Pole' bout was one of the most destructive pieces of booking to escape a WWE creative meeting in years. It was built entirely around Bayley - the perennial do-gooder - and her reticence to attack Bliss with the stick, making for a slow, stodgy layout that wasn't at all conducive to exciting action, and delivered a most epic burial of a marketable babyface commodity.

The ordeal painted Bayley as a meek, overawed challenger, strengthening the impression that she didn't belong in the same ring as someone like Bliss, who'd do whatever it took to win. She used the weapon towards the end, but Bayley was too weak to cover. This allowed Alexa to seize control, hit a DDT, and score the pinfall, justifying Bayley's miserable pre-match narrative.

Unbelievably, Bayley is still struggling to recover from this horrendous feud. Rarely have WWE nuked such a popular wrestler so spectacularly.


18. Shelton Benjamin Vs. Viscera (New Year's Revolution 2006)

momma benjamin
wwe

What happens when you combine one of the worst wrestlers to ever set foot in a WWE ring with an angle that almost single-handedly destroyed a well-admired athletic marvel's career? This monstrosity.

Still stuck in 'World's Largest Love Machine' mode, Viscera had his sights firmly set on Momma Benajmin, who accompanied her son to the ring. Shelton was (and still is) a tremendous in-ring performer, but he couldn't drag anything close to watchable from his lumbering opponent. Even 13 years into his wrestling career, the 500lber still made Giant Gonzalez look like Ricky Steamboat, but his plodding performance wasn't even the worst thing about the match.

The whole clash was built around Momma Benjamin. She constantly distracted Viscera, with the camera frequently cutting away from the (in)action to focus on her at ringside. It all boiled down to Momma striking Vis with her purse, allowing Shelton to hit his opponent with a spinning wheel kick for the win, ending the crowd's torture in just under eight minutes.

Though not quite as abject as his SummerSlam 1995 main event with Diesel, this bout stands among the worst on Viscera's dismal resumè.


17. Randy Orton Vs. Bray Wyatt (WrestleMania 33)

WWE WrestleMania 33 Bray Wyatt Randy Orton Maggots
WWE.com

Randy Orton will be glad to see the back of 2017. 'The Viper' is currently in the midst of the worst in-ring year of his career, but while his WWE Championship bouts with Jinder Mahal spoiled many a summer pay-per-view, none were as bad as his clashes with Bray Wyatt.

Unless WWE drop a major stinker over the next four weeks, Orton vs. Wyatt will go down as the worst feud of 2017, and while WrestleMania 33 wasn't its lowest moment (we'll get to that...), it's definitely up there.

With Bray's WWE Title on the line, the duo worked a basic, heat-less house show style for much of the runtime, despite Orton literally burning Wyatt's compound to the ground a few weeks prior. This was disappointing in itself, but it got worse. Wyatt got all supernatural on 'The Viper,' projecting images of maggots, roaches, and other bugs on the mat to try and unsettle him, but it didn't work. An unphased Orton pinned Bray with an RKO just a few minutes later, vanquishing both the man and supernatural monster with depressing ease.


16. Mike Knox & Kelly Kelly Vs. Kevin Thorn & Ariel (ECW December To Dismember 2006)

Shelly Martinez Kelly Kelly December to Dismember 2006
WWE.com

Generally regarded as one of the worst pay-per-views of all time, ECW December To Dismember 2006 was a complete disaster from start to finish, with none of the night's six bouts delivering on any conceivable level.

It was an evening peppered with misery. Mike Knox & Kelly Kelly vs. Kevin Thorn & Ariel wasn't the night's grandest failure, and didn't provoke anything like the outrage that met Bobby Lashley's ECW Title win later in the show, but it was December To Dismember's worst match. Easily.

This was primarily down to the contest's least experienced participants. Thorn and Knox were basic, but serviceable. Their partners? Not so much. Kelly was always a poor in-ring competitor, but could usually be dragged to something resembling an acceptable match when paired with the right opponent, though Ariel wasn't the woman for the job.

She was brutal throughout, struggling to make even her punches look convincing, though she wasn't helped by her opposite number's complete lack of selling. Ariel hit Kelly with what was supposed to be an STO for the victory, then pinned her by literally sitting on her face: a perfect metaphor for this fart of a bout.


15. Batista Vs. The Great Khali (SummerSlam 2007)

great khali batista
WWE.com

You can't compile a list of historically bad wrestling matches without mentioning The Great Khali's name, and this SummerSlam stinker sits snugly amongst the lowest moments of his ghastly WWE run.

At his worst, Khali was downright uncomfortable to watch. The giant Indian never looked like he was in complete control of his bulbous frame, and his stiff, clumsy offence give the impression that he only a single move away from inflicting serious injury upon his opponent. These concerns were particularly pronounced during his early days, including this World Heavyweight Title fight with Batista.

The glacial Indian jumped Big Dave during his entrance, knocking him down with trademark clobbering blows, then locking in one of those lazy nerve holds that comprised much of his moveset. Batista decided against selling, though. This rendered the sequence torturous, and while 'The Animal' eventually fought back with a Spinebuster, this brief spell had no positive impact on what had become a tiring stallfest.

Khali was eventually disqualified for hitting Batista with a chair, having presumably expended more energy on his stomp to the ring than during the bout itself.


14. The Miz Vs. John Cena (WrestleMania XXVII)

John Cena The Miz WrestleMania 27
WWE.com

In pure wrestling terms, John Cena vs. The Miz certainly isn't as egregious as many of the bouts on our list, and wouldn't have earned a spot at all if it weren't for its lofty positioning. Said positioning is a huge, huge problem though. WrestleMania's main event is supposed to be the biggest match of the year, yet WWE chose to turn WM 27's closer into nothing more than an inflated TV angle that wouldn't be paid off until a full year later.

Miz vs. Cena was a doormat for the franchise player's eventual showdown with The Rock. Building towards this 'Once In A Lifetime' bout was WWE's priority, and Miz, their top champion, was used to facilitate this. Undermined, disrespected, and borderline buried, 'The A-Lister' left with his title, but his credibility was in shreds, as his triumph came through 'The Great One's' direct interference.

Rock laid Miz out with a spinebuster and People's Elbow after the bell, compounding the hatchet job. The problems began long before the interference, though, with both wrestlers struggling for chemistry and cohesion from bell to bell.


13. Kane & The Undertaker Vs. KroniK (Unforgiven 2001)

Kronik Brothers of Destruction Unforgiven 2001
WWE.com

Ex-WCW bruisers Brian Adams and Bryan Clark weren't originally retained when Vince McMahon purchased their former employers in March 2001, but made their way to the company six months later.

Both had worked for WWE under different guises in the past, but this was their first time performing as KroniK in the sport's biggest promotion, and boy, did they bomb. They were brought in to face Kane and The Undertaker, which should have given them a major rub from day one. Instead, it tanked both of their careers.

This was entirely down to a disastrous match against The Brothers Of Destruction at Unforgiven. KroniK were terribly out of sorts. They were allowed to control much of the bout, but Clark's offence was particularly sloppy and weak, and their timing was well off. This led to a number of disjointed, uncoordinated spots ahead of their eventual defeat, with 'Taker Chokeslamming Clark all the way to hell.

So enraged were Kane and The Undertaker by their opponents' lack of finesse that KroniK never wrestled another match for WWE, and were released from their contracts a few days later.


12. Candice Michelle Vs. Torrie Wilson (WrestleMania 22)

Torrie Wilson Candice Michelle WrestleMania 22
WWE

Strictly speaking, every strip match is atrocious now that we're several years removed from Attitude and Ruthless Aggression's gross excesses. We can't include them all, but we can shine a spotlight on the worst of the worst, which Candice Michelle vs. Torrie Wilson most certainly is.

Billed as a 'Playboy Pillow Fight,' it went pretty much exactly as you'd expect, with both competitors stripped to their underwear within minutes. They scrapped on a bed of pillows, but things soon got even weirder. The agents, in all their wisdom, booked a spot in which Torrie grabbed her dog from ringside then used to give her fellow Playboy centrefold a Stink Face. What's even more surprising is that this devastating manoeuvre wasn't the finisher: Wilson eventually ended the bout with a roll-up, having had Candice's Playboy photoshoot shoved in her face seconds prior.

It was everything wrong with the way WWE used to promote women's wrestling distilled into four awful minutes. The crowd hated it, too, proving that the company's exploitative aesthetics-over-everything approach had already worn thin, with such bouts highlighting the product's absolute worst elements.


11. Kane Vs. The Great Khali (SummerSlam 2009)

Kane Khali SummerSlam
WWE.com

For a guy generally regarded as one of the most functional wrestling giants of all time, Kane has been involved in a lot of unwatchable nonsense. It isn't always his fault, as 'The Big Red Machine' has been continually subjected to some of the creative department's worst material over the past two decades, but there's no escaping his catalogue of certified duds.

While not the worst match of Kane's lengthy career, his SummerSlam 2009 clash with The Great Khali was utterly woeful. Always a good athlete for a man of his size, but never one to elevate lesser opposition, this six-minute stodger saw the future Mayor of Knox County, Tennessee work to Khali's atrocious level.

With no drama to speak of and only a moderately surprising finisher kick-out to warm the crowd up, this bout's six minutes felt like sixty. You may think you know what you're getting with Khali, but nothing can prepare you for this contest's monotony, and you should steer well clear unless you happen to be looking for an instant insomnia cure.


10. Bray Wyatt Vs. Kane (SummerSlam 2013)

SummerSlam, Ring of Fire
WWE.com

Inferno matches stink. Sure, walls of flames surrounding the apron looks pretty cool, and WWE will never come up with a more appropriate signature stipulation for Kane, but they're grossly impractical.

Aside from the obvious fire hazard, the flames burn up the oxygen around the ring, making it difficult for wrestlers to last longer than a couple of minutes without gasping for air. On top of this, the performers will typically spend the runtime wrestling on eggshells for fear of catching fire ahead of planned conclusion.

WWE have only booked one variation on the format over the past 11 years, and it was bad. Really bad.

Kane and Bray Wyatt's 'Ring Of Fire' bout was the latter's first on the main roster. He couldn't have had a worse introduction, as he and his monstrous opponent visibly struggled in the stifling heat, the stipulation robbing Wyatt the opportunity of a star-making performance. The one plus point is that he was able to look strong in defeating 'The Big Red Machine' in his own environment, but that one plot point doesn't supersede the stipulation's problems.


9. Teddy Long Vs. Eric Bischoff (Survivor Series 2005)

Teddy Long Eric Bischoff
WWE Network

Reading the names involved should tell you everything you need to know about this bout's quality. Eric Bischoff is an all-time great authority figure, and Teddy Long excelled as a manager, staff member, and referee, but putting them in the ring together was a recipe for disaster. Unsurprisingly, their combined inexperience resulted in the worst Survivor Series singles match of all time.

Neither man looked comfortable out there, so it's tough to rip on Long vs. Bischoff too much. They were personalities, not wrestlers, and should never have been thrown into this position in the first place. Watching the duo struggle to execute even the most rudimentary of strikes and holds was painful to watch, though.

WWE tried to prevent it from becoming a complete trainwreck by having The Boogeyman appear towards the end. Bischoff sent the officials off to hunt for him when the music hit, but Boogey came out from beneath the ring, took Easy E by surprising, then kneed him right in the gonads. One pumphandle slam later and Bischoff was ripe for picking, with Long's pinfall bringing things to a sweet, merciful end.


8. Rosie O'Donnell Vs. Donald Trump (Raw - 8th Jan, 2007)

Donald Trump Rosie O Donnell
WWE.com

Boredom, revulsion, hilarity, disbelief: the various matches on our list should provoke a variety of different response within the average viewer, but 'Rosie O'Donnell' vs. 'Donald Trump' should inspire just one:-

"Why?"

Just... "why?!"

For whatever reason, Vince McMahon decided that filling a small portion of his company's flagship show with a couple of impersonators sloppily brawling their way around the ring wouldn't be a complete waste of time. He was wrong. 'Donald' and 'Rosie' didn't look, behave, or sound like the celebrities they were supposed to resemble, and their 'match' soon had the fans chanting "boooooooring!" at a deafening decibel.

We're all used to McMahon's ill-advised horrendous comedic endeavours, but this might be the worst of all his attempts at making the crowd laugh, only to draw the opposite reaction. Trump won (because of course he did), and while WWE likely put this grand catastrophe together as means of capitalising on the public feud that still rattles on between the two celebs, even in 2017, Vince succeeded only in making a tit of himself, his company, and anyone daft enough to stay tuned.


7. Trish Stratus & Bradshaw Vs. Jackie Gayda & Chris Nowinski (Raw - 8th July, 2002)

Trish Stratus Jackie Gayda
Tumblr

There's an outside chance you might remember Jackie Gayda primarily for her Tough Enough run, but really, this intergender tag match remains her WWE career's defining moment. It's one one of the most notoriously botch-filled messes in company history, and this is mostly down to Gayda, who didn't have a whiff of chemistry with Trish Stratus (who wasn't exactly the finished article at this stage in her career either).

Murphy's Law was in full effect whenever they were in the ring together. It wasn't so much that Trish and Jackie weren't on the same page, but rather they were reading from completely different volumes, and it was abundantly clear that Gayda wasn't ready for television. Her most infamous flub came from a second rope bulldog that she sold several seconds too late, but she wasn't the only culprit. Chris Nowinski, her fellow Tough Enough alumnus, had a few sketchy moments of his own, including a baffling mid-match decision to try and attract the camera's focus outside the ring while actual wrestling was happening inside.

"Mercifully, it's over," Jim Ross sighed after the bout's conclusion - a sentiment shared by us all.


6. Scott Steiner Vs. Triple H (Royal Rumble 2003)

Triple H Scott Steiner 2003 Royal Rumble.jpg
WWE.com

Scott Steiner joining WWE should've been a huge deal.

One of the last ex-WCW stars to cross over following the Invasion angle's conclusion, 'Big Poppa Pump' was still a huge name. He looked like a potential main event commodity, and the company wasted no time in pushing him to the top, throwing Steiner in a mainline feud with World Heavyweight Champion shortly after arriving on Raw.

WWE systematically failed to present him as a big deal. They forced him into an uncomfortably babyface role and let the HHH feud devolve to a series of pose-downs and arm-wrestling contests, torpedoing the audience's interest in their eventual showdown. Still, much of this could've been forgiven had they delivered between the ropes, but they didn't: their Royal Rumble 2003 collision ranks among the worst of either man's career.

The opening stages were lifeless, but the bout didn't come off the rails until the second half, when a visibly exhausted Steiner resorted to spamming the same belly-to-belly suplex ad nauseum, with the fans turning on him by the end.

Steiner and Triple H wrestled a marginally less egregious rematch at No Way Out, but it did nothing to expel the Rumble's horrors.


5. Kaitlyn Vs. Maxine (NXT - 19th Oct, 2010)

NXT has been WWE's most consistent brand for several years now, but its early days as a reality show produced countless hours of irredeemable television, particularly during its third season.

This clash between Kaitlyn and Maxine represents rock bottom To start, both wrestlers looked pensive and unsure of themselves before the bell rang, and it kicked off with one of the sloppiest back suplexes you'll ever see. The problems escalated from thereon out, with Maxine botching a big boot and a clothesline, Kaitlyn selling a hair-whip like a gunshot wound, and heel announcer Michael Cole literally leaving the booth to take a phone call halfway through.

Again, the clash only lasted six minutes, but it should never have made it to television. Neither woman was ready for this spot. Forcing them to go through with this charade totally exposed them, and it didn't help that Cole and his partner, Josh Mathews, spent the entire runtime s***ting on their efforts. Kaitlyn would thankfully develop into a serviceable main roster worker, washing away most fans' recollections of this early-career horror show, but her opponent never made it beyond developmental.


4. Bray Wyatt Vs. Randy Orton (Payback 2017)

Bray Wyatt Randy Orton House of Horrors
WWE.com

Finally, we reach the true nadir or Randy Orton and Bray Wyatt's historically bad 2017 feud: the House Of Horrors.

WWE gave little indication of what the bout would actually entail prior to the event. This wasn't done to build intrigue, but because they themselves had no idea what they were going to do with the gimmick, as confirmed when they circulated a feedback form asking for suggestions before the show. What we ended up getting was a soulless haunted house brawl that was clearly designed to capture the Broken Hardys' Final Deletion magic, but came off campy, absurd, and utterly ridiculous.

It was essentially a lame walk-and-brawl filmed on set during a live action Scooby Doo episode, with Wyatt at his hokey worst, monologuing one of his trademark gaspy promos throughout the opening stages. His spooky bulls*** couldn't unsettle 'The Viper', but he was able to squash him beneath a fridge, allowing 'The Eater Of Worlds' to escape to the arena. Randy followed, and they finished their match inside the ring, with Bray triumphing through Jinder Mahal's interference.

This thing was always going to be a catastrophe, but it somehow came out worse than even the biggest cynics could've anticipated.


3. Brock Lesnar Vs. Goldberg (WrestleMania XX)

Lesnar Goldberg WrestleMania XX
WWE

Brock Lesnar and Goldberg's most recent WWE feud was a complete success. It popped ratings, got people talking, and created a real sense of buzz around the company, and while there was no real need to bring the Universal Title into the equation, the duo at least concluded their rivalry with a thrilling all-out brawl at WrestleMania 33.

It's a good job the rematch succeeded, because their first 'Mania bout was the pits - primarily through a lack of trying.

Both performers were on their way out of the promotion, and neither wanted to exert themselves on their last night with the company. They spent much of the bout staring each other down without actively engaging, but barely broke out of second gear even when they started trading moves, and they crowd responded accordingly.

Lesnar and Goldberg were showered with hatred. The lack of activity coupled with the knowledge of their imminent departures created an impossible hostile attitude, but the performers couldn't have cared less, and continued at the same glacial pace.

The disgraced participants marched out of the company in dismal fashion, with only special guest referee Steve Austin's two post-match Stunners drawing noticeable crowd pops.


2. Michael Cole Vs. Jerry Lawler (WrestleMania XXVII)

Jerry Lawler Michael Cole Steve Austin
WWE.com

Some would have you believe that Jerry Lawler and Michael Cole's ill-advised WrestleMania XXVII bout is the worst in WWE history. It isn't, but it did take place at the heart of an announcer vs. announcer feud that was completely without merit, and was needlessly dragged out to span three individual pay-per-view cycles.

Its problems were legion. Lawler was a fine wrestler in his day, but he was 62 years old at the time, and expecting him to drag anything acceptable from a non-combatant like Cole was ridiculous.

It was nothing more than a pantomime. Cole straight up couldn't wrestle, and he didn't, instead resorting to basic heel tactics to prevent Lawler from gaining too much of a foothold, though the Memphis legend dominating big chunks of it.

Steve Austin saw plenty of action as the guest referee, and Jack Swagger also had an influence, laying Lawler out on multiple occasions, but their shenanigans couldn't mask the catastrophe. WWE should have delivered a quick squash: instead, they made Lawler wrestle Cole for 14 full minutes, completely losing the crowd in the process.


1. Pat Patterson Vs. Gerald Brisco (King Of The Ring 2000)

Gerald Brisco Pat Patterson
WWE

While Pat Patterson and Gerald Brisco were strong in their role as Vince McMahon's corporate stooges towards the end of the Attitude Era, that should've been the extent of their contributions. Aged 59 and 55 respectively, Patterson and Brisco had no business being in the ring anymore, and even less competing in the hardcore division, but WWE still chose to enforce their godawful 2000 feud upon the audience.

This Hardcore Evening Gown clash scored -*** on Dave Meltzer's match-rating system, but should've broken the scale. It was appalling.

The ageing Hall-Of-Fames looked grotesque in their gowns, and were soundly humiliated throughout a contest designed to provide some light comic relief. Patterson shoved a banana and a sanitary towel down his partner's throat, Brisco hit a bronco buster in his gown, and the crowd dumped all over it, filling the building with jeers throughout this wretched flop.

Crash Holly's interference provided a fortunate respite, as the multi-time Hardcore Champion took advantage of the belt's 24/7 rule to pin Pat after just three minutes, ending the contest before it hit full flow, earning our eternal gratitude in the process.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.