3 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Rampage (Feb 23 - Results & Review)

Tony Khan signs ANOTHER wrestler; The Young Bucks thrive; AEW Rampage needs a revamp.

The Young Bucks Matthew Nicholas Jackson EVP
AEW

Tony Khan has a decision to make with Rampage (and most of his programming in general). Does he want to grow the audience with compelling stories and characters people invest in, or does he fancy putting on more indy-riffic spotfests that'll appease hardcores without drawing fresh eyeballs to the product?

That might seem like less of a pressing question for obvious 'C' show Rampage, but everything counts. Even some of All Elite's biggest fans must be numb to the company's familiar tropes. They're overdone, and that includes "blockbuster announcements" that AEW has (surprise, surprise) signed yet another wrestler to the roster.

Someone new debuted on this week's show. Khan booked a few matches in and around that to varying levels of success - one, in particular, was another banner showing from rising stars. Another was just your typical no-sell special. Then, there was the main event. That bout sagged and didn't deserve to go on last.

There were 'Ups' on this week's Rampage, but it's getting harder and harder to justify some of Tony's decision-making. His approach might be a love letter to hardcore fan culture worldwide, but it's obvious something is holding AEW's week-by-week product back.

Here's all the good and bad from Friday!


Downs...

4. Totally Numb To This Now

Penta Matt Sydal
AEW

The opening three-team trios match was indicative of AEW's core issues.

It was just this promotion's latest spotty spotfest with no real sense of purpose. Nobody sold a thing, and it's clear Tony Khan needs to move away from these kinds of bouts for a while. He can always come back to them here or there, but they're really boring now. That's a problem, because they're supposed to be anything but!

Even Matt Menard on commentary said: 'Somebody get a pinfall, I'm begging ya!". That sums it up. Workers in these matches perform a lot of flashy moves without much substance; it's also senseless, 'cause they mean nothing if those taking the hits don't bother to sell them for longer than 3-5 seconds.

Yours truly watched this match around an hour or so ago, and he had to think hard about exactly who was in it. That...isn't good. Where's the pacing and the drama? Endless loops of risky dives over the top rope to the floor don't count as drama, especially when they're about as effective as an airplane spin.


3. Yay! Another Wrestler!

Saraya Zak Knight Harley Cameron
AEW

Oh boy! AEW's roster is already bursting at the seams as it is, but Khan has put pen-to-paper on yet another wrestler's brand new contract. Zak Knight is officially #AllElite. Good on him for inking a contract with a major company, but the last things this locker room needed was another body.

Without being harsh, does Zak have a chance of standing out? Maybe being tied to his sister Saraya will help there, because at least he's guaranteed some TV time. However, it's impossible to trust that AEW will focus on Knight for longer than a few weeks before Tony diverts attention to his next shiny new toy.

That's kinda how he operates.

On paper, Zak will be Saraya's tool to needle Ruby Soho and take down Angelo Parker. Sure, they'll squeeze a few matches out of that, but then what? Will he settle into a nondescript tag-team or trio like Action Andretti has? Hopefully not, but probably.


2. Main Event Wasn’t Worthy

Jake Hager Roderick Strong
AEW

Sorry, but Roderick Strong vs. Jake Hager wasn't it.

Orange Cassidy's involvement (as a thank you to Hager) was supposed to elevate the segment, but even that didn't work. Cassidy was only really there to toss Jake's purple hat towards him in-ring, then the announcers acted like the bucket lid gives Hager special powers. Fair enough.

This is really sad to say, but Strong was infinitely more entertaining when he was yelling people's names from a wheelchair during promos. His in-ring work is obviously robust, but matches like this absolutely will not draw people in. It was a puzzling choice of main event; even for a 'C' level show like Rampage.

Everything meandered along until Cassidy's music hit and the aforementioned purple hat gimmick came into play. Honestly, could AEW do a worse job with this new Undisputed Kingdom faction? They're so listless it's unreal. You've got to be worried if you're an Adam Cole fan, put it that way.


1. Rampage Needs A Revamp!

Jake Hager Oklahoma Mascot
AEW

Tony Khan must decide (and fast) what he wants from Rampage. Sometimes, the boss loads it up. Other times, he phones episodes in like AEW did here. Generally, the show is far too formulaic, and not in a positive, fan-pleasing and comfort blanket sort of way.

The picture-in-picture ad breaks happen at almost the exact same times during matches, and that makes it borderline impossible to maintain interest. In other words, you know nothing of note is going to happen before Excalibur pleads: "Don't go anywhere!". Maybe he's talking about the match layout?

No disrespect intended here either, but is a main event like Roddy Strong vs. Jake Hager really going to entice people to tune in for this stuff? Worse, AEW then crowed about a bunch of other so-so matches to come on Collision. It's like everything, including Dynamite, needs a right good revamp.

Rampage is especially ripe for a rethink. It has been for ages.


Ups...

3. Powerhouse Wrecks Shop Again

Powerhouse Hobbs Sammy Guevara
AEW

No, Sammy Guevara isn't convincing when he does the tough guy babyface act, but his promo on Rampage did pave the way for Powerhouse Hobbs to look like a killer. That's always fun, and you know this pair will have a decent match together. Hobbs has that "Meat Madness" thing going on though, so maybe not.

The segment was serviceable overall.

It's the kind of thing Rampage needs more of, and was certainly better than the awful backstage promos fans are routinely served. Powerhouse always shows good intensity when he's kicking the sh*t out of someone, and Sammy sold the attack like he'd been smacked by an 18-wheeler.

Yeah, serviceable would be the word. Fingers crossed Tony Khan doesn't forget all about this in a few weeks, 'cause there was enough here to suggest Sammy selling his butt off for Hobbs in a 20-minute match laced with spirited hope spots could be really, really good.


2. More Of The Same (But It Worked)

The Young Bucks Tony Schiavone
AEW

It's up for debate whether The Young Bucks needed another squash match win, but their condescending promo afterwards about everyone from Darby Allin and Sting to Tony Schiavone and the fans was top stuff. The brothers are properly embracing this heel EVP stuff - it's the most interesting they've been as characters in years.

Fans are in on the gag too. They refused to follow Matthew's lead when he encouraged an "AEW! AEW! AEW!" chant from the masses. That's a good sign, and it shows people just fancy seeing Sting and Darby smack The Bucks around at Revolution. In retrospect, they look like fine picks for the Stinger's last match.

That isn't something this guy thought he'd be saying, to be totally honest. You've got to give Matt and...sorry, Matthew and Nicholas kudos for showing a different side to their act in 2024 though. They've breathed new life into The Young Bucks gimmick by going rogue.

Can't wait to see what's next after Revolution.


1. Mariah May & Anna Jay

Anna Jay Mariah May
AEW

These women richly deserve the top 'Up' spot this week.

Anna Jay and Queen Aminata got the nod last time too. Arguably, Jay's match vs. Mariah May wasn't quite on par with that one, but they still entertained and put on a show for fans who take the time to sit down with Rampage. One got the sense that both Anna and Mariah wanted to win from the opening bell.

More matches should be that way rather than going through the motions with a procession of spots first. It's so, so heartening to see women like Jay continue to improve all the time. She's on a bit of a mini-losing streak on Fridays, but that's OK. The quality of her performances is what counts right now.

If you're only planning on checking out one match from Rampage, then make it this one. Anna and Mariah gelled immediately, and both were extremely giving. That ebb and flow helped give the match some bite. It'd be amazing if Tony realised what he has with Jay and pushed her to the moon later this year.

She deserves that recognition.

What did you think of this week's AEW Rampage? For more like this, check out 10 WWE Stars Who BADLY Need New Gimmicks After WrestleMania 40 and WWE 2K24: 25 More Screenshots You NEED To See!


In this post: 
AEW Rampage
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.