3 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE Raw (19 January - Results & Review)
Punk and Balor tear the house down, Styles puts his career on the line, Nattie (re)turns.
WWE Raw’s latest offering is sure to spark some spirited debate among fans and critics due to a very hot main event and a high-stakes opening segment.
Beyond those two major storylines, there were some divisive segments that likely elicited very different reactions among fans. Regardless, Raw was a touch better this week than last week, which itself was an improvement from the previous week.
If you’re willing to give WWE the benefit of a couple of doubts and make an assumption or two, you might have found a few other moments to be marked positives rather than negatives. But this isn’t 2023-24 WWE; it’s an iteration that has routinely underperformed, leading to a lack of trust that something simple, like bringing Natalya back to television as her “Lowkey Legend” character, is going to be executed properly (if at all).
Still, AJ Styles and Gunther continue to be a pleasant surprise – not that two consummate professionals mesh well together, but that they have been this good as a pairing. And CM Punk’s two-week storyline with Finn Balor produced an instantly memorable entrance, followed by a fun, old-fashioned wrestling match between two veterans.
Overall, there was enough here to make most of Raw watchable, but WWE just continues to weave in subpar programming to irk fans and try their patience.
Let’s get to it…
DOWNS…
5. An Unfortunate Ending
It’s always difficult to give negative marks to a match due to injury, but honestly, the bout between El Grande Americano and Je’Von Evans wasn’t exactly tearing the house down before the match was called off due to an Evans injury.
Je’Von and El Grande struggled to get on the same page throughout the six-minute match, stumbling about in a few spots. But when Raw returned from commercial, the announcers mentioned that Evans was sitting on the floor next to their table with the trainer, and that the match was being called off. It was later reported that there was concern that Je’Von had sustained a concussion.
This likely would have been Evans’ trifecta over the masked stable or at least set up a more definitive showdown between the rookie and Los Americanos’ leader. Hopefully, Je’Von will be back on his feet quickly and can get himself back in the mix.
4. Natalya Returns… And Turns
Pop quiz: When was Natalya’s last televised WWE match?
Answer: Five months ago, a Women’s Intercontinental Championship loss to Becky Lynch in August, and she hasn’t won a singles match since September 2024.
Monday, Natalya returned to WWE television in person (she was heavily featured in Maxxine Dupri’s training videos) for the first time in months… and immediately turned heel on Dupri in what can only be described as the most obvious heel turn of the young year. Seriously, anyone over 10 saying they were shocked by this is lying or gullible as hell.
Nattie turning heel on Maxxine isn’t a bad call – in fact, it’s absolutely the right decision - but everything seems to be sequenced awkwardly. Natalya appeared in the black-and-white training videos, but she hadn’t been a presence at Raw for months, then her first in-person appearance alongside Dupri was this telegraphed turn. Rather than punishing Maxxine for being inadequate in the ring, she was the root cause of the failure, which raises the question of why Natalya bothered to train her in the first place.
Worse, the post-match beatdown was uninspired at best, with the announcers calling Natalya a “locker room leader” as she punched Maxxine a bunch before locking in the Sharpshooter.
Some fans online reacted with glee because they believe this is the debut of the vaunted “Lowkey Legend” Nattie character that Neidhart has been using in GCW. Until this actually happens and we aren’t simply treated to Natalya slipping on a banana peel and getting eliminated from the Royal Rumble by Dupri, the jury is going to be out on this.
Of course, one must always keep an open mind, but WWE hasn’t really given fans a reason to trust the process here.
3. The Worst Odd Couple
Bayley talks with Lyra Valkyria backstage#WWERAW pic.twitter.com/NH9sHDW6js
— Eslam (@EslamRollins) January 19, 2026
In some ways, WWE has evolved somewhat since Vince McMahon steered the ship. Case in point, Bayley’s whole “hearing voices” or split-personality gimmick was drastically toned down after several weeks of ridicule. Whereas Vince would have stubbornly carried on with the gimmick until it completely tanked, Paul Levesque at least dialed it back a notch.
Despite the character shift, Bayley and Lyra Valkyria’s relationship is producing some of the worst backstage segments on Raw these days. Lyra continuously makes strange, contorted faces as she tries to figure out if she’s getting the Huggable One or the deranged Role Model on a weekly basis, while Bayley alternately laughs and yells depending on the situation.
Monday, Valkyria was timid about approaching a ranting-to-herself Bayley, saying she felt like she had let her friend down. Bayley hugged her and noted that they didn’t get pinned in the triple threat tag match last week and that they had all of 2026 to turn things around… all while Lyra just made weird faces.
Bayley has been on this track for five months now, and the gimmick isn’t doing anyone – especially Valkyria – any favors. Poor Lyra has to act “confused” every week and try to slap Bayley the correct number of times to trigger the right personality traits. It’s just dumb television that isn’t helping anyone.
2. Who Isn’t In The Royal Rumble?
Ah, it’s that time of year, when everyone grabs a mic and announces that they’re entering the Royal Rumble match. There’s no criteria or qualification other than having a pulse, speaking into a microphone, and saying that you’re declaring your entry or participation in the Rumble. That’s it.
Gunther kicked things off by announcing he was entering the Rumble. Jey Uso also announced his entry, despite just last week putting the tag team division “on notice.” Guess that’s on hold for now. (If that gets weaved into a Jey heel turn – that he’s still preoccupied with singles glory – then this works.)
Not to be outdone, the Women’s Tag Team Champions announced that they’re entering the Rumble, as will the three Judgment Day women, who jumped Rhea Ripley and Iyo Sky, beating them down in a predictable go-home heat segment ahead of Saturday Night’s Main Event. Bayley, Lyra Valkyria, Asuka, and Kairi Sane all declared their entrances into the Rumble as well on Monday night.
The Rhiyo/Judgment Day segment was especially disappointing, as both teams tried to use the Rumble to sow seeds of divisions between their opponents – despite the Rumble taking place the week after their SNME tag title match. It also diminished their title match to have half of the promo segment focused on entering the Rumble for a shot at a women’s singles title. Maybe just focus on the titles around your waists and your upcoming defense/challenge? Just a thought.
1. Another Weak Women’s IC Title Showing
Maxxine Dupri is well past her sell-by date at this point as a serious title contender, but that didn’t stop WWE from throwing an 11-minute Women’s Intercontinental Championship rematch out there Monday night.
Becky Lynch assumed the role again of trying to get the most out of Dupri, who had a couple of nice moments, but her fire-up spot (yelling “Again!” as Becky hits her) was cringeworthy. The submission sequences and reversals required a willing suspension of disbelief. And then came the finish.
Natalya put Becky’s foot on the ropes after Lynch smacked the exposed turnbuckle and Maxxine “kicked” (in actuality, whiffed by a mile) her, which gave everyone a full display of Dupri’s “acting.” Maxxine did a full “Why Nattie, why?” routine before turning into a Manhandle Slam for the pin.
Just so we’re clear, Becky was toast if not for Nattie, but Maxxine was such a clueless novice that she just got duped and then immediately was put away. And Nattie then delivered a “C+” beatdown to cap off the heel turn.
Who did any of this help? And is anyone clamoring for a feud between Natalya and Maxxine? Lynch should be fine, as long as she can run away from all of this as quickly as possible.
UPS…
3. Luchadores Take Down The Vision… With Help
The Vision has been running roughshod over WWE Raw’s stale main event scene for quite some time now, so it was nice to see them mix the formula up a bit Monday night.
With Bron Breakker suspended, Bronson Reed, Austin Theory, and Logan Paul wrestled the lucha trio of Penta, Dragon Lee, and Rey Mysterio. Not surprisingly, the masked trio unveiled some triple teams and dives to keep The Vision off balance.
The match itself was fine, if a bit underwhelming when the heels were in control. However, the bout served more as a backdrop to Raw GM Adam Pearce’s growing involvement in The Vision’s affairs. While at ringside for the match, Pearce caught Theory wearing Paul’s brass knuckles and confiscated them. While arguing with Paul Heyman, he left the knucks on the apron, only for Rey to grab them and deck Theory, allowing Penta to finish him with a Mexican Destroyer.
The match and result were fine, but afterward, Heyman continued to press Pearce about his involvement, coordinating a phone call that seemingly prompted the Raw GM to invite Breakker to next week’s show for a conversation.
Authority figure storylines rarely work, but this one, so far, is a bit different and intriguing, so it gets passing marks. Also, good for the babyfaces not being so virtuous that they won’t use the heels’ own attempted chicanery against them.
2. Gunther Raises The Stakes
WWE is clearly going to lean hard into this “career killer” gimmick for Gunther – and they absolutely are correct for doing so.
After securing a rather dubious win against AJ Styles last week, the man who retired Goldberg and John Cena was in full gloat mode Monday night, which drew Styles out for a confrontation. AJ tried to goad Gunther into a rematch, but the Ring General noted that there wasn’t any real incentive for him to pull double duty at the Royal Rumble PLE, until…
Gunther agreed to a rematch with Styles… if AJ put his career on the line. Later in the show, Styles agreed to the stipulation, making it official for the Rumble.
Styles already has said that 2026 is going to be his last year as an active wrestler, so the threat of losing – even in January – is very real, especially against someone who seems hellbent on amassing a collection of vanquished careers. Their match last week told a sublime story, and when they run it back at the Rumble, fans could be in for a real treat.
Regardless, they’ve got fans on the hook here, given Gunther’s momentum, Styles’ dwindling career, and the question of how this match factors into those conditions.
1. A Raucous Main Event
Even during last week’s whiplash-style “build” for Monday’s world title match, there was little doubt that CM Punk and Finn Balor could create magic given their skills and surroundings with Raw emanating from Belfast, Northern Ireland.
Coming out to his old entrance music (drawing a big pop from this writer) and playing to the crowd, Balor rode a wave of home island (WWE was more careful to use this term this week) support to take Punk to the brink in their World Heavyweight Championship match. The fans were firmly in Finn’s corner, casting Punk as the villain, a role he leaned into with a smirk, feeding off the boos.
Punk and Balor mixed in some legit great little moments, such as Punk hitting a superplex, only for Finn to catch his legs in a desperate cradle.
When Balor kicked out of a Go-to-Sleep, Punk lost it a bit, raining down elbows and mounting Finn with a series of punches before cinching in an Anaconda Vice – just in case anyone was confused about who they should be cheering on this night. Balor would get a near-fall of his own with a Coup de Grace before falling to a GTS.
Afterward, Punk offered a handshake and a hug to Balor, who lost honorably (not exactly a feature when it comes to Judgment Day members). It’ll be interesting to see if this show of sportsmanship was a one-off thing because of the audience, or if it will factor into clubhouse tensions with Liv Morgan insisting on a cutthroat attitude to become champions.
As a one-off World Heavyweight Championship match, this was about as good as you could expect, with a memorable entrance from Balor to boot. It just would have been nice if they had actually prepped Finn with a singles win in the lead-up rather than just having him demand a title match after winning one singles match in 19 months.