3 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE SmackDown (9 Oct - Results & Review)

New champions crowned; Raw bleeds into SmackDown; WWE's MITB build is hit and miss.

Bronson Reed Je'Von Evans
WWE.com

Bronson Reed made his presence felt as SmackDown went off the air, but Oba Femi didn't appear despite booming "OBA! OBA! OBA!" chants from the live crowd. Once the cameras stopped rolling, it was actually Cody Rhodes who rushed out to fend off The Vision and send the fans home happy. Live, Cody probably needed that, because his promo about Randy Orton was more of the same and failed to inspire.

"Failed to inspire" might sum up Friday's 'go home' show before Money In The Bank generally, to be honest. WWE crowned brand new Women's Tag-Team Champions, produced a fun segment involving Sami Zayn, CM Punk and Kevin Owens, and put on a cool 6-woman tag that previewed one of the ladder bouts on Saturday, but there was a lot to dislike too.

Again, Rhodes struggled with samey material after Orton had nonsensically travelled all the way to Lafayette to...travel all the way back home as soon as he arrived at the building. Logically, that didn't make much sense. Does Nick Aldis never phone up his talent to let them know what's what?

Sadly, a fresh main event combo pitting Trick Williams vs. Bron Breakker couldn't end the night on a high either. Triple H didn't give the former NXT pair much of a chance with the layout and formatting of their match/segment, and SmackDown going off air mid-Vision beatdown on some babyfaces suggested that WWE ran out of TV time and had to go dark ASAP.

MITB is next then. Before getting there, here's all the good and bad from Friday.


Downs...

5. Why Did Randy Orton Even Show Up?

Randy Orton Nick Aldis
WWE

One Randy Orton appeared to be arriving at the building “earlier today” when he bumped into GM Nick Aldis and offered to go home. Yep, just like that. At first, it appeared that Aldis might ban him from the building to try and keep the peace with Cody Rhodes anyway, but they didn’t get that far. Randy just suggested it, mumbled something about Cody not having it in him to hit the punt, then left.

What a pretty unsatisfying bit of story work for that feud this week. It was phoned in to the extreme, and almost like Trips jotted down the meat of it on a napkin in catering. Some may argue that WWE finding ways to get key players onto television every week is a good thing, and it can be, but more thought should go into layering stories this important. Here, both Orton and Rhodes just repeated the same stuff they've been saying recently.

We get it: Randy doesn't think that Cody has it in him to pull the trigger and get ruthless. Being fair, why would he when the top babyface has resisted the urge to get ultra-violent time after time? That's coming, of course, but we need more of a build towards the crescendo than we got on this week's SmackDown from either side.

Regrettably, Rhodes couldn't even save things live in the arena after Randy's pre-tape trundled along beforehand. This was one of the weaker Orton promos on SmackDown lately, which is a pity because he's been smashing it on the mic.


4. Not Cody’s Best Work

Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Cody was all sorts of fired up when calling out Randy later, but there was no drama because we knew Randy was going to no-show. A pop-up RKO wouldn’t have really achieved much anyway, being honest. As the segment rolled on, it became clear that they were just chewing through time without anything new to say here. Aldis wanted to do business behind closed doors, whilst Cody fancied ranting about how Orton is a “tramp stamp, fragile bitch”.

OK then - that line didn't make Rhodes look like a clever babyface. Maybe they're trying to sell that Randy has managed to get right under his skin, but there was a subtle whiff of Roman Reigns and his "succotash, son" speech from yesteryear about all of this. It wasn't quite on that level of bad, but it got close!

Being real, this couldn’t hold a candle to some of the recent promo work both guys have put out there, and it’s something WWE asks Rhodes to do a lot. ‘Go out there yourself and talk, talk, talk without moving things forwards’. Personally, this writer always really appreciates Cody’s fire, but he needs inspired material to work with in skits like this one.

Do your thing, creative. Uphold your end of the bargain.

Let's just say that WWE's video team won't be spinning any highlights from this week's Smackers into the package for the inevitable rematch between Cody and Randy. Nothing to see here. We couldn't even get a decent set of insults out of things this time.


3. Press Reset On The Tag Division

MFTs War Raiders
WWE.com

The tag-team scene is depressing for those who recall the biggest peaks of double brand warfare in WWE. Backstage, the creative team may contend that MFTs, War Raiders and Bakusai have the makings of a sizzling division, but that's wide of the mark. On Friday, MFTs vs. Raiders never really got going. It should’ve been a slugfest between big meaty teams, but we didn’t actually get that

Also, MFTs winning leaves Erik and Ivar rudderless yet again.

Corey Graves was banging on about how they need to tap into their past and get back to basics. How many times are we gonna hear this about them in WWE?! The War Raiders have stumbled time and time again even though we're persistently told as a fanbase that things will be different this time. They will. Honest...

Pretty lifeless affair on the whole here. The tag division is a total mess and needs ripped up then rethought. Tama and Talla Tonga have Haku and the belts, but precious else, and Bakusai’s momentum/buzz lasted for a matter of weeks. Shinsuke Nakamura and Kyoki do have chemistry inside the ring, but it already looks like WWE can't be arsed developing Kyoki's character or giving people a reason to care about their quest for the belts.

Bakusai will presumably beat the Tongans once management is bored of the Haku add-on. Then, they'll get bored of Shin and Kyoki before moving onto someone else. It's rinse and repeat, and that makes it borderline impossible to get invested. Tragically, MFTs vs. War Raiders didn't even deliver a fun match on this occasion.


2. So Much For That Title Reign!

Alexa Bliss Tatum Paxley
WWE.com

What a puzzling decision to have Charlotte Flair taken out of the Women’s Tag Title match then Fallon Henley and Lainey Reid lose anyway. That didn’t do much to make Fatal Influence look switched on or accomplished. In fact, with Jacy Jayne banned from ringside, the other pair looked out of their depth. Yeah, that was an interesting call to say the least.

Sure, the upside is that Alexa Bliss and Tatum Paxley could get something going with the titles, but it’d be nice if the creative team would properly develop title reigns before just switching the belts. The match felt a tad rushed too, almost like they were short on time and told to speed things up. Hmm. It smarts a little that Henley and Reid came across as cannon fodder for a babyface squad that should've been reeling post-Charlotte ambush.

Hopefully, this result doesn't lead to Jacy tearing her pals a new one before declaring that Fatal Influence is done. SmackDown's female ranks need them, because Jade Cargill and her 'Baddies' don't cut it. Plus, Lainey and Fallon are already more interesting to watch as a combo than Michin and B-FAB.

Henley and Reid won the titles in July, defended them once in August and then lost when attempting to retain the belts for a second time this past Friday night. That's not a well-thought out title reign. It's a pointless one. The only hope coming out of this is that Bliss and Paxley gel, or it leads to Flair getting jealous.


1. Not Much Of A Main Event

Trick Williams Bron Breakker
WWE.com

Final 'Down' time, and maybe a slightly surprising one.

It was actually Raw GM Adam Pearce who made the main event between Trick Williams and Bron Breakker for SmackDown. He did so right at the top of the night because he was ticked off that Nick Aldis had booked some of his roster in the first place. Somewhat strangely, Pearce was wearing a blue suit and Aldis a red one. Hey, at least the days of wrestlers wearing red and blue depending on which brand they're tied to seem to have vanished. About time!

Trick vs. Bron was interesting in theory (not Austin Theory), but they weren’t given much of a chance to do anything special in SmackDown’s headliner. Some brawling kicked things off, then both went to a disqualification finish when The Vision ran in. After that, we got some Money In The Bank preamble from dudes like Je'Von Evans and Penta before The Vision stood tall to close thanks to Bronson Reed.

It was a pretty dull conclusion to the show, and not the best lead-in to MITB either. You just know that Lafayette was bummed out when they chanted Oba Femi's name but didn't see him rush out to put a stop to Reed's domination too. For further proof supporting the 'they ran out of time' argument, just watch cameras fade to black before Bronson went for a second Tsunami too.

Perhaps that's the best way to frame it: SmackDown's main event match was messy and disjointed. It was certainly nowhere near as strong as the hype for the women's ladder match, or even as a promo involving CM Punk, Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens earlier.


Ups...

3. 6-Woman Tag With MITB Flavour Feels Fresh

Lash Legend Sol Ruca
WWE.com

OK, so it's obviously a pretty standard plan to stick SmackDown’s women against Raw’s in 6-woman tag action before Saturday’s ladder match, but the cast helped give this a freshness that many matches of the same type lack. Seeing Lash Legend mix it with Roxanne Perez, or Sol Ruca tangling with Tiffany Stratton, felt like something new for WWE and we don’t get to say that a whole hell of a lot.

At heart, this match was merely a preview for what’s to come at MITB, but it was a rock solid one and a lot of the workers involved looked like bonafide stars hungry for success. Also, both teams picked nice spots to show miscommunication or dissension too, which is cool because they shouldn’t get on ahead of such an important PLE match.

For example, Perez and Ruca refusing to tag one another sold how little regard they have for each other. On the other side of the ring, Jacy Jayne and Stratton kept getting in one another's way, thus putting across that they've got no chemistry together. Why would they? Tiffy has been teaming with Chelsea Green, and Jayne with her Fatal Influence teammates. Tiny flourishes such as this can really make a match worthwhile, so good job to the wrestlers and the agents responsible.

Lash standing tallest over the entire Money In The Bank ladder match field implies that she won't be winning in New Orleans though. Not unless WWE plans to spring a surprise and buck the trend of their usual booking strategy.


2. No Danhausen Silliness = Bonus!

Gunther Finn Balor
WWE.com

After weeks of perpetual whinging about Gunther interacting with Danhausen, it's actually lovely to plonk their business in the 'Ups' section and know it's the right thing to do. On SmackDown, Gunther kicked the spookiness out of Danhausen in a match that never officially started. Then, Finn Bálor rushed out and ran the ‘Ring General’ off before Gunther sneakily returned and hit a powerbomb to Bálor on the announce desk.

There was some tremendous intensity from Gunther and Finn in particular. Dan played his part without anything comedic, which was unexpected - he was only there to take a pasting, and he did. Fair enough. Now, never have those characters interact again! Surely this was the end goal of Danhausen irritating Gunther in backstage skits over the piece. We definitely, definitely, definitely don't need the little goblin cursing a former World Champion and forcing him to relive the worst version of himself.

Can Gunther do comedy? Maybe, but does anyone really need to find out? The closest he should come to seeking laughs is telling Bret Hart that Bill Goldberg is his favourite pro wrestler. Gimmicks like Danhausen don't have a place in the more serious, grounded and realistic world of wrestling this 'Ring General' inhabits.

Besides, it's Bálor who has the necessary motivation to go after Gunther coming out of this show. He was humbled by the power of the Austrian, so he'd naturally want the one-on-one match that wee Danny boy was supposed to get on Friday. Cue Gunther vs. Finn tearing the house down on the upper midcard.

Sounds like a treat.


1. Smart Use Of The Ladders

CM Punk Kevin Owens Sami Zayn
WWE.com

Using the ladders to tell a visual story was really smart.

CM Punk and Kevin Owens bickered, then Sami Zayn interrupted them to do some talking of his own, and this was all much better than last week’s promo segment for the men's MITB. That probably has everything to do with the strength of the characters involved. After all, Punk and Owens are better supporting cast members for Sami than Je'Von, Penta or Trick.

Punk and Owens went eye to eye atop ladders, but Sami was on a shorter ladder and used that to frame the so-called conspiracy everyone has against him. Great idea. No, really. That's not sarcasm. This was a really nifty idea that told the tale of a reigning WWE Champion who still struggles to get respect from the office, his peers and the fans.

Zayn calling out that neither Punk or Owens will win MITB and cash in because they’re too busy arguing with each other was another strong statement, and it shows how useful Sami can be even when he's helping others tell their stories. This is something Zayn does when he's around Johnny Gargano and Candice LeRae too. He always makes sure to give back and elevate others rather than hogging the spotlight.

Above all else, the image of Sami hoisting the WWE Title high above his head yet still looking up at prospective challengers worked. Punk and Owens will presumably cost one another in New Orleans at Money In The Bank, but a Triple Threat for the gold isn't out of the question afterwards, and it could be some laugh.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 7 Behind The Scenes ECW Stories That’ll Shock You and 8 Amazing Wrestlers That Flopped In WCW!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.