3 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE SmackDown (April 7)

Triple H announces WWE's next Draft; Kevin Owens gets taken out; Matt Riddle's revenge.

Jey Uso Solo Sikoa
WWE.com

Everyone rolled into Friday's SmackDown with one name on their lips: Vince McMahon.

Would the returning WWE boss tear up the blue brand script like he did for the flagship on Monday's Raw, or would Triple H be the man in charge of creative? 'The Game' was on FOX - he was there to pat WWE on the back for a brilliant WrestleMania 39 weekend, then move onto coming business by announcing the 2023 Draft.

Fans were...less-than-thrilled by the thought of another Draft, but nobody can blame them for that. WWE largely forgets about brand exclusivity weeks after the fact these days anyway, and it feels like most are ready for crummy Raw vs. SmackDown rules to disappear.

One need only look at the counts for those 'Ups' and 'Downs' to see this wasn't a fab show, but it did have fun moments. Sami Zayn and Jey Uso produced the goods, for example, and there was more Sheamus vs. GUNTHER merriment to enjoy on the undercard.

Sadly, wrestlers warring over broken PlayStation controllers, crappy timing from the writers and an odd amount of silence for Judgment Day hampered the episode.

Here's all the yay and nay from it.


Downs...

5. They're Convincing Nobody

Liv Morgan Raquel Rodriguez
WWE.com

So, as predicted, the women's "Showcase" match at 'Mania meant nothing after all. Despite winning it, Ronda Rousey and Shayna Baszler are nowhere to be found, and the random Raquel Rodriguez and Liv Morgan tandem is being lined up for a crack at the Women's Tag belts instead.

They'll work with Becky Lynch and Lita on Raw, so WWE handed them a routine win over Natalya and Shotzi (why is that still a thing?!) on Smackers. Being brutally honest, people just do not give a rat's ass about any of this. Why should they? The Women's Tag-Team Title division is an absolute mess at times.

Genuine buzz is borderline-impossible for these teams to generate when they're thrown together willy nilly, warmed up for a title shot then forgotten about within the span of a few months. This tag might've been one of the most skippable matches of your entire wrestling week.

Meh.


4. This Again?!

LA Knight Xavier Woods
WWE.com

WWE needs to have more in mind for LA Knight than missing WrestleMania and being some p*ssed off spoilsport who gets annoyed than fellow workers are playing video games backstage. This angle didn't work when Ember Moon's Nintendo Switch got broken years ago, and it won't work in 2023 with LA and Xavier Woods.

What next? A 'PS5 Controller On A Pole' match?

Fans have started to get behind Knight's cause in arenas, so him being some school playground bully who goes around smashing console accessories won't cut it. It'd be a fascinating experience to sit in on WWE creative meetings and find out exactly how writers reckon this will get him/anyone over.

Xavier has already beaten LA on TV too, meaning they'll be one win apiece when they wrestle again and Knight pins him (which will probably happen). 50/50 booking is coming, people. The backstage skit between LA and Woods came across like a bad repeat more than anything progressive.


3. Not Sure Why This Failed To Click

Judgment Day WWE 2023
WWE.com

Judgment Day's promo segment before the tag match vs. Rey Mysterio and Santos Escobar sagged, and WWE should definitely be concerned about the overall lack of interest fans showed when Damian Priest mentioned Bad Bunny; the rapper will do a lot of heavy lifting for Backlash, after all.

This was one of two in-ring promos that reeked of WWE trying to chew up time on the show so they didn't have to book anything that'd push the story forwards. Unfortunately, the aforementioned tag match struggled along until the finish too.

Eek!

Keep in mind that WWE will present pretty much the same match as a possible headliner in Puerto Rico next month. The only difference is that Bunny will replace Escobar - that means general in-ring quality will take a hit. Here's hoping folks are more excited for that than they were for this bizarre anomaly for one of Raw/SmackDown's hottest stables.


2. A Nothing Appearance

Triple H 2023
WWE.com

WWE's social media feeds made a lot of noise about Triple H appearing on Friday's edition of SmackDown and announcing something grand. In the end, that resulted in Trips running through the same celebratory stuff about 'Mania he did on Raw, then talking about the upcoming Draft.

Thrilling scenes, lads.

It's gonna be hard for anybody to get up for that, especially when everyone watching knows creative won't stick to show choices throughout the rest of the year anyway. Hunter's heavily-hyped appearance was a bit of a sh*t segment and a waste of airtime then.

'The Game' could be excused for putting a bow on WrestleMania during Raw, but not here. He defo didn't need to recap the same stuff, or even talk about the Draft at all. His attempts to make this 2023 version exciting were frankly rather tame.


1. Timing Is Everything

Matt Riddle Solo Sikoa
WWE.com

Right, here's the deal: Matt Riddle seeking revenge on Solo Sikoa for putting him out of action late-last year makes sense. However, Riddle literally just returned on Monday's episode of Raw, then got treated like some comeback surprise by the time SmackDown aired.

Huh?

This booking exposed a major flaw in Raw's planning. It revealed that WWE only booked Riddle's return on Monday because they realised they had nothing else for the flagship. So, creative panicked and thought, 'Oh sh*t - we better give 'em something that feels big time!'.

It's hard to dig that lack of foresight for one of the biggest Raw episodes of the entire year, and it kinda did step on SmackDown's toes. Surely a fired up Riddle marching out to go after Solo would've meant more without that skit with The Miz a few days before it?


Ups...

3. Non-Title Tag Feud Goodness

Ivar Ricochet
WWE.com

Zero problems this end with The Viking Raiders feuding against Braun Strowman and Ricochet. Will it be rivalry of the year? Nah, but you've got to take what you can get around these parts sometimes. Besides, this is a non-title tag-team feud, which is something your writer really enjoys.

It has never sat well that duos twiddle their thumbs doing next-to-nothing just because they're outside the title mix, and it's vitally important that WWE keeps them fresh in fan minds consistently. That's what this story represents - it's something for these dudes to do, and will lead to a few cool matches.

Ricochet vs. Ivar was certainly that.

They gelled well, and worked in some tidy big man vs. little man spots that never once made it seem like that's all Ivar can do. He can shift for a bigger boy, but he's way more powerful than Rico too. Decent little match, and it's nice to see WWE keeping an eye on the rest of the tag pack.


2. Hard To Argue With This Quality

Sheamus GUNTHER
WWE.com

Some on socials have remarked that GUNTHER vs. Sheamus feels old hat.

Your scribe almost spat out his pint of Guinness or Stiegl reading that. How could anyone get bored of seeing these workers beat the snot out of one another? They, along with Drew McIntyre, produced one of the best bouts across 'Mania weekend, and they brought a bit of that magic to free TV.

GUNTHER vs. Sheamus will be one that WWE can come back to time and time again over the next few years. It's guaranteed to play before significant noise, because people love seeing this sort of physicality from two well-booked brutes. Speaking of brutes, Sheamus' Brawling variety scored the win this time.

Granted, Imperium backups Ludwig Kaiser and Giovanni Vinci could use a win or two themselves, but that's a small gripe in the grand scheme of things. This six-man sprint was a top start to the show, and even squeezed in more bruising GUNTHER vs. Sheamus exchanges.


1. Could’ve Been Even Better, But…

Jey Uso Solo Sikoa Bloodline Sami Zayn
WWE.com

Greats like Sami Zayn and Jey Uso have set the bar extremely high over the past year or so. Their storytelling as part of the wider Bloodline narrative has been world class, so keep that in mind lest ye scoff at the "could've been better" part of that subheading.

It isn't meant as an insult - more an illustration of how high expectations are due to prior stellar performances from them. This was a good match all things considered anyway, and the setup was some laugh. Kevin Owens got taken out by the ever-dangerous Solo Sikoa, then Sami and Jey thrashed out their differences in-ring.

They've gone from being background players to main-eventing WrestleMania and episodes of TV. What's not to love about that? The finish involving Riddle would've been better without Raw's booking, but he'll only play a small part in the story long-term.

Go out of your way to watch this, because it was another worthy chapter in wrestling's best ongoing narrative.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more like this, check out 10 Nightmares That Could Come True In Vince McMahon's New WWE and Predicting WWE's WrestleMania XL Cards 1 Year Out!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.