3 Ups & 7 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Oct 29)
Halloween wrecks SmackDown; WWE's "new era" presses the repeat button; Shotzi turns heel.
WWE's holiday-themed episodes are rarely must-see wrestling telly. Add to that the fact that SmackDown was on FS1 (not FOX) this week and you had a recipe for disaster. This, to be blunt, was not a great night for the blue brand, and that's hardly forgivable considering all the new toys on the roster.
Those fresh faces were pushed aside in favour of the same old sh*t.
Speaking of which, WWE went one of the worst routes possible with Mustafa Ali. Post-tag with Mansoor, did anybody really need to see more of this race-inspired rubbish? The company has already tried that with the exact same wrestler - it didn't work then and it's not about to start working now.
Yeah, positives are thin on the ground here. The standard "spooky fun" that accompanies this time of year, along with the gross misuse of brand newcomers and "new" feuds that fans have seen countless times, did nothing for the program.
WWE's creative team took a week off. They don't get a pass for that, and their employer doesn't get one for awkwardly ambling towards more Raw vs. SmackDown monotony at Survivor Series.
Downs...
7. Sloppy Moments
Maybe nerves got the best of Shotzi during her opener with Charlotte Flair.
If so, that's understandable. This was the ex-NXT star's biggest solo match on SmackDown to date, but it's one she'll look back on with slight regret. Something was off here, because there were a few obvious miscues and botches - most of them, sadly, came from the newcomer.
It certainly didn't help that Flair dominated 90% of the match either. She has a tendency to gobble lesser opponents up, and that often made for a slow, turgid watch. The clear purpose of this bout was to help Shotzi bed in as an emerging threat without making her look like Charlotte's equal.
Did WWE get it right? Hmm. Sort of. Shotzi didn't impress the same way she did in tag-team bouts alongside Tegan Nox, and that's concerning. Vince McMahon isn't known to have a lot of patience these days - she'll need to come up a notch ASAP.
6. Background Noise
Last week, Hit Row made a splash by getting some decent promo time and an easy squash match win. It was a fine introduction for the group in front of fans that might not know much about them, and it made sense to follow that up with something even better? Right? Right?!
WWE didn't.
Instead, Hit Row were relegated to playing cheerleaders for New Day and doing some hokey 'we're not worthy' bit backstage. This wasn't the correct use of a hot new group the writing team hopes will land with fans long-term. If that's your goal, then at least give them a bloody fighting chance.
Top Dolla and friends should be turning heads on their own merits weekly. They defo shouldn't be acting like marks for King Woods and Kofi Kingston just because creative has nothing else for them but fancies getting them on camera regardless.
5. 'Trick Or Street Fight'
The 'Trick Or Street Fight' name has never and will never make much sense. Halloween revellers are familiar with the 'Trick Or Treat' phrase; tacking 'Fight' onto a word that rhymes with that is rotten. WWE should just call the thing 'Trick Or Street' and then put 'Fight' in brackets, or something.
Rant over. That's the least of this bout's problems anyway.
Subjective tolerance for this goofy nonsense may vary, but it's usually a miss for this fan. Shinsuke Nakamura and Rick Boogs vs. Happy Corbin and Madcap Moss was just a little too long as well, and the involvement of those 24/7 losers and the team of Humberto Carrillo and Angel Garza didn't help.
Carrillo and Garza got zero reaction from the live crowd. Again, much like with Shotzi's fumbles, management will take notice of this. Still, what do they expect when they dress some fresh heels up like "ghouls" and make them feud with a tag-team who...aren't even a real tag-team?
4. Something New? Nah!
Meanwhile, The Usos are feuding with New Day for the millionth time.
It's rather cheap of WWE to boldly proclaim that this is a "new era" for Raw and SmackDown then book the same sh*t they've been booking for years. Practically the entire blue brand tag division continued their issues when they moved to Raw (that's not "new"), and now Friday nights have a reprise too.
Matches between these two teams will always be fun, sure, but come on - going back to Usos vs. New Day is so lazy. That's especially true when King Woods just won the crown over in Saudi Arabia and should thus have a singles program to sink his teeth into. He really deserves that.
Would it have killed SmackDown's writing staff to put Hit Row in this spot, or maybe even another team? Therein lies the problem: SmackDown doesn't actually have roster depth when it comes to tags. Most of them were moved to Raw, so you'll eat another portion of New Day and like it.
3. A Total Waste Of Shayna Baszler
An outburst of joy accompanied news that Shayna Baszler was being drafted from Raw to SmackDown in the annual talent trade. No more Nia Jax, the critics rejoiced! Unfortunately, WWE still don't have a damn clue what to do with Shayna. Hence this Sonya Deville vs. Naomi leech act she's working.
Baszler is lost in this story.
One also has a worrying sense that none of this is going anywhere anyway. Naomi will probs lose to Sonya and then get quietly redrafted to Raw, or something like that. The main concern in all of this should be Baszler though. She can recover from her Alexa Bliss/doll-related nightmare over on Raw if WWE book her as a machine-like bad ass.
Nah, it's much better to script her as Deville's weapon of choice instead...apparently. Someone as good as Shayna shouldn't be having matches that last 70 seconds on TV. That's a total waste of top talent, and it's a damning insight into WWE's plans for her.
2. Xenophobia (Again)
Oh hell no.
Going down the 'you're all racists and only hate me because of my name' path with Mustafa Ali is a huge mistake. Nobody actually hates his heritage, or how proud he is of it. If anything, people agree that Ali is an inspiring human being who should be flying the flag for tolerance and inclusion.
The fact that WWE keep coming back to this is frankly disgusting. Xenophobia has been part of pro wrestling forever, but that argument is flimsy. It becomes even flakier when realising that hey, Mustafa has already done this racial angle before. Good lord, are they trying to make him look silly?
Ali's rants are tedious, ill-advised and add nothing to WWE's product. This forced idea that he feels persecuted because of his skin colour, name or background is hard to stomach considering what's been going on in the real world.
Make it stop.
1. The Complete Lack Of Roman Reigns
No Roman Reigns = no 'Up'.
That's usually how it goes. The Universal Champion always slides his way onto the positive side of this chasm, largely because his segments/promos/matches are high calibre and entertain the p*ss out of this writer. Paul Heyman, by association, also fits that billing.
Not on Friday however. Heyman cut a nondescript promo with Kayla Braxton that discussed Brock Lesnar's £1 million fine. That, being honest, was about all he had to say. WWE are blatantly in time-killing mode here - they've got Survivor Series coming up, and that means they'll phone in some Raw vs. SmackDown stuff until late-November.
The knock-on effect of that is that Reigns might not need to appear every week, which makes SmackDown a much weaker show. It says everything about the 'Tribal Chief' that the roster felt thinner than usual without his presence.
Being fair, the same might also be said about Raw draftees Edge and Seth Rollins.
Ups...
3. Bumping Around For Drew
Drew McIntyre's open challenges are working for him.
His 'let's shut up and wrestle' (unintentional Eric Bischoff line about AEW there) promos are strait-laced and to the point. They fit his no-nonsense character, and formatting them to come after bloated promo trains is smart business. Then, when the bell rings, Drew backs up his words.
McIntyre is a giving-enough worker that even mixing it with the smaller dudes isn't a problem for him. Then, when it's their turn to bump and feed for him, he looks like an absolute monster. In short, Mustafa Ali was the ideal next opponent for Drew on this brand spanking new SmackDown run.
The way the big Scot chucked Ali around like an empty tracksuit was particularly pleasing. Again, he didn't eat Mustafa alive without giving the heel some key heat-seeking spots, but McIntyre shouldn't be having 50/50 matches with most on this roster whilst he's in build mode.
2. Hard To Argue With Quality
As repetitive as the thought of another Usos vs. New Day feud is, only a fool would deny that they get it done in the ring. It's regrettable that WWE don't have something bigger for Xavier Woods on his own now he's 'King Of The Ring', but meh. It's not like Kofi Kingston would die a death hugging the bench for a while either.
Onto the match.
SmackDown's main event zipped along with all the usual energy you'd expect from four guys this experienced and talented. The Usos know when to launch into heat sections better than most tags, and the Woods/Kingston combo will always hear cheers from crowds when they mount a comeback and get some shine.
New Day winning obviously sets up a SmackDown Tag Title match between these teams at some point in the future. That may come after the usual 'us vs. them' vibes of Survivor Series. WWE might prefer that Jimmy and Jey work RK-Bro on that card first.
1. Shotzi’s Logic
Shotzi's vicious attack on Sasha Banks worked despite her aforementioned hiccups against Charlotte Flair. The best villains feel justified in their actions (rightly or wrongly), and Shotzi can point to Sasha jumping up onto the apron for no reason as vindication for her behaviour.
It's not like Banks is 100% babyface in her approach anyway. Having some shades of grey for some select workers isn't a bad idea; it sounds so clichéd, sure, but having multiple layers to a few personalities in that women's division would be a step forwards. They don't all need to be catty bitches or inspiring (often easily-manipulated) heroines, y'know.
Although it remains to be seen how much faith WWE will put in Shotzi, she deserves a chance. This division badly needed fresh blood, and she has the personality to click with fans. Those matches might need to come up a step mind, but turning the newbie heel will maybe help her take charge more in-ring.
Fingers crossed.
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more, check out 4 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Oct 22) and 10 Wrestlers Who Were BEGGING To Be Fired!