4 Ups & 10 Downs From WWE Raw (Oct 5)

RETRIBUTION's leader revealed; Rollins' listless journey continues.

Mustafa Ali RETRIBUTION
WWE

Can one shocking swerve make up for a lacklustre episode that continually disappoints? In short, no.

Raw continued to be a muddled mess of logic gaps, stuck-in-the-mud storylines, poor booking and just general malaise. It had the occasional flash of competence, but the spark just isn’t there. It’s really sad when you start longing for the WWE Draft, just to shake things up a bit and have some fresh matchups for the first time in six months.

Monday night featured yet another instalment of the Hurt Business squaring off against Ricochet & Apollo Crews, but for the first time in what feels like aeons, the Street Profits did not face Andrade & Angel Garza, though Garza’s injury probably had more to do with that than progressive booking.

The Seth Rollins/Mysterio Family saga continued, with Murphy finally lashing out at his Messiah, though by this point the entire storyline has dragged on for so long that it’s difficult to care at all about any development.

Lastly, RETRIBUTION unveiled its leader, and he probably wasn’t on anyone’s shortlist. Is that a good thing? Who knows? But it’s something, and it could lead somewhere. And that, unfortunately, is what qualifies as a positive development on Raw these days.

Until next week, when Raw hopefully gets (figuratively) blown up by the draft and rebooted, let’s get to it…


Downs…

10. Meh

Drew McIntyre Randy Orton
WWE.com

It was a struggle to decide whether the six-man tag team main event was a positive or a negative. There just wasn’t anything really to say. It was a scoop of vanilla ice cream.

There wasn’t anything wrong with the match, and it’s outcome, while predictable, accomplished what it set out to do: give the WWE Championship challenger a bit of a psychological edge and cast doubt despite having lost two matches already. But it also was very stock: Nothing stood out or really made you stand up and take notice.

However, there was one big missed opportunity: This was a prime opportunity to identify and really drive home new tag title challengers for the Street Profits. The recently reunited Dolph Ziggler & Robert Roode, who held the title exactly a year ago, would be ideal opponents to dethrone the Profits, who are now seven months into a reign that has been running on fumes for a while.

Monday’s main event could have done more to sow the seeds that the former tag champs have their eyes on reclaiming their titles. Hell, the announcers at least could have driven the point home that they were former Raw Tag Team Champions.

The Profits have defended the titles three times in the past six months, twice against Andrade & Angel Garza. They clearly aren’t doing anything with the titles, so why not give someone – anyone – a shot with them? Ziggler & Roode, while not setting the world on fire, would at least change things up.


9. So Lana Walks Into The Ring…

It really is beginning to feel like a punchline to a bad joke.

Lana is ringside after losing a match. Shayna Baszler and Nia Jax storm the arena and Jax hits a Samoan Drop, driving Lana through the announce desk. The Ravishing Russian is laid out, the WWE Women’s Tag Team Champions gloat, and that’s that. Lather, rinse, repeat… three times.

We get it: Lana’s husband left WWE and is now working for the competitor. Lana is an inexperienced wrestler. Let’s put her through her paces a bunch of times for no reason other than to do it.

As always, if this was leading somewhere, anywhere, we could give it a pass. But WWE has engendered zero trust when it comes to follow-through on stuff like that. Lana will just keep getting flattened over and over as long as it entertains the brass.


8. Staple Of Raw Vanishes

RAW Underground shane is a state lol
WWE.com

For months, Raw has been inundated with segments featuring WWE’s version of fight club, Raw Underground. And suddenly, it has just up and vanished from TV. No fight club.

Yes, there is a very real-life reason why this has been put on pause: the global pandemic apparently has hit some developmental talent, rendering it impossible to continue with the Underground right now.

But think about how much of Raw has been tied up in this nonsensical segments/storylines. Raw Underground was pitched weekly as this hot new version of gritty combat, with in-ring rivalries being shuttled over to the rope-less ring.

And now… nothing. Welcome to 2020, folks.


7. Cliché Factory

Hey, guess what PPV is coming up later this month? If you’re paying attention to the dialogue so lovingly scripted by the WWE writers, you’d know, it’s Hell in a Cell.

You see, the writers take great pains to make sure at least three different superstars talk about “hell” in their promos, just to remind everyone there’s a PPV with a similar-sounding name. GENIUS. Throw in Drew McIntyre’s awful, cliché-ridden promo where he accepted Randy Orton’s cell challenge. Did you know that Drew wasn’t going to be locked in the cell with Randy, but Orton was going to be locked in with McIntyre?

Because we’ve never heard that line before. Or the one referencing purgatory and hell. Totally original.

Can we at least pass the seven-year statute of limitations?


6. McIntyre’s Mentors

Did you know that Big Show and Christian were mentors to WWE Champion Drew McIntyre? Neither did we.

But apparently, that was the case, according to Randy Orton, as he ran down the events of last week, including a play-by-play of his night-vision goggle attack on the four legends. He then channelled his inner Bluto from Animal House and declared that nothing was over until he said it was before challenging McIntyre to a Hell in a Cell match.

We didn’t get an answer per se, but McIntyre then burst into the room and assaulted Orton until the officials broke it up and the Viper fled. So it looks like we’ll now get a third PPV title match after McIntyre won the first two to successfully defend his championship. Because no one has anything better to do.

Maybe attacking Drew’s “mentors” was viewed as an opening for this rematch, but it’s really, really weak sauce. When you make Dolph Ziggler demanding a title shot seem like a more coherent storyline, you’ve got problems.


5. Has The Draft Started Already?

Sorry, had to check the calendar to clarify, but the WWE Draft has not started yet.

You can be forgiven if you thought otherwise with so many SmackDown superstars just showing up on Raw suddenly. Drew Gulak, Bray Wyatt and Braun Strowman all had turns on the red brand Monday night. Braun even got an “exhibition” match, because apparently while you can’t technically wrestle on Raw as a SmackDown superstar, you can get in the ring on TV and fight.

And let’s not forget that Dana Brooke and Mandy Rose recently joined Raw, and Kevin Owens spent time on SmackDown last week and is headed there again this week.

What’s the point again of these roster splits again?


4. KO The Punching Bag

Kevin Owens Aleister Black
WWE.com

So, Kevin Owens’ new gimmick is that he gets beat up by “tortured souls” a lot?

Someone is going to have to explain this one to this writer. Owens has spent the last few weeks getting jumped by brooding fashion plate pirate Aleister Black, only to head to SmackDown last week and get attacked by The Fiend. He returned to Raw Monday night and called out Fiend, only to get blindsided by Black again.

This is a former Universal Champion and guy who feuded with Shane McMahon for months on SmackDown. And now he’s just kind of listlessly getting beat up with no real purpose evident.

Owens is one of the most gifted performers in WWE. He’s great on the mic, really good in the ring, and can make just about any feud work. Even his banter with Shane a few weeks back was gold, and that was just mindless chit-chat outside Raw Underground. Why is he flailing like this?

That said, a feud with Fiend could be entertaining, but until it takes off and both are on the same brand, it’s just wishful thinking.


3. And On, And On, And On…

Ricochet Shelton Benjamin
WWE.com

If it’s Monday night, then that means that the Hurt Business is facing some combination of Apollo Crews & Ricochet on Raw.

You can almost set your watch to that. And sure enough, we got a tag team match featuring them. And the Hurt Business got the duke, with Bobby Lashley once again tapping Crews out with the Hurt Lock. But don’t worry, Ricochet promised everyone that they’d keep coming back until the Hurt Business was tired of them.

But what about us? What if we’re tired of seeing the limited combinations of these wrestlers fighting over and over and over? Isn’t there any consideration for us?

Won’t someone think of the children?


2. Ali Leads Rejects

Mustafa Ali
WWE

It’s tough to know just yet what to make of Monday’s shock announcement that Mustafa Ali is the leader of RETRIBUTION, putting the cruiserweight right in the middle of one of Raw’s biggest storylines. Here, we’ll offer both positive and negative reasoning. First, the negative…

Simply put, RETRIBUTION already has tanked. It’s a joke. No amount of strong booking can make up for the poor start the group got off to, right down to the unveiling of its main members and their horrible names. The group largely has been regarded as a joke by fans, so why would putting in charge a guy whose credibility is average at best make a difference?

When the group gets its comeuppance, does that mean the end of Ali? It’s gonna take a Herculean effort to dig this group out of its hole, and while Ali is charismatic, he’s not The Rock. And that’s who you’d need at this point.


1. Messiah’s Fall From Grace

Seth Rollins Murphy
WWE.com

Can someone – anyone – remind the rest of us what Seth Rollins’ gimmick is?

The Monday Night Messiah burst onto the scene as some pseudo-cult leader, attracting a small following of wrestlers who were hellbent on remaking Raw in Rollins’ image. If he couldn’t be the babyface hero, he’d burn it all down.

Then Rollins set his sights on Rey Mysterio. That was five months ago. Rollins (and Murphy) and the Mysterio family have been locked in a never-ending feud since May, a rivalry that WWE has tried to pump life into it by interjecting first Rey’s son Dominik, and now his 19-year-old daughter Aalyah.

Monday, Rollins berated his disciple Murphy after the underling demanded that Seth apologize… to Aalyah. This led to the two to brawl and batter each other with a kendo stick. Seriously, we’ve been down this Mysterio-obsessed rabbit hole for so long now, is it even possible to reconnect the dots to the original purpose of the Monday Night Messiah?

We are just so far gone now. None of it makes any sense. They’re just fighting because there’s nothing else to do at this point. It’s not like it’s a great rivalry producing four-star matches every PPV. It just fills space and time. Seth has no purpose. He’s not reshaping Raw. He’s arguing with his disciple and tormenting the same family he’s been feuding with since the spring.


Ups…

4. Women’s Tag Match Passes Muster

Dana Brooke Natalya
WWE.com

A six-woman tag match featuring Lana, Mandy Rose and Dana Brooke isn’t going to win Match of the Year or garner a bunch of snowflakes, but that doesn’t mean it can’t be effective.

Raw’s first match of the night featured Rose, Brooke & Asuka tangling with Zelina Vega, Natalya & Lana. They kept it fairly basic, with Mandy absorbing a bunch of punishment before letting Asuka run wild. That gave way to a Rose blind tag and pump knee strike to fell Lana.

It was an inoffensive match that was actually much better than last week’s tag bout without Asuka & Vega. Monday’s contest made Mandy look a lot better, hitting her finisher crisply.

Hey, on a Raw like this, you’ve got to give a thumbs-up wherever you can.


3. Tag Title Match Effective

Shayna Baszler Ruby Riott
WWE.com

As silly as the bickering between WWE Women’s Tag Team Champions Nia Jax & Shayna Baszler is, at least they are imposing figures who get along well enough to win – as opposed to Andrade & Angel Garza, who argued and lost all the time.

The duo successfully defended their tag titles Monday night, defeating the Riott Squad after a decent little match. No one thought Ruby Riott and Liv Morgan were going to win the titles, but they at least effectively used double-teams to stay in the fight for a little while before Baszler slammed the door shut with the Kirafuda Clutch. For what it was, it was a decent David versus Goliath tag match.

Hopefully some thought has been given to how to take the titles off Baszler and Jax that doesn’t involve them turning on each other and feuding, because no one needs to see that at this point.


2. Ali Gives RETRIBUTION A Face

Mustafa Ali RETRIBUTION
WWE

Until this point, RETRIBUTION has been a masked and hooded group of NXT stars who either remain shrouded or have renamed themselves with ridiculous monikers. Their promos have been insanely over-complex and nonsensical, and it’s tough to determine what their purpose is.

Mustafa Ali was unveiled as their leader Monday, which changes the dynamic. It’s also a shocking development, which is something these days. If his reasoning is sound and if he is able to give the group some real purpose, then it could at least right the ship a bit.

Perhaps he was tired of being an overlooked punching bag, a guy who saw his opportunities given away to other wrestlers (he was rumored to be pegged for a mega-push last year before he got injured, and Kofi Kingston got the chance and ran with it, leaving Ali with nothing). He has preached being the light for WWE, while RETRIBUTION talks about darkness. As someone who already had a contract, he could be seen as the “in” for the group to gain access to the Performance Center and ThunderDome before they got their contracts.

However, we’re putting a lot of faith in the writers to have thought-out and plausible reasons for Ali to lead this band of masked wrestlers. That’s a huge leap of faith. But at this point, it’s a development that moves the ball down the field, and in an era where wrestlers face each other in never-ending feuds, that’s gotta count for something.


1. A Colossal Collision

Braun Strowman Keith Lee
WWE.com

Let’s set aside the whole "Braun Strowman showing up on Raw, looking for a fight" nonsense.

Braun versus Keith Lee is a matchup that could really be fun if done right. We’ve seen in the past that Strowman with an athletic big man can make for an entertaining feud, and Lee certainly fits the bill.

Their showdown Monday night was little more than an appetizer, with their exhibition ending in a count-out just moments after beginning. The brawl outside was a pretext to Lee tackling Strowman off the stage and through a few tables, an effective spot that concluded the melee but didn’t give anything away.

Now, we have to assume that either Braun is coming to Raw in the draft, or Lee is headed to SmackDown so this feud can continue. If that’s the case, then why didn’t they just wait until next week and have the new guy come out to the ring looking for a fight? That’s the only real knock here.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.